Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

How Much Does The Diet Really Help?
0

14 posts in this topic

I am awaiting biopsy in 7 weeks but I have read some discouraging stuff the last few weeks since my blood results researching the condition.  I've seen anything from numerous people claiming the gluten-free diet actually made them diabetic to only 50% of people are healed after 5-10 years since cross contamination simply occurs way too often to get back to 100% capacity unless you literally lock yourself in your house for all your meals.  My only blood test which was positive was the IgA which was 20, the EMA and TtG were raging negative.  I have tried gluten free eating here the last 3-4 days, I plan on doing it for another 3-4 before going back on gluten before the biopsy.  Amazingly my gas and bloating are almost gone completely, still some discomfort but about 90% better overall.  However, I've developed horrible cold hands and feet, not sure if this a withdrawal symptom or my body revolting to getting less or different food than it is used to.  My weight has also dropped off 3 pounds in 4 days, largely because I have not been eating my snacking donuts 3 times a day which are 280 calories a piece, remarkable what a difference losing 840 calories a day can do. 

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Where are you getting those numbers?  And the gluten free diet is only as good as the work you put into it.  Keep eating that gluten utility your biopsy. Even if it is negative you can still give the diet an honest try for three months and judge for yourself the results.

 

Good luck,

 

Colleen 

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In answer to the topic question:

Lifesaving for those with Celiac Disease and some that are labeled Non Celiac Gluten Intolerant.

For all others removing gluten can be beneficial even if not medically required.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some have to be more gluten free than others.  I am one of those who has to be very gluten free.  Let me tell you that the problems associated with the diet are nothing compared to the improved health that has resulted from them.  Don't be discouraged.  The diagnosis was one of the best things that ever happened to me.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As far as i understand it, if you are a celiac, you need to remove all gluten or you will not heal but perfect healing is not guaranteed. A non-celiac gluten intolerant person will also feel very badly if they eat gluten but is is yet unclear what damage (if any) is being done when they eat it... I would guess something is going on because otherwise why would they feel bad?

 

I think of celiac like a fall on the pavement, some people will lose more skin than others, some will heal faster and easier, some will have a scar even if they do eveything right, and some will pick at it (not follow the gluten-free diet 100%) and ensure that they will not heal without a mark.

 

Thankfully celiac is one of the only AI diseases (if there are others, I can't think of them) where you can basically cure yourself with just a diet change; the patient has total control. That is such a good thing!  Yes, it will take time to heal, possibly months or years, but an improvement is a almost a sure thing if you follow the diet.

 

I had my most reactive symptoms clear up quickly. It seems like if it was a sudden symptom, that I got frequently after eating gluten, then it was one of the first to go.  Joint pain and some of my more insidious symptoms took at least half a year to start improving... at first I felt like it took sooooo long but then I tried to look at it as the glass being half full...

 

I was diagnosed with Hashimoto's at the same time as celiac disease and the hashi's is no where near being as under control as the celiac disease. I have to take a pill every day to manage it, and go in for blood tests every 6 weeks. I can't adjust my medicine faster than every two months because it is so slow acting... I'm hoping that by the fall I'll finally feel better. Hopefully.  In the meantime, there is nothing I can do (unlike celiac) to stop my body's attack on my thyroid. It's probably going to continue to die off.

 

I also have ITP, where your white blood cells attack your platelets and kill them when it goes through your spleen. I can't stop that either. I had to have my spleen taken out.

 

Celiac is a pain in the butt but it isn't that bad in the long wrong. Once you embrace that way of eating, it becomes easier over time. The first few weeks are the hardest, especially if you experience a withdrawl. All you can do is go for it (in a few weeks) and then just sit back and wait to see what the gluten-free diet can do for you.  Best wishes.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I'm wondering where you got that 50% figure or the diabetic thing? Never heard those claims myself.

 

All I know is I can ONLY eat a gluten-free diet. I react so strongly to wheat that any other diet is impossible, so for me and many others, there's no question that the diet is not only effective, it's essential to life. (I am apparently not celiac but NCGI and/or allergic to wheat). For true celiacs, it's even more so...

 

Please don't be discouraged, you're already seeing some of the benefits!!! And you'll get much much better at it, trust me. I can't believe some of the dumb stuff I did that made me sick the first weeks, like scraping chicken salad off the bread in a sandwich, thinking that would be okay! (Slaps forehead!!)

