Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Any Celiacs Who Decided To Be Completely Grain-Free?
0

57 posts in this topic

I am wondering why many Celiacs are not healing on a STRICT gluten-free diet. I read medical studies that shows many biopsies show the intestines still remained inflamed 15 years later. Obviously, something is wrong with this gluten-free diet if many people aren't healing.

I just read a blog of someone with Crone's Disease who has basically completely healed Crone's Disease by eliminating all grains completely and making a few other minor changes to his diet.

I am wondering if there are any Celiacs who have eliminated all grain completely? Are you out there? Did you find your other food allergies disappeared? I have become "allergic" to almost all foods - you name it, I can't eat it. Something is causing the intestinal permeability.

Is there anyone out there who does not eat grains and how improved their leaky gut syndrome?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

There are threads here about the Specific Carbohydrate Diet (SBC)which essentially eliminates all grains.

I am trying to eliminate all grains but once in a while I eat a bit of rice, lentils, or corn chips. And every single time I do it...I vow to eliminate all grains. I did do it for 5 years once long ago before I ever knew about gluten. I realized after a year that nothing was bothering me mentally or physically and I was healthier than I had ever been in my life. I am trying to get back there. I thought it was the carbs that got me then, but actually it was gluten. Now that gluten is totally out, I know I would feel better totally grain free.

I know there are people here who are totally grain free.

I hope I will be too. It is just really really hard to do. I'm working on my self-discipline.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have done so by adhering to a paleo diet. It makes gluten free very easy for me. No grains. I still have a ways to go with healing but have never felt better.. relatively speaking.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm relatively grain free. I have some leftover rice products that I'm trying to space out, and I'm not sure I'll ever be able to totally give up chips and margaritas, but I've cut way back on them. When I eat no grains I can sleep all the way through the night (for the first time in my life, that I can remember). It's pretty awesome.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh i know- its very difficult.. i am STILL eating things that mess me up.. hard to give up enjoying my food.

years ago- i was completely grain free & sugar free- but havent gotten back there yet. i am ok with moderate amounts of rice & gluten-free oat products. i can also do quinoa & some millet. all the other grains mess me up- especially corn flour products. i try to avoid them, but i DO have gluten-free bread in the fridge (with potato & tapioca starch, etc).

its hard to give it all up... on top of the gluten-> i avoid most legumes, beans, corn, and excess fructose because of the pain. and soy because of the thyroid.

dairy is a huge addiction for me- and its hard to give up- because it gives me so much pleasure- and maybe 40% of the time- i can eat it and feel no consequence-> but other times it's pretty painful-> and im afraid that secondary glutenization might very well be real.

i know i need to get more strict- cause i still sometimes have some pain, and those horizontal cracks on my fingerprints have not improved- and they should as your gut is healing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I am trying to go grain-free. The thought of eliminating all grains including rice is not daunting to me because I know how bad all traces of gluten affect a Celiac's body -- the brain damage, the intestinal damage, the organ damage.

The daunting part is trying to get ALL GRAINS OUT OF PRODUCTS LIKE SALT AND VITAMINS, LOL.

I just noticed my "all natural" sea salt is "iodized" which means they probably added dextrose (corn) to stabilize the iodine. So I need to call that company.

And of course all vitamins and supplements will use traces of rice and corn and not mention it on the label.

And of course all animal products are out because they are fed diets of corn and soy (which causes them to be sick too since nature didn't intend that!).

I removed the last grain from my diet a few days ago and already the inflammation is down. I hope it stays this way.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh i know- its very difficult.. i am STILL eating things that mess me up.. hard to give up enjoying my food.

years ago- i was completely grain free & sugar free- but havent gotten back there yet. i am ok with moderate amounts of rice & gluten-free oat products. i can also do quinoa & some millet. all the other grains mess me up- especially corn flour products. i try to avoid them, but i DO have gluten-free bread in the fridge (with potato & tapioca starch, etc).

its hard to give it all up... on top of the gluten-> i avoid most legumes, beans, corn, and excess fructose because of the pain. and soy because of the thyroid.

dairy is a huge addiction for me- and its hard to give up- because it gives me so much pleasure- and maybe 40% of the time- i can eat it and feel no consequence-> but other times it's pretty painful-> and im afraid that secondary glutenization might very well be real.

i know i need to get more strict- cause i still sometimes have some pain, and those horizontal cracks on my fingerprints have not improved- and they should as your gut is healing.

