Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Finding The Right Combination Of Learning Sources
0

17 posts in this topic

When attempting to learn about something in depth, the key often is to find the right combination of resources. It's almost impossible to find a one-stop shop that meets all needs when it comes to something as complicated as medicine and celiac disease. I would like to share with this group of people the combination of sources I have found that has helped me unlock many of the mysteries and impediments to my own understanding of celiac disease.

First off, the two books I bought after diagnosis last year were The Hidden Epidemic and Gluten Free for Dummies. Both are your pretty standard purchases and both launched me on my very imperfect often highly frustrating understanding of celiac disease.

The most annoying of my learning blocks was the concept of nutrient absorption. From the Green book (Hidden Epidemic: Celiac Disease) I walked away with - celiac disease prevents the proper absorption of nutrients from food. And that was pretty much it.

My screaming question was: ABSORPTION...WHERE????? Do I want food to pass into the blood stream? Does it go there directly? If we don't have villi then isn't the resulting Katie-bar-the-door free for all state of the small intestines in reality a good thing since then food is more easily and quickly taken into the blood stream?

This was my fundamental question/level of ignorance.

It was not until I happened upon The Key that I got it.

The Key is a wonderful book called Know Your Body: The Atlas of Anatomy, introduced by Trevor Weston MD. (It's also been introduced by others, I learned yesterday.) I l-o-v-e this handy dandy book and cannot recommend it highly enough. I am not particularly scientific-minded but I am curious and I loathe mysteries. This book was just what the doctor ordered.

The villi contain the blood vessels and lacteals that transport the nutrients either to the blood stream or to the liver (for further processing). It's all there in Know Your Body. This is THE supplement to the Green book for all those lay people out there, which is most of us.

Further supplementation: I Tunes U. Please check out this wonderful resource if you have access. Last night I listened to a professor at East Tennessee State lecture a class of what I believe were nursing students. From his lecture on the small intestine, I learned that there are at least three different sets of the most-rapidly dividing cells: nails, hair and those in the villi. In fact the epithelial cells of the villi are The Most Rapidly dividing cells. This is why people who are on chemo get sick. Makes sense! Chemo targets rapidly dividing cells, cancer cells, but also hair, nails and epithelials.

Sidetrack, sorry.

Know Your Body has one key component to facilitate learning: excellent drawings.

Who knows, I may regret my decision to go "all-in" learning about celiac disease, and I still have a long way to go (next up, IgA, antibodies, white blood cells, proteins-amino acids - basically the gluten trigger).

Please consider this wonderful (but hard to find) resource to aid your learning about celiac disease, auto immune disease, and to facilitate your care including doctors' appointments.

Plumbago

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

This is an excellent topic to raise--many of us continue to seek answers, especially the medical community is still pretty much in the dark about celiac and gluten sensitivity.

Your post answered a burning question I've had for about four years. I had chemo for breast cancer in 2007, and prior to starting my treatments, I'd had to receive iron infusions on a regular basis for about two years because of my inability to absorb iron. The last time I had an iron infusion was during my first chemo treatment (since I was being infused with chemicals, they figured that they'd kill two birds with one stone). After four months of chemo, my ferritin tests indicated that my level was normal...and I've never needed infusions since that time. I figured that the chemo probably played a part, but I didn't know how it had worked its magic to heal my gut. From your post, it appears that, along with my hair and nails, the villi also regrew after I finished my chemo treatments. Dr. Green, whom I'd contacted prior to starting the treatments, had told me that many celiacs feel better after having chemo but that I had to be extremely diligent about eating a gluten-free diet while I was undergoing treatment. Now I know why!

As for good resources for learning about the effects of gluten and how to improve nutritional absorption, I can highly recommend, "Primal Body, Primal Mind." I know that the title sounds as though the book is all about touting a particular diet, but it's more than that. The author explains in depth exactly what gluten (and dairy, etc.) can do to a body--right down to the molecular level. She also explains how nutrients work together synergistically in our cells and how to improve absorption and utilization of nutrients. I learned more about nutrition and its effects on the body from this book than any other that I've read (and reading books on nutrition has been pretty much my hobby for the past 40 years).

Thanks for starting this informative thread!

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think "knowledge is power" (teacher that I am), so I am with you!! Aside from consulting hubby's anatomy books, I have tried to read every scholarly journal article I can find. I figure the more I understand about Celiac, the more power I feel I have over it. I was bookmarking all I could find while researching for 2 years, but I discovered some generous person has compiled an incredible collection of Pub Med articles called "The Gluten File." I send this link to everyone I know.

