Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Peanut Butter Contamination
0

16 posts in this topic

About three months ago I realized that peanut butter always made me sick, so I assumed I had a peanut intolerance and stopped eating them. Well, my mother has been trying to find gluten-free peanuts and nearly every package she finds is made in the same facility as wheat products. She was thinking that it's possible that the peanut butter I eat is contaminated since my symptoms are nearly the same. Even though the company tells me their PB is gluten-free, they may not be aware that the peanuts they buy are shelled in facilities that also contain wheat. Does anyone know if peanuts are usually contaminated? Are PB manufacturers required to label their product with "may contain wheat" in this case. Is there a way to find out where peanuts in a certain brand of PB are shelled?

And a related question - is a peanut intolerance similar to gluten in that it causes intestinal damage? I won't eat something if it's made in the same facility as wheat, but I'm not nearly that careful with peanuts and I haven't had any symptoms from possible peanut contamination. Will I be damaging my body if I do get trace amounts of peanuts even if I don't feel symptoms.

And because I know all of you ask such thorough questions - No, my PB is not being contaminated by double dipping because I live alone, and I get sick from nearly every brand of PB I eat. Thanks everyone!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Don't know what brands you've been trying, but I only eat the natural peanut butter. It's just peanuts and salt. Can't get any more "peanutty-er" than that! A good health food store will sometimes grind it right there for you fresh, which is great if you have that option. Certified organic peanuts might be handled in a dedicated facility, thus avoiding the CC.

I don't believe a peanut reaction would actually do intestinal damage. Never saw any references to any such thing.

Now, as for eliminating the CC, suppose you buy peanuts in the shell so you can "unshell" them (or whatever the term is) yourself, throw them into a blender and viola! Fresh peanut butter. Of course roast them first if you like.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ummm... anyone else using your pb? You ever use PB to spread on non-gluten-free food? etc? I would think your source of contimantion is much closer to home.

We get Kroger Natural Peanutbutter which is only peanuts and salt in the ingredients and my son has never reacted to it. CC at the factory is a risk with all foods at all times, theres a point when you give up and take a little risk. :(

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just throwing out another idea--could you be intolerant to legumes? I get intestinal symptoms from peanuts as well as soy, peas, and beans of all types. I love peanut butter, and tried to find a brand that agreed with me. When I began to test myself with the other legumes and peanuts, I realized I was intolerant.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess you could test this by eating some peanuts that you shell yourself. If you react to them, it's pretty sure you're reacting to the peanuts themselves and not to a possible cc with gluten.

I don't know if there's any research about other intolerances and possible damage... I avoid eating all legumes, including peanuts, because they give me gas and loose stools, but I don't look out for trace amounts. I feel generally very healthy so I think it's ok, but I don't have any more proof of it than that.

Pauliina

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




RiceGuy - I have tried all natual PB as well as brands like Skippy and both make me sick. Still, I'm not sure being all natual guarantees anything about whether the peanuts were shelled in a facility with wheat.

VydorScope - I knew someone was going to ask about possible contamination in my own home! No, it's not possible, I live alone, and I only allow gluten-free foods in my apartment. Unless the little gluten elves are sneaking in at night and putting gluten in my PB!

jerseyangel - I've considered a legume intolerance, but I don't get sick from eating any of the other legumes, so I think it's just a peanut thing.

aikiducky - good idea about buying the shell-it-yourself peanuts! I don't know why I didn't think of this one myself... Thanks!

So it seems like if a PB says it's gluten-free, it probably is, and I'm just back to having a peanut intolerance. Which is too bad, because I do like my peanuts. Oh how I will miss peanut butter cups and snickers bars...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Unless the little gluten elves are sneaking in at night and putting gluten in my PB!
They are shifty and underhanded!

I think I'm sensitive to peanuts myself. I get loose bowels sometimes after eating peanuts or peanut butter. I think the idea of trying peanuts alone is a good one.

If you have to give up the peanuts you could try almond butter. I wish they'd put salt in it though, it always comes unsalted!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe you have a peanut allergy? I just developed an allergy to peanuts.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
RiceGuy - I have tried all natual PB as well as brands like Skippy and both make me sick. Still, I'm not sure being all natual guarantees anything about whether the peanuts were shelled in a facility with wheat.

VydorScope - I knew someone was going to ask about possible contamination in my own home! No, it's not possible, I live alone, and I only allow gluten-free foods in my apartment. Unless the little gluten elves are sneaking in at night and putting gluten in my PB!

jerseyangel - I've considered a legume intolerance, but I don't get sick from eating any of the other legumes, so I think it's just a peanut thing.

aikiducky - good idea about buying the shell-it-yourself peanuts! I don't know why I didn't think of this one myself... Thanks!

