Jump to content



Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-m):


  • You've found your Celiac Tribe! Join our like-minded, private community and share your story, get encouragement and connect with others.

    💬

    • Sign In
    • Sign Up
  • Dr. Vikki Petersen D.C, C.C.N
    Dr. Vikki Petersen D.C, C.C.N

    CNN Gets it Wrong: You Can’t Cheat if You’re Gluten Sensitive

    Reviewed and edited by a celiac disease expert.

    Journal of Gluten Sensitivity Summer 2011 Issue. NOTE: This article is from a back issue of our popular subscription-only paper newsletter. Some content may be outdated.

    CNN Gets it Wrong: You Can’t Cheat if You’re Gluten Sensitive - Image: CC--Colin Bugella
    Caption: Image: CC--Colin Bugella

    Celiac.com 12/08/2018 - Recently CNN published an article entitled “Will a Gluten Free Diet Improve Your Health?” Honestly there were a lot of plus-points to this article. But unfortunately the negatives could very well outweigh them if you’re considering, or are new to, the gluten-free diet.

    Let’s review the positives and negatives as they appear in the article:
    1. Dr Leffler from Harvard Medical School was quoted as saying that: “Gluten is fairly indigestible in all people.” “There’s probably some kind of gluten intolerance in all of us.” 



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A12):






    Celiac.com Sponsor (A12-m):




    Bravo! I was very excited to read this remark.  Although I often promote this information, I haven’t heard it from others aside from Dr. Fasano. The fact that humans can’t properly digest gluten is an important truth that should be better known and more widely taught. 

    2. Experts now believe that celiac disease represents just one extreme of a broad spectrum of gluten intolerance that includes millions of people.

    It can sometimes be interesting when unnamed “experts” are quoted, but in this case I agree. I’ve often written about my belief that celiac disease to gluten sensitivity is likely one spectrum. The fact that those with gluten sensitivity don’t undergo the outright destruction of the small intestine as in the case of celiac disease, in no way puts gluten sensitivity in a less serious category. It’s a “different” reaction but no less serious.

    3. They go on to state that people with celiac disease and gluten sensitivity usually have stomach aches, gas, and diarrhea -- as do people with IBS. 
    “Usually” is not the case and it would give someone without digestive complaints a false sense that they do not have gluten intolerance. In fact, according to research, for every person with celiac disease who experiences digestive symptoms, there are eight without digestive complaints. 

    This is why, all too often, people continue to live with migraines, depression, infertility, skin problems, obesity and autoimmune disease that is gluten related but the gluten connection remains undiagnosed because they have no digestive complaints. 
    Let’s not kid ourselves. We’re only diagnosing, at best, seven percent of the celiacs in our country. In our medically advanced society, missing over ninety percent of those suffering with the most common lifelong disorder in the US and Europe, is beyond pitiful. 

    Unfortunately, it is statements such as the above, limiting our focus to digestive complaints that are partly to blame for our poor rate of diagnosis.

    4. Gluten sensitivity, on the other hand, is a gray area that “lacks any defining medical tests,” Leffler says. People who fall into this group exhibit the classic symptoms of celiac disease yet have no detectable intestinal damage, and test negative for certain key antibodies (though in some cases they may have elevated levels of others).

    The issue here might be “medical tests” and Dr. Leffler may not know about the gluten sensitivity tests that are available. However, they are available and they have recently taken a nice jump in sensitivity due to a new lab in the US (Cyrex Labs – again, I have no affiliation with this lab).
    I also take umbrage to the reference to the lab tests as almost an afterthought in parentheses. The truth lies within those parentheses – gluten sensitive individuals do show elevation of key antibodies that are different than those seen in celiac disease. 
    Does that make those elevations somehow less important?  Of course not! They are just different.

    5. “A recent study by Fasano and his colleagues offers some clues about what gluten sensitivity is, and how it differs from celiac disease. Although they show no signs of erosion or other damage, the study found, the intestines of gluten-sensitive patients contain proteins that contribute to a harmful immune response, one that resembles -- but is distinct from -- the process underlying celiac disease. “

    This is a very good point. First, Dr Fasano is spending his time researching gluten sensitivity. This is not something we would have seen several years ago. 

    His latest research showed that the immune system DOES create a harmful immune response in the intestines of those suffering from gluten sensitivity. Is it the same response as that seen in celiacs? No. But we didn’t expect that it would be. We know that small intestinal erosion doesn’t happen in the gluten sensitive patient.