Check this out!

http://sites.google.com/site/jccglutenfree/

I'd like to add two more books to your "library" :)

I HIGHLY recommend:

Recognizing Celiac Disease by Cleo Libonanti, RN

I often send newbies to the list of over 300 symptoms associated with Celiac on her site,

http://glutenfreeworks.com/gluten-disorders/celiac-disease/symptom-guide/

but reading the book made things so much clearer for me.

It explains how the GI tract works IN GREAT DETAIL. (For example, I wondered why I "burned" from my mouth right down my GI tract to you know where--and now I know why. No doctor could explain a burning mouth to me for 2 years before DX --they told me it was menopause and to "live with it" :blink: --so not true! Or why I had dozens of other inexplicable symptoms develop.)

It provides a primer on celiac disease as well as specific dietary guidelines.

But the most amazing part is the list of all the associated conditions, diseases and symptoms of celiac disease. There are charts explaining how vitamins, minerals, and amino acids are depleted in malabsorption. It also cites sources and explains if the condition resolves on a gluten-free diet or if it requires supplementation (such a vitamin D or B-12)or medical assistance and medication (such as thyroid disease).

It is a wealth of information that helped me make sense of what had gone so awry in my body.

Another good book for the newly diagnosed is:

Celiac Disease: The First Year by Jules Dowler Shepard.

Well- written and full of practical advice, including recipes, all from a celiac's perspective.

(I promise I do not know either of these women personally and am not just promoting book sales :lol: .)

This is an excellent idea for a thread. Thanks a bunch! :)

Cheers, IH

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read a few books but the best knowledge I got was here in these forums. I read so many past threads in many different sub forums. I used the search function on this site and read thread after thread. Then of course posting your questions and getting answers helps a lot, but sometimes an issue has been discussed in depth at a different time and you can find a wealth of information.

The only thing I would caution against based on my own personal experience is the fear that can come with all that knowledge. Reading all the stories about people having other diseases and issues put a lot of fear in my head. Even after I was feeling well, I was convinced there must be something else lurking in there and I couldn't enjoy wellness. I had adopted a mindset of sickness and being well didn't cure that mindset.

So when you're reading all this stuff, try not to personalize it. If you identify with something then use it to help you, but our thoughts and our mindset is so important in healing in addition to diet, etc.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only thing I would caution against based on my own personal experience is the fear that can come with all that knowledge. Reading all the stories about people having other diseases and issues put a lot of fear in my head. Even after I was feeling well, I was convinced there must be something else lurking in there and I couldn't enjoy wellness. I had adopted a mindset of sickness and being well didn't cure that mindset. So when you're reading all this stuff, try not to personalize it. If you identify with something then use it to help you, but our thoughts and our mindset is so important in healing in addition to diet, etc.

This is so true!! And this is exactly why it is good to consult valid, reliable sources about the disease process so you understand it fully and to focus on healing your own body. While advice from those who have "been there/done that" is incredibly helpful, you have to use common sense as well. I worried about "maybe it's this, maybe it's that" at first-- because I was not healing fast enough.

Addressing vitamin/mineral deficiencies was key for me --but I only knew what to have tested by reading about the most common deficiencies that occur in celiac and then, telling my doctor to check the levels. I was so exhausted and it turned out to be a folate def. for example--and if I had not read about that, I would still be floundering (because he did not think of it!).

The best advice I try to relay to others who may still feel lousy for months after going gluten-free is...you're still healing; it does NOT necessarily mean you now have thyroid disease or some other complication. Sure you should have follow-up testing with your doctor, but try to relax. I always try to soothe the newbie's feathers because our minds can go to "what else is wrong with me?" so easily. Usually, "It just IS what it IS until it isn't. " :)

Healing takes time and you have to relax and be patient. It's not easy for those of us with major complications and pain, but unfortunately, there is no "fast forward" button. :rolleyes:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I was having lingering fatigue for the longest time. I found out my iron was low normal. Low normal isn't good enough in my opinion considering the range is huge. I started taking iron and what a difference it made. But the doc just said it was normal. I had to look at my own labs and say wait a minute, this isn't good.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was having lingering fatigue for the longest time. I found out my iron was low normal. Low normal isn't good enough in my opinion considering the range is huge. I started taking iron and what a difference it made. But the doc just said it was normal. I had to look at my own labs and say wait a minute, this isn't good.

Good for you! Another good piece of advice for others is: be your own best advocate. I saved my own life. No exaggeration ;)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read a few books but the best knowledge I got was here in these forums. I read so many past threads in many different sub forums. I used the search function on this site and read thread after thread. Then of course posting your questions and getting answers helps a lot, but sometimes an issue has been discussed in depth at a different time and you can find a wealth of information.

