Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Possibly Celiac, Gi Disagrees
0

14 posts in this topic

Where to begin? I am 38, trying a gluten-free diet because ever since I was a kid, I had lots of problems and no answers to them. I had constant ear infections, learning disabilities,mood problems. As an adult, I developed asthma,(no allergies)GERD, IBS, Hashimoto's,depression/anxiety, dental problems. I have put on 100 pounds and very overweight,though I exercise regularly. My idiot pulmonary doc suggested weight loss surgery. I crave sweets and have floaty stools along with edema and swelling in my tissues. The GI tested me for Celiac last winter and it came back normal,so he said gluten was not a problem for me, so I continued my regular diet as usual. I just can't take being overweight and tired all the time. If I'm not Celiac, what the freak am I? Just frustrated with the dozens of doctors I've seen over the years who treat me like a quack job.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

What tests did your GI do? Did he do both a full panel with a total IGA as well as an endo? Even if he did them you could have still had a false negative. You have two choices. Go back to the GI or go to your regular doctor and ask for the blood tests to be repeated as things can change in a year. Or try the diet strictly for a few months to see if it helps. Do be aware though that if you choose to simply do the diet you would need a lengthy time back on gluten if you later decide you want more celiac related tests. Your symptoms do suggest you have found the right place to get answers to your questions as well as support.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, you really do sound like a walking poster child for celiac! I think perhaps your doctor didn't run the full panel...or the test was a false-negative. I'm from the school of thought that you should just go on the diet and say to heck with the doctors, but that's just me. Others on this site will definitely encourage you to have full testing. It's up to you...but I vote for feeling better ASAP!

Since you mention sweet cravings and being overweight, you might find a book helpful that I read about six months ago. It not only successfully encouraged me to give up all grains (and other things, I might add), but it explained nutrition and digestion so well, I'm finally losing weight and understanding why diets never worked. If you're interested, it's called, "Primal Body, Primal Mind." This is THE MOST HELPFUL book on physiology, chemistry, etc., that I've ever read...and, let me tell you, I've read quite a few in my time. You don't have to go on the diet changes it recommends, but it will explain how to eat what you already eat in such a way that your glucose level will stay constant (which is key for losing weight). BTW, I have Hashimoto's, too, as many of us celiacs do.

I hope you'll consider trying the gluten-free diet, as well as eliminating dairy and soy, until you know whether or not the diet will help you. I have a strong suspicion that your life is about to turn around.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you decide to go gluten-free, OK.

However, I wouldn't advise you to stop looking for answers - even while on a gluten-free trial.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If going gluten free helps you, then you are on the right track. It is not going to help someone who does not have gluten issues, ie celiac. For many of us, we noticed near immediate improvement in a lot of issues and then some kinda come back hard with a small glutening or for no overt reason. For me, my body goes wonky a lot. Sometimes when i am 100% strict on what i am eating too. It can take a while for some issues to go away. We have people here who talk about certain issues taking months to a year to go away.

I was diagnosed by all the pretty tests as negative and non-celiac despite almost every symptom. Going gluten-free took care of 95% of them so much so that I have current primary care offering to officially diagnose me as celiac confirmed by gluten exclusion. He said the same thing as we see here. The tests are often wrong but it is the only tests they have. He said to trust a positive and doubt the negatives if the symptoms suggest celiac. The tests are negative for a LOT of people even when they have it. That is a big reason that many take so long to be diagnosed.

You have been through the ringer with doctors so there is not a lot left to continue to look for. For me, I had 23 years of doctor tests. They checked everything over and over. lots of money spent, little progress. Going gluten free and then dairy and soy free (many have soy and dairy issues at least short term) took care of virtually everything at a rapid rate. Try it for a week and see if it helps. Like I said earlier, if you are improving gluten-free, then bingo. Consider yourself a celiac and you can get on with your life and getting better.

