Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Positive W/ Enterolab But Not Going gluten-free Because.....
0

20 posts in this topic

My two daughters were tested positive through enterolab about 2 years ago for gluten and dairy. Their results were the same and they were very mild like 21 is all. Normal being under 10. It was soooo much work going gluten-free and they weren't having many symptoms so I stayed eating gluten becuase I didn't really believe the tests or reliability of Enterolab. While one of my daughters isn't showing symptoms my other daughter has gas, bloating, constipation/diarhea, VERY short, canker sores, naseau and severe emotional outbursts. But.... they don't seem consistant and don't necessarily happen after eating gluten. Seems like there is no rhyme nore reason. I am thinking of doing gluten-free again but its so expensive and so much work and I am really wondering about Enterolab and maybe its a hype?

My husbands two sisters are full blown celiac by biopsy and blood tests. My 2nd cousin is celiac by biopsy so we have it on both sides. Blood test results for my daughters were negative (which is why I didn't really do gluten-free long because I chose to believe the doctors test over enterolab.

Anyone have comments about Enterolab? is eating gluten when they are only mildly elavated ok? because it doesn't seem to bother one of my daughters and not sure about the other. Are these reliable tests? I am very skeptical!!! I gave the results to my naturepath and he didn't really blink an eye since Enterolab isn't well published.

I am wondering about other intolerances as well. Where would I get testing for that? Should I do further testing through maybe saliva so I can back up the tests through enterolab?

Thanks a bunch for any help I am new to this.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Why don't you get your daughter tested for celiac with blood tests? She has classic symptoms.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi and welcome.

Did you and your daughters have TTG on Enterolab or only anti-gliadin? As you mention, on the Enterolab website there is data showing that anti-gliadin shows up in 30% of the healthy people they test. Fecal anti-gliadin is pretty consistently elevated in people with celiac disease, which is why some people find it useful. The other reason people find Enterolab useful is that it can confirm their suspicion of non-celiac gluten intolerance, which can make you very sick even though blood & biopsy are normal. TTG from Enterolab is more of a concern because it's an autoimmune antibody. Especially in your symptomatic daughter I would take Enterolab TTG very seriously.

Blood testing is the other way around. A person can have serious villous damage and a completely negative celiac panel. The blood tests give false negatives about 30% of the time. Biopsies are hit and miss as well, since damage can be patchy and some doctors only take 3 or 4 samples from the whole small intestine. On top of that, there is no indication at all of non-celiac gluten intolerance using traditional blood & biopsy testing. Gluten intolerance can still cause malabsorption to the point of anemia, low calcium, and poor growth and trigger thyroid inflammation and autoimmunity.

I would be very concerned about your symptomatic daughter. The canker sores, short stature, GI problems, and outbursts are very typical of celiac or gluten intolerance and it runs in your husband's side of the family. A lot of us had seemingly random reactions on gluten. Sometimes eating gluten is fine and sometimes you run for the bathroom after a bowl of pasta. On the board we think it's because your immune system is trying to cope with the constant onslaught of gluten. A lot of people find that once they're off gluten their immune system functions more normally and gluten reactions become more consistent and sometimes stronger.

If I were you, I would aggressively try to get your symptomatic daughter blood tested and biopsied, then take her off gluten for at least six months no matter what the results are to check for gluten intolerance. The Enterolab results are one clue, her family history a second, and her obvious celiac symptoms a third. You may see big improvements in her health, which is well worth the expense of the gluten-free diet. If she is celiac, or gluten-intolerant enough to have some malabsorption she may grow up with short stature, weak bones, and possibly other autoimmune diseases if she stays on gluten.

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with Skylark.

Just because her blood test was negative 2 years ago, doesn't mean it won't be positive now. She may not have had enough antibodies get into the blood yet. I would ask to get a copy of those blood tests, too. We have had people on here who have been told they had a negative blood test and the right tests weren't run or the results were positive. Many or most doctors know very little about Celiac so you really need to check up on them.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why don't you get your daughter tested for celiac with blood tests? She has classic symptoms.

Her blood tests were negative.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I agree with Skylark.

Just because her blood test was negative 2 years ago, doesn't mean it won't be positive now. She may not have had enough antibodies get into the blood yet. I would ask to get a copy of those blood tests, too. We have had people on here who have been told they had a negative blood test and the right tests weren't run or the results were positive. Many or most doctors know very little about Celiac so you really need to check up on them.

Thanks ladies! I didn't know I could test again for blood thats good to know. Her symptoms seem to get worse as she gets older. She acts sort of like she has blood sugar issues too! And goes pee ALLLLLL the time! ANd pees the bed.