Do you mean cracks in the finger prints or the nails? My nails have ridges that aren't going away, but I am getting my moons back (in the nail bed) which is supposed to be good.

After a year gluten/dairy/corn free I know I my next step is the SCD. I am back to having some fatigue and I have some inflammation that just isn't going away. It's just so much to give up after my family has already made a huge paradigm shift. I have a book about the SCD. I just need to read it and give it a try. I'm hoping that it will be easier to manage in the summer. It is encouraging that other people here have had such great success on it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am trying to go grain-free. The thought of eliminating all grains including rice is not daunting to me because I know how bad all traces of gluten affect a Celiac's body -- the brain damage, the intestinal damage, the organ damage.

The daunting part is trying to get ALL GRAINS OUT OF PRODUCTS LIKE SALT AND VITAMINS, LOL.

I just noticed my "all natural" sea salt is "iodized" which means they probably added dextrose (corn) to stabilize the iodine. So I need to call that company.

And of course all vitamins and supplements will use traces of rice and corn and not mention it on the label.

And of course all animal products are out because they are fed diets of corn and soy (which causes them to be sick too since nature didn't intend that!).

I removed the last grain from my diet a few days ago and already the inflammation is down. I hope it stays this way.

omg!!!! exactly how frustrated i feel with all the corn crap they put in EVERYTHING and soy & soy lecithin thats in EVERYTHING... it's like the government and their subsidies are poisoning us and we cant do s about it :(

AND YES- all the grains they feed the animals :( sucks cause i eat a more paleo diet... i try to get grass fed beef & dairy products- but its not always possible. and im sure all the eggs i get are from chickens fed grains. but honestly- im not as concerned with the grains making it into the meat- BUT- it could most definitely be in the dairy- as gluten has been found in breast milk. AND i read this the other day:

http://www.nps.gov/archive/libo/white_snakeroot3.htm

so, obviously what they eat COULD possibly pass into their milk .... sucks cause i have not conquered my dairy addiction

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have two friends who are Celiac and corn intolerant (they are problably GRAIN intolerant and don't know it yet!). They cannot eat EGGS that come from hens that are fed corn because all their gluten-like symtpoms return and their inflammation becomes VERY painful within hours. One of them keeps their own hens and feeds them their daily grain-free leftovers.

I have found this Corn Allergy List very helpful: http://www.cornallergens.com/list/corn-allergen-list.php

I did not realize corn was in over 1000 items.

Next I shall try to find a "Rice Allergy List."

Also, I switched all my cats to "grain-free cat food" (it is turkey and peas now) because a Celiac veterinarian noticed that when he put his animal patients on grain-free diets, their seizures went away and their health problems completely improved. Researchers have now discovered the "Celiac" Irish Setter and now believe many, many other animals are intolerant to grains. When we put one of our cat on a grain-free diet, her very grouchy personality has improved and she now lets us hold her.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been browsing over information on the grain-free diet by Dr. Osmonde and Elaine Gottschall. Elaine Gottschall treated Celiacs, ulcerative collitis, Crone's Disease and other intestinal diseases with a grain-free diet. Interestingly, she was unhappy that the medical community started saying that Celiacs only needed to avoid wheat, barley and rye. After that, she began treating hundreds of Celiacs who were not thriving on the "modern gluten-free diet" with her grain-free diet. Now, it appears Dr. Osmonde is following a similar path by creating the Gluten Free Society with a "truly" gluten-free diet and advises no grains, only grass-fed animal products and supplements which are VERY carefully selected.

I found this video of Elaine Gottschall's lecture very interesting. Part Two shows slides of a colon with a mucus overlay because of a potato/soy intolerance:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh i know- its very difficult.. i am STILL eating things that mess me up.. hard to give up enjoying my food.

years ago- i was completely grain free & sugar free- but havent gotten back there yet. i am ok with moderate amounts of rice & gluten-free oat products. i can also do quinoa & some millet. all the other grains mess me up- especially corn flour products. i try to avoid them, but i DO have gluten-free bread in the fridge (with potato & tapioca starch, etc).

its hard to give it all up... on top of the gluten-> i avoid most legumes, beans, corn, and excess fructose because of the pain. and soy because of the thyroid.

dairy is a huge addiction for me- and its hard to give up- because it gives me so much pleasure- and maybe 40% of the time- i can eat it and feel no consequence-> but other times it's pretty painful-> and im afraid that secondary glutenization might very well be real.i know i need to get more strict- cause i still sometimes have some pain, and those horizontal cracks on my fingerprints have not improved- and they should as your gut is healing.

