Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Dairy Free Pie Crust?
0

8 posts in this topic

I'm baking a pumpkin pie for Christmas and I'm making the crust myself. I found a gluten free recipe that uses white rice flour instead of wheat flour, but I also want to make it dairy free so I want to substitute the butter in the recipe as well. The best substitute seems to be Earth Balance or a soy butter, but the store I shop at has a limmited selction of butters and margerine and the ones I've looked at still have buttermilk in them so I'm thinking I'll have to go another route.

I guess the next best thing seems to be vegetable shortening, but my recipes also calls for a fair amount of vegetable shortening so if I replace the butter with shortening I'd basically just be doubling the amount of vegetable shortening that the recipes calls for which doesn't make any sense to me.

So now I'm thinking I should use vegetable oil, but I'm also finding websites that say coconut oil is a better butter substitute for baking than plain vegetable oil. So my question... what do I use to substitute the butter without messing up my pie crust? I'm not an expert baker and I've never made a pie crust before so any help wpuld be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

If I were you, I would make a few test pie crusts before the holiday so you can see if they work or not. I would also, if this is your first time baking any sort of pie crust, follow a set recipe.

The other thing you can do is just bake the pumpkin filling as a pudding, top it with pecans, and skip the crust. That is what we do here because we use coconut milk and the filling is already so rich, it would be superfluous to add calories in the form of crust to it.

As for the butter substitutes, you can use vegetable oil, fruit oil such as grapeseed, coconut oil, or even lard if you want to avoid dairy.

When searching for gluten-free pie crusts that did not use butter, I searched for vegan recipes to make it an easier search.

Here is a gluten free Vegan recipe from nourishingmeals blog, that does not use egg, either, but it will give you an idea. I haven't tried this, but it claims to be flakey. I do know that sorghum flour is a nice thing to put in baked goods. this is a double crust recipe :

gluten-free Sorghum Vegan Pie Crust

http://www.nourishingmeals.com/2010/11/deep-dish-apple-pie-gluten-free-vegan.html

Same blog, single crust recipe with sorghum and ground pecans and coconut oil

http://www.nourishingmeals.com/2009/10/gluten-free-pumpkin-cheesecake-recipe.html

No Roll, Pat in Pan, Gluten Free Vegan Pie Crust from Gluten Free Easily

http://glutenfreeeasily.com/no-roll-never-fail-press-in-gluten-free-pie-crust/

The flour mix was rice, cornstarch, and almond meal. It's easy to grind almonds in a blender.

Here is another Gluten Free, Pat In the Pan, almond flour pie crust with grapeseed oil from Elana's Pantry (a variation on this is the one I would be most likely to use. I would add some cinnamon to it ) This recipe makes a single crust. You can substitute maple syrup or honey for the agave, or even a bit of brown sugar and water, if you don't have any. Almond flour does not need xanthan gum in this recipe. If you cannot find almond flour, you can grind your own in a blender, but they will be more mealy. However, you could then use a cup of almond meal and then a half cup of some other gluten-free flour, anything from sorghum to rice/cornstarch.

Bonus. Recipe for chocolate cream filling on same page, gluten-free and dairy free. whoo !

http://www.elanaspantry.com/chocolate-cream-pie/

This recipe is a version of Bette Hagman's "Donna Jo's Dream Pastry" it calls for butter but all shortening, or half shortening, half lard could be used (makes double crust) Bette Hagman's recipes always have a high probability of working. Get her cookbook to use as a reference, if you can.

http://www.imadetoast.com/2010/10/gluten-free-caramel-apple-pie.html

Gluten Free Girl's (Shauna's) Pie Crust (warning, has oat flour, some celiacs react, may want to substitute) uses butter, or butter substitute, and lard, makes 2 crusts. Shauna's recipes also tend to work, altho they are a bit more complex, because she is very precise with her measurements, I would bookmark her blog and read it regularly, just for all the amazing cooking tips

http://glutenfreegirl.blogspot.com/2009/11/gluten-free-pie.html

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest the Vinegar Pasty from Betty Hagman:

Vinegar Pastry by Betty Hagman. This makes two crusts.

