Jump to content





   arrowShare this page:
   

   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

 
Ads by Google:
Celiac.com Sponsor:                                    


Photo
- - - - -

Dietician Said Not To Go Gluten Free If Negative Results


  • Please log in to reply

14 replies to this topic

#1 Harley0000

 
Harley0000

    Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 29 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:19 PM

Hello Everyone
I was diagnosed with celiac disease with a positive blood test and Endoscopy and went to a Dietician for some advice. What she said struck me as odd and I wanted some of your opinions. I was asking about my husband having similiar GI issues but he had tested negative (blood test only) She said that people who have not had positive diagnosis should NOT do a gluten free diet!!!
I did not ask "But what about false positives?" I figure if being gluten free makes you feel better than why not? I am just wondering why she would have said that. When I did ask her why she said because gluten-free diets are too restrictive and you should only do it if you have that DX for certain..... What do you all think???

Harley <_<
  • 0
[font="Comic Sans MS"]I am 40 years old, married with 4 children. I was just very recently diagnosed with celiac disease (Positive blood test and positive endoscopy). Have a great gluten-free day :)[/size[/font][size="1"]]

Celiac.com Sponsor:

#2 nu_to_no_glu

 
nu_to_no_glu

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 91 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:35 PM

I find that pretty odd, too. There's definitely the possibility of a false negative, and gluten intolerance without celiac. I think she's probably just trying to say it is a challenging diet for anyone, let alone someone who hasn't had a formal diagnosis. That being said, if you have to live that way, it would be a lot easier for him to try the diet as well. I say, forget what she said and he should give it a try :) My husband does it without a diagnosis, just because I do the shopping :)
  • 0

#3 mushroom

 
mushroom

    Mushroom

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 9,448 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:36 PM

Hello Everyone
I was diagnosed with celiac disease with a positive blood test and Endoscopy and went to a Dietician for some advice. What she said struck me as odd and I wanted some of your opinions. I was asking about my husband having similiar GI issues but he had tested negative (blood test only) She said that people who have not had positive diagnosis should NOT do a gluten free diet!!!
I did not ask "But what about false positives?" I figure if being gluten free makes you feel better than why not? I am just wondering why she would have said that. When I did ask her why she said because gluten-free diets are too restrictive and you should only do it if you have that DX for certain..... What do you all think???

Harley <_<

If she thinks gluten free diets are too restrictive, she should try having to live your whole life within two minutes of a toilet and see how restrictive that is :o

Seriously, if eating gluten free relieves your symptoms, why on earth would you continue eating it? To make other people feel better? Because you don't have the willpower to do it? Because of peer pressure? Some people would answer yes to these, but certainly not I. The risk of a false negative is too great and lines you up for some potentially nasty complications. And, those who are merely gluten sensitive are also subject to these nasty complications. To take that risk because of an inadequate test would not be my approach.
  • 0
Neroli


"Everything that can be counted does not necessarily count; everything that counts cannot necessarily be counted." - Albert Einstein

"Life is not weathering the storm; it is learning to dance in the rain"

"Whatever the question, the answer is always chocolate." Nigella Lawson

------------

Caffeine free 1973
Lactose free 1990
(Mis)diagnosed IBS, fibromyalgia '80's and '90's
Diagnosed psoriatic arthritis 2004
Self-diagnosed gluten intolerant, gluten-free Nov. 2007
Soy free March 2008
Nightshade free Feb 2009
Citric acid free June 2009
Potato starch free July 2009
(Totally) corn free Nov. 2009
Legume free March 2010
Now tolerant of lactose

Celiac.com - Celiac Disease Board Moderator

#4 wowzer

 
wowzer

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 675 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:39 PM

Hi, My blood test was negative, but I went gluten free anyway. I have a little sister that was diagnosed at a year old. I had been eating gluten light for a couple of years. I had so many symptoms disappear that I had complained about for years, that I wouldn't go back now. Good LUc,
Wendy
  • 0

#5 Harley0000

 
Harley0000

    Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 29 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:40 PM

I find that pretty odd, too. There's definitely the possibility of a false negative, and gluten intolerance without celiac. I think she's probably just trying to say it is a challenging diet for anyone, let alone someone who hasn't had a formal diagnosis. That being said, if you have to live that way, it would be a lot easier for him to try the diet as well. I say, forget what she said and he should give it a try :) My husband does it without a diagnosis, just because I do the shopping :)


I am with you on that for sure. Its like if you know lets say chili does not sit well with you then.... dont eat it and I think that would be the same for gluten. My husband (unfortunately) refuses the gluten-free diet because he tested negative. I personally think he is just in denial but I cant force him to eat what I am forced to. All I know is I have finally started feeling better being 100% gluten-free!!
  • 0
[font="Comic Sans MS"]I am 40 years old, married with 4 children. I was just very recently diagnosed with celiac disease (Positive blood test and positive endoscopy). Have a great gluten-free day :)[/size[/font][size="1"]]

#6 MySuicidalTurtle

 
MySuicidalTurtle

    "Like a rolling stone?"

