• Ads by Google:
     




    Get email alerts Celiac.com E-Newsletter

    Ads by Google:



       Get email alertsCeliac.com E-Newsletter

  • Announcements

    • admin

      Frequently Asked Questions About Celiac Disease   09/30/2015

      This Celiac.com FAQ on celiac disease will guide you to all of the basic information you will need to know about the disease, its diagnosis, testing methods, a gluten-free diet, etc.   Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts What are the major symptoms of celiac disease? Celiac Disease Symptoms What testing is available for celiac disease? - list blood tests, endo with biopsy, genetic test and enterolab (not diagnostic) Celiac Disease Screening Interpretation of Celiac Disease Blood Test Results Can I be tested even though I am eating gluten free? How long must gluten be taken for the serological tests to be meaningful? The Gluten-Free Diet 101 - A Beginner's Guide to Going Gluten-Free Is celiac inherited? Should my children be tested? Ten Facts About Celiac Disease Genetic Testing Is there a link between celiac and other autoimmune diseases? Celiac Disease Research: Associated Diseases and Disorders Is there a list of gluten foods to avoid? Unsafe Gluten-Free Food List (Unsafe Ingredients) Is there a list of gluten free foods? Safe Gluten-Free Food List (Safe Ingredients) Gluten-Free Alcoholic Beverages Distilled Spirits (Grain Alcohols) and Vinegar: Are they Gluten-Free? Where does gluten hide? Additional Things to Beware of to Maintain a 100% Gluten-Free Diet Free recipes: Gluten-Free Recipes Where can I buy gluten-free stuff? Support this site by shopping at The Celiac.com Store.

Transient Celiac Autoimmunity In A Adult
0

7 posts in this topic

I came across this case report in the pubmed.gov database. It is going to be published in one of the upcoming issues of the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology. Dr. Peter Green, from Columbia, is one of the co-authors.

To summarize, it discusses a 58 year old man who is employed at a bagel shop and eats gluten on a regular basis. Throughout the vignette he continues to eat gluten on a regular basis.

March 2010: referred for celiac testing after found to be Vitamin D deficient. TTG and DGP antibodies normal, small bowel biopsies on endoscopy are also normal.

May 2010: develops hyperparathyroidism. Celiac antibodies repeated, TTG antibodies high at 22, and then repeated and high at 37. DGP antibodies high at 36, EMA antibodies high at titer of 1:40. Patient also found to be DQ2 positive on genetic testing.

September 2010: TTG and EMA antibodies normal, DGP weaking positive.

February 2011: all antibodies (TTG, EMA, DGP) normal.

April 2011: endoscopy and biopsy repeated: well formed villi in duodenal bulb and throughout duodenum, a few white blood cells (lymphocytosis) in villi tips, a pattern described in latent or potential celiac disease.

They do not refer to any other symptoms in this patient (outside of the problems of Vitamin D deficiency and the hyperparathyroidism) so I would assume he is asymptomatic since he regularly eats bagels and works in a bagel shop.

I am curious to see what others on this board think of this case report, and wondering if anyone else has experienced a total flip from positive to negative antibodies while continuing to eat gluten.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:
Ads by Google:


Just realized that I made a typo, the title should include the words "in an adult" not "a adult." Maybe that's why none of you are commenting?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, it's common knowledge among experts that celiac disease occasionally goes into remission. There are other case studies, plus a study on someone who desensitized herself by progressively eating more and more gluten.

There was a recent study on DH where dermatologists mention that the gluten sensitivity goes away in some people after 1-2 years of eating gluten-free. I think they said it's more likely to go away in people with DH only and no small intestine involvement.

Problem is, it's not the majority of celiacs and there is no way to predict who will regain gluten tolerance.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, it's common knowledge among experts that celiac disease occasionally goes into remission. There are other case studies, plus a study on someone who desensitized herself by progressively eating more and more gluten.

There was a recent study on DH where dermatologists mention that the gluten sensitivity goes away in some people after 1-2 years of eating gluten-free. I think they said it's more likely to go away in people with DH only and no small intestine involvement.

Problem is, it's not the majority of celiacs and there is no way to predict who will regain gluten tolerance.

