Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Positive Blood Tests/neg Biopsies - What Now?
0

17 posts in this topic

Help!

Well my dr has called me today to advise that the biopsies have come back normal (5 taken). He said scientifically I don't have celiac disease but all my symptoms point to it including a high reading for Ttg transglutaminase. He has sent me for another set of blood tests to test my levels again plus thyroid, diabetes and a full blood count. I've always been anaemic, have low calcium levels.

I was positive it was celiac disease and now I'm so disappointed I've not been diagnosed. What to do now? Do I continue to eat gluten and try again in a few months but the thought of the pain of bloating etc is so off putting and the cost of all these tests??

Has anyone else been in a similar situation and been retested with a positive result?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:
Help!

Well my dr has called me today to advise that the biopsies have come back normal (5 taken). He said scientifically I don't have celiac disease but all my symptoms point to it including a high reading for Ttg transglutaminase. He has sent me for another set of blood tests to test my levels again plus thyroid, diabetes and a full blood count. I've always been anaemic, have low calcium levels.

I was positive it was celiac disease and now I'm so disappointed I've not been diagnosed. What to do now? Do I continue to eat gluten and try again in a few months but the thought of the pain of bloating etc is so off putting and the cost of all these tests??

Has anyone else been in a similar situation and been retested with a positive result?

Positive blood work IS a diagnosis but the AMA hasn't caught on yet....really! These days, if they don't see it on a picture, they will doubt the diagnosis.

You probably haven't triggered long enough to cause extensive enough damage to be found with just 5 samples. That was not enough samples, either....a good doc would take 10-20 samples, from all over your small intestine.

Did he do a full Celiac panel on you? Just doing a tTg is not enough to get a full picture, either. Those other tests for thyroid and diabetes are good to do as they alone can cause elevated tTg but having positive blood work and a negative biopsy is very common with celiac disease. I would insist on a full panel, along with those other tests and you will get a clearer picture of what's going on. Keep eating gluten, if you can stand it, until testing is complete or it will affect results.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Positive blood work IS a diagnosis but the AMA hasn't caught on yet....really! These days, if they don't see it on a picture, they will doubt the diagnosis.

You probably haven't triggered long enough to cause extensive enough damage to be found with just 5 samples. That was not enough samples, either....a good doc would take 10-20 samples, from all over your small intestine.

Did he do a full Celiac panel on you? Just doing a tTg is not enough to get a full picture, either. Those other tests for thyroid and diabetes are good to do as they alone can cause elevated tTg but having positive blood work and a negative biopsy is very common with celiac disease. I would insist on a full panel, along with those other tests and you will get a clearer picture of what's going on. Keep eating gluten, if you can stand it, until testing is complete or it will affect results.

Hi Gemini

I went back and got extra blood work done on Thursday including the genetic tests so hopefully these will be back next Tuesday. Fingers crossed they provide some answers!

My Gastro Dr also mentioned that the problem maybe lower down so I might need a colonoscopy. Will a colonscopy also show celiac disease? I thought only the endoscopy could do this?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't mean to sound harsh, but my feeling is who really cares if it's an "official" diagnosis? Your blood work has clearly indicated that you cannot tolerate gluten. Clearly it makes you feel sick when you ingest it, so the simple solution is to give it up. While it is important to know whether or not you have celiac disease (and in my opinion you do based on your blood work) you can spend years chasing down an official diagnosis which is very subjective anyway -- one doctor's "yes" is another doctor's "no." Why keep torturing yourself with eating gluten just so another lab tech can possibly misread your slide? The most foolproof way to tell is to go on a strict elimination diet. When the symptoms return after ingesting gluten (and they will), then BINGO! There's your answer! Whether or not it's "official" celiac or just gluten intolerance doesn't matter -- either way you can't tolerate it.

I really don't mean to sound flip. Hope that helps. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nothing harsh about it, gluten mommy-- except, perhaps, to the medical system :-) And that's okay in my book. They deserve it.

Suzy-- I was in your exact same position in 2000. I had classic symptoms and high positives on the blood work (full panel IgG, IgA, tTg, etc.) and a negative biopsy (villi irritated, but not flattened.) They told me I did not have it and they sent me out to keep eating gluten.

I kept getting sicker and sicker. I lost my gallblader. I had to have a hysterectomy. I started getting headaches, nerve problems, muscle spasms, sores in my mouth, bp spikes.... the list goes on and on.

Finally I got DH (which was misdiagnosed as shingles no less than three times). That was the definitive diagnosis.