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,663 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:43 PM

You should be on the diet for sure but your husband should only be on it if he feels better. There is no reason not to do the diet. . .it can be a choice for people who aren't allergic and who do not have Celiac Disease. I bet he'd feel better- most people do! Good luck!
  • 0

#7 Harley0000

 
Harley0000

    Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 29 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:43 PM

Hi, My blood test was negative, but I went gluten free anyway. I have a little sister that was diagnosed at a year old. I had been eating gluten light for a couple of years. I had so many symptoms disappear that I had complained about for years, that I wouldn't go back now. Good LUc,
Wendy


Yes my thoughts exactly. I complained when I found out what I was diagnosed with but once I started feeling better (very recently) I wouldnt go back now. A one year old with celiac disease? Oh my. That must be tough. Poor little thing. Best of luck to your lil sister :)
Harley
  • 0
[font="Comic Sans MS"]I am 40 years old, married with 4 children. I was just very recently diagnosed with celiac disease (Positive blood test and positive endoscopy). Have a great gluten-free day :)[/size[/font][size="1"]]

#8 Harley0000

 
Harley0000

    Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 29 posts
 

Posted 06 November 2009 - 08:47 PM

If she thinks gluten free diets are too restrictive, she should try having to live your whole life within two minutes of a toilet and see how restrictive that is :o

Seriously, if eating gluten free relieves your symptoms, why on earth would you continue eating it? To make other people feel better? Because you don't have the willpower to do it? Because of peer pressure? Some people would answer yes to these, but certainly not I. The risk of a false negative is too great and lines you up for some potentially nasty complications. And, those who are merely gluten sensitive are also subject to these nasty complications. To take that risk because of an inadequate test would not be my approach.


Those are my thoughts as well. Will a blood test be negative if you have a sensitivty to gluten but not actually celiac disease? Did I mention that the Dietician does not have Celiacs? No disrespect but she doesnt know how bad it can get and if giving up gluten can fix the problems, I have to disagree with her. Thanks so much. I just wanted some opinions! :)
Harley
  • 0
[font="Comic Sans MS"]I am 40 years old, married with 4 children. I was just very recently diagnosed with celiac disease (Positive blood test and positive endoscopy). Have a great gluten-free day :)[/size[/font][size="1"]]

#9 digmom1014

 
digmom1014

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 267 posts
 

Posted 07 November 2009 - 09:22 AM

Have him try the diet with you for a week and see if he feels any improvement-for some people that is too short a time but, it might not be for him. The way I see it is, your cooking gluten-free for you anyway so, why make two dinners, etc?

I tested neg. and went gluten-free and improved dramatically.
  • 0
Sarah

"What comes around, goes around"

#10 Harley0000

 
Harley0000

    Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 29 posts
 

Posted 07 November 2009 - 12:08 PM

Have him try the diet with you for a week and see if he feels any improvement-for some people that is too short a time but, it might not be for him. The way I see it is, your cooking gluten-free for you anyway so, why make two dinners, etc?

I tested neg. and went gluten-free and improved dramatically.


My thoughts exactly! Thanks :)
  • 0
[font="Comic Sans MS"]I am 40 years old, married with 4 children. I was just very recently diagnosed with celiac disease (Positive blood test and positive endoscopy). Have a great gluten-free day :)[/size[/font][size="1"]]

#11 Mtndog

 
Mtndog

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,254 posts
 

Posted 07 November 2009 - 01:49 PM

If he feels better on it, no one has ever gotten sick from going gluten-free- the reverse is not true.

It would make it easier on you too- less cross-contamination!
  • 0
***************************
Beverly

Gluten free since 2005

In the midst of winter, I found there was within me an invincible summer.
Albert Careb


Posted Image

#12 TrillumHunter

 
TrillumHunter

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 688 posts
 

Posted 07 November 2009 - 02:02 PM

As long as I'm the primary shopper and cook, everyone who eats here will eat gluten-free. My husband had a negative blood work but is gluten-free. He's seen a drop in migraines that makes it worth it. He's eaten gluten out at work and it always triggers a migraine.

A gluten-free diet can be healthy or not. There's plenty of gluten-free junk food.
  • 0

#13 Swimmr

 
Swimmr

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 282 posts
 

Posted 07 November 2009 - 06:13 PM

Hello Everyone
I was diagnosed with celiac disease with a positive blood test and Endoscopy and went to a Dietician for some advice. What she said struck me as odd and I wanted some of your opinions. I was asking about my husband having similiar GI issues but he had tested negative (blood test only) She said that people who have not had positive diagnosis should NOT do a gluten free diet!!!
I did not ask "But what about false positives?" I figure if being gluten free makes you feel better than why not? I am just wondering why she would have said that. When I did ask her why she said because gluten-free diets are too restrictive and you should only do it if you have that DX for certain..... What do you all think???