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I did read I study showing that Celiacs on a gluten-free diet often still have signs of damage after a time (but I think it was a pretty short period of time, and there was no way to say how strict these people were, so I think it's kind of bunk). I'll see if I can find the link.

 

You have to follow a 100% gluten free diet in order to heal. You can't not to that. However, some of us have to do more than just be gluten free. We may have other food intolerances or other conditions that cause problems. Even strictly gluten-free, some of us still struggle to feel better. However, a lot of celiacs heal up and are perfectly healthy as long as they remain gluten-free.

 

So, don't be discouraged by studies. Trust your gut. If you feel better already, then there's something to it. You'll have to keep eating gluten until your tests are done, and then (depending on the diagnosis, or your personal decision if its negative) go gluten-free and you'll find out for yourself what works and what doesn't.

 

Good luck!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've seen anything from numerous people claiming the gluten-free diet actually made them diabetic to only 50% of people are healed after 5-10 years since cross contamination simply occurs way too often to get back to 100% capacity unless you literally lock yourself in your house for all your meals.

 

 


Where are you getting those numbers?

 

That's a good question !  Because I've seen it elsewhere.

 

The part that I bolded, in the first quote, the (questionable) claim that only 50% of celiacs heal, can be found on this site, the University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center, FAQ page "Why do I need a cure when I can simply eat a gluten free diet."  

http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/archives/faq/why-do-i-need-a-cure-when-i-can-simply-eat-a-gluten-free-diet

 

 
"Fails to heal intestinal damage in more than half of cases"  

 

"The University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center was founded in 2001 by Dr. Stefano Guandalini, a world renowned pediatric gastroenterologist and celiac disease expert. "  http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/who-we-are/history   if you read down to the bottom it claims the Univ. Chicago Celiac Disease Center is completely funded by donations.  It is not the same thing as the Univ of Chicago Hospital itself, which is why they think they can get away with making statements like this.  I would love to see the data and studies ?    This Guandalini is the doctor who wrote the current diagnostic criteria for celiac disease.  

 

According to their "who we are" Fund Allocation page, the Univ. Chi Celiac Disease Center claims to be a 501©(3) organization within the Univ of Chicago. They also claim to be working to establish a $2 million endowment for themselves.  That would make them at least partially non profit, and their donors may be tax- exempt, (see wiki here on the definition of a 501©(3)  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501©_organization ) but they would have to be filing IRS forms for the public records.  I cannot find them listed on this, yet, it doesn't mean that it is not there, but the public sourced charity website searches for IRS filings are not listing a University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center and their IRS filing.  Per wiki, a private foundation receives most of its income from investments and endowments.  This income is used to make grants to other organizations....  defined as 501©(3) organizations, which do NOT qualify as public charities.  

 

 

You may wonder why I just put that information up there -  when one is seeing incredulous statements coming from well known public figures, especially in the celiac medical research field, at the same time there is an ongoing public media campaign by certain agricultural lobbies to maintain funding for grain subsidies and GMO research, and there could be new labeling rules coming this year, which impact food manufacturer's,   it is a good idea to check the source of the funding.  Which is not obvious at all, here. 

 

 

This UCCD Center website has been changed a bit since the last time I looked at it, so they are becoming aware of people scrutinizing it. 

 

________

 

To the Original Poster -  "the diet" really helps, but at times it causes people to say really strange things on the internet.  :blink:  <_<  :ph34r:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Acute food poisoning can occur after gluten exposure"? What does that even mean?.....

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I my opinion.  If you are going to have an AI disease Celiac is the one to have because the fix is gluten free diet.  It is a pain to go out to eat, or go to a party, to me this is the most difficult part of Celiac.  For help there is an App called "Is that Gluten Free?"  I bought the grocery store version and they have information on hundreds of products.

 

Trust me this lifesyle is not easy, but I'd rather see the positive rather than the negative.  I do have my pity parties but life could be much worse.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Acute food poisoning can occur after gluten exposure"? What does that even mean?.....  

 

I could speculate, but........ I am not a licensed medical professional, medical researcher, nor a public relations spokesperson.    Acute food poisoning can occur after non gluten exposure, too ! 

