Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Gluten Challenge
0

9 posts in this topic

Hello! I was diagnosed with celiac disease 14 months ago after blood work and have not been very good about following a gluten free diet until recently (within the last month or so). I went to see a gastro because of some other concerns (he is not who originally diagnosed me, that was a general practitioner) and he's concerned about the results of my blood tests not being conclusive for celiac, so he wants me to do a gluten challenge. My next appointment to take blood is in three weeks and to possibly schedule a biopsy at that time. My question is this. I've been eating gluten for a week now since my last doctor's appointment, and I am miserable! If I stop eating gluten again now, is two weeks from my last ingestion a short enough time that my blood work/biopsy will still show some signs of celiac, or do I need to keep eating gluten and being miserable for another two weeks? I was kind of hoping I could get away with a week's worth of gluten and then stopping, especially since I have only truly been gluten free for about a month before starting to eat gluten again.

Thanks so much for your time!!! This disease is so confusing to me and my family and friends that it's great to have a place to ask questions from people who know something about it!

D

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Well, just to frustrate you some more, nobody can tell you how long to eat gluten for certain because it depends on the individual. Most experts would say that if you've been strictly gluten-free for a while you need to eat gluten for three months. Yes, three months.

The fact that you've improved on the gluten-free diet and and are feeling much sicker eating gluten is some evidence in itself. Are you satisfied you have it based on your reaction? What about the tests was "not conclusive?"

richard

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

3 months is usually how long they tell you to be on gluten to have a positive biopsy and blood results. I know people that have done it in 3 weeks but that varies from person to person and for some people that is too short of a time. Did you have positive blood tests 14 months ago? If you had the positive results then why do you need them now?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Richard:

I wasn't actually feeling much better off of the gluten (which is part of the reason why I went back to gastro doctor). I was still having pretty bad diarrhea and stomach pains, and began having major heartburn, which is why I went to the GI doctor (I wasn't able to sleep because of the severity of the heartburn). The tests I had done previously only came back positive for IGG, not for IGA or anti endomysial antibodies. The doctor said that there's a number of things that can cause a positive IGG and that without the positive IGA or anti endomysial antibodies, it's not a conclusive diagnosis of celiac disease. Is that true? I don't know anything about this. Some information I've read online has said that my symptoms could even be caused by endometriosis! Ack! I know that I can pinpoint the date (to the date) that my stomach problems began over a year ago and that going gluten free has not been "revolutionary", I guess, in terms of helping my symptoms and has, in fact, made some things worse (like heartburn), but now I just feel MORE miserable than I felt before since I started eating gluten last week. I have also cut out caffeine, carbonation, fried foods, red meat, and dairy this last week thinking that I could at least isolate some stuff if I started feeling better even though I was eating gluten. Still feel, no pun intended, like poop. :)

Is the info about the tests the doctor said true? Do I even need to bother with this challenge stuff?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you were not doing good on the whole diet and still eating gluten that could be why you were not feeling better. You are not going to get better while you are still on gluten if you are in fact a celiac. It took me 3 months of being gluten free completely to feel about 85% better and longer then that to get back to normal. So it would not happen overnight. My first blood test 2 of the 3 things came back positive and the IGA negative then I got a celiac test done by a reliable celiac testing lab and that test was able to prove I had celiac.

If you have only been completely gluten-free for the past month that might not have been enough time for your body to heal. For some people it takes months and for some it doesn't take long. Also, at first when I started going gluten free there was so many things I thought were gluten free that turned out not to be so there could still be some things slipping into your diet. I hope you start to feel better :D

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I agree with Kati; if you're not 100% gluten-free it could be why you don't feel better. Honestly, once you start eliminating gluten your body gets really angry when a little slips in. I would even venture to say it makes you worse off than you were before.

I also think the first 3 months of gluten-free diet are just as miserable as being on gluten. I am at the tail end of it and starting to feel better but my body went through some serious withdrawl symptoms. They are finally starting to subside, so I say hang in there.

