Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Bread Without Gum And Starch
0

15 posts in this topic

I'm going to do some experimenting soon to see how much gum and starches really are necessary in bread. Is there anybody who has already experimented in this area? What were your results? I don't use gum in my cookies or pancakes, and they turn out fine. I'm just not comfortable adding things to my food that may not contribute to my health.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

I'm going to do some experimenting soon to see how much gum and starches really are necessary in bread. Is there anybody who has already experimented in this area? What were your results? I don't use gum in my cookies or pancakes, and they turn out fine. I'm just not comfortable adding things to my food that may not contribute to my health.

Cookies and pancakes definitely do not need gums. In fact, one of the pitfalls of making pancakes with wheat is that if you stir them too much, the glutens develop, and the pancakes end up tasting tough. gluten-free pancakes are easier to make, since you can stir them as much as you want, with no fear of making long strings of gluten!

For breads, glutens typically act like velcro - they hold everything together. That's how you can get high rising soft breads with wheat flour, but gluten-free breads are (comparatively) dense and crumbly.

Gum doesn't really replace gluten, but it acts in a similar manner, and helps to hold the dough together more when it rises.

I doubt that you'll be able to make a nicely textured bread without some type of stabilizer, but it may be possible to do it without xanthum or guar gum.

I've heard of some people using Psyllium Fiber (the active ingredient in Metamucil) as a replacement for the gums, but I haven't tried it myself. It may be worth a try.

I'd read up a lot on the chemistry of bread baking before you start practicing, and be aware that you may need to make a lot of bread in order to find out what works and what doesn't.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cookies and pancakes definitely do not need gums. In fact, one of the pitfalls of making pancakes with wheat is that if you stir them too much, the glutens develop, and the pancakes end up tasting tough. gluten-free pancakes are easier to make, since you can stir them as much as you want, with no fear of making long strings of gluten!

For breads, glutens typically act like velcro - they hold everything together. That's how you can get high rising soft breads with wheat flour, but gluten-free breads are (comparatively) dense and crumbly.

Gum doesn't really replace gluten, but it acts in a similar manner, and helps to hold the dough together more when it rises.

I doubt that you'll be able to make a nicely textured bread without some type of stabilizer, but it may be possible to do it without xanthum or guar gum.

I've heard of some people using Psyllium Fiber (the active ingredient in Metamucil) as a replacement for the gums, but I haven't tried it myself. It may be worth a try.

I'd read up a lot on the chemistry of bread baking before you start practicing, and be aware that you may need to make a lot of bread in order to find out what works and what doesn't.

I'm with you.

I've tried bread with psyllium and gelatin with fair results. I've also tried it with psyllium and a gum with better results. Sometimes I've used both xanthan and guar. Many combinations but I know my food science, too. It certainly helps knowing about different ingredients' characteristics, how they interact with other ingredients and their uses.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wan to ask WHY people are afraid of gar gum? It's in everything! Take a look on most any packaged food. It's a laxative.....

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With a pan bread baked in a cast iron skillet, using egg and part amaranth and ground almonds, no gum is needed.

Using a mini loaf pan, I can get small loaves of gluten free bread which are whole grain and whole wheat like, dense, suitable for fresh sliced with butter, toast, or grilled cheese. This bread does hold together, but is not that "flexible" like a gummed bread. I used a mix of flours which includes amaranth and buckwheat and almond, besides the others, because the are "stickier." Used one egg per loaf, but have done it without that. Also used 1 tablespoon chia seed per loaf, soaked in cold water. Tried adding 1/2 to 1 teaspoon soaked in water psyllium as well, that also worked.

See this recipe here, it can be made with an egg added, as well

Gluten free, gum free, yeast free, vegan Buckwheat mini loaf Bread

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I haven't seen anyone mention grinding. You do whisk them in water. The longer they sit, the more they dissolve.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I use chia seeds, do I need to grind them?

Nope! You just put them in tap water and stir to wet them. They gel up on their own. If you have kids, they can have fun watching this. The seeds are not that noticeable in the finished bread.

Flax needs to be ground up for this.

Use gluten free psyllium if you try that route.... be sure to soak that in water, also, before adding to any recipe.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have you tried any of the grain-free breads? I've been making lovely baked goods from flax meal, almond meal, or coconut fiber. They take a lot of eggs and oil, but no starch or gums.

Try this, only don't use the salt. It's plenty salty from the baking powder.

http://www.elanaspantry.com/flax-focaccia-becomes-parsely-bruschetta/

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have you tried any of the grain-free breads? I've been making lovely baked goods from flax meal, almond meal, or coconut fiber. They take a lot of eggs and oil, but no starch or gums.

