Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Coping With Mis-diagnosis
0

11 posts in this topic

I'm writing this because perhaps there is someone else who's hearing the same thing about those with a prior diagnosis that's being reversed.

I have a co-worker, with whom I happened to share the gluten-intolerance issue with who mentions to me that his mother was diagnosed with this about 15 years ago. (here I am thinking, wow...) Then for some strange reason a doctor tells her that she has never had this problem, she should never have gone gluten-free. So, guess what? She's now off the diet after all of those years. ok... :blink:

Then, my grandmother mentions that one of her friends had the same thing.. years and years on the diet, only for a doctor to reverse the diagnosis. She is now also off the gluten-free diet. ok... :blink:

Shame on me for not asking what the issue "really" was, but I didn't think about it until later. Here I am talking with my family and friends about the change in my life and I'm hearing all of this refuted information... that's why I put this in the "Coping" section rather than the "Doctors" section because they all make mistakes (they're human like us). Believe me, this by no means will deter me from going gluten-free and sticking strictly to it. I know I have a problem with gluten... there's no doubt in my mind.

I just had to get this off my chest, as I've heard this issue twice in the past month! I wonder if the 2nd doctors in these cases knew that if their patients were on a gluten-free diet, the blood & biopsy wouldn't show anything unusual. I wonder what led the 1st doctors to give the diagnosis in the first place (I'm assuming it was more difficult then to get a diagnosis than now) What are these doctors doing? Maybe this should be in the "Doctors" section after all... :blink:

Gretchen

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

That's why they call it a medical 'practice'. They are all still practicing and WE are their guinea pigs. :lol: Maybe someday they will get it right. Sometimes practice makes perfect. But I'm not so sure with some doctors who are working with outdated celiac 'profiles' and other celiac myths and misinformation. <_<

Fortunately we know our own bodies better than any doctor can tell us with all their sophisticated tests. I still think reduction of symptoms following a gluten-free diet is a pretty good diagnostic test in itself. However, my second choice is Enterolab. :D

BURDEE

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know what to think of that. It seems... backwards. Yet another sign that a lot more education is needed for doctors who are going to toy in this field. (Though, quite frankly, any doctor who's been through basic bio-chemistry ought to be able to deduce from first principles that your test will be negative if you haven't been eating gluten, so there's really no excuse, even with a lack of education on the specifics of the disease.)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Celiac is one of the most mis-diagnosed problems in North Amercia. The reason is that Doctors here thought of it as a "rare" disorder. NOW they are starting to realize how common it is and are working harder to understand it. I think that if we were in Europe (where Celiac has been understood for longer) we wouldn't be hearing as much about the mistakes the doctors make. Sure they are human, and will make mistakes, but we will see less, I think, as the doctors realize how common Celiac is.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Celiac is one of the most mis-diagnosed problems in North Amercia. The reason is that Doctors here thought of it as a "rare" disorder. NOW they are starting to realize how common it is and are working harder to understand it. I think that if we were in Europe (where Celiac has been understood for longer) we wouldn't be hearing as much about the mistakes the doctors make. Sure they are human, and will make mistakes, but we will see less, I think, as the doctors realize how common Celiac is.

You should try being dignosed over in Australia - only how many years behind? lol

A thought on the diagnosis reversal though... is it possible that because they have been gluten-free for so long that they no longer have the symptoms on being tested (fairly logical if gluten-free), but that if they return to eating gluten it'll have to be reversed again?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




That's what I'm thinking, Mydnyt. I don't know what upsets me more... the celiac diagnosis loss of credibility or the fact that these people might still be celiac and are now hurting their bodies.

As beautiful as Australia is, I sure glad I'm not there through the diagnosis.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd just hope that they get themselves retested after being on gluten for a while and not wait for any serious symptoms.

Yeah, a bit behind everyone sometimes... but I've been lucky. Only 5 yrs before a new GP figured this out, and the only other prob I have my old GP picked up straight away :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have had a diagnosis flip flop since 1989.

