Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Prometheus Labs Vs. Enterolab....
0

22 posts in this topic

One's doing a blood test, one's doing a stool test *mainly*. A friend of mine wants her son tested and I gave her my extra kit from Prometheus. Then a friend in N.Y. was asking me where to get her son tested and I suggested Enterolab on the east coast. So I began looking them both up on line. And now I'm not sure if they're both created equal...you know? So, are there any hard opinions out there?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Personally, I am for Prometheus 100%! They are a great lab for celiac testing.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, Kaiti. I'm feeling the pressure because my friend on the east coast is married to a dr and he's giving her some attitude about testing their son who has had problems since birth. The child is currently on meds and she'd like to find an alternative dx that utilizes a dietary change rather than serious drugs. I'm trying to be delicate in my advice so as not to stir up any tension. She needed to know where to get the tests done, and I'd like all my answers to be the best they can be. So, I will toss out Prometheus as an alternative to Entero in a quick email to her. It must be VERY difficult being married to a dr who questions the likelihood of celiac disease as a reasonable dx. It's bad enough just going into an office you know you can jet out of when you feel ignored.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Two labs are being mentioned here. Can we add yet another. Great Smoky? I understand that in addition to celiac testing they do some other very sophisticated funtional testing. Anyone have any experience? Claire

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Two labs are being mentioned here. Can we add yet another. Great Smoky? I understand that in addition to celiac testing they do some other very sophisticated funtional testing. Anyone have any experience?  Claire

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I've had IgG Food Antibody and Comprehensive Digestive Stool Analysis tests done at Great Smokies. I think they are mainly known for these types of tests..and they have a great reputation. However, I don't think too many people here have used them for Celiac testing. I think they've just recently started testing for celiac disease and I have no idea about their tests. Enterolab and Prometheus seem to be very well known for running these tests. Maybe Great Smokies will build a reputation but so far I havent seen anything about them with the exception of one guy from another forum. I used Enterolab for my tests.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Thanks Rachel. I will be so glad if I ever get something definitve. My tale is way too long to tell - you would age while I was telling it.

Right now I have a diagnosis which I don't believe - at least I don't believe it is a primary diagnosis. I believe I am celiac disease or gluten sensitive. Whatever, I have serious neurological complications and neurologist says no gluten - regardless. I will be evaluated at NIH -as soon as I can get an appointment. That will include DNA mapping for spinoccerebellar ataxia.

I was on a gluten controlled diet for years but not gluten free, I just eliminanted the big offenders. That came about because I was diagnosed Type II, Delayed Food Reactions. Now Blood test for celiac is unreliable because of the gluten withdrawal. Stool sample is the only way left to go - unless NIH will map for celiac as well. I am gluten free now.

I am new on the forum. It is quite an experience. Very helpful. I do get concerned about those who don't seem to realize what severe damage gluten can cause - celiac, gluten sensitive or whatever. Silently, it can do you in! Claire :rolleyes:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks Rachel.  I will be so glad if I ever get something definitve. My tale is way too long to tell - you would age while I was telling it.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yeah...I know how you feel. I had a rough 3 years not knowing what was going on with my health. I've been on disability 2 years and just finally got my positive results last month. I had everything from MRI to Barium to CT scans and tons of bloodwork...nothing ever came back positive till I went to Enterolab. Gluten...who knew??

