Get email alerts Get Celiac.com E-mail Alerts  




Celiac.com Sponsor:
Celiac.com Sponsor:




Ads by Google:






   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts

Celiac Disease: New Hope For A Pill Treatment? - Webmd
0

2 posts in this topic

Celiac Disease: New Hope for a Pill Treatment?

WebMD

FRIDAY, Feb. 8 (HealthDay News) -- For people with celiac disease, everyday foods such as bread, pizza crust and muffins are potential enemies. But scientists anticipate that some day a simple pill could help prevent the digestive upsets caused by ...

15th International Celiac Disease Symposium will unveil new research, dispel ... Phys.Org (press release)

Cutting out gluten is not for everyone Medill Reports: Chicago

all 3 news articles »

View the full article

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:

When I click on the above link here http://news.medill.n....aspx?id=215364

I get this: "Cutting Out Gluten is Not for Everyone" from the Medill School at Northwestern University

Experts, however, caution that it is not a healthier diet for those who do not medically need it.

“It is absolutely not healthier,” said Carol Shilson, executive director of the University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center. “In most cases, it is a deficiency of nutrients.”

Many gluten-free substitute foods are not fortified. For example, whole grains can be fortified with calcium and vitamins, whereas gluten-free foods cannot. Also, many of the gluten-free substitutes are higher in fat, sugar and calories. Instead of a weight-loss mechanism, people end up with a diet low in iron, zinc and B vitamins, Shilson said.

“There is no scientific proof that a gluten-free diet is healthy for people without medical cause,” Shilson said. “There is actually proof of the opposite.”

bolding mine.

Do you ever read something erroneous in the media which gets quoted again and again, and wonder where the original source is ?

Gluten free foods can't be fortified ?!!! :o

Here is Carol Shilson's biography from that website (scroll down). Staff Bios - http://www.curecelia...-are/staff-bios

Is anyone else here feeling appalled that the Executive Director, Shilson, of the "University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center," a non profit which runs on donations, with a VERY similar name to the actual Medical Hospital, "University of Chicago Medical Center," is pushing the "Gluten Free Diet Is Unhealthy" meme to the media ?

What happens if the celiac children read it ? Will they then feel justified in blowing off their medically necessary diet ?

Now look at this link from the same "cure celiac disease.org" which is the site of the University of Chicago Celiac Disease Center

http://www.curecelia...luten-free-diet

Why do I need a cure when I can simply eat a gluten free diet ?"

Why do I need a cure when I can simply eat a gluten-free diet?

A gluten-free diet is only a treatment for celiac disease. There are many reasons to find a cure:

  • Fails to heal intestinal damage in more than half of cases
  • Failure increases cancers and osteoporosis.
  • Food labels are complicated.
  • It’s difficult to eat totally gluten-free, 1/100th of slice of bread is toxic.
  • Acute food poisoning can occur after gluten exposure.
  • Gluten-free food is expensive.
  • A “fear of food” remains.
  • Processed gluten-free products are often high in fats and low in fiber.

It ain't the FOOD I'm afraid of, at this point. With "advocates" like this.... The Medill article also quotes a "Licensed Dietician and Nutritionist" named Judy Manisco, who says the gluten free diet must be "compensated with supplementation" and she means.... fiber supplements. Because the gluten free diet does not have enough fiber. Where do they FIND these people to make such CRAZY, ill - informed statements ?

The Nutritionist's Directory. Illinois, Cook County, Chicago

http://nutritionists...Illinois_529409

Judy E. Manisco, LDN, About, voted one of the "Best Nutritionist and Weight Loss Programs" in City Search - Chicago 2010, and is a frequent guest host on Health Radio, WYLL - Chicago.

Is this non profit organization, Univ of Chi Disease Center, which operates in tandem with the University of Chicago's Dr. Stefano Guandalini (who is the host medical center on that world Celiac Disease Symposium in Chicago later this year) REALLY claiming that a gluten free diet "fails to heal intestinal damage in more than half of cases ?! While its Executive director is giving media quotes claiming the diet is unhealthier, and even HARMFUL to both celiacs and normal people ?! While a Chicago Licensed Nutritionist tells us we all need fiber supplements ?!

