Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Cheese Again
0

17 posts in this topic

Other opinions on cheese requested :D

My nutritionist doc (a new one) has just told me never to have cheese again as I am celiac. She said being celiac I will never completely heal my gi tract, and that cheese or dairy more specifically was detrimental to the absorption of vits and mins! Ok, kind of get her... But! Really??!

I know of celiacs that eat cheese... Would that be because they were not so damaged perhaps? .

Any personal opinion welcome. I've been df for 3 months. Tried introducing 1 month ago but got tummy pain.

Thanks

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

All my biopsies were as flat as possible. I eat cheese. Some people without Celiac can't eat cheese because of lactose intolerances. Give it 6 months or a year and try it again.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Where do they find these people ?   <_<  :angry:  :blink:  :huh:  :o  :ph34r:   

 

No, really, is this a licensed medical professional, or a registered dietician, what state, what affiliation ?  Don't have to give a name, just curious.  Do they promote a vegan diet, in general ?  There are some real whack-a-doodles running around the internet right now, and they're hooked into the various lobbies for promoting higher grain consumption or bogus health care related concerns, not whether or not one wishes to consume animal products on personal ethical grounds. 

 

2 bad misinformation statements:

 

1. Being celiac, you will never totally heal G.I. tract

2. cheese/dairy prevents absorption of vitamins & minerals 

 

You could still be a person who cannot handle dairy, as an adult, whether or not you are celiac or gluten intolerant.  This depends mostly on your genetics.  Some herding/agrarian  people evolved to be able to handle cow milk products, and they then moved up out of the "cradle of civilization" in the middle east thousands of years ago, to Europe and western Asia, and spread worldwide.   You could be reacting to the trace contamination of antibiotics in non - organic dairy, for example, and do better with organic or 'grass- fed only' milk products.  You may be sensitive to lactose, the milk sugars.  Or you can be reacting to casein, the milk proteins from cows.  You might be a person who can only handle goat's milk products.   You could still have ongoing damage and not have completely healed up yet, and still have to wait a while to attempt to reintroduce non lactose dairy, to see what happens. 

 

But to issue a blanket statement that "celiacs cannot do dairy, forever," is not accurate, in the least bit.  :angry:  It really depends on a whole host of other factors. 

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am pretty sure you and I have had this discussion before, but I'll pipe in again.

 

Most celiacs can tolerate dairy, soy and everything under the sun ONCE THE VILLI regrow and the GI tract is healed.

 

My doc recommended 6 months DF, then give it a go. I waited 10.

 

I could not tolerate many foods, dairy included, at first but now, I enjoy it just fine. 

 

A blanket statement such as "NO celiacs can ever eat dairy"  is categorically incorrect.

 

Read the book Real Life with Celiac Disease for some honest, accurate info, including nutritional guidance.

 

http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/real-life-with-celiac-disease-melinda-dennis-ms-rd-ldn/1023352792

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All my biopsies were as flat as possible. I eat cheese. Some people without Celiac can't eat cheese because of lactose intolerances. Give it 6 months or a year and try it again.

Thanks, that's what I thought! I am just interested because of all the conflicting advise ! Ugh! I was marsh 3, dunno what I am now... I tried once then decided to leave it for a year, but this nutritionist doctor stumped me!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Where do they find these people ? <_<:angry::blink::huh::o:ph34r:

No, really, is this a licensed medical professional, or a registered dietician, what state, what affiliation ? Don't have to give a name, just curious. Do they promote a vegan diet, in general ? There are some real whack-a-doodles running around the internet right now, and they're hooked into the various lobbies for promoting higher grain consumption or bogus health care related concerns, not whether or not one wishes to consume animal products on personal ethical grounds.

2 bad misinformation statements:

1. Being celiac, you will never totally heal G.I. tract

2. cheese/dairy prevents absorption of vitamins & minerals

You could still be a person who cannot handle dairy, as an adult, whether or not you are celiac or gluten intolerant. This depends mostly on your genetics. Some herding/agrarian people evolved to be able to handle cow milk products, and they then moved up out of the "cradle of civilization" in the middle east thousands of years ago, to Europe and western Asia, and spread worldwide. You could be reacting to the trace contamination of antibiotics in non - organic dairy, for example, and do better with organic or 'grass- fed only' milk products. You may be sensitive to lactose, the milk sugars. Or you can be reacting to casein, the milk proteins from cows. You might be a person who can only handle goat's milk products. You could still have ongoing damage and not have completely healed up yet, and still have to wait a while to attempt to reintroduce non lactose dairy, to see what happens.