    What’s earth shattering about this research finding is that it completely validates what I and other clinicians like me have been saying for several years – gluten sensitivity is the adverse effect of the body’s immune system having a deleterious reaction to gluten. This research proves that point.

    6. “Recommendations for people with gluten sensitivity aren’t as clear-cut. Unlike celiac disease, gluten sensitivity hasn’t been linked to intestine damage and long-term health problems, so some experts say that people on the less severe end of the spectrum should feel comfortable eating as much gluten as they can handle without feeling sick.”

    Ah, so easy to write, so hard to take back or explain. This is a dangerous couple of sentences. Let’s dissect: They join “intestine damage” with “long-term health problems” as if it were impossible to have a long-term health problem without intestinal damage. Nothing could be further from the truth!

    I have many, many patients with gluten sensitivity, and therefore none of the intestinal destruction seen with celiac disease, who would beg to differ as regards long-term health problems being associated with gluten sensitivity, not just celiac disease. These patients have seen their serious long-term health problems resolve as a result of eliminating gluten from their diet. And they did not have celiac disease.

     Is schizophrenia a health problem? What about migraines?  How about eczema? Is infertility a health problem when you’re trying to get pregnant? What about depression?  

    I could go on and on.  And it’s not just my opinion or my patients’ opinions. This is very well substantiated by research. You cannot “feel” damage and inflammation to certain organs of your body. In fact, autoimmune disease markers can be present for well over a decade before the first symptoms show themselves. Should we wait?  Is that smart?

    Let’s continue: In the last sentence of point #6 above, we come across those unnamed “experts” I was referring to earlier. I would really like to know names on this one. Perhaps they were misquoted, or misunderstood. The truth of the matter is that gluten is not called the “great masquerader” because it creates overt symptoms all the time, quite the contrary. That is why one never is quite sure what symptoms will improve until one actually embarks on a gluten-free diet.  In fact it was this realization that caused us to write the book “The Gluten Effect” two years ago. There was little appreciation at that time of all the effects that gluten could create in the non-celiac individual, which is why we were compelled to share our experiences.

    7. “Some people can be exquisitely sensitive and have to be as strict as people with celiac disease, while others can eat a pizza,” Fasano says. [he was referring to gluten sensitivity]

    You might imagine that a newly diagnosed individual might very well read this sentence and be keeping their fingers crossed that they might be one of the lucky ones who could eat the pizza. 

    I am a huge fan of Dr. Fasano’s and to give this quote the benefit of the doubt I’m going to give you my interpretation. I have patients who have gone out and eaten pizza and “felt fine”. In fact they seemed to feel so “fine” that they did it again.  

    Did they ultimately end up fine? No, they did not. They found themselves days, weeks or months later quite ill, not only with old symptoms returning but often with new ones as well.

    What, then, could Dr. Fasano have meant by his comment? I believe that he was trying to make a point about the difference between a celiac and a person with gluten sensitivity. A celiac could have a miniscule amount of a crouton drop into their salad and be very ill almost immediately, while a person with gluten sensitivity would not necessarily have such an acute reaction. But to take that to mean that it is in some way “fine” or healthy for them to eat gluten is definitely not the case and I don’t believe that’s what Dr. Fasano meant.

    8. “If you suspect your body can’t tolerate gluten, the first thing you should do is get tested for celiac disease. If the test comes back negative, try a gluten-free diet for a week to see if you feel better, Leffler says.” 
    The cells in the intestine take about a month to turn over and renew themselves. A week on a gluten-free diet is not sufficient, in the main, to determine whether one has a problem. A month of absolutely no gluten is a more appropriate standard. With that said, some people do feel better almost immediately but I wouldn’t want to miss those who take several weeks to feel the change by not pointing out the 30 day recommendation.

    9. Finally, ending on an up note: “People with gluten sensitivity who don’t respond this way [meaning feeling ill immediately] aren’t necessarily in the clear, however. Experts like Marlisa Brown, a registered dietitian and author worry that gluten could have long-term negative consequences that just haven’t been identified yet.”

    As we’ve been discussing many of the consequences are known and they are serious. But I do agree with her that just because you don’t feel sick right away is no reason to eat gluten when you are sensitive to it.
    I hope this helps clarify this recent article and gives you and those you care about the support you need to continue your gluten-free lifestyle. It is worth it, I promise!