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, the words 'food poisoning' are accepted as referring to food-borne illness. So

are they saying that a glutening makes you more susceptible to food-borne illness?

So confused.....

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a good question !  Because I've seen it elsewhere.

 

The part that I bolded, in the first quote, the (questionable) claim that only 50% of celiacs heal, can be found on this site, the University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center, FAQ page "Why do I need a cure when I can simply eat a gluten free diet."  

http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/archives/faq/why-do-i-need-a-cure-when-i-can-simply-eat-a-gluten-free-diet

 

I've tried to find what % of knowing celiacs follow the diet.  The only stat I could find was one site that stated anywhetre from 50-70%, not sure if anyone else here as seen numbers on that.

 

I my opinion.  If you are going to have an AI disease Celiac is the one to have because the fix is gluten free diet.  It is a pain to go out to eat, or go to a party, to me this is the most difficult part of Celiac.  For help there is an App called "Is that Gluten Free?"  I bought the grocery store version and they have information on hundreds of products.

 

Trust me this lifesyle is not easy, but I'd rather see the positive rather than the negative.  I do have my pity parties but life could be much worse.

 

When I first got the diagnosis I certainly said some dumb stuff and said I'd rather have a few other conditions than this.  I know people with Crohn's and UC and its a wide range of impact on life, some are suffering way worse than any celiac and others much less, they may be at a much greater risk of other conditions developing which they have zero control over unlike someone with celiac who controls their own destiny to a big extent but their quality of life with a mild case of Crohn's or UC may be impacted less.  I think the biggest fix can be if they can manage to get a drug out there allowing for a reasonable degree of CC, if we can at least get something where the pizza guy can make your pie on the same surface he just made the regular pie on it would probably be the best day of some people's lives on this forum.  I know I'd take modest side effects if it meant I could order off any gluten-free menu and not worry what utensils may have touched the food.  If I get a biopsy confirmation this is indeed celiac I know there are going to be plenty of days down the road it takes every ounce of will I have left in me not to cheat, particularly when I'm traveling which I unfortunately do alot. 

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a good question !  Because I've seen it elsewhere.

 

 

"The University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center was founded in 2001 by Dr. Stefano Guandalini, a world renowned pediatric gastroenterologist and celiac disease expert. "  http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/who-we-are/history   if you read down to the bottom it claims the Univ. Chicago Celiac Disease Center is completely funded by donations.  It is not the same thing as the Univ of Chicago Hospital itself, which is why they think they can get away with making statements like this.  I would love to see the data and studies ?    This Guandalini is the doctor who wrote the current diagnostic criteria for celiac disease.  

 

According to their "who we are" Fund Allocation page, the Univ. Chi Celiac Disease Center claims to be a 501©(3) organization within the Univ of Chicago. They also claim to be working to establish a $2 million endowment for themselves.  That would make them at least partially non profit, and their donors may be tax- exempt, (see wiki here on the definition of a 501©(3)  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501©_organization ) but they would have to be filing IRS forms for the public records.  I cannot find them listed on this, yet, it doesn't mean that it is not there, but the public sourced charity website searches for IRS filings are not listing a University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center and their IRS filing.  Per wiki, a private foundation receives most of its income from investments and endowments.  This income is used to make grants to other organizations....  defined as 501©(3) organizations, which do NOT qualify as public charities.  

 

 

You may wonder why I just put that information up there -  when one is seeing incredulous statements coming from well known public figures, especially in the celiac medical research field, at the same time there is an ongoing public media campaign by certain agricultural lobbies to maintain funding for grain subsidies and GMO research, and there could be new labeling rules coming this year, which impact food manufacturer's,   it is a good idea to check the source of the funding.  Which is not obvious at all, here. 

 

 

This UCCD Center website has been changed a bit since the last time I looked at it, so they are becoming aware of people scrutinizing it. 