Well I'm getting better now but still waiting to see if gluten-free is going to bring me back to 100%...I'm about 75% right now. I was probably at 2% a few months back so I'm doing really good. :)

If you've been gluten-free for awhile you probably want to use Enterolab...I think they're the only one who does the stool test and you dont have to go back on gluten for the test. Does Prometheus only do blood? Maybe someone else knows. I'm pretty sure the one guy who used Great Smokies had a blood test too. A blood test wont be accurate unless you're on gluten. Also if you were interested in gene testing Enterolab tests for gluten sensitivity genes as well as celiac genes. I don't think any other lab does that.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was a little late in seeing this topic, but I, too, would go with Prometheus.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think doctors consider Prometheus labs more seriously than Enterolab. I was not happy with Prometheus.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Personally, I am for Prometheus 100%! They are a great lab for celiac testing.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Thanks Kaiti

Blood work only? I have been on a gluten controlled diet for 15 years. Blood work is unreliable. I need a stool sample test.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think doctors consider Prometheus labs more seriously than Enterolab.  I was not happy with Prometheus.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

What went wrong? Claire

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yeah...I know how you feel. I had a rough 3 years not knowing what was going on with my health. I've been on disability 2 years and just finally got my positive results last month. I had everything from MRI to Barium to CT scans and tons of bloodwork...nothing ever came back positive till I went to Enterolab. Gluten...who knew??

Well I'm getting better now but still waiting to see if gluten-free is going to bring me back to 100%...I'm about 75% right now. I was probably at 2% a few months back so I'm doing really good.  :)

If you've been gluten-free for awhile you probably want to use Enterolab...I think they're the only one who does the stool test and you dont have to go back on gluten for the test. Does Prometheus only do blood? Maybe someone else knows. I'm pretty sure the one guy who used Great Smokies had a blood test too. A blood test wont be accurate unless you're on gluten. Also if you were interested in gene testing Enterolab tests for gluten sensitivity genes as well as celiac genes. I don't think any other lab does that.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Hi Rachel - you seem to be making great progress. Congratulations. Most discouraging for me right now is that everything takes so long. I wait days into weeks just to get a secretary to make an appointment. I have turned into a first class pest. Right now I am waiting for NIH. Once I get a call back it will be two to three months for the appointment and then that long again for results. This testing will be looking for a genetic form of ataxia - which I don't think I have. I asked the doctor to order the DNA mapping for celiac but I don't know if he did or not. Interesting that he was adamant about gluten - even when not considering celiac as the primary diagnosis.

I have been fighting the system on this issue since 1980. It took 10 years to get the Type II, Delayed Food Reactions diagnosis and that has been it until this year - when the insidious gluten damage showed up and I inadvertently stumbled onto the connection between the Delayed Food Reactions and celiac. I have a medical background so I am a real pain to doctors because I push them to find cause - rather than treating symptoms. I believe the neurological problems are symptomatic. The neurologist sees them as a primary diagnosis. It will take so many months to find out which of us is right. In the meantime I am assuming celiac or gluten sensitivity and will have to do that scouting on my own - unless doctor has ordered the DNA at NIH. My blood work on the food issues showed me reactive to all grains except rice and oats -among other things. Thanks for your note. Claire

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What went wrong?    Claire

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the responses. Now can someone help a newbie here with a technical issue. I am new to this forum - have never been on a forum before. How do I reply to a portion of a response without quoting the whole message? I want to make a reply to a response and have it appear with that response but without the quote. Thanks for help. Claire

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think doctors consider Prometheus labs more seriously than Enterolab.  I was not happy with Prometheus.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Sorry - my reply to you didn't go where I expected it to and is floating around loose. You can tell I am a newbie here. What went wrong for you at Prometheus?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks for the responses.  Now can someone help a newbie here with a technical issue.  I am new to this forum - have never been on a forum before.  How do I reply to a portion of a response without quoting the whole message?  I want to make a reply to a response and have it appear with that response but without the quote.  Thanks for help.  Claire

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Instead of hitting reply scroll down a bit farther to the add reply and it will not quote anything from the previous post.

Also, Enterolab is good for an alternative and if you want a stool test. Prometheus is a prominent lab for celiac testing but I do believe that they only do the blood work. Blood work with them has been very reliable though unlike some other labs around. They know how to read celiac panels.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Kaiti -

Now I will see if this reply stays with your message or 'floats' off separately. I knew about the reply but now how to attach it to a message without taking the quote.