She had TTG and IGA done with enterolab. both positive TTG was more positive but still low enough to wonder if it was reliable. I do not want to see her with the healthy problems my mom and sister have. They have never been dx with celiac but they have SEVERAL autoimmune issues and I really believe are at least gluten intolerance. The doctors can't find out why they are so sick. If there is a symptom they have it!! Thyroid, arthritis, weight gain, canker sores, diahrea, vomiting, severe adema, disk degeneration in spine, very low D3 and anemia, both are under 5 ft and I could literally go on and on. You wouldn't believe it! Both are on heavy duty meds with not enough diagnosis.

I am going to talk to her naturpath and see what he says again. I was thinking of getting the york lab testing done. I think its saliva? or redo of Enterolab. In addition to the blood tests again.

Thanks so much for your support. I can't believe how hard it is to dx this!!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure it's worth the money to redo Enterolab or chase down York lab. The information is interesting, but her symptoms really tell the story. With both anti-gliadin and TTG fecal IgA plus obvious symptoms, your daughter REALLY needs to be off gluten. There isn't as much data in PubMed about fecal TTG but the few bits & pieces I've turned up suggest that the positive fecal TTG is much more concern than anti-gliadin and can indicate an inflammatory process like celiac or Crohn's. With the celiac in the family and anti-gliadin IgA it's almost certain that gluten is the issue.

There is no harm getting celiac bloodwork again to see if it's changed. I still think you should push for a biopsy if you can get one fairly fast while she is still eating gluten. Then take her off gluten and don't look back!

Your mom and sister sound like gluten could be their issue as well. I would strongly suggest you try the diet as well. You may be pleasantly surprised how good you feel off gluten.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure it's worth the money to redo Enterolab or chase down York lab. The information is interesting, but her symptoms really tell the story. With both anti-gliadin and TTG fecal IgA plus obvious symptoms, your daughter REALLY needs to be off gluten. There isn't as much data in PubMed about fecal TTG but the few bits & pieces I've turned up suggest that the positive fecal TTG is much more concern than anti-gliadin and can indicate an inflammatory process like celiac or Crohn's. With the celiac in the family and anti-gliadin IgA it's almost certain that gluten is the issue.

There is no harm getting celiac bloodwork again to see if it's changed. I still think you should push for a biopsy if you can get one fairly fast while she is still eating gluten. Then take her off gluten and don't look back!

Your mom and sister sound like gluten could be their issue as well. I would strongly suggest you try the diet as well. You may be pleasantly surprised how good you feel off gluten.

Thanks sooo much for your advice! I will talk to my naturpath about getting her tested and then go gluten-free after those are done~ I do not want her to go through what my mom and sister are going through. My sister sees an endocronologist next week and I told her which tests to get for celiac. I am almost certain she has it. Her son has ALL the symptoms and bipolar!! he is homeless now and I wonder how different it would have been if he was gluten-free from the beginning. His symptoms were SEVERE!!

Wish doctors were more serious about gluten intolerance or celiac. :(

I will ask for biopsy but since she hasn't been in and out of the dr's I doubt that he would do it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with the other posters. I just wanted to share my kids' stories.

I think my youngest son(he is almost 7) has had celiac since he was a baby. We just didn't know it then. I was diagnosed when he as almost 4, and by that time he "seemed" healthy and was doing well. His celiac bloodwork was negative then. Fast forward 1 1/2 years and he started having random symptoms and like your daughter, didn't seem consistant. So I took him to a new allergist to explore food allergies/intolerences and to rescreen for celiac. Two years from his first celiac blood test(he was almost 6) he had another screening and his IgA tTG was positive. We did not do a biopsy. It's been one year since he went gluten free and it has been amazing. He is doing so well now and has grown 4" since he was diagnosed.

I also have an older son(almost 11) who has had his own various issues. I had him screened when I was diagnosed also. I have had him screened three more times since then. Everything is very negative on him. I toyed with the idea of putting him gluten free for around two years. I even had people on here encouraging me to try it. I did not because of the overwhelming negative evidence in his tests. In August of this year I took him for a scope to check in case he was a seronegative celiac. Negative also. Due to his issues he was having and his stalled growth(his brother is 4 years younger and after his major growth spurt gluten free I had a hard time telling their clothes apart) I decided to try him on the diet. You want to know what my regret is? Not trying it sooner! He no longer has the issues he was having prior, has gained 5+ pounds since August and is starting to grow! I think it was starting to bother him that he was one of the smallest in the 5th grade.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Roda thanks for sharing your story!!! I am definately going to have her retested and if negative maybe retest through enterolab just to see if more damage has been done with the TTG test. Thanks for your support.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Roda thanks for sharing your story!!! I am definately going to have her retested and if negative maybe retest through enterolab just to see if more damage has been done with the TTG test. Thanks for your support.

