• Ads by Google:
     




    Get email alerts Celiac.com E-Newsletter

    Ads by Google:



       Get email alertsCeliac.com E-Newsletter

  • Announcements

    • admin

      Frequently Asked Questions About Celiac Disease   09/30/2015

      This Celiac.com FAQ on celiac disease will guide you to all of the basic information you will need to know about the disease, its diagnosis, testing methods, a gluten-free diet, etc.   Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts What are the major symptoms of celiac disease? Celiac Disease Symptoms What testing is available for celiac disease? - list blood tests, endo with biopsy, genetic test and enterolab (not diagnostic) Celiac Disease Screening Interpretation of Celiac Disease Blood Test Results Can I be tested even though I am eating gluten free? How long must gluten be taken for the serological tests to be meaningful? The Gluten-Free Diet 101 - A Beginner's Guide to Going Gluten-Free Is celiac inherited? Should my children be tested? Ten Facts About Celiac Disease Genetic Testing Is there a link between celiac and other autoimmune diseases? Celiac Disease Research: Associated Diseases and Disorders Is there a list of gluten foods to avoid? Unsafe Gluten-Free Food List (Unsafe Ingredients) Is there a list of gluten free foods? Safe Gluten-Free Food List (Safe Ingredients) Gluten-Free Alcoholic Beverages Distilled Spirits (Grain Alcohols) and Vinegar: Are they Gluten-Free? Where does gluten hide? Additional Things to Beware of to Maintain a 100% Gluten-Free Diet Free recipes: Gluten-Free Recipes Where can I buy gluten-free stuff? Support this site by shopping at The Celiac.com Store.

Clarification Please
0

13 posts in this topic

I know the difference between celiac and gluten intol. is that-

1- celiac has the villi wearing away- GS does not

2- celiac is autoimmune- GS is not.

Where I'm confused is:

Is GS genetic like celiac? or not? I am finding conflicting info on the internet, but I am not sure if it is because some websites are interchanging the two terms. Some sites say it is not. What are your thoughts?

Also is NCGS life long like celiac? I am coming across some places that say you might be able to introduce gluten again after a time. What has been your experience?

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:
Ads by Google:


There is not much research done yet on gluten intolerance. That's why you are finding conflicting info. Many things out there are based on opinions and personal experience instead of research. It is my opinion that celiac disease is just one form of gluten intolerance and in the future they may have other forms of gluten intolerance that they can test for with speciific tests. The tests for celiac are not currently 100% accurate, however. There are many false negatives so that people that have negative tests, but positive results with the diet, end up being labled as "just gluten intolerant". Because of the flawed testing, it's my opinion that gluten intolerance is every bit as serious as celiac disease and also requires a life long gluten-free diet. Until there is better testing and more research done we have no way of knowing if people with "gluten intolerance" are really celiacs that don't show up on testing or if they have a different condition altogether.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, gluten intolerance seems to run in families. I haven't seen any genetic studies because gluten intolerance is not a well enough defined clinical diagnosis to even choose people on whom to do genetics.

There is a "board think" here that celiac and gluten intolerance are always lifelong. This is not the case, even with celiac disease. If you read the medical literature, there are documented cases of biopsy confirmed celiacs who become able to consume a normal diet again with no ill effects or villous damage. It's most common where DH is the only symptom. I wouldn't encourage board members to go off and try eating gluten again, as regaining tolerance is not the norm, but it's something to be aware of.

Similarly, my doctor has said he has seen people who were gluten intolerant recover, and that the degree of ones gluten intolerance can change over time. I've read this in articles around the Internet as well, though I consider my Dr. a better resource. Really, just about any allergy or intolerance can come and go somewhat unpredictably. With intolerances it may be related to changes in intestinal microflora, and allergic desensitization is a well documented phenomenon.

I do agree with GlutenFreeManna, that it is very difficult to discriminate between non-celiac gluten intolerance and undiagnosed celiac disease. Further, there is fairly convincing evidence that gluten intolerance is the first step in developing celiac disease, which makes consuming gluten a risky proposition if you are gluten intolerant.

2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know the difference between celiac and gluten intol. is that-

1- celiac has the villi wearing away- GS does not

2- celiac is autoimmune- GS is not.

Where I'm confused is:

Is GS genetic like celiac? or not? I am finding conflicting info on the internet, but I am not sure if it is because some websites are interchanging the two terms. Some sites say it is not. What are your thoughts?

Also is NCGS life long like celiac? I am coming across some places that say you might be able to introduce gluten again after a time. What has been your experience?

Hi, I have read that there is Celiac Sprue [celiac Didease] & Celiac sensitivity [when all blood work positve but biopsy normal] & Gluten intolerance [allergy testing]. It has been said that a confirmed biospy diagnosis can only Rule celiac In, it cannot rule it out [ Clinically pertinent coeliac disease exists despite normal small-bowel mucosal villous architecture]. And all diagnosis and sensitivity and intolerance Need be addressed and patient needs eat gluten free for life before damage can be done through immune system, neurological damage or small intestine damage. They say autoimmune if shows in blood work or biospy. It`s a lot to learn and we all must seek our answers because doctors are not going to give the answers we need. Great that you brought up this topic, terri

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, gluten intolerance seems to run in families. I haven't seen any genetic studies because gluten intolerance is not a well enough defined clinical diagnosis to even choose people on whom to do genetics.

There is a "board think" here that celiac and gluten intolerance are always lifelong. This is not the case, even with celiac disease. If you read the medical literature, there are documented cases of biopsy confirmed celiacs who become able to consume a normal diet again with no ill effects or villous damage. It's most common where DH is the only symptom. I wouldn't encourage board members to go off and try eating gluten again, as regaining tolerance is not the norm, but it's something to be aware of.

Similarly, my doctor has said he has seen people who were gluten intolerant recover, and that the degree of ones gluten intolerance can change over time. I've read this in articles around the Internet as well, though I consider my Dr. a better resource. Really, just about any allergy or intolerance can come and go somewhat unpredictably. With intolerances it may be related to changes in intestinal microflora, and allergic desensitization is a well documented phenomenon.

I do agree with GlutenFreeManna, that it is very difficult to discriminate between non-celiac gluten intolerance and undiagnosed celiac disease. Further, there is fairly convincing evidence that gluten intolerance is the first step in developing celiac disease, which makes consuming gluten a risky proposition if you are gluten intolerant.

Wow Skylark, thanks for sharing this info, these were thoughts I have tossed around in my head and concluded much the same that you confirmed and articulated so well for me and others. Terri

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:


At least they're finally recognizing gluten sensitivity. You might like to read this interview with Dr. Fasano at the University of Maryland School of Medicine's Center for Celiac Research.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice article. I love when he says "The patients, as usual, were visionary, telling us this stuff existed but healthcare professionals were skeptical."

I don't agree 100% with Dr. Fasano that gluten sensitivity is not a precursor to celiac. There are studies linking IL-15 produced in gluten sensitivity to development of celiac disease. Dr. Markku M

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At least they're finally recognizing gluten sensitivity. You might like to read this interview with Dr. Fasano at the University of Maryland School of Medicine's Center for Celiac Research.

Yes , you are so right that they are or need to recognize `gluten-sensitivity` especially if had bloodwork show strong-high-positive.

The experts say the following "Clinically pertinent coeliac disease exists despite normal small-bowel mucosal villous architecture. Mucosal transglutaminase 2-specific IgA deposits can be utilized in detecting such patients with genetic gluten intolerance."

I always learn from you Sylvia, thanks, Terri

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So if one is positive on the blood work, but ends up negative on the biopsy, I should consider them gluten intolerant? To be on the safe side, should I have their siblings tested as well? It is better to assume there is a genetic component until studies prove differently.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In the interview the Dr. said if you are GS you will feel better quickly, in days or weeks.

But if you are celiac it will take weeks, months, or years.

Do you find that to be true?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So if one is positive on the blood work, but ends up negative on the biopsy, I should consider them gluten intolerant? To be on the safe side, should I have their siblings tested as well? It is better to assume there is a genetic component until studies prove differently.

No, a positive on celiac bloodwork indicates they are for sure celiac. Biopsies can miss the damage--the dr may not take enough biopsies, damage can be patchy (they are not able to see it during the endo only after they take a sample out and put it under a microscope), or dammage can be in one place and endoscopy does not reach the entire length of the intestines. The positive blood tests and something like 99% accurate. If they have all negative tests (bloodwork and biopsy), but still respond well to trying a gluten-free diet then they should be considered gluten intolerant or they may be celiac anyway since negative tests have about a 20% false negative rate.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In the interview the Dr. said if you are GS you will feel better quickly, in days or weeks.

But if you are celiac it will take weeks, months, or years.

Do you find that to be true?

I would love to pick the dr's brain about this a little more and see what his context is for making this statement. Is he talking about only people who are diagnosed in older age or everyone? It seems like a very generalized statement to make and doesn't really make sense when you conside r the difference between people diagnosed early in life and people diagnosed later in life. Even amoung biopsy diagnosed celiacs there is a range of damage. And there is also a range of symptoms--some symptoms take longer to go away than others. DH can take months to go away after a flare up. Diarhea may go away in just a few days. Vitamin deficiencies can take months to years to recover from too. It's just going to vary from person to person I'm afraid. I think the dr is implying that gluten sensitive people don't have damage or vitamin deficiencies and therefore they should feel better faster but I know many gluten sensitive people on this board that test negatvie but have neuorogical symptoms and neuro damage that has taken years to recover from. My own experience has been a slow process of rebuilding my muscles, dexterity and memory, as well as treating vitamin deficiencies over the past 18 months. Bloating and gastro issues went away right away. Fatigue, joint pain, muscle pain, etc took longer. Since I didn't do any testing I wonder if the dr would call me celiac or if he would call me gluten intolerant? I think I will respectfully diagree with the dr until they have better tests for celiac disease and have some better definitions of "gluten sensitive".

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also think that is interesting about the gluten sensitive people feeling better more quickly than celiacs. I don't know which one I am either. My worst symptom was anxiety but I didn't know that this was the cure. As far as my GI issues. I had horrible bloating, cramping, heartburn, constipation, and gas and the doctor suggested trying gluten free for a month. Those symptoms started to resolve within a week. The anxiety has been a surprise. A couple weeks in I could go to bed with no anxiety and I used to be so anxious I would keep myself awake out of fear I wouldn't wake up (crazy I know). I got sick as well which before would have me worried something was seriously wrong with me and I would have panicked but I didn't worry about it. I still get anxiety now, but I can sense it coming and talk myself through it much better now. I am hoping in time it goes completely away. So, with as long as I have been gluten free I will never be able to get tested and my anxiety was so bad I am not going to challenge for a test. So I guess stick with it even though I would love to know for sure if I am celiac or not.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      106,460
    • Total Posts
      930,675
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      63,883
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    Stephanie kate
    Joined
  • Popular Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I am very interested in this too. My daughter tested negative for celiac, but has terrible primarily neurological symptoms. Because she tested positive for SIBO at the time and was having some GI symptoms, I was told it was just a Fodmap issue.  I knew better and we have been gluten free for 2 years.  Fast forward to this February. She had a SIBO recurrence that I treated at home with diet and herbal antibiotics because I couldn't get the insurance referral. She was doing great. Then stupid me brought in gluten containing chick feed for the new baby chicks we got.   Feed dust everywhere. Total mess.  Really, no GI symptoms (she was SIBO free by then)...but the neurological symptoms! my daughter couldn't walk for three days. Burning down one leg, nerve pain in the foot. Also heaviness of limbs, headache and fatigue. Better after three days. But unfortunately she had a TINY gluten exposure at that three day mark and had another severe reaction: loss of balance, loss of feeling in her back and arms, couldn't see for a few seconds, and three days of hand numbness, fatigue, concentration problems.  Well, I actually contacted Dr. Hadjivassilou by email and he confirmed that the symptoms are consistent with gluten ataxia but any testing would require a gluten challenge. Even with these exposures, antibodies would not be high enough.  His suggestion was maintain vigilance gluten free.  I just saw my daughter's GI at U of C and she really only recognizes celiac disease and neurological complications of that. But my impression is that gluten ataxia is another branch in the autoimmune side of things (with celiac and DH being the other two).   At this point, I know a diagnosis is important. But I don't know how to get there. We homeschool right now so I can give her time to heal when she is accidentally glutened, I can keep my home safe for her (ugh, that I didn't think of the chicken feed!)  But at some point, she is going to be in college, needing to take exams, and totally incapacitated because of an exposure.  And doctors state side that are worth seeing?  Who is looking at gluten ataxia in the US?
    • Caro..............monitoring only the TSH to gauge thyroid function is what endo's do who don' t do a good job of managing thyroid disease.  They should do the full panel and check the actual thyroid hormone numbers.........T3 and T4. The importance of the TSH comes second to hormone levels. In order to track how severely the thyroid is under attack, you need to track antibody levels.......not the TSH. I did not stay with endocrinologists because I found they did not do a very good job and found much greater help and results with a functional medicine MD.  You should not have a goiter if your thyroid is functioning well and your TSH is "normal".  Maybe they should do a full panel? Going gluten free can have a profound affect for the better on thyroid function and that is something that is becoming more and more accepted today.  Ask most people with Celiac and thyroid disease and they will tell you that. My thyroid never functioned well or was under control under after I discovered I had Celiac and went gluten free.  It was the only way I got my antibody numbers back down close to normal and they were around 1200 when it was diagnosed with Celiac.  I was diagnosed with Hashi's long before the Celiac diagnosis.  I am not sure Vitamin D has anything to do with thyroid antibodies but who knows?  Maybe it does have an affect for the better. It is really hard to get Vitmain D levels up, depending on where you live. Mine are going up, slowly, even after 12 years gluten-free but I live in the Northeast in the US and we don't have sun levels like they do in the South.  I take 5,000 IU daily and that is a safe level to take, believe it or not.  I get no sun on my job so the large dose it is! Having Celiac Disease should not stop you from being able to travel, especially S. America. I travel, although I do agree that some countries might be very difficult to be gluten free in. You can be a foodie and travel with Celiac so no worries on that front. You may not be able to sample from someone else's plate, unless they are eating gluten-free too but I have had awesome experiences with food when traveling so you can too!
    • I don't know what you drank or where.... so here are a few thoughts. - sure, a dive bar might have dirty glasses and serve a cocktail in a beer glass?  But a nice reminder place, with a dishwasher, should be fine.  If it's a sketchy place, Stick to wine, then it's served in wine glasses that aren't used for beer or bottled ciders in the bottle.   - ciders on tap might, just a slight chance, have an issue.  Because of beer on tap, mixed up lines, etc. - you may have a problem with alcohol - you may have issues with The  high sugar content of the drink.  I know I have similar issues if I drink serveral ciders of extra sugary brands - are you positive it was a gluten-free drink?  Not this " redds Apple" pretending to be a cider - it's beer with apple flavor.  Or one of those " gluten removed " beers?  
    • Hi Stephanie, I'm also from the UK, I've found this site more helpful than anything we have!  As already mentioned above, in my experience it could depend on what and where you were drinking. Gluten free food and drink isn't always (not usually) 100% gluten free as you may know, maybe you have become more sensitive to even a trace of gluten that is probably in gluten free food/drink. Is it possible you have a problem with corn, particularly high fructose corn syrup that is in a lot of alcoholic drinks? This was a big problem for me and the only alcoholic drinks I can tolerate are William Chase vodka and gin. I contacted the company last year and all their drinks are 100% gluten and corn free, made the old fashioned way with no additives, so maybe try their products if you like the occasional drink and see how you get on. If you drink out, not many pubs sell their products but I know Wetherspoons do and smaller wine bars may too. l was never a spirit drinker but I must say their products are absolutely lovely! Very easy on a compromised gut too considering it's alcohol. I second the suggestion on seeing a natural health practitioner. I've recently started seeing a medical herbalist, as I've got nowhere with my now many food intolerances since going gluten free last year and I've noticed a difference in my health already. 
    • Sorry for the very late reply and thanks for the replies, I didn't get a notification of any. In case anyone else comes across this and has been wondering the same as I was, I did try a vegetable broth and I did react to it in the same way as if I'd eaten the vegetables.  As for the candida, I've been using coconut oil and am seeing a medical herbalist for this and leaky gut. It's only been a few weeks but I've noticed an improvement all round.
  • Upcoming Events