Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Gluten-Free 4 Yrs, Contradictory Test Results
0

11 posts in this topic

Hi, I am new here, but thought you all might have some insight.

My great grandfather died of Sprue. I have 2 cousins who react to gluten. I have been having problems for years and 4 yrs ago a friend suggested removing gluten from my diet. I felt better, and have become quite vigilant about remaining gluten free and mostly dairy and soy free.

I was dxed with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (thyroidectomy), gall bladder quit (and was removed), IBS (was perscribed Librax), GERD (told to take Nexium), migraines (prescribed Zomig), arthritis (told to take ibuprofen), chronic sinus infections (given claritin)... early menopause (was given estrogen)... and have been trying to keep positive.... sooo... last year I changed to a new primary care physician, and he has been working his way through my body systems... sending me to all kinds of specialists. Most recently, I have been to a GI doctor... had a colonoscopy and endoscopy and the blood test that checks for gluten antibodies.

I asked the GI doctor if me being gluten free for a few years would affect the blood test... he said "No, almost no one is truly gluten free unless they are working closely with a nutrionist" so, hey, I didn't worry.

Test results? Probably not IBS... was told to wean off the Librax... he found very inflamed innards... pathology showed no crohn's diease, not colitis... but DID show partial villous atrophy. Blood test was negative... soooo... he had me have more blood taken to do the test to check for the chromosomal markers for celiac disease. hmmmmm... said not having the marker(s) would rule out celiac.

Test results may come back next week... the local hospital was not sure how to run the test, so it was to be sent to Mayo's I think.

I am unsure about all this. I DO feel better without gluten and dairy... and have always suspected corn to be an irritant... could the first blood test for the anitbodies have been a false negative? He seemed surprised to find the villous atrophy after the negative blood test.

Sigh.

Any insight would sure be appreciated!

Thanks ever so much!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

...

I asked the GI doctor if me being gluten free for a few years would affect the blood test... he said "No, almost no one is truly gluten free unless they are working closely with a nutrionist" ...

...

AAAAARGH! That's SO ridiculous he must have almost no experience w/ celiac patients. The antibody tests need the gluten.

(He might really think that 'in theory' the antibody tests are affected, but that no one's gluten-free so it doesn't matter? Either way a horrible point of view for a practicing GI.

"Unless working closely w/ a nutritionist" makes him sound like he thinks all foods are a mystery. Most ingredients are gluten-free - it can be a shock at 1st to have to pay attn to it all, but 100% gluten-free is not at all impossible.

... ... could the first blood test for the anitbodies have been a false negative?

It's not even that imho. An antibody test is invalid when done after that long gluten-free. An actual false neg requires a valid test.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, it's a little goofy for him to be turning to the murky world of celiac genetics when you have villous atrophy AND a positive response to gluten-free.

Imho, every good GI would dx you on these, unless they have some other explanation for the villous atrophy.

Just shaking my head at that Dr's failed attempt at the blood test & warped view of the gluten-free diet.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First off your GI is pretty ignorant about celiac. The fact you still have villi that are impacted may mean that you have not been as gluten free as you thought you were being. If you are sharing things like toasters, butter, nut butters, condiments, a shared colander, baking with gluten flours for others, eating in restaurants that don't have gluten-free menus etc you may still be getting enough gluten to keep the villi damage going.

Don't rely on the gene tests to rule out celiac as there are more than the two genes that most doctors look for associated with celiac. There are also some rare conditions that can also cause villi damage so do make sure your doctor rules those out. The fact that you improved a great deal gluten free is good and an indication that you do need the diet. You continued issues could be a result of cross contamination. Do make sure you also check all your medications, both OTC and script for gluten and read as much here as you can to learn what you need to do to keep yourself safe. Ask any more questions needed.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ask for a SIBO test. It's a bacterial overgrowth that can damage villi. It can mimick Celiac. As far as the blood tests..it's rediculous to say that you are probably still eating gluten because you can't avoid it.

Also..be aware that most Dr.s agree that you have to have DQ2 or DQ8 to be Celiac. They dismiss anything that doesn't fit as not Celiac. I'm one who has DQ2.2..and had total villous flattening when DXed. Two different GIs did scopes and the biopsies said Celiac. Then they did the gene test and said they weren't so sure. It's ridiculous!