If you pass the three months Absolutely, for sure gluten-free, then check to see what else it could be. I put that last because most of us, by the time we realize we have celiac disease, have already had all of those other tests!!!!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would agree that just a positive Igg isn't an absolute diagnosis (although I do know people who had a positive biopsy after just a positive Igg). Of course I don't know if you have celiac disease, but if you never really followed the diet very well, then there's absolutely no way for you to know if going gluten-free would help or not. Until you go COMPLETELY gluten-free and stay that way for an extended period (more than a month), you can't tell if the diet's helping you. If you DO have celiac disease and you're slipping or cheating frequently, you will continue to fail to improve.

richard

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would say the same as I said in my reply to one of our other correspondents under this topic area, go accompanied, I have had my nose in books on the subject continuously for years (gluten-free diet, not necessarily celiac disease), groups on the subject, kept in touch with individuals doing the same, nutritionist from the Institute of Optimum Nutrition.

To be honest yours is the exact question in my mind when I joined the bulletin board hours ago and I 'm working my way through replying as I go.

I know the answer is, they must take a hike but then I shan't have a plausible prospect of a diagnosis for my job absences. I thought we only have this problem in the UK but it seems doctors are the same the world over.

Thanks so much for daring to post, our Inner Man guides us well...

Best wishes.

Michael

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another thing - if you were diagnosed has this person any business undiagnosing you?

Come to think of it that has been done to me several times as well.

M.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,322
    • Total Posts
      920,392
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • sorry i did not see this until a year later.  i changed all my cat food to gluten free products.  right now i'm using a dry food made by Nature's Variety Instinct Raw Boost.  it has both dry food and freeze dried meat.  since my cats lick my face i had to make the switch.  i did not mean to remove your pets from your home.  they are loved ones and they can be eased into the diet if you have not already tried.  the wet food for my other cat is easier to find gluten free but it is expensive.
    • You might want to check out the Gluten Free Watchdog - just google it - and join. Very smart lady there who also has celiac disease. She's gone to the mats for us many times. She knows her stuff! 8 products are tested per month and there are many great articles and videos as well. She's the same lady who does the Gluten Free Dietician but on the Watchdog site, you get the test results of products as well as faster info. on breaking news.
    • After reading these few posts, I really think it all depends on where you live and the doctors attitude about the whole process. I think a biopsy is not always needed.  It depends on the circumstances and symptoms, etc.  Sometimes it is harder to piece together a proper diagnosis while other times it's so obvious.  Many people now do not even have GI issues, which used to be the hallmark of Celiac. This is why it is so difficult for some.  It would be nice if there was a very definitive test that was either positive or negative, with 100% accuracy!
    • Not to beat a dead horse here but I looked at the linked article you provided and it talked about exposure to animal feed in enclosed spaces, not driving or walking near wheat fields on a windy day.  Unless you are a farm hand, feeding cattle or horses with gluten containing feed in an enclosed, non-well ventilated area, it's not an issue. The Fasano diet is a short term diet for those who are slow to heal. Some people do have problems with grains and they found that putting them on a whole foods diet only, many of them went on to heal and could then consume processed gluten free food items like bread.  Lots of people do this in the beginning for faster healing. But it only works for people with Celiac Disease and you aren't even sure that is what the problem is. I posted this so anyone new to the diet reading these things will not become confused and think you cannot walk past a wheat field or a bakery. Inhaling visible wheat flour in a bakery is not a good idea for anyone with Celiac Disease and will make you sick/react and you won't be able to work in one but walking past bread or any gluten containing food is not cause for concern.
    • I react to certified gluten free breads, but it is NOT a gluten issue.  I react to Xanthan Gum.  I do just fine making my own baked goods from scratch subbing out the Xanthan Gum for guar gum.  My gluten-free hubby does well on commercially gluten-free baked goods.  It is just a food intolerance issue in my case.   Look to other ingredients.    
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,378
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    NightSky
    Joined