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I would suggest reading Healthier Without Wheat by Stephen Wagnen. He discusses a lot about how you can test negative for Celiac Disease and still be gluten intolerant.

Eliminate the gluten and try the diet. See if it works. Give it a month. You don't need a prescription to do the diet. Or a special test. And if it doesn't work, you aren't out much money. But if it does work, you may have found the answer to a lot of your health problems. What do you have to lose?

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest reading Healthier Without Wheat by Stephen Wagnen. He discusses a lot about how you can test negative for Celiac Disease and still be gluten intolerant.

Eliminate the gluten and try the diet. See if it works. Give it a month. You don't need a prescription to do the diet. Or a special test. And if it doesn't work, you aren't out much money. But if it does work, you may have found the answer to a lot of your health problems. What do you have to lose?

I have not read that one, but now I want to. lol

Here are two that I read at day one and really liked:

Celiac Disease: The First Year by Shepard. It helps you by giving you advice by the day, then week, and then monthly. It helped me develop a starting plan. This is what many need as the beginning is overwhelming and it is easy to get glutened by all the junk it is hidden in.

Gluten-Free Diet by Hassellbeck. I thought she gave some decent advice. Some do not care for her book, but I think she is cute and..well..i am a guy, so just let me have this.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gluten-Free Diet by Hassellbeck. I thought she gave some decent advice. Some do not care for her book, but I think she is cute and..well..i am a guy, so just let me have this.

Chad...you have an excellent sense of humor! This line really cracked me up and I am female.... :P

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good grief. Yes, you sound celiac. Also my asthma didn't really improve until I went off grains and dairy too.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Kristinad, I too am new to this forum and I feel like I am loosing the plot. I have had various problems over the years, one of them being an allergy to all types of grass, some trees and I recently had a food intollerance test that came back with a result saying I am intollerant to Rye. I was diagnosed with IBS about 20 years ago, spondylosis about 12 years ago, have osteoarthritis as well. I have so many symptoms I don

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My first AHA moment even though I did not know it at the time was when I went on Atkins. No breads and it just so happened that I naturally avoided a large amount of gluten added things. I felt phenomenatastical that entire year. Until this year I had always wondered what the key element was. Gall bladder died (confirmed?? by HIDA scan/no stones) on me after a year on the diet(family history) although and here is the kicker. The day those issues started was a time I ate a pizza. Yeah...you can see where i am going in hindsight. A year with literally no cheats at all and then one day I ate a whole pizza. As everyone here knows after being so good, you can react hard to a bad choice. Rapid heart rate, profuse vomiting, etc, etc think I was dead. lol. after about 6 months they took out GB but in the meantime i had lost that momentum and was back to eating carbs aka gluteny things almost immediately after that bad episode because some idiot nurse told me I had destroyed my heart with the diet. Later it was confirmed cardiac was perfect and chemistries were perfect. Just had a severe case of dehydration, but the emotional damage was done. I was off track and with no gallbladder, fats were and still are evil on my GI. I often wondered how things would have been different had I found this sight 6 years ago.

Here is the good thing about celiac. No surgery is required. No meds are required. And although I am not suggesting not going to the doctor (most get what I am saying here), no doctor or diagnosis is required. You have the diagnostic tools and treatment tools at your disposal. You can commit to eliminating all gluten for one week and see how you feel. I also agree with all the posts to avoid dairy and soy as well because I had a lot of issues with those things making me think gluten-free was not working.

