Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Friend With Possible Celiac?
0

10 posts in this topic

This is a tough discussion. I am dating someone new. She originally told me she was celiac, which is fine. I helped her, always let her choose where to eat out, etc. First issue is that she was never diagnosed. Her aunt told her she had it, so she assumed she had it as well. (This diagnostic was about 2 years ago). She also says she's allergic to artificial sweeteners (splenda, etc.) (also, self diagnosed).

So, all fine and dandy until I realize that she's been eating gluten items without realizing with no reaction. Is this possible? Went to a japanese restaurant and she ordered some miso soup. This happened twice before she realized (days later while reading online) that Miso soup had gluten in it. Also, at the same japanese restaurant, she has deep-fried sushi. She says it's safe, albeit I'm not sure with how. Another time we went to Red Lobster and had some shrimp, that later on I looked up online and realized that it also had gluten in it.

The problem is that she is suddenly taking things to an extreme. She read online something about latex-allergy/wheat cross-reactions, so now she's forsaken most fruits, even though she's eaten them every day for breakfast.

To me it kind of sounds like a hypochondria. She's reading things and assuming everything. But I could be wrong. Is it possible to eat gluten items (as above) without having any reaction with celiac? Also, as a celiac, can you touch gluten items (wheat/flour) without a reaction? Assuming you don't ingest it.

Thank you so much for your assistance.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:
Also, as a celiac, can you touch gluten items (wheat/flour) without a reaction? Assuming you don't ingest it.

I certainly can. For more than ten years, my wife and I ran a retail store selling pet food and supplies. Every dog that came in was offered a biscuit. The first ingredient listed was wheat flour. I would touch these many times per day--and always wash my hands afterwards. The gluten molecule is a long complex protein which can not be absorbed through skin.

If you have an allergy to wheat, that would be a different situation. Celiac disease and wheat allergy are distinct conditions. You can have one without the other. Some people have both. The majority of the population have neither.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In addition to what Peter has told you, many people with celiac do not have gastrointestinal symptoms at all. They have other, extra-intestinal symptoms though, like hives, neurological symptoms, behavioral problems, urinary tract issues, reproductive issues, etc. Celiac is a multi-factorial disease affecting may body systems.

Here is the part that is most important: you say her "aunt told her she has celiac"---- How is that a diagnosis?

She should be tested properly before she continues to think so many things "might" make her ill.

She could be eliminating perfectly good foods for no good reason.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not all of us are "properly" diagnosed with Celiac disease. If she was feeling ill and exhibiting the symptoms of Celiac her aunt may have "helped" her by telling her about Celiac. I told my sister and she has a child with symptoms who didn't test positive but feels better off of wheat. Therefore, that child is self-diagnosed because her aunt told her about it. Wheat can still be a legitimate issue if she hasn't tested positive but finds she feels better off of wheat. Some people are self-diagnosed because their Dr. won't test them, or doesn't believe the symptoms are consistent with what they believe to be classic Celiac. There is also gluten intolerance that isn't detectable by testing.

If she is eliminating fruits I wonder if she is feeling badly and looking for a cause? The gluten she has been ingesting could be the cause if she is indeed Celiac. As to whether she would be able to eat it and not have a "reaction" well, yes, she could. If she had been fairly consistently gluten free, the antibodies would have subsided and she may not react to gluten as she did before. This is normally a very good thing for a Celiac. However, it can be dangerous when individuals choose to assume that it means they are no longer Celiac or no longer sensitive to wheat. The damage can happen without overt symptoms. It used to be that Dr.'s thought children outgrew Celiac for that very reason, they were no longer reacting and appeared to be able to eat it normally. Until later they learned these are the children who grew up to have the lymphoma's and cancers and auto-immune diseases associated with Celiac disease when it is not controlled by a gluten free diet.

I think it is wonderful that she has a friend like you who is willing to help her figure this out and who wants to understand. Hypochondria is extremely rare. Normally people who appear to be hypochondriac are seeking answers to why they do not feel good. I would encourage you to continue to be supportive of her and maybe do some talking about how it came to be that her aunt thought she had Celiac. Does it run in the family? Is she willing to get tested? Many people opt not to test knowing they have to ingest gluten for a period of time in order to have a chance to test positive.

Maybe she just needs help identifying gluten in foods and eliminating it and the other intolerances will resolve once she is truly gluten free. Obviously she is looking for answers too. Maybe this will be a good opportunity for her to either get diagnosed or learn to be completely gluten free. Feel free to invite her here. Thanks for caring enough to write us and ask questions!

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I apologize about the Aunt thing. The Aunt actually said that the Aunt had celiac, not the girl in question in the above discussions.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Okay, well, now that I see THIS post, this is a totally different issue. I think I understand what you are asking now. But please clarify if I'm still not clear.

You are saying:

(1)the aunt told her that she has celiac and

(2) therefore, your friend assumes that she also has has it-- yet

(3) she has been consuming gluten all along ....but has no symptoms from it.

Is this correct?

It is quite possible your friend has celiac or a gluten intolerance or any number of food intolerances or allergies, but if --as you say---she is not exhibiting any signs, not even extra-intestinal ones, what are you asking us then?

If she is "faking it"? None of can tell you that. We have no clue.

I suggested she see a doctor for testing (if she can), to see if it is a wheat allergy or celiac (or any other food allergies )before she assumes these foods are actually a problem for her.

I, personally, would never call anyone a hypochondriac as I do not walk in his/her shoes. Having suffered dozens of seemingly inexplicable symptoms myself before diagnosis, I am sure some may have wondered that about me.

If she has been consuming gluten all along, maybe she could go get a celiac panel done? Just a thought.

Yes, it is true that many of us DO see gluten intolerance symptoms in our relatives and suggest to them they may have it too.

However, if--- as you say--- she has been eating all these foods (wheat, fruits, etc.) all along without any issues, then I am not sure why she presumes she has celiac or other intolerances in the first place. Just because something "says so" on the internet does not always make it true.

Did you ask her why she thinks these things ---when she eats them and feels fine?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think a few different things are possible. First, there are many people who have celiac and don't take their disease seriously at first then realize that they need to and knock off the crap. Symptoms can vary widely from literally none at all to bedridden for weeks at a time from a single seemingly minor accident with our food. It is possible that she simply has crossed that bridge into being a grown up and has begun to take her health seriously for the first time.

Then, there is the other possibility which I'll catch hell for saying but here it is... maybe she's just a hypochondriac. Maybe she craves attention. Maybe she just thinks she has every disease she reads about online or that every family member has. Maybe she's just a little bit off in that respect and maybe it warrants a discussion with her doctor.

Now before someone goes all crazy on me... I self-diagnosed myself as allergic to my husband's cat. Why? Because whenever it touches me I break out in hives. I'm pretty sure I don't need to shell out money to a doctor to state the obvious. Now if your gluten-free has ever had symptoms of celiac or a gluten intolerance and they cleared up gluten free (although it may be hard to say this has happened since it sounds like she hasn't ever actually BEEN gluten free) then it's fair to say she is likely gluten intolerant. If she never exhibited symptoms but was just like "omg I could have that too" and jumped on the fad diet bandwagon, I'm sorry, but she's simply a hypochondriac. And I'll take the flak for saying so. My point is, it's important to find out how she came to this conclusion besides a simple my aunt has it so I must too statement.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My point is, it's important to find out how she came to this conclusion besides a simple my aunt has it so I must too statement.

I agree -- and it would be different if she were obviously sickly or had other symptoms and was unable to afford testing and did better on a gluten free diet.

This is simply not the case here. She is neither gluten free nor having symptoms that he can tell, so I am not sure what the point is.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's hard to tell, but I MIGHT be that she hasn't been feeling quite right and decided to try gluten-free to see if it helped. Without being scrupulous about her diet of course she has been eating gluten and maybe not realizing it. So she still doesn't feel quite right and is looking for other reasons (the latex allergy).

The thing is, a lot of celiac symptoms are things you would never associate with celiac. Things like insomnia, rashes, brain fog, heart palpitations, and a host of other sometimes vague symptoms. If she just plain doesn't feel good and is trying to find the reason so she can fix it, that is a good thing.

She needs to come here and learn about reading labels and cross contamination. Now that you have written about her, you may be afraid she will recognize you and herself. You could send her to celiac.org instead, or even better yet, ask that this thread be deleted. Just tell her you've been doing some research and found this site and it appears to have the best information (it does) and have her sign up and read. It may seem sneaky, but you are trying to help her and there's nothing wrong with that. And if she learns enough to start taking the gluten-free diet seriously, and if it helps her to feel better, you will be her hero.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I apologize about the Aunt thing. The Aunt actually said that the Aunt had celiac, not the girl in question in the above discussions.

Hey, no offense taken about the Aunt thing at all! I just wanted to let you know that us Aunts can get pretty pushy with our nieces if we think they are Celiac! Well intentioned of course, since it is hereditary. :) Wish you luck, feel free to ask more questions when you have them.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      103,874
    • Total Posts
      919,424
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • gluten intolerance, dairy intolerance and fructose
      I've never gone fructose free so can't help much with that.  But any fruit is probably a problem.  If you are serious about avoiding fructose you could do a search and print out a list of foods to avoid. http://www.mayoclinic.org/fructose-intolerance/expert-answers/faq-20058097 Yes, it very possible to have multiple food intolerance issues.  Many people have multiple food intolerances.  It might help to avoid any foods that are sweet for now.  Meat and most veggies are probably the way to go.  You may want to get some jerky to eat for snacks.  Peanuts might be ok but you'll need to verify that.  Boiled eggs are probably ok.  Most soda would be a no-no.      
    • Help
      Hi Courtney, You asked about dairy, and RMJ got it right.  Celiac disease destroys the villi lining of the small intestine.  Those villi make the lactase enzyme we need to digest dairy. Sigmoid colon thickening could be related to diverticulitis.  Which according to Wiki is a fairly common condition but doesn't always cause symptoms.  Diverticulitis can cause a problem if there is an infection though.  The sigmoid colon is part of the large intestine.  Celiac disease affects the small intestine, so celiac isn't likely involved.  I am not sure why the resident suggested celiac, unless there were some other reason to do so.  Possibly the weight loss, which could be explained by celiac disease.  Thickening of the colon may happen with Crohn's disease also.  And I'm not sure about UCD (ulcerative colitis disease) but it might cause that also, not sure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diverticulosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sigmoid_colon http://biology-pages.info/G/GITract.html#pancreas http://www.ccfa.org/what-are-crohns-and-colitis/what-is-ulcerative-colitis/
    • So I've been glutened....
      Hi JMG, Since it's easy, and always fun, I'd blame your sister. That's what I do.  But seriously, if it's an ongoing problem, rather than an isolated incident stick with your first guess.  Then test it.   So get rid of the oat bread or the sister (her food) or anything that is a consistent part of your diet and you suspect could be the problem.  Of course processed foods are the most likely issue always. It's easy enough to drop back to a very few foods for a few days and see if things improve.  Eating with celiac isn't about having the most exciting diet, it's about eating a medically safe diet.  So it can be boring sometimes.  That's ok, being in pain is exciting but not so fun.   Boring is fine. You might ask your sister what brands of flour she used, and other ingredients.  Then check on those products for possible gluten issues.  If they turn out to be possible problems, make a note of it so you can avoid them in the future. My own sister has been gluten-free for years but she has made me sick several times with her "creations".  It really is best to trust your own cooking and nobody else's for at least 6 months as you are getting used to the diet and healing.  Then slowly branch out and add things in maybe 1 new item in a week.  Slow and controlled diet changes are the way to go.  Boring but safe.  Happy but slow.    
    • So I've been glutened....
      Jmg I am sorry to hear you are unwell. You have been so kind and helpful to me on the boards here. You deserve the time to rant too.   Everyone's suggestion of probiotic is helpful. I have taken them since the 1990's in spurts as needed but was told by my DC after this March glutening I should take it daily "for life". My local store ran out, (I buy the type that must be refrigerated so the manufacturer does not ship direct to customer.) I was ok first day without it but by day 3 I knew I had to locate some for the probiotic/ enzyme blend was necessary for me. I have still not healed well enough yet to be without. As others said it could be cc from sis or the food  industry. Within the food industry even with parameters in place errors can be made- hopefully not too often.  Often rare though especially if not designated facility.  It is hard to know some days what it was. I do hope you get better soon. Yes I do think it can affect the brain/mood. Happens to me a large amount can be immediately,  but a smaller amount by day 2 after glutening. I want to ban gluten everywhere in my environments, unrealistic I know,  but have only been able to do that at home.  Be kind and patient with yourself at this time as you would tell me. ((((((Hug)))))
    • So I've been glutened....
      Yeah I did all the bone broths and sauerkraut after my challenge. Although I wasn't very good at making sauerkraut... Its summer here now so I've eased up on the bone boiling, plus my local butcher is struggling to obtain them. As you say healing to the point where microscopic cross contamination doesn't get you would be a big win.  I was ok with coffee until last few days. I drank decaff black and would have several cups a day without issue. I'll be gutted if I can't handle it any more. I hadn't realised you could get gluten-free miso soup. Will have to look for that    
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

    • Jmg  »  admin

      Hello Admin!
      I don't know whether this is of interest to post on your articles feed:
      http://pratt.duke.edu/about/news/window-guts-brain
      Kind Regards,
      Matt
      · 2 replies
    • celiac sharon  »  cyclinglady

      Hello cycling lady, have you noticed my picture is showing up as you?  Have no idea why but it's rather disconcerting to see my picture and your words 😉  Do you know how to fix it?  You seem to have far more experience with this board than I do
      · 1 reply
    • Larry Gessner  »  cyclinglady

      Hi There, I don't know if there is a place for videos in the forum. I just watched "The Truth About Gluten" I think it is a good video. I would like to share it somewhere but don't know where it should go. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
      Here is the link if you have never watched it.
      https://youtu.be/IU6jVEwpjnE Thank You,
      Larry
      · 2 replies
  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      60,909
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    Fourpeople
    Joined