Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

For Those Who Are Grain Free And Low To No Beans/nuts
0

18 posts in this topic

So, for a little while now, I've been getting headaches with certain foods. Not gluten related, just crummy. These have been getting worse, to the point that freaking WATER was giving me headaches.

I've figured out what has been causing the headaches, it's been tested and confirmed by the doc, and it may be of some relevance for super-sensitives, so I pass it along.

I am severely molybdenum deficient. This is pretty rare, I understand, because humans don't need much of this and we get plenty in our usual diets. However, grains, beans, and nuts are some of the main sources in our diets, so for those of us who have little to none of these, we may run the risk of becoming deficient in this mineral. For example, my headaches started worsening when I dropped legumes due to allergy issues.

Molybdenum levels are not usually tested for (rare and all), so it's unlikely to be discovered unless you ask for the test.

The reason it can cause issues is because molybdenum is needed to create Molybdenum Cofactor. This is used to make 3 important enzymes: sulfite oxidase, xanthine oxidase, and aldehyde oxidase.

Sulfite oxidase converts sulfites to sulfates, so without it, you will become mildly to severely sulfite intolerant/sensitive. Which can be a problem for, say, water with high sulfite levels, many processed foods, many injected medications, eggs, garlic, onions, and more.

Xanthine oxidase is used to metabolize purines, which can be found in many fish, organ meats, beef, and others.

Aldehyde oxidase takes care of aldehydes, which are organic compounds that add the scent for many volatile essential oils, such as what we might find in herbs.

With all three of these depending on molybdenum cofactor, a molybdenum deficiency can have a broad effect. And as I said, with many of us super-sensitives going grain free, and often legume and nut free, it's may be difficult to get enough of this mineral unless your water supply has higher levels. So for anyone getting headaches or other problems with bottled water, injected meds, or a wide range of foods, it might be worthwhile to ask to be tested for this.

I haven't seen any signs that this affects super-sensitivity in and of itself, but there's a little part of me that's crossing my fingers and hoping. If my body's sensitivity levels could chill the heck out once I get my molybdenum levels back up, that would be AWESOME. :D I'll let ya'll know how it goes.

A warning!

If anyone suspects this could be an issue, please check with a doctor and get tested. Supplementing for this vitamin when you are not deficient can be dangerous, because Molybdenum toxicity is a definite risk. It doesn't take much to reach levels that are too high.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

That is a rare deficiency, TH. Hope you get it straightened out ASAP. :unsure: The doc who figured that one out for you deserves big kuddos! :) and he should let someone know because apparently, there are not many documented cases.

From :The Linus Pawling Institute

Dietary molybdenum deficiency has never been observed in healthy people (2). The only documented case of acquired molybdenum deficiency occurred in a patient with Crohn's disease on long-term total parenteral nutrition (TPN) without molybdenum added to the TPN solution (6). The patient developed rapid heart and respiratory rates, headache, night blindness, and ultimately became comatose. He also demonstrated biochemical signs of molybdenum deficiency, including low plasma uric acid levels, decreased urinary excretion of uric acid and sulfate, and increased urinary excretion of sulfite. Thus, the patient was diagnosed with defects in uric acid production and sulfur amino acid metabolism. The patient's clinical condition improved and the amino acid intolerance disappeared when the TPN solution was discontinued and instead supplemented with molybdenum (160 mcg/day) (6).

Current understanding of the essentiality of molybdenum in humans is based largely on the study of individuals with very rare inborn errors of metabolism that result in a deficiency of the molybdoenzyme, sulfite oxidase. Two forms of sulfite oxidase deficiency have been identified:

Isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency: only sulfite oxidase activity is affected.

Molybdenum cofactor deficiency: the activities of all three molybdoenzymes are affected.