I have had a lot of family members and friends contact me about their friends or suggest to their friends to just try the gluten-free for a week or two (relaying my story) to see how they react. It is not dangerous and can arm them for confronting a physician if it helps.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My first AHA moment even though I did not know it at the time was when I went on Atkins. No breads and it just so happened that I naturally avoided a large amount of gluten added things. I felt phenomenatastical that entire year. Until this year I had always wondered what the key element was. Gall bladder died (confirmed?? by HIDA scan/no stones) on me after a year on the diet(family history) although and here is the kicker. The day those issues started was a time I ate a pizza. Yeah...you can see where i am going in hindsight. A year with literally no cheats at all and then one day I ate a whole pizza. As everyone here knows after being so good, you can react hard to a bad choice. Rapid heart rate, profuse vomiting, etc, etc think I was dead. lol. after about 6 months they took out GB but in the meantime i had lost that momentum and was back to eating carbs aka gluteny things almost immediately after that bad episode because some idiot nurse told me I had destroyed my heart with the diet. Later it was confirmed cardiac was perfect and chemistries were perfect. Just had a severe case of dehydration, but the emotional damage was done. I was off track and with no gallbladder, fats were and still are evil on my GI. I often wondered how things would have been different had I found this sight 6 years ago.

Here is the good thing about celiac. No surgery is required. No meds are required. And although I am not suggesting not going to the doctor (most get what I am saying here), no doctor or diagnosis is required. You have the diagnostic tools and treatment tools at your disposal. You can commit to eliminating all gluten for one week and see how you feel. I also agree with all the posts to avoid dairy and soy as well because I had a lot of issues with those things making me think gluten-free was not working.

I have had a lot of family members and friends contact me about their friends or suggest to their friends to just try the gluten-free for a week or two (relaying my story) to see how they react. It is not dangerous and can arm them for confronting a physician if it helps.

Thanks for all of the information. I have soya milk daily, just a drop every morning on cerial, I don

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the helpful information. I did start going gluten-free this month and I have noticed a difference in how I feel---not running to the bathroom and having the runs nearly every day is very nice! I cleaned out my pantry and gave my wheat items to my mom because I might as well go all the way and not half-way, you know? My mom thinks I have lost a little weight but since my thyroid meds were just increased, not sure if it's from that or going gluten-free. I am not as bloated, I have noticed, and I am going to a new GI after the holidays.

I went to my asthma doc this week--prob for the last time since he said I can see him "as needed." Each time I went to him he was always on me about my weight,thinking I eat too much, don't exercise enough and not doing anything to lose weight. When I told him I suspected I was gluten intolerant,the look on his face was priceless,like he felt like a bag of dog poop because he hadn't been able to figure it out himself.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gluten-Free Diet by Hassellbeck. I thought she gave some decent advice. Some do not care for her book, but I think she is cute and..well..i am a guy, so just let me have this.

okay, but just this one time, kiddo. :rolleyes:

:lol:

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      103,872
    • Total Posts
      919,408
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Help
      Ok so I had my colonoscopy & endoscopy last Thursday. Don't get results until July 13th as GI is on vacation. I've had bad pain in my lower left abdomen that wraps around to my lower back as well for the past 4 days..even hurts to touch lightly. Went back to the ER & they did an ultrasound & CT scan. The Doctor said that I have "prominent" lymph nodes in the area that is painful as well as thickening & inflammation of my Sigmond colon? Um ok what is that all about? Kind of freaking out over the whole swollen lymph nodes thing. Has anyone ever dealt with this before? 😒
    • Enormous Stool
      My 2 year old daughter has sufferd with extremely large stools for over a year. She will have a bm once or twice a week there has been blood sometimes i took her to the docs and they gave her some stool softner which didnt help they tried uping the dose which still didnt help and they told me it would eventually work which didnt she was then put on movicol which she was only supposed to get half a sachet still no diffrence i uped it to the the full sachet which helps a little she doesnt always have large stools but most of the time she does. She has got to a stage where she clenches and wont let it out because of how sore it is i try to put her on the toilet for it to come a little easier for her but she screams and will try hide herself in a corner and wont let you anywere near her it is heart breaking to watch her. If anyone has any in advice i would really like to hear.   Thanks.
    • Starting Over with GI Dr.
      Everything I have learned I have learned through this forum or simply from my last EGD results and labs and then looking them up on the internet.  The drs have given no information except for do a gluten free diet.  My understanding is that a repeat EGD is needed to confirm healing.  When I was tested about this time last year I was a Marsh3b.  Which in my research is pretty serious.  I am still having ill effects from god only knows what these days.  I went strictly gluten free June 2015.  I have had glutenings (not by choice) and the last one I had was because of an antibiotic that I took that has sent me through the roof with anxiety issues.  I try to be as careful as possible but it is like it doesn't seem to matter how careful I am I am either aching and hurting in my joints, tired all the time or OK one minute and the next feel like crap and that my world is about to end.  It is very frustrating to say the least when you go to the dr and you are expecting support or some sort of answer and don't get one.  I have eliminated milk from my diet as of about a month and a half ago.  That seemed to help, some.  But I still have days where I hurt and ache in my elbows and in my hands.  I have moments when I am about to freeze to death and sit with a heater and where I live the temps outside are 90+ degrees plus humidity and the AC is not even on.  Most of this has just started happening I would say in the past 4 months or so.  At night when I go to bed I wear sweat pants and a sweat shirt and sleep under 4 blankets and a sheet.  They say my thyroid is fine.  I feel like I have some issues with my nervous system but to be honest with you I haven't seen drs enough to mention this to them because all they are worried about is if I have diarrhea.  Cycling Lady I will be keeping any all records that I have and continue to gather the ones for anything I have done in the future.  .  I have been through health issues with my husband and would keep all of his records and labs so we would have proof.  Just seems like doctors don't care anymore.  The last GP I went to actually listened to me and I will see her again next month after the EGD.  I did give ALL of my records, EGD, labs, medical records, etc. to the new GI prior to our first visit back in January.  She said she reviewed them.  And told me we would re-draw the labs and schedule EGD to check healing when I went to her this month.  We have scheduled the EGD but no mention of labs.  JMG I am having the procedure re-done so that I can see if I am healing.  Mostly because of all the ailments I still have or seem to be developing every day.  I used to be a person who could remember things and get things accomplished but lately that has not been happening and scares me more and more every day. I understand that no procedure is risk free.  I have had 2 C-sections, wisdom teeth removed and tubal ligation.  Each one had its own issues after they were done.  I am a person who has to see it to believe it I guess.  If I don't see it, it is hard for me to understand it.  It is hard to figure this out when I am the one who usually takes care of everyone else but then when I need to be taken care of, nobody knows what to do.  I think that is it in a nut shell.  All that ya'll have told me is a big help.  Around here I have no support groups or even a good friend I can talk to about stuff that would even come close to understanding.  My husband will listen, but he doesn't understand.   
    • Loved ones with Celiac in nursing home
      It will be in Gluten-Free Living later this year, October I think
    • Prague Looks for Consensus on Adolescent and Teen Celiac Disease Management
      The Prague consensus report looks to shine some light on the best options for providing optimal transition into teen and adult healthcare for patients with celiac disease. View the full article
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

    • Jmg  »  admin

      Hello Admin!
      I don't know whether this is of interest to post on your articles feed:
      http://pratt.duke.edu/about/news/window-guts-brain
      Kind Regards,
      Matt
      · 2 replies
    • celiac sharon  »  cyclinglady

      Hello cycling lady, have you noticed my picture is showing up as you?  Have no idea why but it's rather disconcerting to see my picture and your words 😉  Do you know how to fix it?  You seem to have far more experience with this board than I do
      · 1 reply
    • Larry Gessner  »  cyclinglady

      Hi There, I don't know if there is a place for videos in the forum. I just watched "The Truth About Gluten" I think it is a good video. I would like to share it somewhere but don't know where it should go. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
      Here is the link if you have never watched it.
      https://youtu.be/IU6jVEwpjnE Thank You,
      Larry
      · 2 replies
  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      60,906
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    staceyO1
    Joined