Blood TTG does not correlate very well with the amount of damage, let alone fecal. You would need to have her biopsied for that.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Blood TTG does not correlate very well with the amount of damage, let alone fecal. You would need to have her biopsied for that.

Would the test read a higher number though? or does the number not really matter. Hers was 19 and normal is 10 and under so it really wasn't all that high!! Which is why I was thinking its no biggie and probably didn't need to go gluten-free.

Thanks again for all your advice. I am new to all this.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would the test read a higher number though? or does the number not really matter. Hers was 19 and normal is 10 and under so it really wasn't all that high!! Which is why I was thinking its no biggie and probably didn't need to go gluten-free.

Thanks again for all your advice. I am new to all this.

No, the test doesn't necessarily read a higher number for more damage.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Would the test read a higher number though? or does the number not really matter. Hers was 19 and normal is 10 and under so it really wasn't all that high!! Which is why I was thinking its no biggie and probably didn't need to go gluten-free.

Thanks again for all your advice. I am new to all this.

My youngest son's tTG was 16 with > 15 positive. So he was only one number over being positive. I have no idea if he would have had any visible damage or not since we did not do a biopsy. He reacts terrible when he injests gluten. We got his 1 yr blood work back and I'm happy to report that it is now negative at a 2!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

about the sisters with all the health problems, if they take any steroids for the other issues, the celiac tests will show negative despite them being gluten sensitive.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

about the sisters with all the health problems, if they take any steroids for the other issues, the celiac tests will show negative despite them being gluten sensitive.

Really?

How long does the steroid effect last?

Wow, the more I learn the more I'm convinced I wouldn't have tested positive if I'd done it. Maybe the Hashis would have helped boost the scores but otherwise it sounds like I'd be neg all around (steroids, DH, neuro, no GI symptoms except d).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do not know for how long, but steroid effects usually last three weeks, and then the gluten damage has to start building up after that, in order to start getting positive on tests...

I did take some low dose steroids too back then when I got ill from gluten, and I guess I tested negative for that reason too.

They use steroids to treat those with refractory celiac too (bad cases of celiac) because it helps

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do not know for how long, but steroid effects usually last three weeks, and then the gluten damage has to start building up after that, in order to start getting positive on tests...

I did take some low dose steroids too back then when I got ill from gluten, and I guess I tested negative for that reason too.

They use steroids to treat those with refractory celiac too (bad cases of celiac) because it helps

I had two steroid shots and a week of prednisone 2 months prior to starting gluten-free. Hmmm...

They say the shots can stayaffective 3-6 months.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, that would mess with diagnosis.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, that would mess with diagnosis.

So I guess I'll stop wondering "what if"....

Still debating on eating sushi, cheesecake and souffle again and going in for a skin biopsy to see if it's DH....

