Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Positive Home Test, Negative Lab Test - Manufacturer's Response
0

6 posts in this topic

Hello Everyone,

A few weeks ago I received a positive result from a Biocard home celiac test. I then received a negative lab result (they only ran one test). I emailed the company to ask them about the different results. This is the response I received:

In clinical studies in the EU where the Biocard has been used and there has been a discrepancy between the equivalent Elisa lab test and the Biocard (Biocard “+” and Labe “-“), over time the “-“ lab tests become “+”. This has been explained by the sensitivity, specificity and cut-off limit of the Biocard relative to lab testing. The cutoff for the Biocard is 5u (international units). Many laboratory tests are between 10 and 20u.

So should I wait to see if I eventually get a positive blood test? Will my doctor even consider retesting? Should I just go ahead and try a gluten free diet?

I have an appointment with a Naturopathic Doctor next week. I'll see what she has to say.

Thanks for listening.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

What was the one test your doctor ordered? The doctor really should have done a full panel. Can you see if you can get the doctor to order a full panel or perhaps the naturopathic doctor could order it?

If you can you should wait until all celiac related testing is done to start the diet. However if your doctor won't order more testing for you then you really don't need a doctor's permission to go gluten free. Just make sure you are strict with the diet when you do your trial. Being gluten free will not impact testing for any other issues you might have.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What was the one test your doctor ordered? The doctor really should have done a full panel. Can you see if you can get the doctor to order a full panel or perhaps the naturopathic doctor could order it?

If you can you should wait until all celiac related testing is done to start the diet. However if your doctor won't order more testing for you then you really don't need a doctor's permission to go gluten free. Just make sure you are strict with the diet when you do your trial. Being gluten free will not impact testing for any other issues you might have.

The only tests that I had were Tissue Transgluaminase Iga and Immunoglobulin A. I was under the impression that they were going to do the whole panel. Apparently the labs here in Calgary only run the other tests if the TTg Iga come back positive. This really does not make sense to me! I would think that they would especially run the other tests if the first was negative.

Thanks for your advice!

I will see if the Naturopathic doctor says.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In clinical studies in the EU where the Biocard has been used and there has been a discrepancy between the equivalent Elisa lab test and the Biocard (Biocard “+” and Labe “-“), over time the “-“ lab tests become “+”. This has been explained by the sensitivity, specificity and cut-off limit of the Biocard relative to lab testing. The cutoff for the Biocard is 5u (international units). Many laboratory tests are between 10 and 20u.

That response does not make sense. Each machine has different methods, even the ELISA based tests will vary from lab to lab. Each lab will come up with appropriate negative values based on several factors. It is important to remember that if a normal test is under 30 and you have a reading of 25 it is not because you have some antibodies, it is against dilutions and any number below the limit means a negative reading upon first dilution.

I for example tested 30 on a test were below 35 is negative for TPO ab's. I went to another lab that uses a cutoff value of 25 and my value came back at 14. It is all relevant to the labs specific tests and methods used.

If I were you I would ask for the research supporting their hypothesis, you have to remember they are a business and will say whatever they legally can to get your repeat patronage.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello Everyone,

A few weeks ago I received a positive result from a Biocard home celiac test. I then received a negative lab result (they only ran one test). I emailed the company to ask them about the different results. This is the response I received:

In clinical studies in the EU where the Biocard has been used and there has been a discrepancy between the equivalent Elisa lab test and the Biocard (Biocard “+” and Labe “-“), over time the “-“ lab tests become “+”. This has been explained by the sensitivity, specificity and cut-off limit of the Biocard relative to lab testing. The cutoff for the Biocard is 5u (international units). Many laboratory tests are between 10 and 20u.

So should I wait to see if I eventually get a positive blood test? Will my doctor even consider retesting? Should I just go ahead and try a gluten free diet?

I have an appointment with a Naturopathic Doctor next week. I'll see what she has to say.

Thanks for listening.

If I understand that statement correctly, Biocard is saying that they have a lower sensitivity levels so their test will read positive at a lower level of ttg Iga in the blood. I suppose that makes sense... you had a really low ttg Iga through Calgary labs though, didn't you? My guess is that CLS tested wrong somehow. Since they are currently being investigated for messing up hundreds of labs (I didn't hear all the details of what they did wrong) it doesn't seem so far fetched.

I just don't know how the Biocard test could come up positive unless ttg Iga was there in a measurable amount. :huh: I really wonder if ttg iga levels can wax and wane based on how overactive our immune system is at the time. I know this happens with other autoimmune disorders so it would make sense if it did with celiac too...but I have no info to back that theory.

I hope the naturopath can help you with some answers. If you can't get a definitive answer, I guess you have two options:

1. Contune to eat gluten and test periodically. This gives you the benefit of possibly getting a positive quantifiable test result but if you do have issues with gluten, you'll have to continue to live with the symptoms it could be causing.

2. Go gluten free, which could relieve the symptoms but you will not test positive for celiac in the future.

At this point if I was you, I would continue eating gluten until the New Year (I remember you said going gluten-free would be tricky over the holidays) and then retest. Perhaps you could get the naturopath to order the ttg Igg and the DGP IgA and IgG for you on top of the ttg IgA; or maybe you could order some labs through the mail... I have no idea if that's done up here like it is in the states. After this final try of testing, I would then go gluten-free for a minumium of 3 months; 6 would be better. See if it helps. Cut out dairy too if you think it's an issue; if a glass of milk on am empty stomach bothers you (like it did me) then I would cut it out too.