Because molybdenum functions only in the form of the molybdenum cofactor in humans, any disturbance of molybdenum cofactor metabolism can disrupt the function of all molybdoenzymes. Together, molybdenum cofactor deficiency and isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency have been diagnosed in more than 100 individuals worldwide. Both disorders result from recessive traits, meaning that only individuals who inherit two copies of the abnormal gene (one from each parent) develop the disease. Individuals who inherit only one copy of the abnormal gene are known as carriers of the trait but do not exhibit any symptoms. The symptoms of isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency and molybdenum cofactor deficiency are identical and usually include severe brain damage, which appears to be due to the loss of sulfite oxidase activity. At present, it is not clear whether the neurologic effects are a result of the accumulation of a toxic metabolite, such as sulfite, or inadequate sulfate production. Isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency and molybdenum cofactor deficiency can be diagnosed relatively early in pregnancy (10-14 weeks' of gestation) through chorionic villus sampling, and in some cases, carriers of molybdenum cofactor deficiency can be identified through genetic testing. No cure is presently available for either disorder, although anti-seizure medications and dietary restriction of sulfur-containing amino acids may be beneficial in some cases (7).

http://lpi.oregonstate.edu/infocenter/minerals/molybdenum/

Feel better soon. Headaches are the worst!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is a rare deficiency, TH. Hope you get it straightened out ASAP. :unsure: The doc who figured that one out for you deserves big kuddos! :) and he should let someone know because apparently, there are not many documented cases.

Heh...this falls in the same category as my celiac disease: patient diagnosed, doctor confirmed. ;-)

I happened to come across a site mentioning headaches and bottled water, due to sulfite content. And the only bottled water that had low sulfites coincided with the only bottled water that I could tolerate.

So started looking, found that many people with sulfite sensitivity had some relief if they supplemented with molybdenum or vitamin B's, and then noticed what sources were for molybdenum and realized I wasn't eating any of them. Found a way to get straight sulfites and make a very diluted solution, tried it, had a killer headache of doom. So I asked for the test at my next doctor appointment.

My MD(just a general practitioner MD) has been great. So much weird stuff seems to go on with me that he doesn't even pause, just goes and orders the tests after I explain my reasoning to him (he had to look this one up because he'd never ordered it before). So far, I've been right in my 'guess-diagnosis' more times than not...don't know if that's a good thing or not. ;)

It sounds like he's been taking note, because more than once when a test comes back positive, he shakes his head and wonders out loud how many people have this and are being missed because it's almost never tested for. He seems like a doctor who really incorporates anything new he comes across into his future diagnoses, so at least I can feel better knowing that if anyone else comes along with this issue, he'll be more likely to catch it. :-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heh...this falls in the same category as my celiac disease: patient diagnosed, doctor confirmed. ;-)

Ditto for me. Long struggle, but I was persistent.

Good thing or I'd probably be dead. Or wheelchair-bound and insane by now. :rolleyes: It was that bad.

My new GI is appalled by what happened to me---to any long- unDXed celiac. He says there is no excuse for that now.

As a result of malabsorption, we can be deficient in any number of vitamins, minerals, amino acids, etc.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Curious.

For anyone worried about their intake, WHFoods.org lists a number of sources including summer squash (18% dv), eggs (11%), carrots (8%), romaine lettuce (7.5%), cucumbers (7%), bell peppers (6%), and a bunch more. The peas and beans have more like 200% of dv, as Shauna said.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




For anyone worried about their intake, WHFoods.org lists a number of sources including summer squash (18% dv), eggs (11%), carrots (8%), romaine lettuce (7.5%), cucumbers (7%), bell peppers (6%), and a bunch more. The peas and beans have more like 200% of dv, as Shauna said.

From what I understand, part of the issue can be that, because Molybdenum is a mineral, it has to be absorbed from the soil. So if the soil is in an area that has had a lot of farming and this particular mineral has been depleted, or if the soil is naturally low in this mineral, the veggies may not have lower amounts of it. :-( I've heard that this can be an issue for Iodine in veggies, as well.

Interesting to hear about the veggie sources, too, because summer squash, lettuce, cucumbers, and bell peppers are a huge part of my diet this time of year. Wonder if that means the soil's depleted around here more, or if I just don't absorb molybdenum well. Guess I'll find out soon enough!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Curious.

For anyone worried about their intake, WHFoods.org lists a number of sources including summer squash (18% dv), eggs (11%), carrots (8%), romaine lettuce (7.5%), cucumbers (7%), bell peppers (6%), and a bunch more. The peas and beans have more like 200% of dv, as Shauna said.

I figured there must be more ways to get it or lots of us would be deficient. We didn't eat beans growing up because my mom didn't like them. I eat them now but not everyday.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From what I understand, part of the issue can be that, because Molybdenum is a mineral, it has to be absorbed from the soil. So if the soil is in an area that has had a lot of farming and this particular mineral has been depleted, or if the soil is naturally low in this mineral, the veggies may not have lower amounts of it.