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      103,644
    • Total Posts
      918,442
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • How effective is HD skin biopsy after being gluten free for a year
      Looks like you got some good info from previous posters.   I don't understand why you and your doctor think that dairy contains gluten?  Lactose is a sugar not a protein like gluten.  I think you have some other issues.  
    • Question on posting
      I made an informative video for Celiac Awareness Month that demonstrates how small 20ppm is. Am I allowed to post a vimeo link? Thanks!
    • Celiac Awareness on NBC Nightly News
      http://www.nbcnews.com/nightly-news/video/celiac-disease-affecting-millions-of-americans-often-goes-undiagnosed-692131907739   This was on last Tuesday. So happy that a popular national news program is spreading good information!
    • The US Preventative Services Task Force needs our help - tell them why Celiac screening is important!
      I am so angry. I am all about universal screening for Celiac Disease. It is a tricky disease to diagnose. Your only symptoms may be joint pain, depression, or weak nails, which people will try to cure with medication or a good manicure. With roughly 80% of the Celiac population remaining undiagnosed, universal screening could save thousands of lives. This article popped up in my twitter feed regarding US physicians who are unsure whether universal screening would provide “health benefits” for those who exhibit no symptoms (http://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-celiac-screening-idUSKCN0XU2G6?utm_content=buffer3ed50&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer) First of all, no symptom is a symptom! There is something called “Silent Celiac Disease”, and I personally know several people who have it. They experience no outward symptoms caused by gluten consumption, but their insides are being torn apart. If they eat gluten, they may not feel it, but they are highly at risk for long term complications such as cancer, miscarriages, and osteoporosis, just to name a few. Also, let’s consider the non-GI related symptoms of Celiac. Doctors, how many times does someone walk into your office and say, “Gee, Doc, could you test me for Celiac Disease? I have (insert one of the following)”: asthma bladder infections dental problems dandruff high blood pressure headaches blurred vision leg cramps back pain pale skin brittle nails acne bad bread mood swings ADD Anxiety Depression a short temper night terrors panic attacks irrational anger sinus pressure Those are just a few of the symptoms that people don’t think to associate with Celiac Disease, and I’m sure that you, Mr. Doctor, will not test someone with Celiac Disease if they have dandruff. This is why so many people are undiagnosed! People do not recognize the symptoms and doctors won’t think to give them a blood test. This is why I always say – You cannot know that you do not have Celiac Disease until you get tested. “One concern with widespread screening is that biopsies aren’t risk-free and may confirm cases of celiac disease that weren’t causing problems for patients and didn’t necessarily require treatment, Krist noted.” WHAT?????? First of all, most Celiac screening starts with a gene test or a blood test. That aside, ALL confirmed cases of Celiac Disease require treatment!! Untreated Celiac Disease can cause many problems in the future. “Guidelines for gastroenterologists recommend celiac screening for people with a close relative with celiac and for diabetics who are at increased risk for the disease, Murray said by email.” I was the first person in my family to be diagnosed. 80% of Celiacs don’t know they have it. I would have never been diagnosed if my gastroenterologist said, “Well you don’t have diabetes and no one in your family has it….” No one in my family had heard about Celiac Disease, let alone had been tested for it. And we have all of the tradition GI symptoms. This is not a rare disease. About 1% of the population has Celiac Disease. Take a look at your facebook friends list – have 500 friends? Odds are that you know four or five friends with Celiac. MAYBE one of them will be diagnosed. Maybe. The others will be suffering in silence. “The USPSTF, a government-backed independent organization that reviews medical evidence, issues recommendations that are closely watched by doctors and insurers. This is the first time the USPSTF has weighed in on screening for celiac disease, and the task force will accept public comments until May 30 before releasing final guidelines.” This brought me to the USPSTF website. In their draft, here is what is listed as “Potential Harms” of screening in asymptomatic populations. I’ve included my response: False positive – there are rarely false positives Unnecessary serologic tests and biopsies – umm…only do a biopsy if you have a positive blood test. And what’s so bad about a blood test? Anxiety of complications from testing – I had much more anxiety in my pre-Celiac days, not knowing if I would poop my pants at work. “Some patients with positive serology who do not undergo histologic confirmation may embark on efforts to avoid dietary gluten, which can increase costs and burdens and may result in decreased quality of life” “– I’m glad that you think my life is so terrible. “Limited evidence from long-term followup studies have shown that some persons with biopsy-confirmed celiac disease may never develop symptoms or complications” – I’m not going to risk getting cancer, are you??? The USPSTF is taking public responses to their draft, all of which must be submitted by May 30th. I highly urge you to write in and explain why universal screening is important. My Celiac diagnosis saved my life. If universal screening can do the same for a huge portion of the population – I am all for it. This could be the most important thing you do for Celiac Awareness Month. Read the draft and write to the USPSTF here. http://www.uspreventiveservicestaskforce.org/Page/Document/draft-recommendation-statement150/celiac-disease-screening
    • New to this--first gluttened exp. How to feel better?
      Just adding to what others have said.  It does take some time but it's likely you will start to feel better.  It took me about a year but now I feel great.  A good probiotic might help.  I use one from Synergy that my naturopathic doctor sells at her office.  I have gotten in the habit of emailing restaurants before I try them and have had very good luck.  One owner of a very popular restaurant in my area took the time to reply and said she had Celiac disease (she sent great detailed info about their food).  Many of the people responding will even tell you who to ask for when you come in.  Good luck and hoping you feel better soon.
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

    • celiac sharon  »  cyclinglady

      Hello cycling lady, have you noticed my picture is showing up as you?  Have no idea why but it's rather disconcerting to see my picture and your words 😉  Do you know how to fix it?  You seem to have far more experience with this board than I do
      · 1 reply
    • Larry Gessner  »  cyclinglady

      Hi There, I don't know if there is a place for videos in the forum. I just watched "The Truth About Gluten" I think it is a good video. I would like to share it somewhere but don't know where it should go. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
      Here is the link if you have never watched it.
      https://youtu.be/IU6jVEwpjnE Thank You,
      Larry
      · 2 replies
    • ChiaChick  »  Peaceflower

      Hi Peaceflower, Just wanted to say thank you for the chat.
      · 0 replies
  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      60,738
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Ladywolf
    Joined