    References:

    1. www.CyrexLabs.com
    2. www.Enterolab.com
    3. Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics. 2009 Jun 15;29(12):1299-308. Epub   2009 Mar 3.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    As I have posted before, I was diagnosed in 2013 after severe anemia, which corrected itself when I went gluten free. I did not have the intestinal issues beyond IBS which I've had since I was 8; those did not correct with a gluten free diet.    I did not have eroded intestines, at the time the "gold standard."  But at least 5 times since then I have had violent vomiting reactions when I accidentally get glutened.  It shows up a few hours after eating.  I can link each episode to a specific food, and I do NOT get violently sick at other times.  

    So I agree completely that there is a spectrum.  Whether I would now be diagnosed as gluten sensitive or celiac, I don't know.  I certainly am not going to do a gluten challenge to check my intestines again.  I do know that a) I am no longer anemic and b) something has changed so gluten makes me actively sick. 
     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites


    Join the conversation

    You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • About Me

    Dr. Vikki Petersen D.C, C.C.N

    Dr. Vikki Petersen, a Chiropractor and Certified Clinical Nutritionist is co-founder and co-director, of the renowned HealthNow Medical Center in Sunnyvale, California. Acclaimed author of a new book, "The Gluten Effect" - celebrated by leading experts as an epic leap forward in gluten sensitivity diagnosis and treatment. Dr. Vikki is acknowledged as a pioneer in advances to identify and treat gluten sensitivity. The HealthNOW Medical Center uses a multi-disciplined approach to addressing complex health problems. It combines the best of internal medicine, clinical nutrition, chiropractic and physical therapy to identify the root cause of a patient's health condition and provide patient-specific wellness solutions. Her Web site is:
    www.healthnowmedical.com


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-m):




  • Related Articles

    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 02/11/2014 - More and more people are reporting gastrointestinal symptoms that improve when wheat and/or gluten are removed from the diet. There is a diverse group of people who avoid wheat and/or gluten (PWAWGs), and who predominantly self-diagnose prior to presenting for clinical evaluation for celiac disease.
    A team of researchers recently set out to compare patients who avoid wheat and/or gluten against patients with celiac disease, and with healthy control subjects. The research team included A. Tavakkoli, S.K. Lewis, C.A. Tennyson, B. Lebwohl, and P.H. Green, all with the Department of Medicine of the Celiac Disease Center at Columbia University in New York, NY.
    The team set out to characterize PWAWGs who were receiving treatment at a tertiary care referral center and to compare them to patients with celiac disease, and with subjects from the National Health and Nutrition examination survey (NHANES). The team conducted a cross-sectional study to evaluate patients seen by four gastroenterologists at a celiac disease referral center. They compared baseline characteristics, laboratory values, and medical comorbidities for these patients against results for celiac disease patients who presented at the same center, as well as for subjects enrolled in NHANES.
    The team compared results for eighty-four PWAWGs against results for 585 celiac disease patients and 2,686 NHANES patients. The found that doctors made a total of thirty-two alternative diagnoses in 25 PWAWGs (30%). Diagnoses included small intestinal bacterial overgrowth and fructose/lactose intolerance.
    When compared to patients with celiac patients, PWAWGs had similar body mass index (BMI, 23.1 vs. 23.5, p = 0.54) and mean hemoglobin value (13.4 vs. 13.3, p = 0.6). When compared to male and female patients in NHANES, PWAWGS showed lower BMI, folate, and mean hemoglobin values, while both male and female PWAWGs had a lower prevalence of hypertension.
    While there are similarities between celiac disease patients and PWAWGs that could arise from shared HLA haplotypes or result from the gluten-free diet, alternative diagnoses are common in these patients. PWAWGs have a similar cardiovascular profile as celiac disease patients in terms of lower BMI and lower prevalence of hypertension.
    Source:
     Dig Dis Sci. 2013 Dec 28.


