Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Update....... Confused More Than Ever
0

15 posts in this topic

Ok I am a person that needs yes or no. Either I have celilac or I don't. Lol

Today I went back to my specialist. My genetic test is still not back until tomorrow so still waiting for that one. My other blood work is great. Normal antibody test and all vitamin and mineral levels are great. So Dr Gi is still hesitant to say yes 100% to celiac. As I have been gluten free for 3 weeks now she said there is no point doing more biopsies now.

But because my initial biopsy was positive even though it was only a screening biopsy as opposed to a diagnostic biopsy (3 sections taken instead of 8) but all 3 sections showed villi damage and increase in those cells too. The lab said "indicative of but not diagnostic of partially treated celiac disease, recommend serological investigation". So because of that biopsy and the fact that after 3 weeks gluten free I'm feeling better and things are changing as one would expect if I were celiac, she wants me to stay gluten free and go back in 3 months for follow up and at that point she may want to do a gluten challenge for a month and then do more tests and biopsies then.

I need an answer.

If I had only negative blood work done and responded to gluten free ok could safely say it's just gluten intolerance. But because the biopsy picked up the damage, something is causing it!

Symptom relief so far:

Foggy brain almost gone

Sleeping better

More awake during the day

Sinus are clear for the first time I can ever remember

Post nasal drip is gone (this I have had since I was a child and it has never gone before)

Gerd is gone! No reflex, no burping, no food coming back up.

Bad breath during the day going. I used to be able to taste it.

Bloating receding

Stools changing towards solid but still tan colour and float.

Anxiety gone (normally in this situation I would be having panic attacks waiting for results)

Irritability going.

Brain working again. I am not fumbling for words anymore and I feel sharper.

My sister has just been diagnosed from the blood test her TTG WAS 300+ and the one that should be under 5 was 42. So family link is there.

I jjust don't know. I'm gonna stay on the diet and hope my genetic test lights up tomorrow but even then Dr won't say yes. :-(

Is it celiac or just gluten intolerance and something worse causing the damage?

I'm not lactose or fructose intolerant.

Help me lovely people :-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

Ok I am a person that needs yes or no. Either I have celiac or I don't. Lol

With a necessity for a yes/no, I'd be tempted to shift the question to "either I feel better gluten-free or I don't ".

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks tom, but that question is not good enough. Yes I feel better but that does not mean I have celiac. I may just have gluten intolerance which is fine, but then what's causing the intestinal damage? That's my dilemma. I'm not happy to take a chance.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks tom, but that question is not good enough. Yes I feel better but that does not mean I have celiac. I may just have gluten intolerance which is fine, but then what's causing the intestinal damage? That's my dilemma. I'm not happy to take a chance.

You had a positive biopsy, your sister is a diagnosed Celiac, and you have had a positive response to the diet....explain to me why this hasn't convinced you? You could keep eating gluten for another biopsy down the road but are you willing to trash your intestines completely and develop other AI diseases to convince your doctor to baptize you as an official Celiac?

Having negative blood work and a positive biopsy is all too common for a Celiac. It sounds like you are being swayed by a doctor who does not know how to diagnose Celiac Disease. From what you have described, you have Celiac. I hope you do the right thing and stay gluten free!

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks tom, but that question is not good enough. Yes I feel better but that does not mean I have celiac. I may just have gluten intolerance which is fine, but then what's causing the intestinal damage? That's my dilemma. I'm not happy to take a chance.

Don't think I have ever seen the term "screening" used with an endoscopy when biopsies have been done.

Either those specimens were positive or not. Sounds like an attempt at duplicate procedures to make money. Going gluten free and continuing to pursue other reasons for damage are not mutually exclusive.

See if you can get your specimens sent to another lab for rereading.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




You had a positive biopsy, your sister is a diagnosed Celiac, and you have had a positive response to the diet....explain to me why this hasn't convinced you? You could keep eating gluten for another biopsy down the road but are you willing to trash your intestines completely and develop other AI diseases to convince your doctor to baptize you as an official Celiac?

Having negative blood work and a positive biopsy is all too common for a Celiac. It sounds like you are being swayed by a doctor who does not know how to diagnose Celiac Disease. From what you have described, you have Celiac. I hope you do the right thing and stay gluten free!

Yes I know it sounds silly but after being misdiagnosed for so many years has made me question everything. I would love for this to be celiac because it would be easy to treat. But I just can't help thinking what if it's wrong and I'm missing something more serious. It's not a silly thought but i agree not helpful.

I'm staying gluten free. Thanks everyone for your answers :-)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So...you had enough damage that they found it with only 3 biopsy samples? The reason 8-12 samples is recommended is because some people don't have enough damage to find it with only 3 samples.

I guess you can live in denial for a few more years. That denial can lead to the more serious issues you are looking for.

I know you don't want to have Celiac, none of us really do, but looks like that is what you have.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really want this to be celiac. But when the Dr says "this list of diseases can also cause villious atrophy" you start to wonder when the tests don't all point to yes.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is the Yes/no for you.

Symptom relief so far:

Foggy brain almost gone- YES!

Sleeping better- YES!

More awake during the day- YES!

Sinus are clear for the first time I can ever remember- YES!

Post nasal drip is gone (this I have had since I was a child and it has never gone before)- YES!

Gerd is gone! No reflex, no burping, no food coming back up.- YES!

