Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Positive, Negative, Really Confused


moonunit

Recommended Posts

moonunit Apprentice

Hi, I wrote a while back on another thread about my situation, but I have more information.

Here's the deal:

1993 bowel resection, pathology lab says Crohn's.

I take 12 pills a day for the next 9 years, which seem to do nothing but I take them dutifully.

2002 I ask for a colonoscopy from a different gastro to confirm Crohn's diagnosis. He says there is no evidence of Crohn's and suggests that I may never have had it. Takes me off the meds. My condition stays the same.

2004 after the birth of my daughter and son (in 2005) my abdominal symptoms get considerably worse.

2006 my aunt is diagnosed with celiac disease, my entire family says "wow, look at the symptoms, it's totally you, you should go get tested too!"

The rest happened this month:

My dad had the gene test, came back positive

I had the blood work, came back positive and my primary care set up an appointment with the gastro

I met with the gastro, who looked at the blood results and said "nah, you don't have celiac disease, you have Crohn's." Told me to go on a high-fiber diet and said my blood work was only borderline positive. But he did set up a biopsy anyway. Plus a small bowel x-ray for the Crohn's. The x-ray came back normal.

Had the biopsy on Monday. Asked him at that time for a copy of the blood work. He refused, but did tell me that one of my numbers was 33 (and that negative was up to 30). Based on what was written on the lab request, I know the test was the IgG and IgA AGA, and on the web it says that 20-30 is borderline and 30+ is moderate to strong positive. I pointed out that the numbers DID come back positive according to my primary care, and he said "she's not an expert, I'M an expert." He was really huffy and kind of a jerk, though I don't know that that makes him less competent as a physician, right?

He did the biopsy, which he said he "had to rush through because I was wrestling him" under anesthesia. He had me set up an appointment for two months from now.

Today I got a call from someone at his office, saying that my biopsy was "totally normal" and that "this is as far as we go with the celiac thing." She said if I wanted more information I should speak with my primary care and she would explain it all to me. I asked what about getting medication for Crohn's if that's what I have, and she said to just talk to my primary care.

So that's that. I'm in the San Diego area, and there are a lot of really good celiac experts here. I guess what I'm wondering now is whether to stay on the normal diet and try to get a second opinion from one of them, test the gluten-free diet and then what, if it works, my doctor has already decreed I don't have celiac disease so does it really matter? As far as insurance, I'm stuck because all the gastros covered under my plan work in the same office as he does.

I guess the main issue is that I'm second-guessing myself like crazy. I know people see a zillion doctors before they're diagnosed, but what if I actually DON'T have it? Wouldn't that be nuts to keep asking until I find someone who will tell me that I do? I'm also worried about my kids and whether they might have it. Again from the pediatrician I got a "nah" and he won't test them.

I just don't want to be one of those angry bitter people who was sick for another decade, but I also don't want to be the difficult patient who self-diagnoses in the face of medical expertise to the contrary.

Got any encouraging words? :)


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Guest nini

talk to your primary care Dr. that said your results were positive. Personally, I think that GI sounds like an arrogant jerk and reminds me of the arrogant jerk that misdiagnosed my daughter as having IBS (at age THREE!) and told me to feed her more whole wheat (the very thing that made her break out in hives all over.

Celiac is genetic, if you have family members that have it, the odds of you having it are really really high. In my opinion how you respond to the diet is the most conclusive diagnostic test there is. So ask your PCP if she would support you in a dx of Celiac based on positive bloodwork (which you have) and positive dietary response (If you respond positively to the diet, which I suspect you will) along with the genetic factor.

I wouldn't bother going back to that arrogant GI or any other GI for that matter. Yes the biopsy can be falsely negative, especially if damage is only sporadic and Dr. only took a few samples.

Read Dangerous Grains for some more insight...

jerseyangel Proficient

Really, don't go back to that GI. I've said it before, but I have to say that I think a lot of these doctors are trying not to diagnose Celiac. There just does not seem to be any other explaination for it. You have had a positive result, and strong family history--not to mention your symptoms. My symptoms took a jump after I had my second child, also. That is a common trigger. Even my GI told me that. My advice--go totally gluten-free yourself. Start feeling better now, and have the energy for your kids and yourself. You really don't need a doctor's permission to eat this way and it is a healthy way of life. Keep a close eye on those kids, too for any suspicious symptoms. I don't know how their doctor can tell they won't get it by looking at them. ;)

Guest Robbin

Your story has completely left me stunned. This is completely insane. I think he is so arrogant that he would let you live a life of illness and misery, possible death --not to mention your children--just because he won't admit he missed it, or he was wrong, or the fact that you suggested it--ABSOLUTELY UNBELIEVABLE. I wish you could just wash your hands of the two of them and go to someone sensible that actually CARES. I am so angry on your behalf, I am beside myself. :angry::angry::angry::angry:

If the diet helps you, as nini said, then you have celiac. Try to find a dr. to help you, or take matters into your own hands and get the tests from enterolab. Call your ins. to see if they will cover it before you do, and go from there. I had to do that since my dr. was so ignorant of the illness. Good luck to you and your family and keep us posted.