Get the SIBO test to see if it could be the cause of the villi blunting. AND..I'm banging the drum now for no GMOs. Corn, soy, canola, cottonseed, sugar beets, papaya, and zucchini and summer squash are all suspect. They have been genetically modified to produce insecticide which doesn't break down and can be released into our systems.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Thanks for the comments :) I had not previously heard of SIBO... that is a good idea... also, I am reading all I can to learn more so when I go in again I can ask better questions. I knew you folks would help :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

got my test results back today. I have the DQ8 marker... so can't rule out celiac... he didn't really say I have celiac disease, but wants me to go see a registered dietician to follow a gluten free diet... I explained again that I have been gluten free for 4 years and have been very scrupulous (as much as I can be) for 2 years... he told me to humor him, to see the dietician and then come see him in a few weeks. He said if the dietician agrees that I am doing what I need to do, that is great, but I don't think he realizes that I have been sooooo careful. I feel as though my problems have just been handed off to someone else. ah well... at least I am now officially supposed to be gluten free and can tell my family as much :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Going against what others are saying I think you have a good GI, he is not jumping to the conclusion of celiacs until all else is ruled out and getting you properly diagnosed and treated with a nutritionist shows that he cares. Be happy you have someone who is very thorough and is not just handing you a celiac pamphlet and saying get the hell out. At least after all this you can be assured of whatever it is you have.

This is an interesting article on a rare case:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9672361

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Going against what others are saying I think you have a good GI,

...

Are we reading the same story? The Dr who said the blood/antibodies test will work fine despite 4 yrs gluten-free?

That's an ignorant Dr.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are we reading the same story? The Dr who said the blood/antibodies test will work fine despite 4 yrs gluten-free?

That's an ignorant Dr.

I was looking at the whole picture and not every word that came out of his mouth. My only direction is that you can have more than one issue going on at the same time and at least this doctor is taking his time to look into everything.

Unfortunately not everything that comes out of a doctors mouth is always accurate, but this one seems to at least be trying to find the cause.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

interesting abstract, thanks! Fortunately, they did not find any evidence of crohn's in the pathology report.

it is interesting to me that his first impressions, based on what he saw during the endoscopy and colonoscopy changed dramatically when my pathology report showed villous atrophy. I am glad that that at least now I can say that a doctor has told me I should follow a gluten-free diet... and he does want to make sure I am doing it well and completely... and he does want to see me in a few weeks after I have had time with the dietician... it just frustrated me a little to feel like I was being pushed off onto the dietician and that he really didn't believe that I have been as careful as I think I am being... and maybe he is right... maybe I am being exposed somehow... I do have the damage in there. I just hope we can figure out how to fix it so everything can heal. I worry about not absorbing vitamins and minerals and medicines properly.

But I kinda want to smack him in the head with the blood report I just picked up from his office which says in big all cap pletters that the results of the antigen test would be affected by previous non-gluten diet.