You say 'know how to read a celiac panel'. Explain please. Did you have some experience or know of labs not reading the panel correctly?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks Kaiti -

Now I will see if this reply stays with your message or 'floats' off separately.  I knew about the reply but now how to attach it to a message without taking the quote.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Claire, whenever you post it will automatically go to the end of the topic...regardless of who you are responding to. If you want to respond to an earlier post its a good idea to use quotes so that your post will be understood. Its not that the post is "floating" off seperately...its just that the posts are in order by when they were sent. The last post will always be the most recent post. Hope I'm making sense. :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks Kaiti

Blood work only?  I have been on a gluten controlled diet for 15 years. Blood work is unreliable. I need a stool sample test.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Claire,

How gluten-free have you been over the last 15 years? If you haven't been eating gluten for such a long time I don't think even the stool test will be accurate. Enterolab says 1 year off gluten can still provide positive results..I don't think there is any guarantee though. 1 year is a long time and 15 years is a REALLY long time. Have you read the FAQ on Enterolab's site? I think they say in this type of scenario the gene testing would be of more help. If you've been eating some gluten I guess you could still try with the stool test.

Sorry you've been through so much....I had to become a pain to my doctors as well..it was the only way to get them to do anything. In the end they never helped. All of the months that I was at my worst and had lost 25 lbs. they never sent me to the GI or even considered Celiac. I was tested once at MY request but I'd already started a gluten-free diet and didn't know any better. :(

They are running all the celiac tests now including the biopsy but its too late cuz I've been gluten-free 5 months now.

Even more frusterating is that I was so sick for 3 years with no answers and all these miserable symptoms. Today I find out my roommate who has the same HMO (different city) is getting tested for the full celiac panel. She has NO symptoms whatsoever...she's healthy but went to the doctor for the flu she had last week. Her liver counts were high and she was sent to the GI right away...He's testing her for lots of things including celiac disease. What the heck! :blink:

I was 94 lbs. and couldn't even hold my own head up and my mom had to cry and beg them to send me to the GI after 3 whole years!!! I still to this day have not had the full celiac panel!! I'm very upset about this. :angry:

My roommate is laughing and saying I have "celiac panel envy"....which I do!!!

Anyways the panel is meaningless to me now that I'm gluten-free...I wont go back on gluten for the tests so even though they're going to test me now...it'll just be negative.

Sorry for the rant....I just needed to get that out.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Claire, whenever you post it will automatically go to the end of the topic...regardless of who you are responding to. If you want to respond to an earlier post its a good idea to use quotes so that your post will be understood. Its not that the post is "floating" off seperately...its just that the posts are in order by when they were sent. The last post will always be the most recent post. Hope I'm making sense.  :P

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Absolute sense. How do you get just part of a quote - enough to identify it? Some messages are long.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Absolute sense.  How do you get just part of a quote - enough to identify it? Some messages are long.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You just erase whataver you don't want in the qoute...you can narrow it down to whatever you want. Just dont mess with the mumbo jumbo computer jargon stuff on the top and bottom of the quote....because thats what keeps the quote intact.