Oh, and as for that "dr." Remember "what goes around comes around, mister." :angry: He will someday get paybacks. The longer I live, the more that is true. (Sorry -I am in one of those moods tonight!)

moonunit Apprentice

Thanks, guys. You make me feel better. :)

I'm going to talk to my primary care next week (she has a very heavy Chinese accent so I am assuming, perhaps incorrectly, that she was trained outside the U.S. and maybe that's why she took me so seriously). I'll bring all my stuff that I've printed out from the web, nice valid sources like Columbia U and the Mayo Clinic, as well as my book "Celiac Disease: A Hidden Epidemic" and talk to her frankly about my concerns re myself and the children.

The suggestion that I get her to endorse a positive diagnosis if the diet works is a great one! I will definitely try that, and show her that the blood work she ordered, if I'm not mistaken, was only 1/4 of the panel currently recommended. She might just order the full panel, which would help things if that's the only positive indication I've had so far. Meanwhile, I'll stay on a normal diet until I talk to her. If I can put up with the big D for 13 years, I can do it for another week or two. :)

It is of course possible that Dr. Arrogant-pants is right, and I don't have celiac disease. Even if that's the case, though, I'm definitely switching gastros. He's a class-A jerk with a God complex regardless of whether he diagnosed me correctly, and I don't need that in my life! Like many of the people on this board, I have had lifelong issues with being called a drama queen and a hypochondriac, so now that I'm in charge, he can stick his attitude where the sun don't shine. Being a gastro, as well as an a-hole, he should be intimately familiar with the region. ;)

Thanks again. Y'all rock.

Guest Robbin
:lol::lol::lol: :lol Love the attitude now, you go girl!!!!
Guest nini

I had a really long post and then lost it... grrrrrr...

bottom line, even though you had an incomplete panel, you still had a positive result, which is still indicitive of Celiac. The problem with an incomplete panel is that a lot of Celiacs get a false negative that way, but that can happen even with the complete panel, just not as often.

My daughter was dx'ed based on genetic factor(me) and positive dietary response only, after the idiot GI said she "JUST" had IBS (at three???) Anyway, her pediatrician backed me up on the dx, but also said "we KNOW it's Celiac, but I'm going to put Gluten Intolerant in her permanent record so that she doesn't run into problems with Insurance companies on down the road", like being denied coverage... yes it can happen, and it happened to me after my employeer terminated our insurance benefits and I had to try to get ins. coverage on my own. With a positive dx of Celiac on my chart, I was literally determined "UNINSURABLE" which is ridiculous because I'm healthier on the gluten-free diet with the Celiac dx than I was before... idiots.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



penguin Community Regular

Why is it that gastroenterologists are all part of the MEDICAL DIETY club? <_<:rolleyes:

Pisses me off.

My internist (my normal doc) is the one who diagnosed me. She said that going to a gastro was unnecessary, given my funky bloodwork and dietary response. Think about it- your PCP is the one who sees you the most often, sickness and health, and knows your history on a day-to-day basis. It seems to me, in my experience, that internal medicine docs tend to keep more "up" on things than specialists. They're good at seeing the whole picture. My doc also encouraged me to research stuff online, and that I would find more that way than through a nutritionist.

I won't even go into my experience with a gastroenterologist. <_<

Sounds like your PCP has her act together, and her word is just as valid as the numbnut that played a cheap "you're dumber than me" card.

Stick with your doctor, and it's not like you produce antibodies for no reason, and borderline is still positive.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Donate

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):





    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):




  • Recent Activity

    1. - Wheatwacked replied to BIg Nodge's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      7

      Opinions on my test results/symptoms

    2. - Wheatwacked replied to Nicbent35's topic in Introduce Yourself / Share Stuff
      4

      3 year old gluten intolerance?

    3. - Wheatwacked replied to Nicbent35's topic in Introduce Yourself / Share Stuff
      4

      3 year old gluten intolerance?

    4. - knitty kitty replied to plumbago's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      3

      Anyone else with very high HDL?

    5. - Nicbent35 replied to Nicbent35's topic in Introduce Yourself / Share Stuff
      4

      3 year old gluten intolerance?