Certain forms of dairy have more casein than others (as well as lactose I believe) and that could be why you are more sensitive with certain dairy items. I tested pretty high for cottage cheese, mozzarella and parmesean were a little lower and casein was even lower than that. I just aviod all dairy now.

I am seriously going to try out the paleo diet. I have barely eaten anything the last few days due to the stress of my phlebotomy class and I felt fine. Today I ate a bowl of gluten free pasta and about an hour later my heart started having abnormal beats again. I just don't think my body likes any kind of carbs.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

AND YES- all the grains they feed the animals :( sucks cause i eat a more paleo diet... i try to get grass fed beef & dairy products- but its not always possible. and im sure all the eggs i get are from chickens fed grains. but honestly- im not as concerned with the grains making it into the meat- BUT- it could most definitely be in the dairy- as gluten has been found in breast milk.

Our supermarkets have just started touting the wonders of corn-fed chicken!!! as if it were some sort of delectable delicacy. :lol: Gads, there's enough contamination in chickens already without adding corn to the mix. I worry about the lectins in the dairy, because cows' stomachs were not designed to digest grains and that is why I HAVE to eat grass-fed beef - the lectins can be found in the meat (and presumably in the milk too) :unsure: Y'all are going to laugh when I tell you this, but I bring my powdered yogurt mix for homemade yogurt with me when I come over to U.S., enough to last my entire visit, because I am afraid (because of the amount of dairy I eat) of having reactions to dairy and having to eliminate that too!!! And I eat goat and sheep cheeses a lot :D And just altogether try to stay away from dairy lectins as much as possible.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Our supermarkets have just started touting the wonders of corn-fed chicken!!! as if it were some sort of delectable delicacy.

:o :o

The chicken instructions tell you to minimize corn since it isn't very good for them.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been completely grain free in the past. I was grain free for about 3 years....I was and am still developing more food intolerances though. I use some buckwheat flour now (if you consider buckwheat a grain. Some people consider it more of a seed).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been grain free (and LOTS of other "frees") for 8 months now, gluten free for 14 months... if anything my sensitivities have gotten WORSE. I was so hopeful that things would improve for me but they just haven't. If I stick to my 7 safe unprocessed foods I feel pretty awesome. But if I make [grain free] cookies with my kids, what I inhale makes me sick. If I walk through a bakery I get sick. If I trial a new food (in the past 3 months, I've only had the guts (ha!) to trial strawberries and asparagus), I get sick. I pray that maybe I just need more time to heal. We'll see!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Certain forms of dairy have more casein than others (as well as lactose I believe) and that could be why you are more sensitive with certain dairy items. I tested pretty high for cottage cheese, mozzarella and parmesean were a little lower and casein was even lower than that. I just aviod all dairy now.

I am seriously going to try out the paleo diet. I have barely eaten anything the last few days due to the stress of my phlebotomy class and I felt fine. Today I ate a bowl of gluten free pasta and about an hour later my heart started having abnormal beats again. I just don't think my body likes any kind of carbs.

i believe u yes- with the different types of dairy- i do know there are certain cheeses that im completely fine with, etc.. when i said "40% of the time"- i meant with the same product- like 1/2 cup of whole milk in my mocha- 1/2 the time- it doesnt do a thing to me, other times- if i take a lactaid i'll be ok, and then other times- im in so much pain, im totally home ridden for the night laying on a heating pad and pillow under my stomach- and if i still have to shower- it's excruciating to stand up- and then i start the interogation in my head: "is it the lactose? or the casein?? or was it the fructose? did i overdo the fructose? or CRAP- was it gluten from the grains the cow was consuming????" oy vey, it drives me nuts- i guess i could just NOT consume it huh? :huh:

also- u said the gluten-free pasta made your heart race?? was it corn pasta? corn products make my heart race and my blood pressure go up- similar to gluten but not as bad