 

________

:

This has nothing to do with the original question but I'm going to respond. I don't know a lot about the tax laws, but I believe endowments are allowed. It would be silly for a charity not to have " savings " for a capital improvement or to tide it over when donations are low. Or to fund research or perhaps, scholarships.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,374
    • Total Posts
      920,570
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • https://www.facebook.com/groups/SingaporeCeliacs/
    • Today was the big day when I went to the GI and this is the first time I have felt heard about and well taken care of.  I told him about the two celiac blood tests  (in my first post) normal, he said that often happens, even with people who do have celiac and he needed to see the report and pictures from my endoscope.    I had filled out the appropriate Kaiser paperwork for Sutter to send all my medical records, but they ended up sending a celiac disease to me with the records, which Sutter said they could not use.  We also talked about gluten sensitivity v. celiac, and he said a lot of people are sensitive to gluten even if they don't have celiac. He said that my symptoms sound like classic IBS, which can be caused by any number of things.  He asked if I would try the FODMAP diet, which limits certain foods and requires no gluten due to what being He said my symptoms sound like classic IBS, which he said can be caused by any number of things, including gluten sensitivity.  He has asked if I would try the FODMAP diet, which has restricted foods as well as no gluten because most gluten products have wheat in them.  So, since I am planning on going gluten free anyway, and I don't want another endoscope or blood tests if absolutely necessary, I am going to try the FODMAP diet and see what happens. I filled a consent form at the GI office today to have all my records sent to him so he can view the endoscope pathology report and photos.  I have an appointment with a Registered Dietician on September 30, and follow up appointment the GI in 4 months. 
    • gluten-free andee, according to an article on celiac.com  that talks about this subject see this link http://www.celiac.com/articles/24406/1/Celiac-Diease-and-Other-Autoimmune-Diseases-Equals-Low-Inflammatory-Diet/Page1.html Quoting the author "In the author's personal experience, a gluten-free diet has many limitations. The reactivity between alpha gliadin and corn, millet, oats, rice and dairy has been denounced as invalid by gastroenterologists and celiac disease researchers. While at a medical school in Missouri, biopsies did not show improvement in villous atropy until all alpha gliadin sources and corn, millet, rice and oats were removed from the diet."  Note this research is two years old but hilites the problem with non-gluten rice protein that you are having. It is the alpha gliadin sources that it causing the cross reactivity you are experiencing when you eat rice protein's. She says quoting "Celiac disease has gotten the most attention in antibody research, but the current data on cross-reactivity of antibodies is allowing a better understanding of gluten sensitivity. Antigen reactivity to alpha-gliadin can trigger immune attacks on many individuals beyond those with positive DQ 2, DQ 8 and TTG test results. She goes on to say "A low inflammatory diet customized to each person through testing for cross-reactivity or elimination diet protocols is needed to restore a state of health and well-being."  which sounds exactly like what you are doing. If you are still having problems after elminating rice a 30 day elimination of all the alpha gliadin proteins might be in order.  Corn is a common reactivity problem I hear with a gluten allergy from my friends as well as the obvious lactose problems that can be common among celiacs.  But rarely do you hear Rice allergy's brought up in context of a gluten allergy. I am glad you are making progress on finding your triggers. Read the whole article for yourself to see if there are nuggets of truth I did not highlight in my response. I hope this is helpful. Good luck on your journey to health. Posterboy,
    • One other thing - you might be able to tolerate some dairy if it's only the FODMAPs problem. I discovered that many cheese such as cheddar have effectively no lactose. And my wife sometimes makes 24 hour yoghurt, which also has effectively no lactose. Those have been fine for my tummy.
    • I'm new to the forum, so this topic may already have been covered....please forgive me, if that's the case.  I am in the beginning stages of guiding the development of a 504 plan to file for my 6th-grade daughter who was diagnosed with Celiac Disease 2 weeks ago. The diagnosis was made with a biopsy. My first question...A 504 is what's necessary....not just the IHCP, correct or no? I have the Physician's Statement & the Medical Evaluation report from our GI specialist. What else do I need to have at the ready? The team has requested we go ahead and write the IHCP & then include it with the 504.  And my second question...What accommodations have others found relevant to include on the IHCP  & 504? I just watched a 504-Plan webinar I found on this forum & it recommends the following: -access to gluten-free food in classroom & cafeteria - excused absence from activities that use gluten-containing foods or materials -  prevent cross-contamination in school food service - use of microwave to heat personal meals -  bathroom priveleges Is there anything I need to consider adding? My daughter does prefer eating school meals rather than packing a lunch from home & I am concerned about special events, overnight field trips etc. My learning curve is steep. What am I missing? Teach me, please & thanks so much! This forum has already helped me tremendously these past few weeks.
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,450
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Chellygirl
    Joined