1 c white rice flour

3/4 c tapioca flour

3/4 c cornstarch

1 t xanthan gum

3/4 t salt

1 T sugar

Combine all of the above. Cut into it: 3/4 c shortening.

Blend together:

1 egg, lightly beaten

1T vinegar

Add this to the flour mixture.

Add ice water, 1 T at a time, and toss with a fork until it holds together when squeezed without being crumbly or sticky. Divide in 2 and wrap with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 min. At this point you can freeze it.

Roll out between pieces of rice-floured wax paper or plastic wrap, remove the top one and invert into the pie plate. Finish and bake as usual for your pie recipe. Bake all the scraps as well, spread them with jelly, and pretend they're poptarts.

I have had good luck thawing this after months of freezing, and gluten-eaters don't know there's anything different from regular crust.

I made this for pie at Thanksgiving...it was AWESOME!!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest the Vinegar Pasty from Betty Hagman:

Vinegar Pastry by Betty Hagman. This makes two crusts.

1 c white rice flour

3/4 c tapioca flour

3/4 c cornstarch

1 t xanthan gum

3/4 t salt

1 T sugar

Combine all of the above. Cut into it: 3/4 c shortening.

Blend together:

1 egg, lightly beaten

1T vinegar

Add this to the flour mixture.

Add ice water, 1 T at a time, and toss with a fork until it holds together when squeezed without being crumbly or sticky. Divide in 2 and wrap with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 min. At this point you can freeze it.

Roll out between pieces of rice-floured wax paper or plastic wrap, remove the top one and invert into the pie plate. Finish and bake as usual for your pie recipe. Bake all the scraps as well, spread them with jelly, and pretend they're poptarts.

I have had good luck thawing this after months of freezing, and gluten-eaters don't know there's anything different from regular crust.

I made this for pie at Thanksgiving...it was AWESOME!!

I agree with Melinda on this recipe...it is the one I use all the time.....a great starter recipe for those who have never made a gluten-free pie crust before.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with Melinda on this recipe...it is the one I use all the time.....a great starter recipe for those who have never made a gluten-free pie crust before.

I saw this on a TV show. The filling (which I am not including as it has cream), is not cooked, so I expect you could substitute any uncooked filling after this is made. I will try this soon, but the TV show cooks said it was very easy.

* 6 ounces ground almonds

* 1 egg white

* 2 ounces caster sugar (superfine)

Work the ground almonds, egg white, and sugar into a paste and knead into a ball. On a sugared surface, roll out to a round large enough to line an 8-inch nonstick flan tin, 1/4-inch thick and leave to dry for 30 minutes.

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.

Place the rested pastry in the tin and decorate the edges with the finger and thumb technique. Line with foil (but no baking beans) and bake blind for 20 to 25 minutes. Watch carefully to avoid scorching. Leave to cool.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I saw this on a TV show. The filling (which I am not including as it has cream), is not cooked, so I expect you could substitute any uncooked filling after this is made. I will try this soon, but the TV show cooks said it was very easy.

* 6 ounces ground almonds

* 1 egg white

* 2 ounces caster sugar (superfine)

Work the ground almonds, egg white, and sugar into a paste and knead into a ball. On a sugared surface, roll out to a round large enough to line an 8-inch nonstick flan tin, 1/4-inch thick and leave to dry for 30 minutes.

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.

Place the rested pastry in the tin and decorate the edges with the finger and thumb technique. Line with foil (but no baking beans) and bake blind for 20 to 25 minutes. Watch carefully to avoid scorching. Leave to cool.

Sounds yummy! I will have to try that for cheesecake pie!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been wanting to try the vinegar recipe, will have to. I was going to also suggest using extra virgin coconut oil as a butter replacement. Might work.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest the Vinegar Pasty from Betty Hagman:

Vinegar Pastry by Betty Hagman. This makes two crusts.