Here is the truth. If you have positive bloodwork, you have celiac disease with nearly 99% accuracy and specificity. There are no false positives with this bloodwork.

If I could spare you the years and the suffering that I went through before getting the official dx, I would. No matter what happens to you after this point, consider yourself a celiac. Get the diagnosis if you must (and maybe get yourself a more enlightened doc,) but at this point you have all the information you really need.

Welcome to the club.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Nothing harsh about it, gluten mommy-- except, perhaps, to the medical system :-) And that's okay in my book. They deserve it.

Suzy-- I was in your exact same position in 2000. I had classic symptoms and high positives on the blood work (full panel IgG, IgA, tTg, etc.) and a negative biopsy (villi irritated, but not flattened.) They told me I did not have it and they sent me out to keep eating gluten.

I kept getting sicker and sicker. I lost my gallblader. I had to have a hysterectomy. I started getting headaches, nerve problems, muscle spasms, sores in my mouth, bp spikes.... the list goes on and on.

Finally I got DH (which was misdiagnosed as shingles no less than three times). That was the definitive diagnosis.

Here is the truth. If you have positive bloodwork, you have celiac disease with nearly 99% accuracy and specificity. There are no false positives with this bloodwork.

If I could spare you the years and the suffering that I went through before getting the official dx, I would. No matter what happens to you after this point, consider yourself a celiac. Get the diagnosis if you must (and maybe get yourself a more enlightened doc,) but at this point you have all the information you really need.

Welcome to the club.

Hi Lisa,

Thank you so much for sharing your story with me. I honestly believe I have celiac disease but it's upsetting that I can't a medical diagnosis and the system has failed me. I've decided that I will go gluten free and see how I feel after this which I'm sure I will feel better. All the symptoms you have described above I continue to have.

I agree with you I need another doctor. The expense is just the off putting part.

Take care

Suzy

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And getting another doctor is also taking a chance-- you don't know if the person is any good or not. It is very hard.

I was misdiagnosed for over 23 years (before 2000) and I have been through every conceivable test, taken tons of medicines and hit the wall with the medical system more times than I care to count. Doctors definitely have their limitations.

celiac disease is a very frustrating disease.

But I think you will find that having a diagnosis doesn't really make that big of a differnce in the long run-- the outcome is exactly the same anyway. You are now gluten-free for life.

Hang in there and good luck.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, reading all of this makes me appreciate the new doctor I've found! He's trying to help me figure out why I'm so tired a lot of the time, even after being on medication for 2 years to help my hypothyroidism. When he reviewed my test results with me, he told me he's pretty sure it's celiacs and I needed to go gluten-free. He said that a lot of docs want a biopsy, just to make sure, but he doesn't think it's necessary (he would do it if I wanted one). I'm still waiting for the results of the genetic tests he ran, but he based his diagnosis on an elevated gliadin AB IGG. I don't see too much mention of the gliadin tests on here, so I'm kind of curious why he might prefer to use that. I guess I'm still in denial and trying to sneak in that last bit of pizza, but would a high gliadin AB IGG mean for sure that I need to eliminate gluten? Thanks for letting me jump in here!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Wow, reading all of this makes me appreciate the new doctor I've found! He's trying to help me figure out why I'm so tired a lot of the time, even after being on medication for 2 years to help my hypothyroidism. When he reviewed my test results with me, he told me he's pretty sure it's celiacs and I needed to go gluten-free. He said that a lot of docs want a biopsy, just to make sure, but he doesn't think it's necessary (he would do it if I wanted one). I'm still waiting for the results of the genetic tests he ran, but he based his diagnosis on an elevated gliadin AB IGG. I don't see too much mention of the gliadin tests on here, so I'm kind of curious why he might prefer to use that. I guess I'm still in denial and trying to sneak in that last bit of pizza, but would a high gliadin AB IGG mean for sure that I need to eliminate gluten? Thanks for letting me jump in here!

Mom2Boys - you are very lucky indeed to have found the dr that you have. I have just spoken with my mother as I know she has had problems with her thyroid over the last 5 years and she advised me she has had her thyroid gland removed as she had goiter. This has also been related to celiac disease. I told my mum that she should probably be tested but she is a bit of a health nut and doesn't eat gluten these days anyway so her test would probably be negative.

Thinking back now I've probably not eaten large amounts of gluten until about 5 weeks ago and this is when all my problems started to happen ie. bloating, fatigue, depression, basically a lack of motivation to do anything. Maybe the fact that I hadn't eaten enough gluten has given the negative biopsy results?