But to issue a blanket statement that "celiacs cannot do dairy, forever," is not accurate, in the least bit. :angry: It really depends on a whole host of other factors.

Thanks takala!

You made me smile, thank goodness for people like you!!

I am in the UK. I personally believe we are a little behind on the times with regards to celiac. I lived in London until recently, I had a great doctor, but useless gastroenterologist. This consultant told me I should have healed in 9wks! I was gluten free for 9 weeks before biopsy then told I was not gluten free compliant as my biopsy results showed severe damage.

I have since moved. Again, completely useless doc. Changed again. This last one told me that my allergies (since bring gluten-free) are nothing to do with leaky gut and that leaky gut was a debatable condition.

So. I went privately. A classically trained medical doctor, knew all about leaky gut. Spoke lots of sense, agreed that a lot of my recent allergies were probably to do with leaky gut and an over active immune system etc... Then progressed to tell me that my gut would never heal completely. That I would never be able to eat gluten again (er, hello?!!) and that cheese was off the menu due to celiac being a malabsorption disease. The argument being that cheese 'coats' the mucosa and hinders the absorption of other vits etc.

She tried the old story 'what other animal drinks milk from a different species?/as adults we do not produce as much lactase' blah blah, usual contra dairy arguments. Having been veggie for 25 years I've heard about every possible theory argument on moral and ethical reasons for consumption of dairy or meat etc! I want hard facts! She seemed quite sure and confident that dairy was of no real use in our diet and must be avoided for sure being celiac! I kinda get her point in a way... But can't see that assuming that every meal wasn't a lump of cheese, that it would inhibit vit and min uptake?!

I really missed cheese to start with, dreamt about it too. I'm getting over cheese now slowly, but I must say I agree with you. Makes FAR more sense.

Thanks again :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am pretty sure you and I have had this discussion before, but I'll pipe in again.

Most celiacs can tolerate dairy, soy and everything under the sun ONCE THE VILLI regrow and the GI tract is healed.

My doc recommended 6 months DF, then give it a go. I waited 10.

I could not tolerate many foods, dairy included, at first but now, I enjoy it just fine.

A blanket statement such as "NO celiacs can ever eat dairy" is categorically incorrect.

Read the book Real Life with Celiac Disease for some honest, accurate info, including nutritional guidance.

http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/real-life-with-celiac-disease-melinda-dennis-ms-rd-ldn/1023352792

I will order the book tomorrow thanks for the link. Yes, I know we touched on the subject before, it's just that I saw this new doc, I had high hopes for her and actually she has the been the best so far!

I think she meant that as a celiac we never recover all of our villi, especially if we have been severely affected. Therefore eating dairy coats the villi hindering nutrient absorption. This is why celiacs should not eat dairy!

Not my words, hers! This was only on Thursday, and it has been bothering me for a few days as I really can't believe I will NEVER have a cheesy spud again!! ;) it's been bothering me! I tried cheese reintroduction about 6 weeks ago but it caused tummy ache. So I decided to leave it a year. Happily. But I was surprised by this woman's response. I had high hope for her... I may even show her this thread to see what she says.

Thanks Irishheart, looking forward to reading the book

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never read a medical journal that says "as a celiac we never recover all of our villi"

 

and

 

"Eating dairy coats the villi" --hindering nutrient absorption?????

 

 

what the heck does that even mean?? how does dairy COAT the VILLI

 

Is this exactly what  she said? Are you sure, because this makes NO sense whatsoever, so I am skeptical of her advice. Sorry

 

 

 

You posted:

I think she meant that as a celiac we never recover all of our villi, especially if we have been severely affected. Therefore eating dairy coats the villi hindering nutrient absorption. This is why celiacs should not eat dairy! 
Not my words, hers.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have never read a medical journal that says "as a celiac we never recover all of our villi"

and

"Eating dairy coats the villi" --hindering nutrient absorption?????

what the heck does that even mean?? how does dairy COAT the VILLI

Is this exactly what she said? Are you sure, because this makes NO sense whatsoever, so I am skeptical of her advice. Sorry

You posted:

I think she meant that as a celiac we never recover all of our villi, especially if we have been severely affected. Therefore eating dairy coats the villi hindering nutrient absorption. This is why celiacs should not eat dairy!

Not my words, hers.

I cannot say if word for word this is EXACTLY what she said but I'd say my rendition is 85% there. The meaning however is completely there! She even drew me diagram to show how dairy 'coats' the lining over the villi. She asked me if I'd ever heard the old wives tale, 'drink a pint of milk before you go out drinking alcohol'... Obviously I have. She said there's more truth in it than we know as milk will line the stomach and stop alcohol absorption.

