• Ads by Google:
     




    Get email alerts Subscribe to Celiac.com's FREE weekly eNewsletter

    Ads by Google:



       Get email alertsSubscribe to Celiac.com's FREE weekly eNewsletter

  • Announcements

    • admin

      Frequently Asked Questions About Celiac Disease   09/30/2015

      This Celiac.com FAQ on celiac disease will guide you to all of the basic information you will need to know about the disease, its diagnosis, testing methods, a gluten-free diet, etc.   Subscribe to Celiac.com's FREE weekly eNewsletter   What are the major symptoms of celiac disease? Celiac Disease Symptoms What testing is available for celiac disease? - list blood tests, endo with biopsy, genetic test and enterolab (not diagnostic) Celiac Disease Screening Interpretation of Celiac Disease Blood Test Results Can I be tested even though I am eating gluten free? How long must gluten be taken for the serological tests to be meaningful? The Gluten-Free Diet 101 - A Beginner's Guide to Going Gluten-Free Is celiac inherited? Should my children be tested? Ten Facts About Celiac Disease Genetic Testing Is there a link between celiac and other autoimmune diseases? Celiac Disease Research: Associated Diseases and Disorders Is there a list of gluten foods to avoid? Unsafe Gluten-Free Food List (Unsafe Ingredients) Is there a list of gluten free foods? Safe Gluten-Free Food List (Safe Ingredients) Gluten-Free Alcoholic Beverages Distilled Spirits (Grain Alcohols) and Vinegar: Are they Gluten-Free? Where does gluten hide? Additional Things to Beware of to Maintain a 100% Gluten-Free Diet What if my doctor won't listen to me? An Open Letter to Skeptical Health Care Practitioners Gluten-Free recipes: Gluten-Free Recipes

Caffeine & Autoimmune
0

Rate this topic

15 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Right now I am reading a really interesting book called Caffeine Blues.

What has gotten my attention is how frequently the author goes back to auto-immune problems being exacerbated or even CAUSED by excessive caffeine.

It works two ways - caffeine exhausts your adrenal glands so that your body either can't respond to allergens or over-reacts. It also destroys the mucosa lining in your gut ("leaky gut" anyone?) so that food gets through the lining under-digested and your body responds to it as an allergen.

There are other things, but those are the two things that stuck out to me.

More than anything, though, I'm really concerned about my own auto-immune problems and all the various ways caffeine could be making it much, much worse. Not to mention the dependency on it means that I have such terrible problems getting out of bed in the morning, so I don't get up early to exercise, which contributes to feeling even crappier and having more weight issues.

The authors points out study after study that shows there is NO "moderate" amount of caffeine. Different people are affected in different ways, but no one gets off scot-free.

Today I'm going to start working on going caffeine-free. It takes three weeks to rid it from your system, according to this guy (that seems to agree with my previous experiences), so sometime around the New Year I'll try to report back on how it has gone - how it has affected my stomach problems, energy problems, etc.

I'm hoping to draw some attention to this, since EVERY person on this board has an immune problem! And hoping to hear from anyone here who has gone caffeine-free and seen an improvement. Wish me luck! And I'll report back.

In the meantime, the book is Caffeine Blues by Stephen Cherniske. I'm in no way affiliated with the author, etc. I read many nutrition & health books, and find most of them to be total junk. I only pay attention when the facts presented are backed up by heavy research, and this book is full of HUNDREDS of references to research published in respected journals. Otherwise I wouldn't give it a second glance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:
Ads by Google:


I can't be of much help because I abandoned caffeine long before gluten and everything else. It was my first intolerance :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Research can be spun to make it mean what you want it to. I have a very hard time believing that caffeine causes autoimmune diseases. There are also studies that show that moderate amounts of coffee is good for you and tea... well there are so many studies on the benefits of black and green teas which both contain caffeine.

What is his background? Sounds like hyperbole to me. If you want to cut it, I'm sure it's not going to hurt you, but I wouldn't give up my coffee and tea over that.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've never really been able to tolerate caffeine, so I've mostly been caffeine-free by default most of my life. I can handle about one cup of coffee without overt symptoms. At the second cup, my stomach turns, I get jittery and shaky if my stomach is empty, and I get very lethargic and sleepy but unable to truly fall asleep. As a child a drop of caffeine after 12 noon would keep me up for a good chunk of the night.

Altho, I can tolerate green tea pretty well, and other milder caffeine sources, but I haven't been partaking of late. When I first got to Ireland I was taking one cup of black tea every morning and it was really nice, actually, but I stopped for various reasons. I haven't noticed a difference being 100% caffeine free except that it's ever so slightly harder to get going in the morning...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a caffeine intolerance which has gotten progressively worse over the last year to the point now that I can't tolerate it at all really. I gave up all soda, tea and coffee about 9 months ago.

Three weeks ago I went to the cinemas and got a frozen coke for the first time in 3 years. I was so sick for the next however many days it wasn't funny. I've never been good with soda in general but this was the first time I was throwing up multiple times and still sick more than three days later.

I feel ten times better off the caffeine and soda, which is a pity because I really love coffee. Whether the intolerance is inherited or simply a result of my stomach lining being really screwed up, I'm not sure but at this stage I think it's a little of both.