I really hope that naturopath can help you out. I know how frustrated you are by this. (hug) Let me know what the nauropath says, okay?

Best wishes to you.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Wow this is me! I did two biocard tests and both came back positive. I had blood work done and got the negative results yesterday. Only one test was completed, Anti Transglutaminase and it was negative. I'm up in Edmonton. Keep me updated if you can on your results :D

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,698
    • Total Posts
      921,787
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • When it's that high, it almost always means Celiac.  Sure, you can have Crohns, too.  Just like you can have Celiac and diabetes, the common cold or a hang nail.  I wouldn't jump to Chrohns.  I don't think the tTg really has anything to do with Chrohns?  Where did you see that?  Sometimes, a slightly elevate tTg can be elevated from other issues, but >100 is not a " slightly elevated" reading
    • Hi! I'm new here, and I'm looking for some information because I'm having a hard time finding it.  Over Labor Day weekend I got some kind of intestinal bug. I didn't think much of it until the D persisted once a day up til now. I tried a priobiotic but that didn't help much. I have bad anxiety and began to think that I was just anxious and stressed. No fever, no pain, all bloodwork is normal, so no infection or anemia. My mother has 5 siblings and 3 have celiac. One other one had a high result on a blood test but was never officially diagnosed and insists she doesn't have it. So I went to my local health fair and got the ttg-iga test, just in case. My result came back at >100. So I have called and scheduled a visit with a GI for next week. Aside from the recent intestinal issues I have never thought that I had any signs of celiac. I do have dermatographism and have had that since I was 20 (I am 28). I have severe anxiety. I had PUPPPS when I was pregnant with my daughter and it was miserable. It looks much like the skin rashes that celiacs have. Again, didn't think much of it. Because of my anxiety I am terrified that this high blood test is from something else, like crohn's. I don't have diabetes, my liver and thyroid numbers are fine. I think it's much more plausible that this is celiac because of my family history. But my anxiety says "what if it's crohns?" Does anyone have any insight? Is it true that the ttg iga can be elevated from crohns and not celiac? Is >100 pretty definitive of celiac? I didn't know if crohns was the cause if the number would be this high.  I'm just freaked out. 
    • This does say it is for NCGS....so not  for Celiacs.  There is a drug being developed that may actually break down the gluten in the stomach before it hits the intestines.  However, that is still in clinical trials.
    • could be from your neck, or it is, literally, in your head. perhaps a scan is needed.
    • The anxiety thing is there I take teas, and supplements along with CBD oil to help with it, and long walks and exercise when I get antsy. As for the human interaction it is a mix of other mental issues, and the way I feel about people who can eat gluten. If they are not eating I have no issue talking with people. I mentioned I have issues accepting them as the same species when I see them eating. My reaction to gluten is so ingrained in me that it is not a food but a poison, that watching others eat it causes a subconscious reaction where I find myself avoiding them and looking down on them like something from another planet. I end up disgusted with them and walking away, I will go out of my way to avoid people and places where foods like this are present. This is my TRAUMA part of the gluten exposure, and one of the big things I am trying to address in my life right now. I know it is irrational to do so but I end up doing it, I have never cared about others race, religion, or looks, but if I see them eating a gluten/poison, it somehow changes how I perceive them and interact with them and I hate this part about me. It is taking a lot of mental effort to try to smile and treat them as a human, and not something to be looked down upon in disgust. I just recall that mental state that gluten puts me in with my mind and body turning against me and not doing what I will it and the fear comes back. This diet is pretty much like mine, I take Doctors best Magnesium powder in a tea that is actually brewed with st johns wort (never thought much of it) , I use Liquid Health Stress & Energy along with the Neurologic Support they have, twice-three times a day for B vitamins(along with a bunch of other supplements) . I can not digest meats or carbs well, meats it is a issue with breaking them down same with egg yolks, I literally just burp up the undigested meats hours later. I have found the only way to eat them is to boil/slow cook them til they melt then blend them into a broth and have it with digestive enzymes so only do it with turkey bacon, longhorn, and salmon in small amounts in soups or for flavoring stock for stir frys.  As for Carbs like rice and potatoes I end up getting really gassy and bloated, same with sugars in any amount greater then like the size of my thumb give or take. Oats I only have gluten-free Harvest in about a tbsp amount when tasting recipes of stuff I sell at farmers markets. So I eat mostly fats and protein from egg whites, nuts, seeds, veggies, and vegan protein powders blends balanced for complete proteins. I have at least 1-2 dried fig, dates, handful of banana chips, or a 1/4 of a small fruit with meals for fruits.  My meals are mostly egg white and veggie omelettes, stir frys, and soups, Always with lots of fats and proteins in each meal. I have found having nutritional yeast to help with my mood and energy levels also and find someway of having it in meals often. I keep my foods on rotation and keep getting updated feed back on ratios with my dietician. I also have a rather odd list of foods I can not eat due to allergies/intolerance.
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,704
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    Fbmb
    Joined