Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Conflicting Diagnoses?
0

11 posts in this topic

In march of 2004, following c/o of constipation, frequent loose stools, tummy aches and fatigue, my son was diagnosed with gluten intolerance. His bloodwork was normal except for low iron and an IgG of 117 (norm is up to 22). His doc (a family practice doc) said that very high IgG was enough to start him on a gluten-free diet.

We went for another opininion with a ped. gastroenterologist. After completing just about the same tests, he said that my son was G.I. and just put him on iron supplements for low iron. My family doc strongly disagrees with this dx and wants him to have a biopsy. I'm wondering if the biopsy comes back negative, is the IgG level enough for a G.I. diagnosis and could it indicate any other disease that might be overlooked?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

If G.I. means gluten intolerant, the daignoses are pretty much the same. Even though they are techinically different, the end result is the same: no gluten whatsoever for the rest of his life. I wouldn't worry too much about it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oops! I meant to say that the ped gastroenterologist said that my son was probablt not gluten intolerant.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I keep on reading posts from moms whose kids are told by GI docs that the elevated IgG means nothing and does not support a gluten free diet. GRRR!!!

The problem with these narrow minded GI docs is that they refuse to accept or see that gluten intolerance is what causes Celiac's disease! If somone develops a gluten intolerance they should not be eating gluten. If they do it will most surely lead to one or more auto immune disorders.

My son had the same experience and without a positive endoscopy the GI would not recommend a gluten-free diet.

The tremendously high IgG level indicates that his body is currently at war with gliadin. Continued consumption will only exaccerbate the problem. His response to a gluten free diet along with the blood results would be enough in my eyes to keep him gluten-free and label him gluten intolerant.

Priscilla

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did your son go gluten-free and if so, did he start improving? If the answer is yes, then I think you have your answer.

richard

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Gigimom: I agree with Richard. -- Many, many years before my husband was diagnosed as having Celiac Disease, he was misdiagnosed by no less than 4 gastroenterologists as having IBS or colitis. My point is, just because the person has a medical degree it doesn't mean that they are always correct. Heck, we ran into 4 of them! Sometimes professional jealousy takes over, especially when the Primary care doctor is correct then the specialist tries to countermand their diagnosis due to it, and sometimes vice versa.

After the specialist pronounced my husband last Autumn as celiac, his primary care doctor expresed skepticism and said the blood tests were in his opinion inconclusive. Well, the gluten free diet proved the gastro correct.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:blink: I think many of us here on the board have had similar circumstances with our doctors. First off, I respect the education that it takes to become a bonified physician but to swallow one's pride and admit that "I don't have all the answers and I am still learning" (sometimes from my patients) is indicative to a great doctor!

When I was dx'd as having Microscopic Colitis last year from biopsies from the colon my GI said that I should avoid simple carbs. He said I could eat wheat! I began my venture on the internet and investigating this syndrome. I saw how it is connected to celiac/gluten sensitivity and began to question whether wheat derived foods had an influence. It most certainly does in my case.

I have the main gene that predisposes to gluten sensitivity and celiac sprue. That was found through Enterolab testing of mouth swab dna and stool samples. I was having upper leg pain, backaches, headaches, lower left sided abdominal pain, diarrhea/constipation; these have all been significantly reduced when I took wheat out of my diet. I also stopped taking advil/ibuprophen and just use tylenol when needed.Constipation is indicative to a gluten intolerance.

I wonder how many individuals who have been dx'd with IBS are really celiac or gluten sensitive?

That is rather scary isn't it.

I am so glad that we have the internet which opens us up to education, health and healing.

Keep your stress down too~ that contributes to gut problems as well

Mary

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

mary-

I think about the same thing- how many people who are diagnosed with IBS (Me, for ten years) have celiac. I saw an add for ddrugs on TV the other day to help with IBS, and I got really mad. Here is this ad, full of women running through feilds because they aren't boated anymore. How much damage can these drugs be doing to undiagnosed celiacs by masking symptoms and giving another false road to exlore before diagnosis.