The only thing I would caution against based on my own personal experience is the fear that can come with all that knowledge. Reading all the stories about people having other diseases and issues put a lot of fear in my head. Even after I was feeling well, I was convinced there must be something else lurking in there and I couldn't enjoy wellness. I had adopted a mindset of sickness and being well didn't cure that mindset.

So when you're reading all this stuff, try not to personalize it. If you identify with something then use it to help you, but our thoughts and our mindset is so important in healing in addition to diet, etc.

Thanks for this. So true about fear being a contagion on the Internet at times.

But it's not really what I was referring to in my original post. What I was saying or trying to say had to do with studying as opposed to quickly looking things up on the Internet, and darting from site to site. Book-learning vs Web-learning to put it simplistically.

I want to learn this thing from the inside out.

When I delve into it in this way, I actually have less fear (as someone earlier pointed out).

Plumbago

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I want to learn this thing from the inside out.

When I delve into it in this way, I actually have less fear (as someone earlier pointed out).

Plumbago

Yes! That's what I was saying!! I have no fear now ---because I know my "enemy" :)

NOT knowing WHY I was so ill and incapacitated and slowly dying for nearly 4 years was frightening. I KNEW there had to be an explanation for it all.

I find that most people are intimidated by this DX because they do not really understand it. No reason to be scared.

I'll say it again...Knowledge is power. ;)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All the replies have been very good so far. I wish there were more!

One thing that I would like to have are more recommendations for books. The Green book was very good, once I supplemented my knowledge with the Atlas of Anatomy. Without the latter book, the Green book was only moderately useful to me, if that.

We've gotten some good recommendations so far. Are there any more? In particular, I'm looking for a description of the "attack." The gluten attack. Antibodies, white blood cels, messengers telling attackers to continue or to cease.

And gluten.

What is this thing? Does it have any nutritive value (for non-Celiacs of course)? Where does it go? Does it just lodge in the wall of the small intestine? Or does it go somewhere else?

Proteins, amino acids. A good description.

So please recommend away!

Also, would it not be great to have a live online discussion with some celiac disease experts from time to time? Advertised with a big scrolling banner, so that we can all mark our calendars ahead of time?!

How can we make this happen?

I hope everyone enjoyed their Thanksgiving.

Plumbago

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

All the replies have been very good so far. I wish there were more!

One thing that I would like to have are more recommendations for books. The Green book was very good, once I supplemented my knowledge with the Atlas of Anatomy. Without the latter book, the Green book was only moderately useful to me, if that.

We've gotten some good recommendations so far. Are there any more? In particular, I'm looking for a description of the "attack." The gluten attack. Antibodies, white blood cels, messengers telling attackers to continue or to cease.

And gluten.

What is this thing? Does it have any nutritive value (for non-Celiacs of course)? Where does it go? Does it just lodge in the wall of the small intestine? Or does it go somewhere else?

Proteins, amino acids. A good description.

So please recommend away!

Also, would it not be great to have a live online discussion with some celiac disease experts from time to time? Advertised with a big scrolling banner, so that we can all mark our calendars ahead of time?!

How can we make this happen?

I hope everyone enjoyed their Thanksgiving.

Plumbago

The book I recommended (above) Recognizing Celiac Disease --has quite a bit about gluten, what it is and how it "attacks", protein toxicity, antibodies, and what ensues in the GI Tract and the entire body in celiac disease. Not sure how much else there is to know after all that, but if I find anything else, I'll let you know. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The book I recommended (above) Recognizing Celiac Disease --has quite a bit about gluten, what it is and how it "attacks", protein toxicity, antibodies, and what ensues in the GI Tract and the entire body in celiac disease. Not sure how much else there is to know after all that, but if I find anything else, I'll let you know. :)

Sorry, I meant to comment specifically on that recommendation. First I was going to check it out from our library system (you know, that of the capital of the United States?), but alas, not available. Sadly this is not unusual.

So, I called a local bookstore. No, not available to order. I prefer to buy things at real walk-in stores, but I'm not sure this is going to be possible.

Thanks for the recommendation, wish me luck tracking it down.

Plumbago

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry, I meant to comment specifically on that recommendation. First I was going to check it out from our library system (you know, that of the capital of the United States?), but alas, not available. Sadly this is not unusual.

So, I called a local bookstore. No, not available to order. I prefer to buy things at real walk-in stores, but I'm not sure this is going to be possible.

Thanks for the recommendation, wish me luck tracking it down.

Plumbago

Go to the site link I posted earlier..it's there. About $36 I think.??

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Go to the site link I posted earlier..it's there. About $36 I think.??