    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 06/05/2015 - For anyone with celiac disease, following a lifelong gluten-free diet has been shown to relieve symptoms, and in celiac patients it has been shown to normalize serologic markers of celiac disease, and to restore damaged intestinal villi.
    Not following a gluten-free diet, on the other hand, can result in serious complications associated with malabsorption.
    When celiac disease goes untreated, when people who have celiac disease refuse to follow a gluten-free diet, chronic gluten-related inflammation and damage impairs absorption of nutrients, and likely causes malabsorption of oral medications.
    Malabsorption resulting from damaged mucosa can lead to:
    Nutritional deficiencies of the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K, as well as the B vitamins, thereby diminishing the absorption of iron, calcium, and folic acid. Nutritional deficiencies can lead to: Iron-deficiency anemia refractory to oral iron supplementation, and potentially osteoporosis and osteopenia due to bone loss due to decreased calcium and vitamin D absorption. A combination of nutritional deficiencies and the damaging effects of systemwide chronic inflammation can cause: Reproductive abnormalities, such as delayed puberty, secondary amenorrhea, infertility, or decreased fertility. Adverse immune responses to gluten ingestion can trigger other common manifestations, such as: Dermatitis herpetiformis, a papulovesicular rash. Beyond that, problems can include: Fractures secondary to low bone mineral density. In some cases, untreated celiac disease can lead to intestinal malignancies such as: Intestinal T-cell lymphomas. Small-bowel adenocarcinoma. Esophageal cancer. B- and T-cell non-Hodgkin lymphomas. Rapid, proper diagnosis and effective treatment of celiac disease are crucial to preventing a cascade of related problems that can further impair diagnosis, and cause irreparable damage to patient health.

    Source:
    US Pharmacist. 2014;39(12):44-48.


    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 06/19/2015 - And the biggest gluten-free diet cheats are? Men.
    According to a recent survey commissioned by U.K.-based gluten-free bread company Newburn Bakehouse, gluten-intolerant men feel stigmatized by their dietary restrictions, which leads them to cheat on their diets far more commonly than women. 
    The survey showed that 36 percent of U.K. men sensitive to gluten in food regularly cheat, even though cheating can have adverse health consequences.
    Moreover, one in five of those surveyed said they believe a gluten-free diet is “not for real men.”
    This makes for some fairly large numbers of male gluten-free diet cheats.
    Studies by the University of Maryland Center for Celiac Research show that about 6 percent of the U.S. population suffers from some degree of gluten intolerance, while about 1 percent has celiac disease.
    How about it? Do you or any males you know have celiac disease or gluten intolerance? Do you or they cheat of a regular basis? Share your thoughts below.


    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 01/20/2017 - A team of researchers recently investigated trends in the prevalence of diagnosed celiac disease, undiagnosed celiac disease, and people without celiac disease avoiding gluten (PWAG) in the civilian non-institutionalized US population from 2009 to 2014.
    The research team included Rok Seon Choung, MD, PhD, Aynur Unalp-Arida, MD, PhD, Constance E. Ruhl, MD, PhD, Tricia L. Brantner, BS, James E. Everhart, MD, and Joseph A. Murray, MD.
    They are variously affiliated with the Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN; the Department of Health and Human Services, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD; Social & Scientific Systems, Inc., Silver Spring, MD; and with the Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.
    Their team studied the occurrence of celiac disease and PWAG in the 2009 to 2014 National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys. They tested serum of all participants aged 6 years or older from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys from 2009 to 2014 for celiac disease serology at Mayo Clinic.
    They also interviewed participants for a diagnosis of celiac disease, and the use of a gluten-free diet (GFD). They incorporated the design effects of the survey and sample weights into all statistical analyses.
    Results
    They found that, in the US general population, rates of celiac disease did not change significantly from 0.7% (95% CI, 0.6%-0.8%) in 2009 to 2010 to 0.8% (95% CI, 0.4%-1.2%) in 2011 to 2012 to 0.7% (95% CI, 0.3%-1.0%) in 2013 to 2014. However, rates of undiagnosed celiac disease decreased from 0.6% in 2009 to 2010 to 0.3% in 2013 to 2014.
    In contrast, the prevalence of PWAG increased significantly from 0.5% (95% CI, 0.2%-0.9%) in 2009 to 2010 to 1.0% (95% CI, 0.6%-1.4%) in 2011 to 2012 to 1.7% (95% CI, 1.1%-2.4%) in 2013 to 2014 (P=.005 for trend).
    Their data shows that, even though rates of celiac disease remained largely stable from 2009 to 2014, the percentage of individuals with hidden celiac disease decreased substantially.
    Moreover, the proportion of individuals who follow a gluten-free diet without celiac disease rose sharply during that period. Long-term health consequences of a GFD warrant further investigation.
    Source:
    Mayo Clinic Proceedings. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mayocp.2016.10.012


  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...