Anyway thank you all so much for taking the time out to reply to queries.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
but would a high gliadin AB IGG mean for sure that I need to eliminate gluten? Thanks for letting me jump in here!

Being new here, I'm confused about the gliadin AB IGG. Is it different from AB IgG? I can only find AB IgG on my LabCorp report.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do a search on each of these tests-- either on the board or on google. You will find lots of information about what each one measures and what the elevated numbers mean. Even wikipedia will have this.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Do a search on each of these tests-- either on the board or on google. You will find lots of information about what each one measures and what the elevated numbers mean. Even wikipedia will have this.

OK, I did a wikipedia search on; gliadin AB IGG

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...fulltext=Search

Search results: Did you mean: gliadin ABA IGG

I've noticed that some members type their labs all lower case while others use all upper case letters.

I guess the question I need answered is, does upper and lower case letters mean the same test?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OK, I did a wikipedia search on; gliadin AB IGG

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=...fulltext=Search

Search results: Did you mean: gliadin ABA IGG

I've noticed that some members type their labs all lower case while others use all upper case letters.

I guess the question I need answered is, does upper and lower case letters mean the same test?

Hey Captain...Hope I'm not adding to your confusion as I'm just a confused newbie myself and certainly may not be typing things as they appear on my labs. I've been reading a lot and it sure is hard to sort out everything, even seeing it all right in front of me. I read on one website that the gliadin antibody tests aren't used much these days, but I'm sure my doctor has his reasons for using them; I have a message in with his office, so I hope to find out soon. Good luck with everything!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mom2Boys - you are very lucky indeed to have found the dr that you have. I have just spoken with my mother as I know she has had problems with her thyroid over the last 5 years and she advised me she has had her thyroid gland removed as she had goiter. This has also been related to celiac disease. I told my mum that she should probably be tested but she is a bit of a health nut and doesn't eat gluten these days anyway so her test would probably be negative.

Thinking back now I've probably not eaten large amounts of gluten until about 5 weeks ago and this is when all my problems started to happen ie. bloating, fatigue, depression, basically a lack of motivation to do anything. Maybe the fact that I hadn't eaten enough gluten has given the negative biopsy results?

Anyway thank you all so much for taking the time out to reply to queries.

SuzyQ2 - It's amazing to think that gluten can cause all these problems. I always thought that celiacs had lots of GI issues that alerted them to the condition, but was never aware it could be related to autoimmune disorders. My doc said that's probably why my thyroid is out of whack. So the gluten can make you noticeably fatigued? Inconsistent energy levels, fatigue, brain fog and vague body/muscle aches have been my main complaints over the last few years; can all that be caused by gluten?? I just thought I was having trouble getting on the right dose of thyroid meds.

Yes, I'm thankful to have found a new doctor that actually listens to me and tries to help me get better. My family doctor didn't even want to treat my thyroid because I wasn't "that bad" (in his opinion) and he consistently blows off any issues I have. He also got a bit miffed when I told him I was going to consult with this other doctor and shared the labs that the new doc had ordered. The only bad thing is my new doctor doesn't work in a primary care capacity; he just works as an adjunct to my family doc. Guess I'll be shopping for a new family doc that is more accepting of me getting more than just his opinions.

Good luck to you!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hey Captain...Hope I'm not adding to your confusion as I'm just a confused newbie myself and certainly may not be typing things as they appear on my labs. I've been reading a lot and it sure is hard to sort out everything, even seeing it all right in front of me. I read on one website that the gliadin antibody tests aren't used much these days, but I'm sure my doctor has his reasons for using them; I have a message in with his office, so I hope to find out soon. Good luck with everything!

My doc included Gliadin in the labs.

Deamidated Gliadin Abs, Iga 36.8 High U/mL 0.0 - 10.0

Deamidated Gliadin Abs, IgG 3.1 U/mL 0.0 - 10.0

I'll Post the complete Lab Report in the near future..

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My doc included Gliadin in the labs.

Deamidated Gliadin Abs, Iga 36.8 High U/mL 0.0 - 10.0

Deamidated Gliadin Abs, IgG 3.1 U/mL 0.0 - 10.0

I'll Post the complete Lab Report in the near future..

Hello again. I just looked at my lab sheet from Quest and all of the test names are entirely in caps (a formatting thing with Quest). Mine doesn't say "deamidated", but just Gliadin AB IGG and Gliadin AB IGA. Wonder if those are the same thing? My IGA was normal, but the IGG was high. Were you gluten-free when your tests were done?

