Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Confusion
0

8 posts in this topic

Hi again,

After reading these posts about this condition {celiac disease}, I thought

I was clear about the difference between wheat allergy, which I have,

gluten intolerance, and gluten insensitivity. however, some people seem

to interchange them.If you have intolerance and /or sensitivity do you actually have celiac disease? Or if not ,is intolerance and/ or sensitivity more like wheat allergy which

will probably never develop into celiac disease?

Also can the difference be determined by a blood test? If so, which one determines

which condition?

Also I read somewhere, wish I could remember, that if you have a wheat allergy

the damage done to the sm intestine can only be down 3 levels whereas,

a person with celiac disease can have damage to level 5. Can anyone comment on that

and where I could find more information on these facts. I was so sick when I

last saw the GI doc that I didn't feel much like asking questions.Although he

didn't explain much, he has done a lot in diagnosing celiac disease. He found a 100

new cases in the past year in the small Pennsylvania town where he practices...

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Hi Judy,

If you have a wheat allergy, then you shouldn't have any intestinal damage. Only gluten intolerance causes damage. The difference between gluten intolerance/sensitivity and celiac disease is the stage of the damage. Some people never progress to the degree of damage doctors want to see in order to diagnose celiac disease, but it doesn't really matter since the treament is the same. Lifelong adherance to the gluten free diet. The problem arises when the doctor says,"You don't have celiac disease. Gluten is not your problem." This leaves a lot of gluten intolerant people in the dark. They trust the doctor and stay on gluten. IBS is the most common diagnosis for undiagnosed gluten intolerant people. Blood tests can detect the level of antibodies in your blood, assuming you are in an advanced enough stage to develop enough antibodies to gluten that cross over from your intesting to your blood. If you are not producing very many antibodies you will test negative on the blood test and be told you don't have it. Most will never get to a biopsy if they test negative on the blood test. And if they do they will often test negative on the biopsy as well.

One of the best new tests out there (but not yet accepted by the mainstream medical field) is the stool tests for Gluten Sensitivity offered by Dr. Kenneth Fine at Enterolab . They are the most sensitive and are able to find gluten intolerance/sensitivity at an early stage, well before most conventional medical doctors would give you a diagnosis. Many people who test negative on the conventional blood tests/biopsy will test positive on these stool tests.

It is possible to have both gluten intolerance and a wheat allergy. The difference is that a wheat allergy will cause symptoms such as rash, itching, sometimes breathing problems, etc. and is mediated by IgE (immunoglobulin E), and an intolerance is a reaction against the offending food that happend in the intestines and is mediated by IgA (immunoglobulin A).

I hope I helped to answer your questions.

God bless,

Mariann :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi,

I just wanted to thank Marian for the useful information. I was told after undergoing a biopsy that I definately did not have celiac disease. All my blood work was also inconclusive. I decided to follow a gluten-free diet 7 months ago and I am finally feeling well (except for the unintentional ingestion of gluten.) I am so frusterated with the inability to diagnose this disease. Do you know if the stool test works for someone on a gluten-free diet?

thanks Donna

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Donna,

The stool test can be used while gluten-free, but it really is just to check to see if you are getting any accidental gluten. The antibodies will continue to be present for a while in your intestine while gluten free. The length of time varies for each person, but for a few months at least. Dr. Fine does not recommend going off gluten for testing. He recommends having the gene test done if you have been gluten-free for a while. This will not tell you if you have Celiac Disease, but it will tell you if you carry the gene(s) to support the diagnosis. This way you could safely rule out Celiac Disease if you did not have the gene(s). Check out their website. I ended up using their tests after the conventional medical testing failed me. I was negative on the blood tests and the biopsy, but positive on the stool test, and gene test. I'm one of those people who have "slipped through the cracks" and that is the people Dr. Fine hopes to help the most. He has Celiac Disease himself and knows how hard it is to get a diagnosis before the onset of severe illness. You have to be half dead before most doctors will even consider celiac disease!