This sounds pretty sensible. I think over-farming and inorganic fertilization has screwed up a lot of our veggies

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course, when I asked my science-geek chemist hub about this, he pronounced "molybdenum" with no trouble :lol: and told me quite a bit. Smart dude. ;)

Apparently, there is quite a bit written about the soil deficiency. There is even an International Molybdenum Association.

who knew?

http://www.imoa.info/HSE/environmental_data/biology/plants_soils.php

Most of the articles I found are from the 50's through the 90's.

but this is interesting--

American Cancer Society:

"Humans require very small amounts of molybdenum, and deficiency appears to happen only under the rarest of circumstances. For example, molybdenum deficiency may appear in a person fed entirely through the veins for a very long time, or in a person with a genetic problem in which the body cannot use the molybdenum that is eaten in foods."

TH, that seems to be repeated in all the info. Did you doctor check if this is a genetic disorder?

Just wondering.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TH, that seems to be repeated in all the info. Did you doctor check if this is a genetic disorder?

Thankfully, I don't have to worry about the genetic disorder. That disorder (It's called molybdenum cofactor deficiency) actually results in a pretty awful death a few months after birth. The sulfite levels build up and literally dissolve the brain. It's simply awful and so, so sad.

In 2009, though, an Autralian and a set of parents pushed to use an experimental drug for the first time, without even human trials, to try and save a little baby's life who had this and it actually worked! One of those really awesome stories with a really dedicated and awesome doctor:

http://www.news.com.au/national/doctor-cures-baby-z-of-molybdenum-cofactor-deficiency-in-medical-world-first/story-e6frfkvr-1225794526262

So it's not the genetic issue, and like you said, according to the literature, I shouldn't be having this issue. But my molybdenum levels were so low they registered as '0,' or 'below the detection level of the test.'

In forums for people with sulfite sensitivity, fibro, chemical sensitivities and a few other issues, I am finding the odd person here and there who tested low for Mo, so it looks like at least I'm not the only one bucking the odds, as it were. There's also a few in the same groups who have taken molybdenum supplements and had noticeable improvement in their symptoms (especially for sulfite sensitivity), but these were never tested.

I'd be interested to know if that latter group might have tested positive for deficiencies, too, or if they simply do better with higher levels of molybdenum than average, you know?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This sounds pretty sensible. I think over-farming and inorganic fertilization has screwed up a lot of our veggies

Molybdenum is inorganic. Metals are inorganic. I think you mean something like not organic. The inorganic/organometallic chemist in me is coming out again.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In forums for people with sulfite sensitivity, fibro, chemical sensitivities and a few other issues, I am finding the odd person here and there who tested low for Mo, so it looks like at least I'm not the only one bucking the odds, as it were. There's also a few in the same groups who have taken molybdenum supplements and had noticeable improvement in their symptoms (especially for sulfite sensitivity), but these were never tested.

I'd be interested to know if that latter group might have tested positive for deficiencies, too, or if they simply do better with higher levels of molybdenum than average, you know?

oookay...well, when I read about the genetic link, the material did not say the patient died shortly after birth. Well, that WOULD preclude you then. Since you are clearly, quite alive. :)

hmm...well, it might be that the "leaky gut" is perhaps an issue? I mention this as I have had multiple chemical sensitivities and some weird histamine/preservatives reactions going on myself and my GI doctor is stumped. (no allergies or intolerances show up on testing either!) :unsure: Doing an elimination diet has helped enormously, so I may be on the right track.

So, it would make sense that any deficiency might contribute to ill health--- as absorption would be compromised, yes?

Again, kuddos to you and your doc for figuring it out and I hope you feel better soon! We have to be our own best advocates.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Molybdenum is inorganic. Metals are inorganic. I think you mean something like not organic. The inorganic/organometallic chemist in me is coming out again.

Should have said 'petroleum based', since that's what I meant anyway.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Should have said 'petroleum based', since that's what I meant anyway.

Sorry for putting the wrong words in your mouth. I didn't even know that there was petroleum based fertilizer.

I went into another window and searched that and it looks I've come across another controversy. I don't think I want to get into that.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I checked a NatureMade multivitamin for men bottle and it has 100% RDA of molebdenynum in it. I imagine it is in other multivitamins also?