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Our supermarkets have just started touting the wonders of corn-fed chicken!!! as if it were some sort of delectable delicacy. :lol: Gads, there's enough contamination in chickens already without adding corn to the mix. I worry about the lectins in the dairy, because cows' stomachs were not designed to digest grains and that is why I HAVE to eat grass-fed beef - the lectins can be found in the meat (and presumably in the milk too) :unsure: Y'all are going to laugh when I tell you this, but I bring my powdered yogurt mix for homemade yogurt with me when I come over to U.S., enough to last my entire visit, because I am afraid (because of the amount of dairy I eat) of having reactions to dairy and having to eliminate that too!!! And I eat goat and sheep cheeses a lot :D And just altogether try to stay away from dairy lectins as much as possible.

shroom- you're not in america??? how funny- i never even thought that you were overseas... or r u in canada?? hhmm..

no, i do not laugh at u at all- in fact i daydream about bringing in my own goat milk to starbucks - but afraid of everyone thinking im a freak or telling me it's illegal or something.

and i LIVE on goat milk yogurt!!!!! love love love it- get it at whole foods- vanilla is my favorite :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been grain free (and LOTS of other "frees") for 8 months now, gluten free for 14 months... if anything my sensitivities have gotten WORSE. I was so hopeful that things would improve for me but they just haven't. If I stick to my 7 safe unprocessed foods I feel pretty awesome. But if I make [grain free] cookies with my kids, what I inhale makes me sick. If I walk through a bakery I get sick. If I trial a new food (in the past 3 months, I've only had the guts (ha!) to trial strawberries and asparagus), I get sick. I pray that maybe I just need more time to heal. We'll see!

You get sick when you make grain-free cookies?

You get sick when you inhale the odor of gluten? This is interesting. I just read that a study found that breathing in gluten affected some Celiacs. This will make me more cutious.

Are you eating soy? If you are, is it GM soy?

Are you eating legumes?

Sorry for all the quesitons, I'm trying to figure out what could cause the intestinal permeability and all your food sensitivities?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I stick to my 7 safe unprocessed foods I feel pretty awesome.

What can you eat? I'm having such a hard time figuring out what I can and cannot eat.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats basically how I am now.

I have so far found that I can't eat corn or rice. I can't eat nightshades (potatoes, tomatoes, egg plant, peppers). I cannot eat many greens such as: broccoli, kale, spinach, carrots, cauliflower, bok choy, brussel sprouts. I fall asleep after eating them. I cannot eat legumes.

So its basically ice berg lettuce, squash, nuts (but not seeds!), olive oil, basamic vinegar, romaine lettuce, salt and pepper and some fruit. I am testing sweet potatoes tonight!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been grain free (and LOTS of other "frees") for 8 months now, gluten free for 14 months... if anything my sensitivities have gotten WORSE. I was so hopeful that things would improve for me but they just haven't. If I stick to my 7 safe unprocessed foods I feel pretty awesome. But if I make [grain free] cookies with my kids, what I inhale makes me sick. If I walk through a bakery I get sick. If I trial a new food (in the past 3 months, I've only had the guts (ha!) to trial strawberries and asparagus), I get sick. I pray that maybe I just need more time to heal. We'll see!

If you are grain free and still getting sick, are you also avoiding meat and animal products from animals fed grains? Vitamins and supplements are also grain free? I have friends who are corn intolerant and cannot eat the EGGS that comes from hens fed corn. They have a severe reaction.

I can't find "100% grass fed" anywhere. When I call "grass-fed, organic" companies, they explain that the animals are allowed a diet of 20% corn and soy.

So how is everyone doing grain-free while using animal products?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am testing sweet potatoes tonight!

Good luck with the sweet potato. I had one yesterday and have to figure out if that is what I reacted to. The dreaded D was back today. I'll have to challenge sweet potatoes again but don't think I'm going to feel up to that any time soon.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good luck with the sweet potato. I had one yesterday and have to figure out if that is what I reacted to. The dreaded D was back today. I'll have to challenge sweet potatoes again but don't think I'm going to feel up to that any time soon.