I was originally diagnosed with Celiac Disease back in 1989. After a year on the diet with no improvement, the dr. changed his diagnosis to Crohns. Well, 2 years ago, the bloodwork and biopsy confirmed Celiac Disease 100%. So I have been back and forth, back and forth.... Oh well, at least now I know 100% for sure what it is and just have to give it more time than 1 year (almost 2 yrs. on the diet and still no change in the diarrhea)......

Karen

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Karen, have you determined if you have other food intolerances that are contributing to the problem?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right now he has me on also a dairy free/sugar free/caffeine free/soy free diet along with the gluten free...... at least until I have the colonoscopy on September 28th. The results of the blood tests will tell us which way to go from here.... he is checking for numerous things, i.e. collagenous colitis....

I have to admit that since I have been dairy free, the gas and bloating have just about disappeared.... we just can't get rid of this darn diarrhea!!!!

Karen

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm right there with ya, Karen! I can't get rid of mine, either! Being gluten-free helped me gain all my weight back, and added a little energy, but nothing else has changed at all. My antibodies are still high and I still have lower back pain, abdominal bloating and pain, and a rapid heart rate. Being gluten-free wasn't the cure I was hoping for.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,341
    • Total Posts
      920,478
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • As a GI specialty nurse who also has celiac I can tell you that it can not be diagnosed by CT and rarely unless you have severe disease can it be diagnosed by colonoscopy.  Those that have had it diagnosed by colonoscopy have such because their MDs were above to get into the small bowel from the bottom and take biopsys.  Celiac damage is not seen in the large intestine.  Also many people do not have diarrhea, many have constipation or a 50/50 mix between the two.  Celiac has 300 connected symptoms and sometimes no symptoms at all.  It's called the " great pretender" because of this.
    • Okay, thanks! I am 24 but my husband and I don't plan on having kids. However, the more I thought about it, the more I think I should get one for my brother's sake. Especially after my doctor's office called this evening to say my bloodwork tested positive for Celiac. Guess I will be on this forum longer than I thought!
    • You just got diagnosed Celiac and are wondering how serious this really is. What if there is just a little gluten in your food? What if you use the same toaster for your gluten-free bread as your wife's/husband's regular bread? What if those french fries are gluten-free but they fry them in the same fryer as those nice gluten coated onion rings? View the full article
    • Hi, I've never been on a forum before but thought I might find some answers here.  I have never been tested for celiac but a nurse practitioner I saw a few years ago told me she thought I would benefit from a gluten free diet.  At first, I thought I could never do this but after some encouragement I did try.  I did feel much better after going gluten free.  She never tested me for celiac. I turned 50 years old last year and I had a colonoscopy for the first time and had three polyps removed.  The surgeon said that my colon looked like I was a chronic laxative user.  I haven't used a laxative for a very long time.  I was at the time drinking a natural tea to help me to have bowel movements.  Before starting the tea I had always had difficulty with bowel movements and never had them once a day but with the tea I was able to go once a day. At the end of last month I developed severe pain after I would eat (I had my gallbladder removed at the age of 19).  One night the pain got so bad my husband had to drive me to the ER.  My liver functions were high as well as a few other things.  They did a CT scan of my abdomen and pelvis that showed wall thickening of my transverse colon and minimal irregularity involving the transverse colon.  My descending and sigmoid colon were collapsed.  There were a few tiny mesenteric lymph nodes present on the right.  They diagnosed me officially with colitis but said that most likely I had a gallstone (even though I don't have a gallbladder) that had come from the liver and had gotten stuck in the common bile duct (it did not show up on the CT scan).  I usually have a high ferritin level too.  I've been home from the hospital stay for about a month now and still have tenderness in the epigastric area. Some of this may not have anything to do with celiac but was wondering if anyone has been diagnosed with celiac by CT scan or colonoscopy or if anyone has had the same problems that I have had and found out what has caused it.  I cannot see the gastroenterologist who saw me in the hospital for a couple of months.  Can you have celiac and not have diarrhea as I am just the opposite? Any help would be appreciated!  Thanks!  
    • I had an acne flair up after going gluten free but it ended up improving and some long-term back acne I had been dealing with actually went away.  I think going gluten free was a shock to my system and at first I actually felt worse but after about a month things got better. 
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,411
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Aly46
    Joined