It is certainly one I never thought about though. Thanks for posting about it Shauna! :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

:lol:

I only heard of it when reading about amino acids months ago and how we celiacs are deficient in them and some trace elements and checked my vits, too! there it is.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I checked a NatureMade multivitamin for men bottle and it has 100% RDA of molebdenynum in it. I imagine it is in other multivitamins also?

It often is, that I've seen. Unfortunately, for vitamins that are free of a lot of allergens (especially corn), many seem to leave out certain nutrients. I'm not sure why. Wonder if perhaps the usual carriers or sources for these are typically from the allergens trying to be avoided, so it's easier/cheaper to just leave them out. Sometimes a company will have a secondary 'trace minerals' supplement that can be purchased in that case, but not always.

I have a lot of problems with supplements since I went gluten-free - they've all made me really ill. The molybdenum supplements have turned out to be even more frustrating than usual, sigh. With low molybdenum, one cannot properly process sulfites. Guess what's usually in molybdenum supplements? Sulfited ingredients. Argh.

Hopefully the one I ordered will work for me! :-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,384
    • Total Posts
      920,609
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • shellyb, I have info. for you & you may yet be able to get an official dx from your dermatologist as she sounds like she would be willing to learn. If you are dx'd with dh it is definitive & no other testing is needed. You don't need to see a GI. Im in FL & have had a long day watching Tropical Storm Hermine & making preparations for it's track which is over where I live. I'm tired! I will have links for you to reputable medical info. on the rash but it make take me till tomorrow or even longer if we lose power.  I'll be back as soon as I can. Question: You're on Dapsone now? How long have you been on it? How is it working for you? Are you getting the proper testing at regular intervals to make sure it isn't doing bad things to you? Were you gluten free before the skin biopsy?
    • Thank you so much for your quick response, GFinDC. While I wouldn't be completely opposed to another skin biopsy, I already had 4 done (3 were done prior to my dermatologist suspecting DH) so I don't love the idea of  yet another hole and scar on my body. Plus, fortunately I don't have any fresh lesions now, which I believe is needed for the biopsy. I wish I would have known to see a GI before going gluten free but I was so desperate to get any relief that I started that and Dapsone as soon as my doctor mentioned it to me.  My rash is definitely symmetrical and I have it in all of the "classic" DH spots although it basically spread over my entire body. As much as I'd like a more formal diagnosis, I really don't think I can go through all of that again. It was so bad that not only was I getting no sleep but I had to change my sheets every morning because there was blood all over them. Sorry, TMI. The worst part is that this all developed during my ninth month of pregnancy and got much worse after I delivered my baby. So not only was I dealing with this insanely itchy rash but I had a newborn and a toddler to take care of.  My daughters' pediatrician did mention doing DNA testing on me first and then my daughters to see if there's any concern that they may be susceptible. I may just go that route for now. I was just curious if others have had similar test results to mine and how did their doctors treat it? Thanks again!
    • Hey guys, the last year and a month of transitioning to totally gluten free was hard, but I now seem to be healthy. The first six months I got horrible cramps that would suddenly come and hit hard, but I really havent seen any of those since about February-March. One thing that I wouldnt say has gotten better is my psyche. I was always sort of an anxious person (hard not to be when you dont feel well yet you have "IBS" and you're just "nervous", which all of you probably know), but I am borderline hermit now. I finally went to the doctor today and was prescribed prozac, so hopefully that helps, but I was just wondering about you guys? Thanks  
    • Thank-you, thank-you! I am so relieved to have input from others who have experience with celiac disease. I'm not sure what I'm going to do about the school cafeteria. I'll ask our very nice and experienced Cafe Mgr for realistic info and details. My primary concern is the safety of my daughter and packing a lunch will not be that big a deal, even though she prefers the fresh prep instead of lunchbox offerings. Sigh. It sounds as if the 504 is unquestionably the preference over the IHCP, since the 504 is binding and follows the student through his/her academic career. I have a meeting with the admin team on Tuesday. Until then, I'm reading lots so i can be informed. And, dkader, I sent you a private message via the blog's feature. I'd certainly love to read the 504 info you have squirreled away. Thank-you so much!
    • The risk of a non-celiac getting intestinal lymphoma is extremely tiny.  The risk of someone with refractory celiac disease is higher (I think maybe double?) but 2 x extremely tiny is still extremely tiny, and an elevated antibody level is not enough to say you have the refractory version.  You could have a repeat endoscopy to look for damage.  Are you still having symptoms?
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,455
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    JLeigh
    Joined