I had that two nights ago and I think it was on apples. :(

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been grain free without resolution of my issues and just got and read Elaine Gottschall's "Breaking the Vicious Cycle" Intestinal Health through Diet" book on the specific carbohydrate diet. I am sorry I didn't get this some time ago. Fast read and interesting as well. I think it may be a better starting point than a paleo diet.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are grain free and still getting sick, are you also avoiding meat and animal products from animals fed grains? Vitamins and supplements are also grain free? I have friends who are corn intolerant and cannot eat the EGGS that comes from hens fed corn. They have a severe reaction.

I can't find "100% grass fed" anywhere. When I call "grass-fed, organic" companies, they explain that the animals are allowed a diet of 20% corn and soy.

So how is everyone doing grain-free while using animal products?

I'm sure the meat I eat has been fed grains. We go through a LOT of meat in our household and buy a 1/2 cow at a time - I can't imagine the cost if we needed strictly grass-fed! :o My vitamins and supplements are all safe (I spent over 18 hours seeking out safe varieties of everything I use - talk about wanting to rip my own hair out!). As long as I stick to my list of safe foods - chicken, beef, sweet potatoes, carrots, apples, blueberries, olives/oil, and a handful of spices - I feel excellent. So I truly don't suspect that grains are getting in through my animal products. When I make meringue cookies w/my kids, I suspect it's the inhaled cocoa powder that's getting me. And I definitely react to inhaled gluten. As well as any gluten that gets on my skin - instant angry red itchy rash. I hope you're quickly able to get to a list of foods you can rely upon. That's almost the worst part - not knowing for sure WHAT you can eat that WON'T make you sick. I complain a lot (okay, a really lot) about how limited my diet is, but the fact that I have a safe list is worth so much to my sanity. Hang in there!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,120
    • Total Posts
      919,468
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hi Alok, I suggest not eating any soy.  Soy is one of the top 8 food allergens in the USA.  Soy has other things about it that are not helpful to us.  Plus it is often sprayed with pesticides that are not so great for people.  Maybe you can try some other food for a while?  Also it might help to wash all your vegetables before using them. Just some ideas, I hope they help.
    • What she said!     The antibody panel is an important part of follow-up!
    • I have Celiac, Hashi's thyroid disease, Sjogren's Syndrome and Reynaud's Syndrome.  All have gotten better, inflammation wise, after 11 years gluten free.  I am very strict with my diet, never take chances if I feel the food is not really gluten free and limit the number of times I go out to eat.  I am not saying I never go out but it is normal for my husband and I to not see the inside of a restaurant for 3-4 months at a time and then I only eat at the places that have never glutened me.  I am lucky in that the state I live in has 3 restaurant chains that are run/owned by Celiac's, so they get it right every time. You have not been gluten free for very long, in reality.  It took me three years to completely rid myself of all symptoms related to the disease.  I was 46 at the time of diagnosis.  I know it is hard to accept that healing can take that long but you have to measure it differently.  Looking back, you should feel better than you did a year ago.  As time goes on, healing slowly takes place until you realize that certain problems have disappeared.  It is not as cut and dried as taking an antibiotic for an infection. http://www.drweil.com/drw/u/ART03424/Elevated-Creactive-Protein-CRP.html  Read this article on elevated c reactive protein. It is by Dr. Weil, who is a Harvard trained physician who chose to go the more natural route to healing people.  All his stuff is interesting.  Yes, your elevated level will most likely come down, as you heal better.  Pay attention to it but don't let it freak you out too much! 
    • Hi Calla, I think the safe answer is 12 weeks on gluten for a blood test.  I am pretty sure they say 2 weeks on gluten for the gut endoscopy.  But usually people/doctors don't want to  do an endoscopy before a positive blood test, so catch 22 there. There's a chance you still have active antibodies in your blood after 3 weeks off gluten.  But nobody can tell you for sure.  If you can get you doctor to test you now and in 9 more weeks if you are negative now, that might work.  If the doctor is willing to do 2 tests, that would be great. The best thing would have been to do all celiac disease testing before going gluten-free.  But sometimes it doesn't work out that way. The University of Chicago celiac center has an FAQ that answers some of your questions. http://www.cureceliacdisease.org/faq/i-dont-have-the-money-to-get-tested-for-celiac-disease-but-a-gluten-free-diet-makes-me-feel-better-is-it-okay-to-start-the-diet-without-being-diagnosed/ Welcome to the forum!  
    • Couldn't have said it better!  
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,159
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Anns
    Joined