So it seems like if a PB says it's gluten-free, it probably is, and I'm just back to having a peanut intolerance. Which is too bad, because I do like my peanuts. Oh how I will miss peanut butter cups and snickers bars...

Yep, it sounds like you need to aviod peanuts in general. :( Sorry, was hopping it was simpler cc from other ppls. :(

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just read recently that you can buy peanut butter certified to not contain the mold that causes so many of our peanut allergies. I have eaten almond butter for years ... I've heard this peanut butter is carried by Wild Oats (their brand name, though when I read their jars I didn't see mention of it). I'm happy with my almond butter, but this might be something you want to research.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For a peanut butter alternative, you might look into Peabutter. I haven't had to try it, so I can't say how it tastes.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For a peanut butter alternative, you might look into Peabutter. I haven't had to try it, so I can't say how it tastes.

I've tried it, and it isn't bad at all! It has a smoother taste than peanut butter--not as good as the real thing, though. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I made a roasted pumpkinseed butter that had the exact texture of peanut butter. The flavor was different, and the color could best be compared to woodchuck poo.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I personally like the theory of little elves putting gluten in. If thats the case, then elves in my house must be busy with my intolerances! haha!

regardless of the elves, I hope you figure it out. :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I should try some of that peabutter. I did find sunflower seed butter at my local Cub Foods and that's pretty good. It's got the same consistency as PB, just has a slightly more sunflower seedy taste. Which you barely notice if you're putting it in a sandwich.

Carla - do you have any more information on the mold-free PB? Is there any way to tell if someone is allergic/intolerant to the mold in peanuts rather than the peanuts themselves? What kind of mold is it in peanuts? I'm asking mainly because I have a doctor's appointment on Thursday, and I was going to ask for some food allergy testing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use sunflowerseed butter as an alternative to peanut butter. if it's making you sick, it's making you sick. I would check by trying peanuts (whole) on their own (IF and ONLY IF you're certain its not an anaphylactic allergy), but you might just not do well with peanuts.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,667
    • Total Posts
      921,670
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Marip, Have you been diagnosed with celiac disease or Non-celiac Gluten Intolerance?  I notice you joined in 2014.  Did you ever go guten free?  How can we help?   Sorry, I'm not a stool expert!  You could Google it...  Malabsorption?  Standard lab tests that check for anemia and vitamin deficiencies, etc.  should help make that diagnosis.  
    • You can eat just a slice or two (or equivalent) of bread a day for accurate testing.   I understand about the high deductibles.  We're self-employed and we pay for our health insurance. 
    • Sure, if it's gluten free, then fine.  I am very allergic (like anaphylactic) to ibuprofen and aspirin.  So, in my case, I would just tough it out.  Go to bed.  Sleep it off.....eventually. My money is on the garlic and onions.  I can't consume those either (damn that zonulin/leaky gut -- google it along with Dr. Fasano).  I just season with salt, pepper.  Boring.  But no gut issues.  I'm hoping like my lactose intolerance (resolved), that I will get garlic and onions back.   Finally, sometimes just eating anything can hurt when you still have intestinal damage.  Hopefully, you'll feel better in two or three hours if it's celiac related.  Longer if it's an intolerance (leaky gut thing....) Hugs!      
    • I read on their website that all Advil is gluten free, I had such bad pinching cramping today(which I don't why since I prepared all my food at home today.) I made a pot roast, salt garlic, onions...No gluten but still pain, That's the only thing I ate today..I don't eat breakfast or anything.   Anyways.   Is it a good idea to take Advil for the cramping? That's how I would describe it like someone is reaching inside me and pinching me and twisting my insides.    This is what I took  
    • I'll give my PCP a call tomorrow and see what they can offer. My only worry is the expense as anymore tests will put me behind in being able to afford to see the GI. I have high deductible insurance but get money put into my HSA. I'm still trying to pay off the CT scan though. Which is why I'm trying to pick and choose which poses the greatest risk for me right now and what can wait. (Though I would prefer not to wait on any of it.)

      I really do hope its only IBS. Though I always worry IBS is more or less a doctors way of saying "I have no clue" at that point. :C

      Again, I'll be sure to give my PCP a call tomorrow then and see what the options are. I can feel a lot better trying the blood work first. however, once that is done, do I still need to be on a gluten diet before the endoscopy? Also, is it ok if I still mildly reduce the gluten. As in, can I avoid a whole wheat pasta dinner, but still be eating the peanut butter crackers? That sort of thing. Again I guess that is more of a doctor related question. I just wasn't sure if in order to raise your chance, you have to mass consume gluten or not. (Its already in just about everything to begin with.)   --Edit--
      I just now reread the part that you still need to be on the gluten foods even for biopsy so I'll be sure to do that too.
       
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,666
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    epalmer9
    Joined