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      127,890
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Barb Gray
    Newest Member
    Barb Gray
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121k
    • Total Posts
      70.5k

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Wheatwacked
      Many of the symptoms, there are over 200, associated with celiac disease and NCGS are vitamin and mineral deficiencies caused by small intestine damage in the case of celiac disease and food avoidance and the poor nutrittion of the Modern American Diet (MAD) I used to turn the heat on even at 78 degrees.  The 600 mcg of Liquid Iodine helped.  Also good for hair, nails, skin and brain fog.  Another good thing for brain fog is phosphatyl choline.  It is essentil for acetylcholine- a brain chemical. I have familial hyperlipdemia and instead of a statin I got a prescription for Nicotinic Acid, 2000 mg a day.  I was already taking 500 mg a day and was really surprised when my HDL when up to  44 and I began sleeping better and my legs and back are getting more flexible.  In addition after the first few doses of itchiness I get a warm fuzzy feeling Raising your vitamin D is crucial.  Low vitamin D allows the immune system to run amuck. intermittent bouts of fatigue, chills/cold intolerance, and shortness of breath/air hunger (sometimes feels like a hollowness in my chest, hard to describe).  Look at Thiamin deficiency. consistently ran hot, was always cranking the a/c, to someone who wears a down vest.  Any combination of deficiencies in B1, B2, B3, B5, choline and Iodine can cause this.  Likely all of them. After a lifetime of mouthbreathing GFD cleared my sinuses.  Post nasal drip is my first symptom of cross contamination nowaday.  
    • Wheatwacked
      If you mean continueing on Gluten Free my answer is yes.  She showed significant improvement in her behavior and that translates to a happy family.  Do get her tested as sooon as you can.  You might want to investigate genetic testing for Celiac Disease.  Children recover more quickly than adults.  It took my son about 6 months on Nutramigen before going to regular food, gluten free.  Blood tests are not always accurate in very young children. You may be advised to see a gastroenterologist instead of relying on blood tests results. Logic: She is better off gluten than before.  Wheat flour has no nutritional value and has an omega 6: omega 3 ratio of 22:1.  Our bodies do better at 3:1.  Omega 6 causes inflammation. When my son was diagnosed, back in 1976, his doctor recommended my wife and I also go gluten free.  We declined and lived to regret it.  I started GFD at 63 and have spent the last 10 years undoing the damage, some of my symptons went all the way back to my childhood and things I lived with all my life got better.
    • Wheatwacked
      Hi @Nicbent35,             When my son was diagnosed with Celiac Disease when he was weaned, so I understand your frustration.       With improvement so dramatic, it cannot be a coincedence. Get her to the doctor and tell the story and insist on testing.  In the meantime, though, continue on GFD.  Her health is more important than convincing a doctor.  Bring videos of her behaviors if you can.  Even if the blood tests and biopsy prove negative, that is part of the diagnosis process for NCGS and later when she is recovered you can always do a Gluten Challenge.      This is an important time in her developement.  Celiac Disease causes malabsorption syndrome, leading to malnutrition, regardles of what she eats.  Though NCGS may not cause malabsorption, it will affect food choices which can lead to malnutrition.  There may be benifits that an official diagnosis may have, but they don't trump a healthy child.      Get her healthy, then worry about validation later.  Celiac Disease is difficult to diagnosed, especially in children, because doctors look for antibodies in the blood and young children have immature immune systems.  Also you don't mention any gastrologic symtoms and celiac disease is traditionally considered gastrolic only.  Not true.  There are over 200 symptom that celiac disease and the accompaning malnutrion mimics or causes that often causes misdiagnosis and delay in recovery. While at the doctors, ask them about vitamin D deficiency and Iodine deficiency in particular. Milk being the primary source of iodine in the diet, but concerns exist regarding the lower iodine content in organic milk and reduced milk consumption in certain demographics.  Vitamin D deficiency is 40% of the industrialized population and a recent study in the Great Britain showed a wopping 60%, beaten only by some areas of Canada at 70%. And B1, B2, B3, B5 and B6.  Deficiencies in these are common in untreated Celiac Disease and they affect energy production. Are You Confused About Your Celiac Disease Lab Results?
    • knitty kitty
      @plumbago, Are you taking any folate with your B12?   Folate helps regulate HDL levels.  You may try taking a methylfolate supplement with your B12.   If there's a folate deficiency because you aren't absorbing sufficient folate, or have the MThF mutation causing a functional folate deficiency (methylfolate trap), you can have a functional B12 deficiency despite supplementing, resulting in HDL levels not getting regulated, but running high or low.   Pushing the envelope in explanations, too. P. S. Are you taking a B Complex?  Folate and B12 Cobalamine need enzymes made from B6 Pyridoxine's interaction with Thiamine, and B2 Riboflavin's interaction with Thiamine.  Is your Vitamin D low?
    • Nicbent35
      Thank you for all that helpful info, does that mean it’s not a good idea to do what I’m doing? Or since it’s only been a week should I see if I could get her tested now? Would it show up still since it hasn’t been long if they tested her?
×
×
  • Create New...