:)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good. Thanks. I spend a lot of my life on a computer but that doesn't make me forum smart. Here I am definitely 'challenged'. But kind ones like you take pity on me and before you know it I will know what I am doing. :lol:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,657
    • Total Posts
      921,628
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hi, you can try reporting your own post.  That should alert the site admin of your request.  I don't think they can delete your posts, but changing your user name may be possible.
    • Hi Pablito, Welcome to the forum! You are right, you should keep eating gluten  until the tests are all done.  The skin problems you describe ma be a condition only celiacs get.  The condition is called dermatitis herpetiformis (DH for short),  DH causes an itchy rash that is usually symetrical on the body.  You get the rash on both arms or legs etc.  It makes little blisters on the skin.  They are caused by IgA antibodies in the skin.  There i a test for DH where they take a small skin sample (biopsy) from the skin next to a blister and check it for IgA antibodies.   If they find DH, then you have celiac disease.  The 2 conditions are never separate.  there is a section of this forum dedicated to dermatitis herpetiformis with lots more information. The usual diagnostic process is to do a celiac antibodies blood test first, and then an endoscopy to test for damage to the gut lining.  But with DH, it is better to get the skin biopsy done instead of the endoscopy. Celiac disease is passed on in genes, so your children should be tested also if you are diagnosed.
    • Research Celiac Ataxia for potential diagnosis. Look at Milk and dairy for potential head and sinus related issues.  I stopped dairy and I can breathe now! Saturated fat may also be a problem, but it's mostly dairy!
    • It is best not to try and do this on your own. Talk to your allergist. Not all will deal with food intolerances but if yours doesn't find one who will.  Mine had me fill out a very detailed diet questionaire and tested for true allergies before he gave me my starting point. I will admit I wasn't real happy with my starting point since none of my usual foods were on it. He said that I was most likely to react to foods I ate the most so most of the 5 I either rarely ate or didn't really like. The prescribed starting point he formulated was designed to make sure I had adaquate nutrition and enough calories.   It took about 2 weeks before a lot of my tummy issues resolved and I was then able to start adding foods in one at a time for a week before moving on to the next.  He said food intolerance reactions can take up to a week to show up so I had to be sure it was a full week between food additions. I did have to call three offices before I found a doctor who could do the formulation of the diet but this guy truely saved my life. Out of all the doctors I had seen, including specialists in big hospitals, he was the one responsible for finally realizing I was celiac. He of course referred me back to my clueless GI doctor who confirmed the diagnosis by almost killing me with a gluten challenge. I should note that some of my intolerance (not gluten of course) did resolve after I had healed. Even dairy which I hadn't been able to have for years! I hope you can get some answers and are able to heal soon.
    • I'm 43 years old. I'm married and have two teen daughters. After all these years it was one of my daughters who tonight said to me: "you probably have Celiac disease" after hearing my wife and I talking about all the pimples I always get on my arms. I never heard of the disease but I have heard about a lot of people having gluten allergies and didn't know they were the same thing. So I started looking it up on the internet. Turns out I have had all the symptoms all my life and no one has ever said anything about it possibly being Celiac disease. When I was a kid my doctor gave me prescriptions to antibacterial soaps to use for the arm pimples. Hibitane I think was one of them. And I've always had swollen looking ankles as long as I can remember. All my life people have noticed it. As a kid and teen I played lot's of sports and have broken my ankles and sprained them so my mom and I brushed it off at that and so did my family doctor when I was young.  But I always thought it was weird that the swelling continued all these years.  I have had a bloated feeling stomach all my life too and chronic diarrhea. My stomach is always hard and swollen feeling. Not ever knowing what that stuff was related too so I have never mentioned the bloat or diarrhea to a doctor. Just kind of embarrassing I guess. As my wife and I were reading about Celiac Disease on the internet together tonight she pointed out to me that that's probably why these symptoms almost all went away when I did a very low carb diet for about a year straight to lose weight a couple years ago. I had solid bowel movements, no bloat, ankle swelling went down but I thought the improvements were from weight loss and just eating healthier . But perhaps in reality it probably had a lot more to do with not eating all the wheat products/gluten products. So tomorrow I will be seeing my doctor to talk to him about it and to ask for the blood tests. I have read that I should continue eating gluten though until my testing is done. So that is crappy but I guess it's better to know for sure. Something else I think I should point out too is that I get headaches quite a bit after having big meals. Now I am thinking that may have something to do with the gluten too. I have read that some people with Celiac also get headaches with the other symptoms. It's great to see there is a forum like this to help people out with these issues. If I test positive for Celiac I will for sure be following this forum closely for advice and diet/nutrition help.
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,657
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    pablito
    Joined