Saw you're in Baltimore. I'm in south-central PA, but am using a doc I found in Owings Mills, MD. So far, very happy with him.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hello again. I just looked at my lab sheet from Quest and all of the test names are entirely in caps (a formatting thing with Quest). Mine doesn't say "deamidated", but just Gliadin AB IGG and Gliadin AB IGA. Wonder if those are the same thing? My IGA was normal, but the IGG was high. Were you gluten-free when your tests were done?

Saw you're in Baltimore. I'm in south-central PA, but am using a doc I found in Owings Mills, MD. So far, very happy with him.

Looks like Caps don't matter.. I had the blood work done a day or 2 after I was diagnosed with DH by biopsy and still under the influence of gluten. I've been gluten-free since except for the hidden oops and I'm suffering from one this weekend.

Owings Mills is located in Baltimore County. I live on the other side of the County(NE side), Kingsville area.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,385
    • Total Posts
      920,613
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Squirmingitch, I forgot to mention best of luck to you during the storm! I hope you are safe and that your home isn't impacted too badly! I'm on the coast in SC so we will see some storms from it but nothing near as bad as what you will have. Take care and good luck.
    • SquirmingItch, I really appreciate you gathering info for me! To answer your questions, yes, I'm on Dapsone now and have been on it for about 4.5 weeks. I have been gluten free for the same amount of time. I started on 50 mg of Dapsone which didn't seem to help much. I spoke to my doctor about it and after about a week she raised it to 100 mg. Since then I did notice a huge improvement in both my rash and itch. I no longer have any active rashes and my itching isn't completely gone but it's very minimal. I have been getting weekly blood tests done and will soon be moving to monthly.  My DH skin biopsy was done before the gluten free diet and Dapsone. My results for the skin biopsy came back as inconclusive, but even with those results, my doctor was convinced I had DH. I specifically asked her about the fact that she took the biopsy directly from the lesion rather than next to it and if that affects the result. Her explanation was that if it's a fresh enough lesion that isn't scratched, there should be IgA antibodies present. But she said that an inconclusive result isn't surprising because the IgA antibodies come and go from the skin so quickly that it can be very difficult to get a positive result, even in someone who is positive.  That's when she decided to run the celiac blood panel on me. And even though those results came back positive for the deamidated gliadin and negative for tTg, she still is very convinced that I have DH. I am happy that my doctor seems to be certain, but I would just feel better if the results were more definitive. The one other thing I am waiting on is I have been asked to attend grand rounds at the local academic hospital in 2 weeks. I guess grand rounds is where all of the academic dermatologists and dermatopathologists get together to review certain complicated cases. They will meet with me, review all of my pictures, biopsies and blood tests. My situation has been so complicated so they asked me to come. I am hoping maybe then I will get some more answers. 
    • It sure is, it really is. 
    • shellyb, I have info. for you & you may yet be able to get an official dx from your dermatologist as she sounds like she would be willing to learn. If you are dx'd with dh it is definitive & no other testing is needed. You don't need to see a GI. Im in FL & have had a long day watching Tropical Storm Hermine & making preparations for it's track which is over where I live. I'm tired! I will have links for you to reputable medical info. on the rash but it make take me till tomorrow or even longer if we lose power.  I'll be back as soon as I can. Question: You're on Dapsone now? How long have you been on it? How is it working for you? Are you getting the proper testing at regular intervals to make sure it isn't doing bad things to you? Were you gluten free before the skin biopsy?
    • Thank you so much for your quick response, GFinDC. While I wouldn't be completely opposed to another skin biopsy, I already had 4 done (3 were done prior to my dermatologist suspecting DH) so I don't love the idea of  yet another hole and scar on my body. Plus, fortunately I don't have any fresh lesions now, which I believe is needed for the biopsy. I wish I would have known to see a GI before going gluten free but I was so desperate to get any relief that I started that and Dapsone as soon as my doctor mentioned it to me.  My rash is definitely symmetrical and I have it in all of the "classic" DH spots although it basically spread over my entire body. As much as I'd like a more formal diagnosis, I really don't think I can go through all of that again. It was so bad that not only was I getting no sleep but I had to change my sheets every morning because there was blood all over them. Sorry, TMI. The worst part is that this all developed during my ninth month of pregnancy and got much worse after I delivered my baby. So not only was I dealing with this insanely itchy rash but I had a newborn and a toddler to take care of.  My daughters' pediatrician did mention doing DNA testing on me first and then my daughters to see if there's any concern that they may be susceptible. I may just go that route for now. I was just curious if others have had similar test results to mine and how did their doctors treat it? Thanks again!
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,455
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    JLeigh
    Joined