I ordered it from Abe Books. Thank you so much for the recommendation.

Although I haven't read it yet in much detail, it is a workbook and seems to be just in line with what I am looking for.

We'll see if I can at last understand the gluten attack!

Plumbago

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I ordered it from Abe Books. Thank you so much for the recommendation.

Although I haven't read it yet in much detail, it is a workbook and seems to be just in line with what I am looking for.

We'll see if I can at last understand the gluten attack!

Plumbago

It's not really a workbook exactly, but the layout seems like one. :)

I found it to be an excellent resource and it explained why I burned so much and how I developed all my deficiencies, etc. It all made sense.

The GI tract is explained in such detail.

Hope you find it helpful.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Celiac Disease: The First Year by Jules Dowler Shepard.

Well- written and full of practical advice, including recipes, all from a celiac's perspective.

I really liked this book too. It's a good book for coping with a diagnosis and the next steps to take.

I just finished reading "Healthier without Wheat" by Stephen Wagnen. He covers both Celiac and NCGI in the book. He describes a lot of the medical issues but in laymen's terms. I liked that he acknowledged a lot of the NCGI issues as well as the actual Celiac stuff.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really liked this book too. It's a good book for coping with a diagnosis and the next steps to take.

I just finished reading "Healthier without Wheat" by Stephen Wagnen. He covers both Celiac and NCGI in the book. He describes a lot of the medical issues but in laymen's terms. I liked that he acknowledged a lot of the NCGI issues as well as the actual Celiac stuff.

I have that one by Wagnen as well. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,341
    • Total Posts
      920,478
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • As a GI specialty nurse who also has celiac I can tell you that it can not be diagnosed by CT and rarely unless you have severe disease can it be diagnosed by colonoscopy.  Those that have had it diagnosed by colonoscopy have such because their MDs were above to get into the small bowel from the bottom and take biopsys.  Celiac damage is not seen in the large intestine.  Also many people do not have diarrhea, many have constipation or a 50/50 mix between the two.  Celiac has 300 connected symptoms and sometimes no symptoms at all.  It's called the " great pretender" because of this.
    • Okay, thanks! I am 24 but my husband and I don't plan on having kids. However, the more I thought about it, the more I think I should get one for my brother's sake. Especially after my doctor's office called this evening to say my bloodwork tested positive for Celiac. Guess I will be on this forum longer than I thought!
    • You just got diagnosed Celiac and are wondering how serious this really is. What if there is just a little gluten in your food? What if you use the same toaster for your gluten-free bread as your wife's/husband's regular bread? What if those french fries are gluten-free but they fry them in the same fryer as those nice gluten coated onion rings? View the full article
    • Hi, I've never been on a forum before but thought I might find some answers here.  I have never been tested for celiac but a nurse practitioner I saw a few years ago told me she thought I would benefit from a gluten free diet.  At first, I thought I could never do this but after some encouragement I did try.  I did feel much better after going gluten free.  She never tested me for celiac. I turned 50 years old last year and I had a colonoscopy for the first time and had three polyps removed.  The surgeon said that my colon looked like I was a chronic laxative user.  I haven't used a laxative for a very long time.  I was at the time drinking a natural tea to help me to have bowel movements.  Before starting the tea I had always had difficulty with bowel movements and never had them once a day but with the tea I was able to go once a day. At the end of last month I developed severe pain after I would eat (I had my gallbladder removed at the age of 19).  One night the pain got so bad my husband had to drive me to the ER.  My liver functions were high as well as a few other things.  They did a CT scan of my abdomen and pelvis that showed wall thickening of my transverse colon and minimal irregularity involving the transverse colon.  My descending and sigmoid colon were collapsed.  There were a few tiny mesenteric lymph nodes present on the right.  They diagnosed me officially with colitis but said that most likely I had a gallstone (even though I don't have a gallbladder) that had come from the liver and had gotten stuck in the common bile duct (it did not show up on the CT scan).  I usually have a high ferritin level too.  I've been home from the hospital stay for about a month now and still have tenderness in the epigastric area. Some of this may not have anything to do with celiac but was wondering if anyone has been diagnosed with celiac by CT scan or colonoscopy or if anyone has had the same problems that I have had and found out what has caused it.  I cannot see the gastroenterologist who saw me in the hospital for a couple of months.  Can you have celiac and not have diarrhea as I am just the opposite? Any help would be appreciated!  Thanks!  
    • I had an acne flair up after going gluten free but it ended up improving and some long-term back acne I had been dealing with actually went away.  I think going gluten free was a shock to my system and at first I actually felt worse but after about a month things got better. 
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,411
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Aly46
    Joined