Which is fine and great but I said I thought I was talking about the villi in the small intestine? So she said 'same principle applies'.

She did say that in most people it didn't cause a problem but in celiac disease because of unrecovered damage to lining we had to encourage as much absorption as possible. Again, perhaps not exactly vertabim but pretty much

I'm glad you disagree. It's a shame, she seemed quite well informed otherwise.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Still flabbergasted by that sentence.  :lol:  

 

I do not think "old wives' tales" constitute sound medical advice.

 

The tips of the villi is where lactase, the enzyme that helps us to digest the  lactose in milk is produced.

When the villi grow back, people usually can digest lactose once more.

Some celiacs still have problems with dairy, yes, but not the vast majority.

 

Milk does not "coat the villi" and hinder nutrient absorption. If this were the case, wouldn't ALL people who

drink milk  be malnourished? celiac or not? 

 

May be time for a new dietician??.Or just read for  yourself and carve out a dietary plan. 

 

Look up Shelly Case or Tricia Thompson. REAL celiac R.Ds--their advice may be more helpful. IMHO

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I noticed dairy bothering me way before I noticed gluten. But after reading up on Celiacs and gluten issues, I wonder if down the road, dairy will be okay for me. It'd be nice if it was. I do love cheese and ice cream, lol. 

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Still flabbergasted by that sentence. :lol:

I do not think "old wives' tales" constitute sound medical advice.

The tips of the villi is where lactase, the enzyme that helps us to digest the lactose in milk is produced.

When the villi grow back, people usually can digest lactose once more.

Some celiacs still have problems with dairy, yes, but not the vast majority.

Milk does not "coat the villi" and hinder nutrient absorption. If this were the case, wouldn't ALL people who

drink milk be malnourished? celiac or not?

May be time for a new dietician??.Or just read for yourself and carve out a dietary plan.

Look up Shelly Case or Tricia Thompson. REAL celiac R.Ds--their advice may be more helpful. IMHO

Thanks Irish.

I too was also quite shocked which is why I came on here to ask... I thought it over a few days, looked it up... And thought exactly what you said ... If that the case, wouldn't everyone that ate cheese be malnourished! I have to go back for pee analysis (payed money for it!)... So will seem it to be my last appt with her. I am going to show her this thread too. Perhaps she has further info!!

I will read up, I DO read up! Cheers

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I noticed dairy bothering me way before I noticed gluten. But after reading up on Celiacs and gluten issues, I wonder if down the road, dairy will be okay for me. It'd be nice if it was. I do love cheese and ice cream, lol.

Hi

I always had a diarrhea episode (4weeks long) when I ate too much pizza! And had the classic pale stool thing too! I think it was too much cheese, it was always on a fat overload day that it tipped me over...

I love cheese and ice cream too. I dream of cheesy baked potato, followed by green & blacks dark choc ice cream.... Oooooooo yum! I'm serious too, I dream about!!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am 3.5 months gluten free and I can't have dairy :(  I was still eating dairy until this past week but I was still sick all the time.  Then I finally decided to bite the bullet and get rid of dairy and my stomach bloat, gas, and diarrhea has gone away.  So I am going to do dairy free for 6 months and then try introducing small amounts again.  I don't know what in the world we are supposed to eat when we can't have gluten or dairy!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Everything else, hon! :) It's do-able, I assure you. Hang in there.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am 3.5 months gluten free and I can't have dairy :( I was still eating dairy until this past week but I was still sick all the time. Then I finally decided to bite the bullet and get rid of dairy and my stomach bloat, gas, and diarrhea has gone away. So I am going to do dairy free for 6 months and then try introducing small amounts again. I don't know what in the world we are supposed to eat when we can't have gluten or dairy!

I understand your pain!! I am dairy and gluten free. And corn free (almost worse than gluten cos it's everywhere and in everything)... Caffeine free, citrus free, egg free, processed free. Also asthmatically allergic to dates, quinoa, seeds... Paprika, celery gives me hives... Etc etc, so on and on. It's a nightmare. But it's doable as Irish heart says and knows. I have found the easiest way is to not make food the centre of your life... Easier than it seems. But I just realised the other day how good my skin is looking from all the green juice breakfasts I've been having...

I do get baaaaad cravings sometimes for a nice bit of cheese. Ugh!! Oh well. As long as I live to see my son grow up ANYTHING is worth it!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some doctor's (and savvy celiacs) recommend going dairy free at the beginning because your vili are still healing, making it hard to digest dairy. Dairy won't cause additional damage. (Wow, some "doctors"...)