Do you remember what the so-called "proof" of the "opposite" was, since the source was not cited ? Was it the bogus study by the "doctor" who turned out to be a PhD of exercise (not a medical doctor) at the University of Arizona, which in turn was paid for by.... THE WHEAT LOBBY ?

Remember when the "Wheat Belly" guy was recently catching all the flack for criticizing Dr. Guandalini ? Maybe he deserves an apology. What he's claiming doesn't really sound any crazier than the stuff I have just found. We (gluten free eaters of the world) do our best to remove the trigger of our physical reactions- gluten. They ("The Experts in Chicago") tell us this is harmful ?!

I think I'm starting to comprehend why he took that tactic ! There are other medical researchers studying athletes responding to a Paleo diet (that's a grain free one) are claiming that all humans react somewhat negatively to wheat family grains, there are just degrees of sensitivity to it, from almost no reaction, to gluten intolerance, to full blown celiac disease. Here is the Univ of Chicago spokesperson claiming the lack of wheat is dangerous. It seems to be implied that restoring a celiac to a wheat containing diet is a health benefit. :ph34r:

Wait.... half of them supposedly don't respond to a gluten free diet to the point of full healing? So the goal is to get them eating wheat again ?

Would some one, any one, get these people a course in logic and deduction, STAT ?! :blink:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      104,352
    • Total Posts
      920,503
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I already did. Thats how i found the place. Its amazing to actually go to a restraunt again.
    • This is EXACTLY what happens to me. It has twice now and both times was after both glutening episodes but once it was the day after and the other time it was a week and a half. So I'm still not sure if it's related or strange bug bites...

      Did they stop happening when she stopped being glutened? Did you decide they were definitely related? I'm really confused by this and would love to know whether to insecticide my house or....
    • Thankyou both! I was wondering if my high levels left much doubt on the diagnosis. I don't see the GI until the 15th Sep and I don't think I can stand to eat gluten in that time. If he tells me to I will do so after then. After 25 years of symptoms I don't think there is much chance of healing my bowel In a couple of weeks. I'm actually terrified of the damage they might find. But I think I will need the endo since there may be other things going on with me. So great they didn't put your son through the biopsy! Once I have a formal diagnosis I have my kids to worry about also. I can't even stand the thought of my daughter having a blood test. I think she would need to be sedated as she is so fearful and pain sensitive. My son is not yet 2 so I don't think they will test him. I'm feeling so off at the moment. I think I have some anxiety and reflux going on complicating things quite a bit.
    • My son's antibodies were 300. Based on his extremely high levels, his pediatric GI suggested genetic testing instead of the biopsy. Genetic testing can't diagnose celiac on its own but combined with such high levels, the gi dr was confident a positive genetic test would confidently diagnose celiac. He warned that biopsies are small snapshots of the intestine and can miss damage. He said this is an approach used very often in Europe but not as much in the US. What sold me on that approach was the ability to put my son directly on a gluten free diet instead of waiting three weeks for the biopsy, during which time he would continue to eat gluten and feel terrible. I'm not sure if this is more common with younger patients though (our son is two), based on the idea that he's had less time to inflict damage that would show in a biopsy? We are very happy that we immediately started the gluten free diet and chose the genetic testing. Our son got the proper diagnosis and his recent number shows a drop to 71 after only 4.5 months gluten free! Not sure if this helps. Good luck and I hope you feel better soon!
    • We have been off gluten for a while now, and symptoms return when I've allowed gluten full meals… so something still isn't sitting right with me.  Checking with her doc about seeing a pediactric GI although I'm not sure how long that will take since we live in small town America. I know she didn't get at least one of the recommended full panel tests but maybe two, can someone help clarify, or is she missing two? DGP for sure and possibly EMA? And if I understand what I'm reading in other posts that the DGP can be more accurate? Thanks Her blood panel results: Ttg ab iga <.5u/ml ttg igg <.8u/ml aga ab iga <.2 u/ml aga an igg <.7u/ml iga 61mg/dL  
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      61,416
    • Most Online
      1,763

    Newest Member
    djs2117
    Joined