God bless,

Mariann :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mariann,

I found the article about levels of damage on this web site under Site

Index, Allergy vs Intolerance, by Kemp Randolph, Will ther foods

affect the Villi. Question and answer on milk and eggs. I wish I knew

about doing the "Quote" so that I could post it here..

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Mariann,

This is the quote I wanted to run by you.

Do you think all of these food allergies can cause damage

but no wheat? Scroll down, I hope I did this right, thanks Mariann!

Copyright

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It has never seemed quite right to me that celiac isn't considered an allergy just because it doesn't trigger an IgE response (but instead triggers an IgG and IgA response). There's a wonderful book by Jonathan Brostoff (Food Allergies and Food Intolerances) that talks about the differences between allergies & intolerances and the history of western medicine's focus on IgE responses.

My recollection is that western medicine focused on IgE responses, partly due to the fact that some IgE responses can cause anaphylaxis, and ignored IgG, IgA and other immunological respoonses for a very long time. Everything not IgE was relegated to the category of "intolerance" even though IgG and IgA symptoms can be as severe (or more severe) that IgE responses.

Personally, my IgG casein response is more painful and long-lasting than my IgE almond allergy. And most of us would agree, I think, that our IgG and IgA responses to gluten are nothing to trifle with.

After reading this book and getting a better understanding of the rather arbitrary distinction (medically speaking) between allergy and intolerance (e.g. why is IgE so different that IgG and IgA?), I have no trouble thinking of celiac as an allergy. If there are any immunologists out there reading this, I'm interested in your opinions on this topic. I have noticed that many labs / phyicians are now choosing to refer to IgG and IgA responses as "allergies" - do a google on "food allergy IgG" and you'll see what I mean.

Okay, that's enough on this topic. Can you tell this is a button for me? THere's nothing like arbitrary western medicine to get me going.

cheers, Laurie

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You know, I've just recently started telling people about the fact that I have celiac disease. They don't understand Celiac Disease, or gluten intolerance, but they do understand allergy. I just say that I am allergic to gluten, which is part of wheat and also casein which is part of milk, and they seem to understand. And I know it bugs some celiacs since it is technically not an allergy, but it is so much easier to get through to people that way. But people don't always get it. I had a lady tonight tell me that I should be able to eat the cake she made, since it contained only "white flour", not wheat. Well I explained to her gently that white flour is made from wheat, and then she seemed to think about it and she looked at the table full of desserts and said astonished, "Well what can you eat?" I could eat the cookies I brought! And everyone loved them. So it made me feel good.

I agree that they should just call it a food allergy. My soy allergy is nothing compared to my reactions from gluten and casein!