 

I didn't go dairy-free until a couple years after gluten-free (and held out as long as possible). I seem to be able to handle very small (a nibble) of aged/hard cheese on occasion, and a little bit of butter as long as i overdose on enzymes. I'm holding out hope that I'll be able to tolerate more cheese at some point. That's the one thing I really can't replace.

 

As for eating dairy free, I use almond milk for coffee/cereal. Coconut milk is a great cream substitute. I can't do soy either (which is even worse to avoid than gluten, I swear!), but if you can, then there's a bigger selection of non-dairy products out there.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,132
    • Total Posts
      919,526
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I think the idea of grinding your own at home stems from the thought that flavored coffees might be ground on the same machines.  The grinders in the grocery are not cleaned between uses.  However, I have not found a flavored coffee bean that had gluten, so it's probably not a real concern.  For coffee that comes from a factory ground, I wouldn't worry at all.   Machines would be cleaned between flavors and nothing but coffee could be made on the machines or even in the same building ( everything made would taste/ smell like coffee). if you still have doubts - I went to the International Celiac Disease Symposium a few years back.  This is held every few years in different countries for medical professionals that study and treat Celiac.  They present research, etc.  All food served was gluten-free.  We drank a lot of plain, already ground, coffee!  A lot!   Coffee is not on any lists as a gluten containing food.  Talking legitimate organizations - not some blogger or pseudo- science website.   After all this, if you still doubt that coffee is gluten free...... Then don't drink it!  It leaves more for me!    
    • To answer some of your questions.... Non celiac gluten sensitivity does not cause any damage to the small intestine so that is not the source of the "little holes or bumps".  You need to get her records including the report of the endoscopy to see exactly what it says as well as the pathology report of the biopsies. You should always get medical records anyway & keep a copy for yourself. How many biopsies did he take? There should be a minimum of 4, ideally 6. The small intestine is very vast even in a small child. An adults is the size of a tennis court! That's a whole lot of territory so biopsies can miss damage especially when enough of them are not taken! She has 2 positives on the serum panel. This crap about "weak" positives should be thrown out of the nomenclature! A positive is a positive, weak or not! Her DgP IGG is way over the range and extremely telling. As far as my knowledge goes, there is nothing else that causes a positive DgP IGG other than celiac disease. False positives are really rare and to have 2 false positives would be astronomically rare! You are right & smart that she really does need an official diagnosis! IMHO, keep her on gluten for right now. Get a second opinion pronto & I believe you'll be able to get her a dx based on the 4 out of 5 rule if nothing else. I wouldn't think it's going to take more than a month to get to see another doc for a second opinion. Then you can take her off gluten. Kids heal up really fast, way faster than us old geezers! I'm sure as others  wake up & get on their computers they will be along to voice their knowledge. I am in the eastern time zone & rise before the birds so I was on here early. Hang in there mom! You're doing the right thing!
    • Now that my initial rage has calmed a tad.... your daughter has to fulfill 4 out of 5 of the diagnostic criteria. Second opinion can do a gene test. If positive, then she will have4 out of 5 of the dx criteria to dx without a positive biopsy. See: http://www.gastro.org/news_items/a-biopsy-should-not-be-required-to-make-the-diagnosis which says in part: The presence of signs and symptoms compatible with celiac disease. Positive serology screening (high serum levels of anti-TTG and/or EMA). Presence of the predisposing genes HLA-DQ2 and/or –DQ8. Histological evidence of auto-insult of jejunal mucosa typical of celiac disease. Resolution of the symptoms and normalization of serology test following the implementation of a gluten-free diet.   Also see: http://www.tenderfoodie.com/blog/2014/5/1/dr-fasano-on-new-gut-autoimmune-research-autism-clearing-up.html She can get a dx after her symptoms resolve on a gluten-free diet!
    • OMG!!!! The doc wants her to get sicker & sicker & do further damage so he can diagnose her? Don't do me any favors doc!!! I'm so spitting med right now I can't even speak! Find a new doc, take the records & get a second opinion. Maybe the next doc will have a freaking brain & dx your daughter. She should be dx'd! This is absurd in the extreme. The very least that should happen is the doc give her a dx now & then in a year or 2 have her do a gluten challenge & do a biopsy all over again but seriously, that would be just as cruel as what he's doing now. He's an ASS!
    • Celiac disease may lead to a host of other inflammatory, gluten-related ... Fortunately, Diet Doc offers gluten-free diet plans which are customized to ... View the full article
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,167
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    jen4az
    Joined