Bad breath during the day going. I used to be able to taste it. - YES!

Bloating receding- YES!

Stools changing towards solid but still tan colour and float.- YES!

Anxiety gone (normally in this situation I would be having panic attacks waiting for results)- YES!

Irritability going.-YES!

Brain working again. I am not fumbling for words anymore and I feel sharper.-YES!

My sister has just been diagnosed -YES!

Do positive biopsies diagnose Celiac? -YES!

Is it commonly known as the Gold Standard of diagnosing Celiac?- YES!

Is there any other disease that has all these symptoms AND they all go away when you go gluten free?-- NO!

Celiac?- YES!

I think you are diagnosed...

And I think any other Dr. than the one you have would say you are Celiac.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What were the list of the other things that cause flattened villi? And are you experiencing any symptoms that sound similar to any of those things? Sounds like celiac to me, I'm not a doctor obviously.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Casein sensitive enteropathy and parasites are a couple of other villi flatteners' But neither should improve because of a gluten-free diet.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Casein sensitive enteropathy and parasites are a couple of other villi flatteners' But neither should improve because of a gluten-free diet.

This is a really good point! Other problems can cause villi flattening but your doctor wants you to go gluten-free to see if you feel better because he thinks it could be celiac. gluten-free diets only help celiacs so it sounds like you are in the process of confirming the diagnosis through diet... successfully. I guess that's the good and bad news all rolled into one, isn't it?

I believe I've seen stats stating somewhere between 20-30% of celiacs have negative blood tests, and their ceilac is only found through biopsy or vitamin deficiencies. It sounds like you fall into this group.

I hope you continue to improve on the diet. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please give me your address so I can direct the skywriter to spell out YOU HAVE CELIAC.

Seriously....if you keep looking, you will find a reason to convince yourself that it isn't celiac. But it won't make it true.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please give me your address so I can direct the skywriter to spell out YOU HAVE CELIAC.

Seriously....if you keep looking, you will find a reason to convince yourself that it isn't celiac. But it won't make it true.

Thanks it's all good now :-) diagnosis is 100% celiac. No other health issues. Onwards and upwards from here

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For what it's worth, most food intolerances are *only* diagnosed by 'Not eating it, I feel better, and when I try it again, I feel worse'. There just don't exist accurate enough tests to say otherwise. And I say this now because celiacs often have other food intolerances which we only figure out once we've been gluten free.

It's very frustrating not knowing 100% for things, but for the vast majority of medical diagnoses, 100% certainty is just an ideal we strive for.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,099
    • Total Posts
      920,354
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Oh, Trish at the GlutenFreeWatchDog tested Planter's honey roasted peanuts three years ago.  The can did not state gluten-free, but showed no gluten ingrediants (per Kraft policy).  Test result: less than 5 part per million which is pretty much gluten-free.  
    • What if it were something else that glutened you?  Maybe you ate too much of a good thing?  I once (three months post dx) ate too much gluten-free fried chicken, vomited, passed out and fractured my back (osteoporosis) in the process.  Paramedics, ER doc and Cardio all thought I was having a heart attack.   No.  It was sheer gluttony and bad bones.  Not good to overload with a damaged gut.    Maybe you did get some contaminated nuts.  Afterall, anything processed is suspect.  What might be well tolerated by some, might be too much for others.  We all have our various levels of gluten intolerance.   The old 20 parts per million is just a guideline, but science does not really know (lack of funding......doe anyone really care enough to find out?)  My hubby has been gluten-free for 15 years.  When I was first diagnosed, I tried to eat the gluten-free foods that I normally gave him.   Problem was he was healed and I was not.  Things like Xanthan Gum in commercial processed gluten-free breads make me feel like I have been glutened, but it is just (and still is) an intolerance.  So no bread for me unless I make it myself using a different gum.   Too lazy, so I do without.   so, ask your doctor if you really want to know or lay off the cashews and test them again in a month using a certified gluten-free nut.  I wish this was easier!    
    • I have intolerances to a few foods now, so I was wondering about that.. I love cashews though, and a month or two ago I was eating them all the time with no problems at all. I mean, could I really have developed an intolerance to them since then? I don't know if they're made on shared lines (it didn't say on the package so I assumed they weren't), but I'll give them a call. I'm really, really sensitive to cross contamination. Even if something is just made in the same facility (but not on shared lines) it will make me sick. If that's not it, then I'm not really sure
    • Research with KP and find a celiac-savvy GI in your area ( read the biographies). and ask your PCP/GP for a referral to that specific GI (not his buddy).  Ask the GI for the rest  of the celiac panel or proceed with an endoscopy/biopsies -- 4 to six.  Keep eating gluten daily until all testing is complete.  Document and request in writing.  Do not worry about symptoms.  There are over 300 of them and some celiacs have none!   Research all that you can about celiac disease.  The University of Chicago has a great celiac website that has testing Information etc.   Poet me know how it works out.  Hope you feel better soon!  
    • I react to both wheat and barley.  I've opted to just go completely gluten free, for the sake of simplicity and my sanity.  I don't have a diagnosis of celiac disease, but I strongly suspect it.  Unfortunately, I'm not willing to endure the misery of staying on gluten long enough to pursue further testing.  I just know I need to avoid the gluten grains, so I do.  
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,133
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Mycaringkidsmom
    Joined