Try this, only don't use the salt. It's plenty salty from the baking powder.

http://www.elanaspantry.com/flax-focaccia-becomes-parsely-bruschetta/

This does make a decent bread but I do prefer it with a finishing salt on top (that's just me - I love the pure flavour of fleur de sel, not to mention the crunch. I am a texture person. :D ).

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As was stated, pancakes and cookies can turn out well without any gums, and thus far I get better results without much of any binders in pancakes, and none in cookies. I agree with what Glutin-Free Man said.

As for chia seeds, I haven't found any need to grind them. Simply soaking them in water works well - similar to soaking flax seeds. Though flax not only effects the taste, but also remains quite noticeable in the bread, and may detract from the desired result. This is why flax is usually ground before using for its mucilaginous characteristic. However, I've also found chia to be ineffective as a binder in breads. It may have some binding ability, but leaves much to be desired.

Being that gelatin melts at a fairly low temperature, it (and other substances with similar characteristics) are basically ineffective as binders when it comes to achieving a risen bread. Once the bread cools enough, this type of ingredient may contribute to the moistness, and alter the way it feels in the mouth. There may also be some effect on shelf life.

Eggs can work as a kind of binder, but do not function like the gums enough to replace them. Things like cake are where eggs generally have more utility than they do in breads.

Having experimented extensively, I can say without a doubt that xanthan and guar gum are the most effective binders I'm aware of for making gluten-free breads. They are not laxatives, but acting as dietary fibers, can effect the digestive tract the way certain fibers do. Although the amount generally consumed in a serving of bread is rather small, thus the effect should also be quite minimal, if even noticeable at all. That said, some people are very sensitive to them, either because of an intolerance/allergy, or their digestive systems may be more sensitive to certain types of mucilages/fibers, or some other reason. We're all different in that respect. Xanthan is usually derived from the fermentation of corn, while guar gum is from a leguminous tree.

More of what I've learned about using xanthan and guar can be found in this thread.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As was stated, pancakes and cookies can turn out well without any gums, and thus far I get better results without much of any binders in pancakes, and none in cookies. I agree with what Glutin-Free Man said.

As for chia seeds, I haven't found any need to grind them. Simply soaking them in water works well - similar to soaking flax seeds. Though flax not only effects the taste, but also remains quite noticeable in the bread, and may detract from the desired result. This is why flax is usually ground before using for its mucilaginous characteristic. However, I've also found chia to be ineffective as a binder in breads. It may have some binding ability, but leaves much to be desired.

Being that gelatin melts at a fairly low temperature, it (and other substances with similar characteristics) are basically ineffective as binders when it comes to achieving a risen bread. Once the bread cools enough, this type of ingredient may contribute to the moistness, and alter the way it feels in the mouth. There may also be some effect on shelf life.

Eggs can work as a kind of binder, but do not function like the gums enough to replace them. Things like cake are where eggs generally have more utility than they do in breads.

Having experimented extensively, I can say without a doubt that xanthan and guar gum are the most effective binders I'm aware of for making gluten-free breads. They are not laxatives, but acting as dietary fibers, can effect the digestive tract the way certain fibers do. Although the amount generally consumed in a serving of bread is rather small, thus the effect should also be quite minimal, if even noticeable at all. That said, some people are very sensitive to them, either because of an intolerance/allergy, or their digestive systems may be more sensitive to certain types of mucilages/fibers, or some other reason. We're all different in that respect. Xanthan is usually derived from the fermentation of corn, while guar gum is from a leguminous tree.

More of what I've learned about using xanthan and guar can be found in this thread.

I made pancakes using KA flour. I make a full batch of batter and refrigerate half overnight for the next day's pancakes....

Anyway, the batch using the chia was fine the first day (noticed no difference between using chia and xanthan). Second day it was hideous.

Made another batch leaving out chia and xanthan... first day was better than the two using chia or xanthan. Second day was AWESOME - I guess the flours had time to do some magic. I will no longer use xanthan or chia in my pancakes!!

Thanks for insisting pancakes don't need either, or I wouldn't have tried it!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As much as I really wanted to do some experimenting, it turns out I'm actually sensitive to all grains at the moment. So, no bread for me. :(

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As much as I really wanted to do some experimenting, it turns out I'm actually sensitive to all grains at the moment. So, no bread for me. :(

Ooh, that sucks.

Hope you get it straightened out soon.

