Get email alerts Get E-mail Alerts Sponsor: Sponsor:

Ads by Google:

   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE email alerts

Kimball Genetics Testing

2 posts in this topic

I've been reading past posts about Enterolab testing and the genetic testing but haven't seen much about Kimball Genetics. We had the celiac disease DNA test done hoping it would give us some answers -- it did, but ended up giving us more questions. Three of my children had very high IgG levels in their initial bloodwork. Only one came back with a positive biopsy. One of the children with a negative biopsy has frequent headaches with vomiting so I put her on the gluten-free diet hoping it would take care of the headaches. It didn't seem to change anything (maybe 3-4 months wasn't long enough?) To give us answers, we thought we'd find out if she carried the gene for celiac disease but hadn't developed full blown celiac disease.

We tested me, my husband and this one child. My husband and daughter tested negative for DQ2 (DQA1*05/DQB1*02) and DQ8 (DQB1*0302). They detected one of the DQA1*05 alleles in me but that alone was not enough to result in celiac disease. So...according to Kimball Genetics, neither me nor my husband has the celiac disease associated molecules necessary to result in celiac disease and therefore our children do not posess the necessary genes for celiac disease. My doctor doesn't want to put full faith in these tests and so celiac disease remains the diagnosis for my biopsy positive child.

Can anybody tell me if the Enterolab testing is more specific for possible gluten intolerance genes? (There seem to be more gene types with Enterolab).Has anybody else had a positive biopsy without a celiac gene?

I know people will say to just follow the gluten-free diet and if it works let that be enough. But I keep thinking that there may be some other factors making my children sick.

Can anything else elevate an IgG level other than gluten?


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ads by Google:

I was reading something yesterday (I don't remember the site) that was saying that the IgG is the least specific of all the bloodtests. Apparantly a positive IgG alone does not conclude celiac disease because people with other intestinal conditions can also have a raised IgG. Also your daughter could have gluten intolerance w/out celiac disease. I find it interesting that your biopsy positive child can't carry the celiac disease gene...are you sure? Does Kimball only test for DQ2 and DQ8? I tested w/ Enterolab and came back positive for everything w/ high malabsorption but with NO celiac genes...I have DQ1 and DQ3. I have all the symptoms but have been wondering if something other than gluten could be making me sick since I don't carry the celiac disease genes. I think obviously if your child had a positive biopsy then he/she does have celiac disease.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • My newborn grandson (4 months old) is on one and thriving.  I have a friend with a three year old that is just learning to eat by mouth.  These tubes are very common, but I have no experience with someone of her age.  
    • First of all- who are these a-holes making fun of you? It's making me heated just thinking about it. Coworkers? If you don't like your job much I suggest taking a diarrhea sh*t in a bag and leaving it on their desk. Then see how hard they laugh. (sorry I have quite an interesting sense of humor/need to make people realize how not funny their jokes are). I haven't had a whole lot of people who poke fun at me, I get the annoying "oh! That must be why you are so skinny- you are SO lucky!" Even one of my very close friends says that to me sometimes- that she wishes she wouldn't absorb all the nutrients in her food so she could lose wait. I'm sorry WTF did you just say to me?! Seriously? IF you are that desperate to lose weight maybe TRY to do something about it instead of complain to me and wish you had some effed disease. Phew- tangent. Um. This might be against what others think or recommend. But I want to share so maybe you feel less overwhelmed. I didn't worry about other cross reactive foods or even think about it until later on. And with some worries about this and that (coffee mostly) I stopped thinking about it and stopped googling it. There are enough things for me to worry about just avoiding gluten. And I still drink coffee. Dairy has only recently become a (noticeable) issue after 3 years gluten free. The kissing thing- I don't worry about either. Maybe because I have been with the same guy for 11 years but we don't do a whole lot of hard make out sessions right after dinner. LOL. I don't know how sensitive you are- I don't know if you even know how sensitive you are. It takes a long time to really figure this whole thing out. And then once you get it figured out- something changes (just like parenting small children!) I think with the other foods issue, because you are feeling so depressed- I would just worry about the gluten part for now (after you get through this nightmare of eating it again). Do you have to have the diagnosis? Is it really worth it in the end? I know having the official diagnosis can make it easier to see necessary specialists and get tests done- when you stay in the hospital they try to feed you the right food. But. I don't know. Hard for me to say because my dr went about things a little differently and gave me a diagnosis just based on my symptoms being better without gluten and having a genetic test that was positive. After reading what you are going through I would bail in a heartbeat- eating that gluten for that long and still working and all that is a lot. And it will make the depression you are already going through seemingly worse. I am in no position to suggest what you should do in this instance but just a thought I wanted to share. Anywho- hang in there. Hire a hit man perhaps to take out these evil people. or leave flaming poop bags on their porch (so you can keep your job  )
    • A new understanding of CD30 expression in EATL may lead to better therapies using anti-CD30 monoclonal antibodies, like brentuximab vedotin (BV). View the full article
    • There is a low starch diet that is paleo with reduced or eliminated starch for people with ankylosing spondylitis, or any of the spondyloarthropathies. It was developed by Dr. Ebringer in London so it was at first known as the London Low Starch Diet. You can find out more information about it at a support group called Kickas dot org. I have axial spondyloarthritis and I do much better not simply gluten free, but low starch (grain free, legume free, and reduced starchy veggies and fruit). Best wishes!
    • Hello, I have a new possible Celiac diagnosis and was hoping y'all could help me! I am 25, and after going to see many different doctors with no real answers as to why I felt generally sick all the time (headaches, GI symptoms including stabbing stomach pains, weight fluctuation with no explanation, fatigue, brain fog, etc.). I went to a more homeopathic doctor a couple of months ago (still an MD) who was more receptive and ran a ton of tests. She diagnosed me with Celiac based on a blood test. I went off gluten (that was about 7 weeks ago) and while I did start to feel better (certainly less stomach pain & brain fog) I have also just felt like my body was completely knocked out of whack since then--weird issues with blood sugar where I've felt like I was going to faint sometimes, my period came two weeks early (rare for me), stomach not hurting but just acting bizarre, etc.  I went last week to a Celiac specialist. I know going off gluten before doing more testing was going to skew the results, but I couldn't get this appointment for 6 weeks after the initial diagnosis and I didn't want to wait. Plus, my sister has Celiac (diagnosed 6 years ago through blood tests--though we don't think she had the genetic test--& had an "inconclusive" biopsy--she has been generally symptom-free since going off gluten). So I went to talk the specialist and she agreed to do the blood tests again even though I'd been off gluten (personally I wanted to know if they had gone down, plus with 6 weeks of gluten I knew there was a chance they'd still be high). This doctor now says she wants me to try a gluten challenge and agree to do the tests again and the biopsy--but I am not super interested in that. It seems that she would still recommend never eating gluten again if additional tests were inconclusive, so I just don't know what the point would be. Every doctor I've been to said the endoscopy could be negative for damage and they'd still recommend not eating gluten.  I also have had some nutrient deficiencies in the past year. I became a vegetarian a year ago and three months ago a different doctor realized I had iron & B12 deficiencies (which she attributed to not eating meat though I was watching my diet very closely to make sure I was eating right... so that supported the next doctor's Celiac theory). So my iron & B12 went back up with supplements. I asked the Celiac specialist to do some other nutritional panels just to see, though, and my zinc was low (only one she did where I am not supplementing). I thought that was odd. Also, my CRP has decreased since going gluten-free which I found very encouraging (I have also been supplementing since August with turmeric, however).  Here are the relevant test results (as they appear on lab reports): Aug. 19, 2016 TTG igG - 10.2 U/ML (positive >9) High Sensitivity CRP - 5.0 MG/L (high >3.0) Oct. 18, 2016 (after about 7 weeks gluten-free) Deam Gliadin IgA Ab - 7 U (standard <20 U) Tissue Transglutaminase IgA Ab - 7 U (standard <20 U) Tissue Transglutaminase IgG Ab - 7 U (standard <20 U) C-Reactive Protein - 3 mg/L  (standard <5 mg/L) Zinc - 0.59 ug/mL (standard 0.66 - 1.10 ug/mL) Though I don't totally understand the new test results (and the doctor isn't going to discuss with me until our next follow up) my interpretation is my antibody levels are now normal, which would be consistent with going off gluten... I guess I am just generally frustrated. I would really like to "buy in" completely to the Celiac diagnosis and not have nagging doubts that there's still something else I need to be doing and I'm never going to feel better. I know going gluten-free can take more than 7 weeks to relieve symptoms, but it's hard when I still don't feel great. Also, for the record, I've had a sister with Celiac for 6 years, so I am very confident that I have actually been gluten-free for the past 7 weeks (it wasn't something totally new to me). The Celiac diagnosis FEELS more right to me than anything doctors have told me in the past, but it still feels like there's some piece missing, I guess. But maybe it just hasn't been long enough.  The Celiac specialist also started me on Xifaxin (antibiotic) for symptom management whether or not I have Celiac. Only been on it for a couple of days, though. I have also been trying digestive enzymes and have experienced some relief in the past week or so--one question I've been grappling with is whether I should eat meat for awhile--the veggie/bean heavy diet can't be easy while my stomach is supposedly healing--but I of course would rather not.  Any advice?
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
    • Most Online

    Newest Member