God bless,

Mariann

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,644
    • Total Posts
      921,583
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • The first two tests (at least in the US and most of the EU) have been replaced by the DGP tests (at the bottom) of GFinDC's list of celiac tests.  Not all celiacs test positive to the common Screening TTG.   The TTg is good and catches most and it was cheaper to run the best one (it is all about the money), but researchers realized they were not catching all celiacs.  Here is a link to the University of Chicago's celiac website.  When I was diagnosed three years ago, this site recommended just the TTg (as did the American GI Association).  Now they have expanded the list of celiac tests.   http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/screening/ Luckily, my GI must have just attended a GI conference and he ordered the complete panel for me.  ($400). It paid off.  Only my DGP IGA was positive and the rest of the blood panel (including the popular TTG test) was negative.  My biopsies revealed some severe intestinal damage.  My new health provider only allows PCP/GP doctors to only order the TTG.  So, if I want the follow-up testing to see if I have improved or had a gluten exposure, I must go to my New GI.  Yep, it is all about the money!   Keep eating gluten and make sure your  GI takes four to six samples during the endoscopy.  Maintain copies of all your results.   Your symptoms?  Yes, there are over 300 celiac disease symptoms.  celiac disease does not just affect the gut, but mis-informed and those who do not keep up with the latest in medical, do not seem to know that!   Do not give up!  
    • It's great to hear from you, Nightsky.  Glad to also hear of your steady progress.  Living gluten free is definitely a learning process, and even the baby steps are times to celebrate.  Wish you all the luck in the world as you continue to heal for the glutenization.  
    • Hi Nicky, When you first go gluten-free your symptoms often do change.  Feeling better or worse is possible.  The healing process is a major change in our gut and that means a big change in the gut flora is likely,  which can cause symptoms by itself.  Additionally the immune system doesn't stop making antibodies on a dime.  the immune system keeps working  to defeat the gluten invaders until it is darn good and ready to take a break. You really shouldn't start the gluten-free diet until all testing is completed.  That includes a full celiac disease panel and an endoscopy with biopsy samples.  It's much easier to complete testing while still a gluten eater than it is to stop gluten and go  back on it for testing later.
    • Hi Kircket, Welcome to the forum! Yes, he could be wrong.  Not everyone passes the blood tests.  And they are just one part of the diagnostic process anyway, although an important one.   Did you have the complete celiac antibodies panel? Anti-Gliadin (AGA) IgA
      Anti-Gliadin (AGA) IgG
      Anti-Endomysial (EMA) IgA
      Anti-Tissue Transglutaminase (tTG) IgA
      Deamidated Gliadin Peptide (DGP) IgA and IgG
      Total Serum IgA If you didn't have the full celiac disease antibodies test panel, I'd insist on getting it done.  There have been numerous people on the forum who tested positive on one antibody but not on others.
    • Three years ago I lost about 40kgs (Aussie lol) by better diet & exercise. All was going great til I stopped losing. I upped my exercise but bizarrely started gaining weight. One night a week of not being able to sleep soon became two, then virtually every night with either 1-2hrs tops or none at all. These weird symptoms started about two years ago, becoming worse in say, the last 9mnths. Then I started to get diarrhea. Occasionally then weirdly 2-3 days with multiple occurences then a day or two with nothing, then back to loose & offensive. My GP ran tests, including the TTga (hope that's  right) antibody blood test. Negative so he tells me that's not it. After 9mnths of this he shrugs and says, "I don't know what it is I've run out of ideas what ideas do you have?" Finally refers me to a gastrointerogist.  Private, of course and can't really afford it but we (my fiance and I) go. Stools and blood samples are ordered, basically bye, see you in a month. I have looked my symptoms up and they seem to point to Celiac. Today we went back. I have been having bloated stomach, sore back and limbs,  lovely burps, constant urination and crushing anxiety attacks folowed by depression (which I have never had before in my life). Admitted over the last weekend I didn't sleep for two and a half days and found myself hallucinating and crying to just be able to sleep. Mr fancy pants gastrointerogist says," Hey great news, the stools samples rule out parasites and Crohns!" I tell him how excrutiating the last month has been to which he replies, "It's not Celiac disease, (points at negative blood test results). Celiac doesnt present with diarrhea, anxiety and frquent urination all together." I also had a fecal occult blood test which showed positive & notes say are maybe due to a lower gi bleed, and a ct scan that says shows some damage which, in their words, could be due to a condition such as Celiac disease. He has booked me for a double scope as the next step, has a few ideas what it could be (won't tell me because he doesn't want me to be 'anxious'). Told me to consider that all these symptoms could be me just worrying and being anxious. Told him when this started I was not worried about anything, shrugged and said, It could stil have happened, hey, sometimes we never find out what causes it and your just stuck with diarrhea forever." Then as I was leaving he slapped me on the back and said, "Don't worry so much, see you soon." I need to have the scopes done but is it me or are the things I was told today not true?  I would honestly love it not to be Celiac disease but could he be wrong?
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,651
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    Kricket73
    Joined