If you can do nuts and dates and sugar (honestly you could do without the sugar in the recipe), and coconut I posted a bourbon ball recipe the other day that's grain free.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,703
    • Total Posts
      921,801
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hi everyone, I've been reading this forum sporadically and have some questions of my own. I'm in my 40s and was diagnosed with celiac last December by biopsy and blood work after months of tests by my primary and then a gastro. My husband, around the same age as me, was dx'd with stage 4 cancer a month later, so admittedly it's took me longer than I'd have liked to learn about celiac. Now I feel pretty on top of my diet. I mostly make my own food - proteins and veggies, with some certified gluten-free snacks in the mix - and am pretty strict about what I will/won't eat at friend's houses or in restaurants (I prefer to go to dedicated gluten-free kitchens whenever possible). I'm doing okay on the diet, but still getting glutened every so often, usually when I let me guard down outside the home. I also periodically see my primary and a naturopath (who happens to have celiac!), but still, I have many questions if anyone would care to answer:

      -FATIGUE. I'm still so tired, fatigued so much of the time. My doctors blame this on the stress of my husband's diagnosis and my periodic trouble sleeping. But even during weeks where I'm sleeping enough (8-10 hrs a day), eating right, exercising as I can, trying to keep stress at bay, I'm still so bleeping tired. Maybe not when I wake up, but by late afternoon. Often my legs even feel weak/wooden. Has anyone else experienced greater fatigue early on after being diagnosed? This will pass, yes? I know I could cut out the sweets and that could help, but also, being a caregiver is hard and sometimes it's nice to eat your feelings between therapy sessions.  

      -SYMPTOMS CAUSED BY FATIGUE? Sometimes I'll have other "feels like I've been glutened" symptoms if I haven't gotten enough sleep, though I'm trying so hard to sleep at least 8 hours a night these days. Hasn't happened in a while thankfully, but there was a point this summer where my insomnia was bad and my arms were achy and I had some crazy flank/back pain I'd never experienced before. For weeks. Doctor ordered me to sleep sleep sleep, taking Benedryl if needed. I did, and the symptoms went away, but weird, yes? Has this happened to you? I ask because I want to make sure I'm getting all strange pains tested to the full extent if there's a chance it's something other than celiac. I do sometimes still feel that strange side stitch after a CC incident.

      -SKIN PROBLEMS. I have had a smidge of eczema since I was a teen and it - and the dermatitis herpetiformis I've acquired with my dx - are out of control right now. I recognize the connection with stress, but also, has anyone found any great natural remedies for DH to stop the itching? I've tried so many useless ointments and medicated creams, a number of them given to my by a dermo months ago. I see my naturopath this week, but thought I'd ask here too.

      -MOSTLY gluten-free KITCHEN GOOD ENOUGH? My husband is supportive of my diet and mostly eats gluten free meals with me, but we still keep a gluten-y toaster for him and the gluten-y dog food in a corner of the kitchen and he still makes the occasional meal with gluten for himself on his own cookware (ravioli, pizza, mac n cheese, etc). Or sometimes I make eggs/toast and the like for him when he's too sick to move. Otherwise, we're militant about how we cook, which cookware we use, etc. He even has a kitchen nook off our den where he makes sandwiches. But sometimes I wonder if having two separate sponges in our shared-ish main kitchen is enough and I should just banish all gluten whatsoever from the kitchen. I can't be the only one with a mixed kitchen, right? How do you do it if you have a mixed-eating family?

      Thank you so much!  
    • Hang in there!  Count your blessings.  Do something you like to do and relax. I know that is hard to do as a young mother (as I sit here in the kitchen sipping coffee quietly as my teenager is sleeping in after a late football game last night where she marched in 90 degree plus weather in full uniform).   But seriously, take a few minutes to relax!  
    • Meredith, this is very true. A colonoscopy is for diagnosis of the lower intestine, endoscopy for the upper intestine.  How did your doctor interpret the tests? I suggest you read the link Cycling Lady gave you because it contains a lot of good information. 
    • Sorry, but this product (supplement) is not even certified gluten free.   Seems odd that a product geared to Non-Celiac Gluten Intolerance would not take the extra step of getting certified.   I guess I am a Nervous Nellie, especially after the reports that several probiotics were contaminated with gluten.   https://celiac.org/blog/2015/06/probiotics-your-friend-or-foe/
    • Thank you for posting that. I've had a lot of that bloodwork done and everything is normal. At the peak of this belly bug I had blood work done and my white count was fine. I think it's just my health anxiety scaring me into thinking this is something scarier (to me) than celiac. Maybe the anxiety will subside once I go gluten-free. The anxiety is brutal.
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,705
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    imissdonuts
    Joined