This is interesting because at the end of this case report the authors claim that this is the first report of such a phenomenon. Perhaps because the patient wasn't actually ever diagnosed with celiac disease. Do you have/know the references for the other similar case reports?

I would appreciate it.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Peter Green likes to claim he is some kind of special snowflake. Apparently the reviewers haven't read enough of the celiac literature to catch his BS. This happens a lot in scientific articles. When I saw Marku Makki talk, he spoke about desensitization and spontaneous remission in some celiacs. He has seen it in his decades of practice. It's part of the reason a vaccine for celiac is thought to be feasible. Makki's observations are in one of his articles but I can't seem to turn it up. I did find some other stuff for you. I don't know whether the Gut links will work for you because I have an academic affiliation that allows me to see a lot of research articles but I copied the conclusions.

Desensitization.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16388719

This is the best article I can find. It is a retrospective study on 70 people diagnosed with celiac in childhood.

http://gut.bmj.com/content/56/10/1379.full

"In conclusion, this study indicates that up to 10% of celiac disease patients diagnosed in childhood can spontaneously recover a normal villous architecture after a long period of normal diet without retaining any clinical or biological sequelae of celiac disease. The persistence of immunological stigmata of celiac disease and the risk of relapse indicate, however, that this remission state must not be considered as a definitive recovery but as a return to latency that requires a regular follow-up. Most of the patients with celiac disease diagnosed in childhood who resumed a normal diet, however, have an active celiac disease at adulthood, even in the absence of symptoms. These patients should be screened for the presence of villous atrophy and osteopenia, and should be advised to return to a GFD in the case of persisting villous atrophy."

A case study.

http://gut.bmj.com/content/57/5/715.full

"If the initial diagnosis was correct this represents a previously unrecognised course of childhood coeliac disease with either cure or prolonged latency (during which a normal diet may be tolerated). This has major implications to the individual, their families and to the provision of health care resources, particularly in the context of the increased prevalence of coeliac disease. The key questions that arise are whether lifelong gluten exclusion is necessary in childhood coeliac disease and whether gluten exclusion in children with coeliac disease has the potential to promote a period of prolonged latency or remission? In the context of the exponential increase in diagnosis and advent of screening further study of the natural history (including the potential impact of gluten challenge) and revision of the diagnostic criteria are indicated. We must ensure that patients are fully informed about uncertainty and that we do not over-diagnose or over-treat a condition that may not be lifelong and may, in a number of children, have the potential to enter a prolonged remission. "

Remission in DH

http://archderm.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/archdermatol.2010.336v1

Reuters summary of the research and interview with Stephen Katz at NIH

http://www.reuters.com/article/2010/11/19/us-painful-gluten-rashes-might-be-foreve-idUSTRE6AI44620101119

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:


Peter Green likes to claim he is some kind of special snowflake. Apparently the reviewers haven't read enough of the celiac literature to catch his BS. This happens a lot in scientific articles. When I saw Marku Makki talk, he spoke about desensitization and spontaneous remission in some celiacs. He has seen it in his decades of practice.

It's part of the reason a vaccine for celiac is thought to be feasible. Makki's observations are in one of his articles but I can't seem to turn it up. I did find some other stuff for you. I don't know whether the Gut links will work for you because I have an academic affiliation that allows me to see a lot of research articles but I copied the conclusions.

Desensitization.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16388719

This is the best article I can find. It is a retrospective study on 70 people diagnosed with celiac in childhood.

http://gut.bmj.com/content/56/10/1379.full

"In conclusion, this study indicates that up to 10% of celiac disease patients diagnosed in childhood can spontaneously recover a normal villous architecture after a long period of normal diet without retaining any clinical or biological sequelae of celiac disease. The persistence of immunological stigmata of celiac disease and the risk of relapse indicate, however, that this remission state must not be considered as a definitive recovery but as a return to latency that requires a regular follow-up. Most of the patients with celiac disease diagnosed in childhood who resumed a normal diet, however, have an active celiac disease at adulthood, even in the absence of symptoms. These patients should be screened for the presence of villous atrophy and osteopenia, and should be advised to return to a GFD in the case of persisting villous atrophy."

A case study.

http://gut.bmj.com/content/57/5/715.ful

"If the initial diagnosis was correct this represents a previously unrecognised course of childhood coeliac disease with either cure or prolonged latency (during which a normal diet may be tolerated). This has major implications to the individual, their families and to the provision of health care resources, particularly in the context of the increased prevalence of coeliac disease. The

key questions that arise are whether lifelong gluten exclusion is necessary in childhood coeliac disease and whether gluten exclusion in children with coeliac disease has the potential to promote a period of prolonged latency or remission? In the context of the exponential increase in diagnosis and advent of screening further study of the natural history (including the potential impact of gluten challenge) and revision of the diagnostic criteria are indicated. We must ensure that patients are fully informed

about uncertainty and that we do not over-diagnose or over-treat a condition that may not be lifelong and may, in a number of children, have the potential to enter a prolonged remission. "

Remission in DH

http://archderm.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/full/archdermatol.2010.336v1

Reuters summary of the research and interview with

Stephen Katz at NIH

http://www.reuters.com/article/2010/11/19/us-painful-gluten-rashes-might-be-foreve-idUSTRE6AI44620101119

Excellent links. Thank you!

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Other autoimmune disorders are known to have flares and periods of remission. Surely it is not a big stretch to see Celiac following such a pattern as well?

I had what now seems to have been my first brush with Celiac 25 years ago, but it was put down to "mono" and post viral fatigue (the accompanying digestive problems were simply ignored by the docs!). I was ill and unable to work for quite some time until I tried an anti-candida diet which was, you guessed it, gluten free. I recovered sufficiently to be able to return to work, and dropped the diet (I'd never even heard of Celiac at this point). I struggled a bit with ongoing fatigue etc for another 18/19 years but otherwise had a normal life. I then used a gluten free/gluten light diet and excercise therapy for a while to recover from lingering joint and soft tissue pain after a car accident, and felt really well for several years afterwards, even after reintroducing normal amounts of gluten to my diet. The penny about needing to stay gluten free still did not drop, until very recently after 2-3 years of increasingly poor health.

Although this is not entirely the point that jwhale is making about recovery while still eating gluten, for me Celiac seems to have grumbled in the backgound for years, with periodic flare ups being treatable by a being gluten free for a while, and the symptoms returning to a grumbling level on reintroducing gluten, and maintaining this low symptom position for a long time.

I am therefore strongly tempted to see Celiac and gluten intolerance as a spectrum disorder, in which the severity can vary between people and also in the same person over time. Other autoimmune disorders behave in this fashion, e.g. lupus. Why not celiac too?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      106,786
    • Total Posts
      932,420
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      64,267
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    Michelle Robinson
    Joined
  • Popular Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I can tell you that the head pressure you are speaking about is one of the symptoms I am experiencing now.  And fogginess and dizziness.  I'm going to go as long as I can with my challenge. Im hoping the new GI I'm going to see will work with me. I would like him to do blood work every month to see if levels are changing.  There were so many problems with my daughter's challenge and testing. U of C at the time only recommended a 6 week challenge. And only tTG IgA and total IgA were run. Not a full panel. Well after the biopsy and when insurance wouldn't give us another referral we were told that there was a more extensive panel. By then she was gluten free and we were not going back.  
    • People are able to find a very old topic and add to it (bumping it up to current).  We need to remember to check the dates and realize that these people from 10 years ago may not respond.  Also, remember that product info, ma be even medical info, can change in that amount of time.
    • When I was changing doctors due to insurance issues, I got one doc who I told I had celiac, and had been gluten-free for 2 years. He ordered a blood test and said I DID NOT have celiac cause the blood test came back negative....I looked at him like it was crazy, told him course your not going to detect the antibodies in test if I am not eating it. Told him to go back to med school and never went back. Similar experience with another doctor around that time....funny memory glad I found one that knows about the disease to some extent.
    • ÖThe potential celiac or  NCGS  diagnosis is given to me by the Celiac researchEr.  I do not think it's official until after we meet again.  actually I have not heard of that doctors work. I will look it up and see if I can listen to an interview. Thanks for sharing.  some of the symptoms that I continue to have Had on a strict gluten-free diet or similar to what I have now  and some of them disappeared. Of course During that time I was thrown on Xanax and some Protonix even though I don't actually have acid reflux. So there may have been some symptoms that were caused by those medications but I've been off Of Them for months now.  I guess headed pressure would be one of the more prominent symptoms  that I still had on a gluten-free diet although it's much much worse recently well I'm gluten.  it was almost like I can feel a strange sensation in my gut and the head at the same time but it's nothing like what you would think it wasn't cramping it wasn't... I don't know how to describe it. it does not feel anything like sinuses it's a really strange feeling like my brain Is inflamed Or being squeezed.  When I first started getting it it scared the living crap out of me because I thought I was going to end up passing out. I would be afraid to drive alone with my young son. Now admittedly I was diagnosed with inflammation of the small intestine in late August and was gluten free throughout the fall but started eating it again in late December. So I may not have given myself a tremendous amount of time to heal from the August duodenitis.   Currently I have pain in the right rib cage area,  I also get a tremendous amount of pressure in that area mostly when I'm sitting. Kind of like when us pregnant women had a baby's foot stuck up in that area.  I get nausea on and off, some shortness of breath, dizzy,  when my brain gets that  pressure my eyes often feel it as well, and I get some transient numbness and tingling in my hands and oddly in my face.  last summer I had Random episodes of blood pressure drops as well. I would start to really not feel well and noticed that eating actually helped those episodes. I was exercising a lot At the time but ate constantly  and was maintaining my weight. One doctor theorized it might be my blood sugar dropping so I bought a monitor but I never caught that. The only thing that I did catch was when I bought the blood pressure monitor and started taking my blood pressure when these episodes were happening.   for the most part I had pretty good health up until about a year-and-a-half ago and a very strange six months or so about 13 years ago where a lot of neurological stuff happened as well. I had vertigo, visual disturbances, eye floaters, muscles twitching, ants crawling sensation on my scull, some really strange stuff. It lasted about 6 months and over time it just went away.  except for the eye floaters, they stuck around. I'm not particularly concerned about them it's just that they were not there one day and I had some visual disturbances and Bam there they were and they never went away. I have a half-sister with MS but we ruled it out for me at that time and we also ruled it out last summer as well.   I did the whole 12-week thing that they're suggesting for your daughter. We figured the six weeks wasn't long enough.  For the most part other than a few weird things I honestly didn't get strange symptoms until the end of the six weeks so 12 weeks made sense. I think I actually ended up doing 10 weeks before the biopsy This time. Nothing but the increase in IELs.  I know they only biopsy the duodenum and I wonder sometimes if it's not just lower down. But with the negative blood work except for that one random test I don't know if it's really worth pursuing any more testing at this point. I'm so tired.  I know my brother is seronegative but that's pretty rare although I have no idea whether or not they've ever done a study on if that happens to be familial.  I also would really like to know if people who test positive for TTG 6 have any gut damaged. Because if that's the case perhaps there is no seronegative celiac disease  Have you read Dr. Fasano's work?  he writes back both Celiac and ncgs.  How long are you doing your challenge for again?  I know you may be anxious for answers as well but my suggestion just from personal experience would be to go as long as you can. 
    • I should qualify that I'm actually consuming the equivalent of 1-3 slices of bread in the form of vital wheat gluten. Sometimes I have bread, if I'm eating out. But I don't really want all of the carbs and I want to demonstrate that it actually IS the gluten causing the problems and not a Fodmap issue.  My reaction to bread and my reaction to the gluten are the same.  I'm actually shocked at how quickly things have changed. My hair is starting to thin again (boo hoo 😩), and my stools are completely different and it's only been about two weeks. The headache and dizziness and nausea are the worst.  Ennis, you are right. You would think that all of these symptoms would show on blood work. Grrr. I'm hoping that the GI I'm seeing on June 7th will run a preliminary full celiac panel.  It will only be 4 weeks by then.  Will it show something?  My sister has her PhD in immunology and I remember her saying how difficult research in immunology is because you need clearly high antibodies to demonstrate anything. 
  • Upcoming Events