1 c white rice flour

3/4 c tapioca flour

3/4 c cornstarch

1 t xanthan gum

3/4 t salt

1 T sugar

Combine all of the above. Cut into it: 3/4 c shortening.

Blend together:

1 egg, lightly beaten

1T vinegar

Add this to the flour mixture.

Add ice water, 1 T at a time, and toss with a fork until it holds together when squeezed without being crumbly or sticky. Divide in 2 and wrap with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 min. At this point you can freeze it.

Roll out between pieces of rice-floured wax paper or plastic wrap, remove the top one and invert into the pie plate. Finish and bake as usual for your pie recipe. Bake all the scraps as well, spread them with jelly, and pretend they're poptarts.

I have had good luck thawing this after months of freezing, and gluten-eaters don't know there's anything different from regular crust.

I made this for pie at Thanksgiving...it was AWESOME!!

I have gotten lazy. I figured out I could throw everything in my Kitchen Aid and mix it. It doesn't get tough like gluten pasta does. :D

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,144
    • Total Posts
      919,566
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Mnoosh, I had swollen lymph nodes prior to celiac dx and for a while after going gluten free. My neck as well as groin. The groin ones were the worst. Guess what? All gone! It's hard to recall a time line & consider that everyone is different but I think mine completely resolved within a year.  You've been given great information. Just breathe and then again, breathe. You're going to be fine. 
    • It is the only thing you have eaten, so it can't be anything else?  I eat it with no issues so I am not sure how you can be certain that is the problem.  All I am saying is that its sort of "your word against mine and the company's word".  
    • Thanks cyclinglady & manasota! I appreciate it. I came to give an update...... I'm still 99% itch free. I get a "place" like a bug bite once in a while that itches and I just use the prescription steroid cream on it & that takes care of the itch. My rash is healing up rapidly everywhere. Almost clear skin now! Yaaaaayyyyyyyyyy! Now for a rundown of the "treatment". For 20 days I took a 100mg doxycycline twice a day. Then we upped it to two 100mg doxy twice per day. I took those for 5 days & made rapid progress and the itching stopped. The doxy was getting my tummy though. It was getting really rough despite my eating yogurt. So on day 6 and day 7, I took two 100mg doxy in the am but in the pm I just took 1 of them. On day 7, I was nauseous for hours on end. So since I was still doing well without itching and the rash was healing everywhere, I decided to cut back some more. On days 8, 9, & 10 I have only taken two 100mg doxy in the am and none at night. I'm doing good and my tummy is much, much happier! No more nausea!  I'll update as things go along.
    • Many things can damage the small intestine besides celiac disease: http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/faq/what-else-can-cause-damage-to-the-small-intestine-other-than-celiac-disease/ Happily, I can share that I became a Great-Aunt this week for the first time  to a charming little boy. Sadly, my lovely 19 year old niece was diagnosed yesterday with Crohn's.  She had so many symptoms of celiac disease, I was sure she had it.  Actually, I was hoping that she'd have it, because Crohn's can be much worse.  At least there is a "cure" or known trigger for it -- gluten!   Anyway, your daughter might be suffering from something other than celiac disease.  It is possible.  It could be a food intolerance (e.g. milk).  My niece has suffered for years with periodic episodes of abdominal pain, vomiting, etc.  She doesn't have all the "classic" Crohn's Disease symptoms either, yet a recent pill cam revealed a lot!  Her endoscopy was normal.  Celiac panel normal.  Gallbladder scan normal (non-functioning gallbladder is a family curse).  My heart goes out to her, but at least we know what we are dealing with.  Will she ever get celiac disease?  It could happen. Keep advocating, Mom.  That's what I kept telling my SIL.  I also provided my SIL  a family health history tree that each GI was happy to receive.  Unfortunately, no one has had Crohn's in the family.  But, at least it allowed him to test my nieces gallbladder and for celiac disease (a full panel,  mind you).   It would not hurt to get a second opinion.  
    • That uncle bens 10minute brown rice with the gluten free table on the box, i been going through hell these last few days, this shit is Not gluten free its contaminated 
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,176
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Red Butt in hemet
    Joined