Harley <_<


I think it's ignorant for her to assume. What makes me tick is when they throw out info and advice on something they know little about.

There aren't many doc's who will allow a patient to do their own diagnosing and "fixing of the problem" except diabetes (and the like) because the doc can't watch over a person's shoulder. However with anything a doc diagnoses, there is usually a medication involved. Then follow-ups...then checkups...then more meds...more follow-ups. etc, etc. If more docs would be more knowledgeable on this issue, we wouldn't be here on celiac.com asking questions and getting support.

With celiac or a gluten/wheat intolerance, you change your diet and voila! You don't see a regular doc for diet needs, so then there's that too...so if she/he says "Yes you might have a gluten/wheat intolerance" they're literally saying goodbye to seeing you again, lol. Sorry but I feel it's all about the almighty dollar.

*disclaimer* I am not in no way saying EVERY doctor is like this. With my experience and reading about others, it appears this is true to the majority.
  • 0
-Self-diagnosed gluten/wheat intolerance 2007. Negative (basic) blood test for celiac disease March 2009.
-Diagnosed positive for Celiac 5/11/2010!!
-Vitamin D low (last year was deficient), Iodine low, Protein S low. Balance/dizziness not related to Celiac.
-Elimination diet 11-4-2009 and ended 02-28-2010. Tolerating dairy again. Highly intolerant to soy, sensitive to green peas and corn kernels.
"Oh CRAP! Are you SERIOUS??

#14 Harley0000

 
Harley0000

    Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 29 posts
 

Posted 08 November 2009 - 06:33 AM

I think it's ignorant for her to assume. What makes me tick is when they throw out info and advice on something they know little about.

There aren't many doc's who will allow a patient to do their own diagnosing and "fixing of the problem" except diabetes (and the like) because the doc can't watch over a person's shoulder. However with anything a doc diagnoses, there is usually a medication involved. Then follow-ups...then checkups...then more meds...more follow-ups. etc, etc. If more docs would be more knowledgeable on this issue, we wouldn't be here on celiac.com asking questions and getting support.

With celiac or a gluten/wheat intolerance, you change your diet and voila! You don't see a regular doc for diet needs, so then there's that too...so if she/he says "Yes you might have a gluten/wheat intolerance" they're literally saying goodbye to seeing you again, lol. Sorry but I feel it's all about the almighty dollar.

*disclaimer* I am not in no way saying EVERY doctor is like this. With my experience and reading about others, it appears this is true to the majority.


I agree that she must not have been very knowledgable on Celiacs because what I have read on here over and over and read in other places is: If gluten-free makes you feel better than do it. Its not like taking meds for a condition you dont have but simply taking a specific thing out of your diet that you know bothers you.
You made alot of sense with the doctors not wanting to "let you try and cure yourself" because this may have you feeling better and NOT needing their services. And yes unfortunately it is about the almighty dollar with some doctors...... :( Thanks
Harley
  • 0
[font="Comic Sans MS"]I am 40 years old, married with 4 children. I was just very recently diagnosed with celiac disease (Positive blood test and positive endoscopy). Have a great gluten-free day :)[/size[/font][size="1"]]

#15 tarnalberry

 
tarnalberry

    Advanced Community Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 9,542 posts
 

Posted 08 November 2009 - 10:40 AM

Doctors (and, it seems, some nutritionists) have this strange fear of putting people on a "restricted" diet. "Oh, it's too hard, don't even try." If I didn't tell myself that to get through quantum mechanics (or pick your difficult subject in school), why the heck would I say that for a diet? "Oh, but you have to change so much!" Like change is some super scare awful thing that shouldn't ever be attempted. Maybe it's scary, but that doesn't mean you should never do it. "Oh, you have to eliminate so many healthy foods!" Well, *fortified* foods, that allow you to rely on added things, like folic acid, rather than get them naturally, from things like leafy greens. Not to mention you don't actually lose much in the way of *healthy* food. And, not to even mention the idea of replacing it with food at least as healthy - but hey, if your dietitian only recommends rice and corn as replacements for wheat, they may not know enough about a healthy variety of foods.

(I know of some nutritionists who *are* good, and wouldn't do this. But I've read a lot of people on here with nutritionists like this. Annoying as all get out that someone claims they went to school and can charge for that sort of crappy service.)
  • 0
Tiffany aka "Have I Mentioned Chocolate Lately?"
Inconclusive Blood Tests, Positive Dietary Results, No Endoscopy
G.F. - September 2003; C.F. - July 2004
Hiker, Yoga Teacher, Engineer, Painter, Be-er of Me
Bellevue, WA




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Celiac.com Sponsors: