Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Glutened By Vapors
0

51 posts in this topic

I think the use of the terms psychosomatic and psychological were perhaps not the best to use.... your body reacted as if it had been glutened even though gluten did not acutally enter your body. This is not in your mind it has more to do with a complex system of sensory neurons. As to what was the stimuli that caused your body to react this way it could have been the vapors. But something did cause your body to detect a presence of gluten or wheat and so it reacted. The body can really be a difficult thing to understand at times.

Well thought out words, well seasoned with salt. Thank you very much!

The presentation of the posters here to portray me as simply being wrong or reacting psychosomatically did NOT sit well with me. I emailed my question to six celiac centers and/or physicians. The response I'm receiving does NOT agree with how the posters here have presented the situation. I'm not a 'told you so' kind of person, so I will simply recommend that anyone experiencing the same thing that I have should also consult with a professional and not a forum. Simply google "celiac research facilities physicians" and start emailing.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

I am sure no one here meant to upset you or deny your symptoms. They are just trying to provide correct information regarding Celiacs and/or gluten sensitivity.

This is exactly the case. I did not deny her symptoms at all.

I have reread this thread and no one called her a "psycho" as she has stated.

I tried to explain what the word psychosomatic meant in terms of the bodily response (it's the same explanation as yours) and I tried to provide a possible and reasonable explanation for what may have happened.

If Chopper has received different information regarding the presence of gluten in steam and vapors from 6 major celiac centers that clarifies this, I, personally, would be very grateful to see it.

I love reading research and learning more about the complexities of this disease. I tried to find information about gluten molecules in vapors, but came up empty.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chopper, I'm not gonna beat a dead horse here but if you do have evidence to support your theory, I wouldn't consider it an "I told you so", rather information that would benefit all of us. I'd be very interested to read what you have.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well thought out words, well seasoned with salt. Thank you very much!

The presentation of the posters here to portray me as simply being wrong or reacting psychosomatically did NOT sit well with me. I emailed my question to six celiac centers and/or physicians. The response I'm receiving does NOT agree with how the posters here have presented the situation. I'm not a 'told you so' kind of person, so I will simply recommend that anyone experiencing the same thing that I have should also consult with a professional and not a forum. Simply google "celiac research facilities physicians" and start emailing.

I am sorry that you seem so offended by a completely normal occurrence that happens to many people...myself included. If I thought the term psychosomatic was so bad, I certainly wouldn't use it to describe my experience but I am not an overly sensitive person...just one who seeks out and learns the truth.

That seems to be the problem here more than anything else. If you are so convinced that forum information is so wrong, then why come here? You posted incorrect information about a Celiac reaction and then get all indignant when a number of well informed members of this forum try to correct your information, for the benefit of those new to this disease.

I, too, would like to see all the information from the 6 different Celiac centers and or physicians you contacted because apparently, they know something the rest of the Celiac experts don't. You can believe what you want, whether it's correct or not. Just don't come on here acting all offended when you don't like the responses you read. I don't sugar coat things.....there's too much of that going on already.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of us react to smaller amounts of gluten than others. Some things that are considered to not be present at all can be present in very small amounts. I am a chemist and routinely do distillations. They are not 100.0000000% perfect. I get spectroscopic analysis of my products. There can be other things in there in small amounts, even things with much different boiling points.

As stated above. Trust your reactions. If something makes you sick, don't do it. You don't need to justify avoiding something that will make you ill.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




I don't know that there have been any studies on gluten particles specifically, but there have been studies on various allergens and whether particles are present in the air after processes such as boiling, frying, etc.... So far, the evidence is that there are enough particulates aerosolized by cooking processes that an allergic person can respond.

Again, this is looking at those with allergies, not Celiac Disease. However, allergies are a reaction to proteins, and gluten involves proteins, so I'm just looking at these as examples of whether or not proteins can become airborne by some process of cooking.

I'll list a couple examples. One is primarily industrial, so not as useful to this discussion. I include it merely because it briefly discusses the fact that aerosolization during the cooking process is a known issue. The second is a study with allergic individuals in a closed room where food was cooked. That may be more relevant.

This doesn't address any issues about quantities released into the air vs. quantities required for most Celiacs to react, but it does address the possibility of aerosolization.

http://www.clinicalmolecularallergy.com/content/7/1/4#B3

"Processing of a food, such as boiling, steaming, or frying, can also release significant quantities of particulates into the air. This aerosolization has also been identified as a potential high risk factor for sensitization by inhalation..."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12121190

From the Abstract:

"Subjects were exposed for 20 min to the aerosolized form of the allergen and the symptoms and the lung function were monitored. Aerosolization was achieved by cooking the food in a small room. Where possible challenges were double-blinded....The implicated foods were fish, chickpea, milk, egg or buckwheat...Our data demonstrates that, as in the case of other aeroallergens, inhaled food allergens can produce both early- and late-phase asthmatic responses..."

Oh, and Irishheart? Just because you mentioned feeling sick from strong perfumes.:-) Am I recalling right that you have issues with sulfites? If that's correct, you might be interested to know that a lot of sulfite sensitive folks react to perfumes. Some have severe reactions, but most I've spoken to say their reactions are mild, often headaches, dizziness or nausea.

I've heard a lot of anecdotal reports re: sulfites in perfumes, but the closest to a 'source' I've found is 'A Consumer's Dictionary of Cosmetic Ingredients,' which said that sodium metabisulfite is used as an antifermentative in perfumes, so maybe your reaction isn't as psychosomatic as you may have thought. :)

Shauna

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh, and Irishheart? Just because you mentioned feeling sick from strong perfumes.:-) Am I recalling right that you have issues with sulfites? If that's correct, you might be interested to know that a lot of sulfite sensitive folks react to perfumes. Some have severe reactions, but most I've spoken to say their reactions are mild, often headaches, dizziness or nausea.

Thanks for your thoughts, TH! :)

I did have a reaction to all kinds of strong odors when I was very ill from the celiac--before DX .(smoke, perfume, candles, gasoline, truck or bus exhaust....those kinds of things...and holy moly when a skunk came through the property :blink: ). I have noticed I am less sensitive than I used to be, which gives credence to the theory that healing the gut may relieve those chemical sensitivities many of us suffer? I recently tried wine again and I did not have a problem (yaay!!) so maybe sulfites are less of an issue as well.

From what I understand, consumption of food with sulfites is generally harmless, unless you suffer from severe asthma or do not have the particular enzymes necessary to break down sulfites in your body.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[oh and Irishheart? Just because you mentioned feeling sick from strong perfumes.:-) Am I recalling right that you have issues with sulfites? If that's correct, you might be interested to know that a lot of sulfite sensitive folks react to perfumes. Some have severe reactions, but most I've spoken to say their reactions are mild, often headaches, dizziness or nausea.

I've heard a lot of anecdotal reports re: sulfites in perfumes, but the closest to a 'source' I've found is 'A Consumer's Dictionary of Cosmetic Ingredients,' which said that sodium metabisulfite is used as an antifermentative in perfumes, so maybe your reaction isn't as psychosomatic as you may have thought. :)

Shauna

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest that we don't know anything like as much as we need to about the way the body recognises and reacts to a substance which triggers an auto-immune response.

Just because there isn't actually "gluten" per se in steam or vapour doesn't mean the body might not recognise the smell or some kind of similarity with what it used to know as the evil gluten that triggered an almighty defense.

I too would be quite insulted at terms like "psychosomatic". I am fairly sure I react to the smell of toast for example. And I know perfectly well that this isn't because there are large gluten protein molecules floating around in the air!

Best wishes to all,

Carolyn

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I too would be quite insulted at terms like "psychosomatic". I am fairly sure I react to the smell of toast for example. And I know perfectly well that this isn't because there are large gluten protein molecules floating around in the air!

If you react to the smell of toast, and I would assume you mean wheat toast, then you most likely had a psychosomatic reaction. That's what happens with me around strong gluten smells. It happens for many different reasons to people and why anyone would be insulted is.....well..... :blink:

To the newly diagnosed and still in the learning process....do not fear the boiling pasta water! Just don't get it on your food!

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you react to the smell of toast, and I would assume you mean wheat toast, then you most likely had a psychosomatic reaction. That's what happens with me around strong gluten smells. It happens for many different reasons to people and why anyone would be insulted is.....well..... :blink:

To the newly diagnosed and still in the learning process....do not fear the boiling pasta water! Just don't get it on your food!

No - the reason it isn't psychosomatic is that I don't react at the time - and indeed it's taken me ages to work out what I think the cause is. I react the next day - my system goes into overload and kicks everything out. And it's the same deal when sitting in a room with people eating sandwiches. If it were psychosomatic I would expect to feel ill when I were aware of being in a place of gluten. But actually that doesn't happen and it never occured to me that it might so it certainly wasn't something I was "expecting". I have had to try and work out why I keep getting a bad stomach - and have started to see a pattern of being exposed to (presumably) air-borne / smell of gluten triggers the previous day.

I have been ridiculously careful about avoiding gluten for a couple of years now and basically cook everything myself from scratch to avoid any potential for cross contamination. It's been extremely good for healing the gut, but I am with people who think they become more sensitive the more careful they are I have to say.

I have a degree in Experimental Psychology by the way, and I do know a lot about psychosomatic reactions, but this is not one of them!

Best wishes, Carolyn

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The body has many physiological responses, reflexes and defense mechanisms which are not always understood or even recognized. Physiological conditioned responses of the body are widely accepted due to Ivan Pavlov and his famous experiment of eliciting the secretion of the salivary glands in dogs by the ringing of a bell. Pavlov abandoned his former career and pursued a science one. He contributed to many areas of physiological and neurological science. He went on to perform experiments on digestion and eventually published "The Work of the Digestive Glands".

I mention Pavlov because it is interesting that both posters (Chopper and Carolynmay) had the same reaction of their digestive system emptying out the next day. And so possibly it could have been a conditioned bodily response...the body detected wheat in the nearby environment and reacted just as it would have to the actual ingestion of wheat even though wheat was not actually ingested.

If the response was truly due to a physiological cause such as a conditioned response then psychosomatic would not be the correct term to use. On the other hand, if a physiological conditioned response was the cause then "being glutened" would not be the correct term to use as a true Celiac reaction did not occur. Perhaps it would be better to say you had a "Celiac-like reaction".

I believe it is fairly common and usual for people to become upset in response to someone mentioning their physical symptoms are psychosomatic. And so I don't disregard your upsetment but ask you to let it pass and move forward. Upsetment only distracts you and hinders your ability to perform well and comprehend and understand information. Better to focus on your own well-being, identifying the situations that caused you a reaction and planning on how to avoid them in the future.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think we can all agree on this: if something makes you feel lousy, don't do it anymore.

I think we can all agree on this too: just because this reaction happened to the OP, it doesn't mean it will happen to all of us.

We could speculate all day long what caused her to feel ill, but we will never know the answer.

In regards to the technology in labs today that are available to detect small amounts of anything that may be present, well, I agree with that as well. The difficult part of all of this is---the world we live in is full of contaminants. If we really knew what was in our food and drink, we'd probably end up not eating or drinking anything. :ph34r:

At some point, we have to decide what works for us individually, based on the current understanding of gluten and how it affects the small intestine in a celiac--and how it affects the whole body--- as a result. I never could have imagined what this thing did to my body and brain.

With varying levels of sensitivity to gluten, this becomes a personal choice: what makes me feel bad should be avoided, but it does not mean everyone else will feel this way.

Case in point: I rarely eat at restaurants, but I did a few weeks ago as I was traveling and meeting up with family members.

3 of us are gluten-free. We all ordered the same dinner from the same gluten-free menu (beef tips, potato, broccoli) and I am the only one who got sick and had symptoms for 3 weeks.

Lucky me? <_< No, that's just my system--still sick from celiac and a gut still on the mend. Those are foods I eat regularly at home without issues. My doc's words? "Wow, you are very sensitive to trace cc".

Yes, thanks, Dr. G---I got that. :)

But, I do not rush to post something like : "beef tips, potato and broccoli" got me! as a result of my experience, nor do I say "you should not eat out --ever."

Because neither of those statements are universally applicable to everyone else that reads this forum, even those of us who are very sensitive.

The OP believes the gluten vapors got her. And that's fine!

But, if she emphatically states that leading celiac centers and doctors say "it can happen", it would be good of her to share this information with the rest of us sensitive types who have researched this thing to death and want to learn all we can.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I got sick once from sitting in a pizza place with the guy tossing pizza in the air. Throwing flour on the board and then patting it out and tossing the dough up and all that fancy - schmancy pizzza stuff they do. I suppose it was the flour in the air thing that got me. I don't get sick walking through the bakery aisle at a grocery store though.

I did a little distillation when I was younger. Distilled spirits are not just alcohol. They contain flavor essences also. If you boil your mixture at just high enough temperature to get only the alcohol boiling off, you end up with grain alcohol. Not many people like to drink pure grain alcohol. So the common process is to raise the boiling temperature near the end of the cycle to get some of the flavorings airborne in the steam. That way you get whiskey or whatever you are making instead of just pure alcohol. With vodka they try to keep most of the flavorings out though. So I think that makes it clear that other things can be carried in steam, not just water vapor. Otherwise we would all have nothing but flavorless , plain alcohol beverages to drink. Or beer or wine, which aren't distilled.

I am not saying gluten can be carried in steam, but other things certainly can be. Maybe gluten is too heavy to be carried by steam, I don't know. But other things like flavorings are not.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After reading all of the comments and being a member on this board for a few years I have a couple of comments for this post.

1. From my understanding Chopper was venting about their glutening and just wanted some support. This is a support group.

2. I understand why people reacted the way they did. If newbies come on this site and read vapors glutened someone they are going to assume the same can happen with them.

3. I myself know that I have over reacted to situations and have felt like I have been glutened but I wasnt.

4. I can see why Chopper felt attacked on this board.

Please remember people have feelings and even if they are not relevant to you they are to the poster.

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After reading all of the comments and being a member on this board for a few years I have a couple of comments for this post.

1. From my understanding Chopper was venting about their glutening and just wanted some support. This is a support group.

2. I understand why people reacted the way they did. If newbies come on this site and read vapors glutened someone they are going to assume the same can happen with them.

3. I myself know that I have over reacted to situations and have felt like I have been glutened but I wasnt.

4. I can see why Chopper felt attacked on this board.

Please remember people have feelings and even if they are not relevant to you they are to the poster.

Your analysis tries to look at all sides and is very gracious.

Number 3 may well be the most telling--as it supports what many have said to her.

Number 2 is the primary reason why many members responded.

The members acknowledged her reactions as being real.

The members offered rational reasons for why she may feel that way (CC from gluten exposure )

and the members gave her our best advice IN SUPPORT.

That's it.

She is the one who became defensive and lashed out saying someone called her psycho (no one said anything of the kind) and then, she said she can prove it is possible with evidence from leading celiac doctors. (she has not returned)

With all due respect, no one "attacked" chopper, however-- and using that word seems unfair and inflammatory.

IMHO

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am glad I dont use this site for support anymore... Some come off as rude these days and not helpful.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry you feel that way. :(

I agree with you completely! Some people do come off as rude in their delivery and we do try to keep that in check.

But I guess I just do not agree with you that the OP was attacked.

That is a strong word ---and if it had happened, I would have been one of the first ones to have stepped in.

This is just my humble opinion, of course and is offered with respect for yours as well.

Best wishes,

IH

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am glad I dont use this site for support anymore... Some come off as rude these days and not helpful.

There will always be a certain segment of the population who, unfortunately, are offended by everything. You can choose whether to come here or not but your feelings are in the VAST minority. I am the one who you posted about because my comment of it possibly being a psychosomatic reaction was taken entirely out of context by the overly sensitive (and I'm not referring to gluten here). No one was rude or needs to apologize to the OP. I always strive to post accurate information so those in need of a Celiac education will get the correct info. That is much more important than not posting something because it might offend someone.

After doing this for almost 8 years (being Celiac, that is), good luck finding another site that has more compassionate, caring and smart Celiacs than this site does.

Not going to happen. Many have inaccurate and false information on the Celiac lifestyle. This one rocks so the choice is yours.

3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just wanted to point out that msmini14 never said that anyone on this board "attacked" anyone.

She just said that she could see why the OP might have felt attacked.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Really? None of us can know how someone actually feels

and you are just playing semantics here.

I have tried to help everyone see all sides and many of us have tried to help the OP figure out what reasonably may have made her ill so she could avoid it in the future. That's what motivates me to reply in threads, to try and help, not to attack or argue over how we "think" someone "may feel".

My advice is almost always: "if it makes you feel bad, don't do it anymore."

But, as another member said earlier in the thread (and I wish I had just exited when she did because it was very wise),

I tried my best ---and now, I'm done here. No point in belaboring it.

Best wishes to all.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gemini and Irishheart. I did not respond to this post to stir up everyone

4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Irishheart. I did not respond to this post to stir up everyone’s opinions. I simply felt the need to stand up for someone who had feelings. She had valid feelings about having issues with the vapors. Who knows, maybe being around that aroma all day caused her to have a headache the following day. Regardless if she was right or wrong they were her feelings.

Please don’t forget how it was for you going gluten-free years ago. Sometimes we have gotten so sick we grasp for straws and try to figure out what caused it.

I ALWAYS stand up for people on this site. :o

Do you even know me?

Then you would know this for sure!

I validated her feelings, hon...over and over.

I said she had "real symptoms".. ..didn't I?

Please read what I said carefully.

The very reason why we are sick and grasp for "straws"-- is the very reason why we come to this site. TO GET REAL ANSWERS.

This is what she was given.

I have given her all the possible reasons why it happened so she could avoid it in the future and spare her this misery.

And to answer you--NO, I NEVER forget what this thing did to me because I suffer the consequences every single day.

I said I "was done" here on this thread, but when you question me and what I do on here because I DO care so much, well, I had to respond.

You also said:

"And like I said before any newbie reading this post could think, “I can be affected by vapors” so again I understand why people said this was a mental issue."

I am not quite sure what you mean here, hon so, please clarify ---

because NO ONE said it was a "mental issue".

This whole discussion has become negative and controversial--when all anyone tried to do was help.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So, Gemini please don

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My husband took up a new hobby, brewing beer. After he made it two different times, the next day I got sick. (I'm always sick the next day when I'm glutened.) He didn't believe me when I blamed it on the boiling brew. I volunteered to help at the fire department for their chicken bbq, and I was working in the kitchen with the boiling macaroni. Sure enough, next day I got sick. Even when he tried to make it when I wasn't home for a third time, I still got sick the next day. This tells me I've moved into the super sensitive arena. But I have to believe that's because I've done such a good job of avoiding gluten, that when I get a little bit, I'm not used to it and react stronger. So be aware of vapors!!!

It's been a long thread and some discussions went astray .. Have you reached a conclusion? Have you found an answer? :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,655
    • Total Posts
      921,622
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Below is copied & pasted from this thread:   My celiac doctor is Dr. Syed Jafri, in Webster, TX (just south of Houston -- basically the Clear Lake City area), saved my LIFE.  I would recommend him to the whole, entire world.  I was desperately ill, and am still struggling, and he's a wonderful, sweet man who listens and is very proactive in helping you solve whatever problems you're having.  I wish all doctors were like him.  I have to fight and struggle with too many doctors to just listen to me and what I live with, day in and day out.  He's not like that.  Good luck to you.     There are recommendations on this thread too:  
    • I never worried about cross contamination because i was originally told i was just intolerant. after going gluten free i felt so much better up until this last march. dairy and fructose have been giving me problems but both lactose and fructose test came back negative.  this is what my gi doctor emailed me today 
    • Any place you know of to find more info? Seems like I am still in so much pain/bloat, I am not even sure if I would pick the right 5 foods!
    • Don't freak out worrying about other maladies yet. You would be absolutely amazed at the things that can/will resolve on the gluten free diet. Some take longer than others -- neurological seem to take the longest for most people but really, I guarantee, there will be things you had no idea or expectation of resolving will. There were tons for me and then there were things I sort of "woke up one day" & said, "hey, that's gone and that & that & that". Other, larger things had taken my attention so I hadn't paid attention to the smaller things until...... On the other hand, not everything is related to celiac but I bet you wouldn't find a handful of celiacs who didn't say something very similar to what I said above. Yes, thyroid problems are common with celiac but I'll also tell you there are/have been people on here who were hypothyroid before dx but after being gluten-free for a while they actually went back to normal thyroid numbers. My husband is one (yes, we both are celiac - it happens). He was on synthroid for 20 years or more. Guess what? He's not on it anymore. We've had his thyroid panel done several times since about a year gluten-free & he is no longer hypothyroid. 
    • Yes please, that'd be awesome Having a fun time trying to reply on my phone due to broken screen but will be back on tomorrow after results of doctor appointment to get to the bottom of why they've given me seemingly wrong advice re: next steps. Yup I'll admit to pity, anger, frustration and outright fear, been through the mill of emotions in this first week that's for sure. One thing before I go for that; back when I was self-diagnosing I wanted a full thyroid panel (T3, T4 etc.) and also ESR & CRP checks for vasculitis and similar maladies. Now it seems from my reading they can often follow celiac so my worry level of those has gone up a notch, more blood tests ahoy it seems? Main reason for worrying about those is the nearly constant tight / tender head I have at the moment. Top and sides of scalp. Could be the stress tensing the shoulders and occipital muscles at back of head but after the celiac diagnosis being missed I'm fearful of anything else being missed. Did anyone else have this tight head feeling at the start? Feels like the skin is being pulled inwards, sometimes goes down for a few minutes here and there and gets worse when sitting I think. I see the term "brain fog" a lot but luckily don't seem to have too much of that at present, this is more a physical sensation.
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,656
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    bentcreekmom
    Joined