ah well... next hoop... I will jump... I just want to figure it all out. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      103,880
    • Total Posts
      919,455
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Depression / anxiety issues
      Thanks for the advice Irene. I will look into that book. I know I'm a long away from healed but I got my hopes up when I felt better in that first week, it's just constantly a battle. I am hoping and praying that I get better soon 
    • Celiac - How many symptoms can there be?
      Do you take digestive enzymes and probiotics? That may help. Have you met with a dietician for help figuring out how you're getting glutened?
    • Depression / anxiety issues
      You should read the book' Jennifer's Way" you might find her story similar.  You will find better health- but be patient- it's an up and down road and takes a long time! For me it's been 7-8 months and I'm not well but slowly improving I hope
    • Celiac - How many symptoms can there be?
      Hi Everyone I am new here and wanted to see if anyone else is experiencing the same thing I am.  I was diagnosed positive for celiac in 2/2016 via biopsy from an endoscopy.  I was negative for blood work because I self-eliminated gluten 9 months prior; so I guess I had not antibodies register in my lab work.  Prior to 2/2016 I was having symptoms for almost an entire year.  Despite cutting out grains in general for 9 months, I would have a gluten attack at least once a month.  I have had a history of sinus, bronchial infection.  I remember as young as 17 getting sick but I always bounced back and was active in sports and working out.  But in the past year I developed the following symptoms - Sudden desire to pass out, nausea, headaches, heart palpitation, crashing exhaustion as if I was recuperating from the flu, wheezing in my chest. I was bounced around to an allergist at this and was told I was asthmatic and I had food sensitivities to dairy, nuts, corn or corn derivatives (including corn syrup) and grains.  so I cut everything out!  Despite cutting everything out I was still have episodes at least monthly, possibly cross contamination.  In April 2015 I traveled to the Carribean for 2 weeks,  I became very ill with a urinary tract infection, stomach bug and severe back pain with constant fever.  I was treated with antibiotics (Bactrim) for 10 days which did clear up the situation. I came home and dismissed everything to a coincidence.  Six weeks later the GI distress woke me up in the middle of night.  The pain was so excruciating that when I sat on the toilet thinking I had to go, I almost past out from the pain.  I lay myself down on the floor until it subsided.  The next day I contacted my primary and was immediately seen.  She referred me to a GI specialist but the appointment was not until August.  Then 2 weeks before my GI appointment they called and rescheduled for late September.  I saw him and by then I was feeling better; no epsides for almost 2 months.  So we did nothing.... boy did I talk to soon.  Immediately after the appointment I had an attack.  These were the symptoms: Nausea, crashing fatigue (as if I was hit with the flu), diarrhea, dizziness,, loss of appetite,  lower back pain, specifically in the middle; intestinal discomfort and body aches which lasted 10 days!! and abruptly disappeared, thank God.
      . I had to wait to see the GI until 1/2016.  Once I saw him he did labs which were all normal.  He checked my liver, kidney, pancreas, blood count which was all normal.  He also scheduled the endo/colonoscopy for end of 1/2016.  Speeding forward in time....since the Endo/Colonscopy procedures, I had attacks January through March which last 7-10 days each time.  I finally had a break for 2 months and today as I type this I am on day 6 of another episode.  What I wanted to see if anyone has experience the following.  For me each episode is getting worse with the following symptoms: Nausea (horrible), back pain on the left side both in the rib cage (the front and back) at times this pain also gravitates toward my left hip.  I also get diarrhea, bloating, intestinal distress, crashing fatigue and loss of appetite.  What really hits me hard is the rib cage pain that is in the front and back on my left side.  I will be seeing the GI doctor in August; but I am hoping to see him sooner Any input in reference to symptoms is appreciated.    
    • Depression / anxiety issues
      Hi all  10 weeks ago i was diganoised with celiac with blood work and a endoscopy. I have had the worst 2 years of my life that started with blood being in my stool everyday. I have always suffered with anxiety for as long as I can remember but I always just pushed trough it. I then I started having panic attacks, insomnia and major depression that I could not handle, I could not function, I lost my job because I could not leave my bed, I shaked as I lay in bed everyday uncontrollably. I met with a doctor who put me on lexapro (antidepressant) I finally gave in after 6 months and started taking them, they made me worst than I already was so I had to stop after 14 weeks. Fast forward to 15 months later and the symptoms still persists including the bloody stools, I was in and out of hospital every week and told I had all sorts of conditions, then the blood work and endoscopy Finaly discovered the celiac. I have been on the diet now for 10 weeks, the first week my anxiety went away, the horrible knot in my stomach that I have had everyday, the hot flushes, the tingling I had run trough my legs. This all left but only for a couple of days then it came back, the depression also lifted but has now came back, I have been more than strict with the diet, I check everything twice before I eat it, me and the misses have thrown away everything from our kitchen and replaced it with new things. I had my Vitiam levels checked and I'm deficient in b12, Vit D, all B vitiams. It's like one step Foward 2 steps back in tearms of healing, I know these anxiety / depression feelings are not me but I've had them for so long that I can't seem to see light at the end of the tunnel. The couple of days that they left me when incredible I felt human and alive. Just wondering if any of this has happened to anyone else with celiac or gluten intorlance. Any advice or hope In tearms of healing or am I to feel like this for the rest of my life (I'm 28) by the way. Thanks a lot   
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

    • Jmg  »  admin

      Hello Admin!
      I don't know whether this is of interest to post on your articles feed:
      http://pratt.duke.edu/about/news/window-guts-brain
      Kind Regards,
      Matt
      · 2 replies
    • celiac sharon  »  cyclinglady

      Hello cycling lady, have you noticed my picture is showing up as you?  Have no idea why but it's rather disconcerting to see my picture and your words 😉  Do you know how to fix it?  You seem to have far more experience with this board than I do
      · 1 reply
    • Larry Gessner  »  cyclinglady

      Hi There, I don't know if there is a place for videos in the forum. I just watched "The Truth About Gluten" I think it is a good video. I would like to share it somewhere but don't know where it should go. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
      Here is the link if you have never watched it.
      https://youtu.be/IU6jVEwpjnE Thank You,
      Larry
      · 2 replies
  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      60,924
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    sealy-yak
    Joined