After ten years of getting progressively sicker ( I am 24), Knowing what is truly going on in my body (versus the useless IBS) has changed my life. I have been gluten-free for 10 months nbow, and have started mountain bike racing! This from a girl who used to ihabit the couch!

Lib

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just wanted to add something in the doctors' defense...my 3 year old daughter has been undergoing testing the past year for loose, foul smelling stools. We've seen two peds, two ped GI's and an allergist. She had a colonoscopy which showed colitis. Amongst many other tests, they did the celiac panel which showed elevated IgA's and IgG's, though the other two were negative. Anyway, it's possible to have elevated anti-gliadin antibodies due to the "leaky gut" effect. If you have any inflammation in the small bowel or colon, food proteins can leak out. You can then develop antibodies against the food protein circulating in the blood. Once the inflammation in the GI tract subsides, this effect should subside as well and the antibodies should decrease.

I'm not 100% convinced of my daughter's diagnosis, though the docs have been great. We are retesting her celiac panel next week to see if the numbers have decreased now that she's on anti-inflammatory meds for her colitis. (By the way, her symptoms have improved significantly.) Anyway, I just wanted to pass this bit of info along...Hope this helps some people understand a little better!

Sue

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's been a while since I posted my first question. I just wanted to update. We did go through with the biopsy on the advise of my family doc and my son was positive for celiac disease. In the meantime, a letter came from the ped. gastroenterologist stating that my son did not have celiac disease. We decided to test my 4 year old son and his IgG was at almost the same level as my first son. What concerns me is that he had very few symptoms other than being very emotionally sensitive and slight and occasional constipation. How many other kids are out there falling through the cracks? oh yeah, another symptom that set off little alarms in my head were large cavities even though we are diligent about oral hygeine. Aren't tooth enamel deficits a symptom of celiac disease? Now we are having trouble convincing family members with symptoms to believe that they should be tested. We have no family history of the disease that anybody can recall. We are checking into the possibility of genetic testing to see where this could have come from -- this might help convince other family members.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the link to enamel defects is fairly well known... amongst the educated dentists/doctors. ;-) you might send the biopsy results back to the doc who didn't think he was GI, just to let him know.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,137
    • Total Posts
      919,540
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • My DH was diagnosed with celiac disease several months ago and I was just getting a handle on baking again, turning out gluten free quick breads, muffins, biscuits, breads and cakes like a champ when.....more allergies. Now we are gluten free, dairy free, egg free.....and rice free. Yikes. I've converted to almond and coconut milk, that was a breeze. Vegan egg substitute just made its way into the house for baking and I have high hopes, though I haven't used it yet.  I need a gluten free flour blend that doesn't contain rice flour. On hand I have oat, coconut, sorghum, fufu and amaranth flours, potato starch, corn starch, and xanthan gum. I need a mix that will use what I have on hand, and that will work for quick breads like banana and pumpkin bread.  Anyone have a recipe that has worked for them in the past?
    • Thankyou so much that's really helpful I did wonder about dairy as I seem to bloat a little after a coffee with milk
    • Love your attitude - it will really help you going forward (I was you three years ago...) Don't be surprised as time goes on if you have a lull in your fortitude.  Every once in a while I see (or smell!) a food I really miss, or have an accidental glutening that sets me back, or someone that doesn't understand my issues and thinks I'm a faddist.  I've learned to let myself have a sulk and a pity party and then move on.   Good luck!
    • Hi Natalie, That sounds like how it often goes after beginning the gluten-free diet.  We'd like to think that it would be steady progress in the up direction but it seems like our healing goes back and forth a little.  The immune system reaction takes a while to settle down, weeks to months.  So it is hard for the gut to heal while that reaction is going on. It's helpful to eat simple foods at first and avoid dairy.  Processed foods including baked goods are best left on the shelf.  Try to eat whole foods only including meats, vegetables and nuts.  Carbs and sugar are not helpful. Things should get better after a month or two if your diet is clean of gluten and diary.  Then you can try adding things back in slowly one item a week. Peppermint tea can help with bloating.  Probiotics may help too. Welcome to the forum!
    • like I said I am new and just learning ...   Is Mirlax gluten free
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,170
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    trecio
    Joined