For most people with celiac disease or a gluten intolerance, I think it would probably be mainly due to the gut lining. While dealing with your intolerances and things that will make them worse is a step forward, it is not the same thing as healing our gut which is really what needs to be done in order to feel well again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:


I had awful seizure type migraines on coffee. Gave up coffee before gluten and though I still had migraines on gluten they were completely different. Now I don't feel like I'm forcing myself to run on empty. When tired I rest.

Coffee really messes with your endocrine system, cortisol levels etc. I think even after nearly 5 months of not drinking it my body is still recovering from the adrenal exhaustion effects! I have the book. It is a bit cursory in places and doesn't fully explain things but I guess if you feel better off of coffee than on then that can only be a good thing! :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Research can be spun to make it mean what you want it to. I have a very hard time believing that caffeine causes autoimmune diseases. There are also studies that show that moderate amounts of coffee is good for you and tea... well there are so many studies on the benefits of black and green teas which both contain caffeine.

What is his background? Sounds like hyperbole to me. If you want to cut it, I'm sure it's not going to hurt you, but I wouldn't give up my coffee and tea over that.

I so agree with this. Guess I should google Stephen Cherniske's credentials. I suspect they may be "interesting". I've been around too long to believe everything I read.

WhenDee, if you want to give up caffeine because of what Stephen Cherniske says, that's fine with me. And I know that some people do not tolerate caffeine (or hundreds of other random things). I've been drinking coffee for over 50 years so am not about to give it up now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:


a quick Google for his name shows that he is "Chief Scientific Officer" for some MLM scheme, and his degree in nutrition is in question from a non-accredited university.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He does have a master's degree in nutrition, but it still sounds like a bit over the top to me. I'd like to know how coffee causes adrenal exhaustion and how they proved that. I'm dealing with adrenal issues now and they are really hard to diagnose and figure out. I'm seeing a famous endocrinologist who is a researcher and teaches at UCLA and at another medical school and even he doesn't have all the answers.

Adrenal fatigue isn't really proven either and it's a controversial subject. Adrenal crisis, Addison's disease and Cushings are proven and hypoalosteronism which is what I have but I'm not sure how they would prove a link between "adrenal exhuastion" and coffee. I'd like to see research on coffee drinking and people with verifiable diseases.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

a quick Google for his name shows that he is "Chief Scientific Officer" for some MLM scheme, and his degree in nutrition is in question from a non-accredited university.

Nice Googling, Reba!

Our puritanical, drug-bashing society really wants to make caffeine into a villain. It's just not so simple. Caffeine is anti-inflammatory, and coffee drinking may protect against Alzheimer's. Caffeine is also immunomodulatory and the latest idea is that it might help folks with TH1 dominant autoimmunity.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16540173

As for so-called adrenal fatigue, don't even get me started. :angry:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:


It's interesting to me how defensive people get about their coffee!

The same site that mentions his degree ALSO states that the university was accredited when he received his degree, and lost its accreditation 15 years after his graduation, after an administration change.

But it wasn't Cherniske who convinced me. It was all that pesky science he used, and the many, many studies he referenced. I paid most attention to the parts regarding gut and immune problems.

If it isn't for you, or you're too addicted to even consider it, that is nothing to me. I posted because I thought it might help someone. But you don't have to make ugly comments or try to discredit it based on faulty information. You could always just IGNORE the post, you know. You might be discouraging someone else who would really benefit from the info.

I'm willing to try anything to improve my health. I'm not going to compromise it by clinging to a drug addiction. If it turns out going caffeine free doesn't help my stomach, well, at least I'll be sleeping better and have whiter teeth!

PS... Out of curiosity I searched Pubmed (referenced above) and found SEVERAL published studies that say caffeine affects the immune system in numerous negative ways...

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's interesting to me how defensive people get about their coffee!

The same site that mentions his degree ALSO states that the university was accredited when he received his degree, and lost its accreditation 15 years after his graduation, after an administration change.

But it wasn't Cherniske who convinced me. It was all that pesky science he used, and the many, many studies he referenced. I paid most attention to the parts regarding gut and immune problems.

If it isn't for you, or you're too addicted to even consider it, that is nothing to me. I posted because I thought it might help someone. But you don't have to make ugly comments or try to discredit it based on faulty information. You could always just IGNORE the post, you know. You might be discouraging someone else who would really benefit from the info.

I'm willing to try anything to improve my health. I'm not going to compromise it by clinging to a drug addiction. If it turns out going caffeine free doesn't help my stomach, well, at least I'll be sleeping better and have whiter teeth!

PS... Out of curiosity I searched Pubmed (referenced above) and found SEVERAL published studies that say caffeine affects the immune system in numerous negative ways...

Lashing out at all us "addicts" is not exactly constructive.

Do you realize that book was published in 1998? The research in it is over 13 years out of date. Also did you look at his other books? This guy likes to make money off fad science. He has a whole book on using DHEA for crying out loud. That stuff is dangerous.

For every article in Pubmed that you find about caffeine and methylxanthines that is negative, I'll find one that is positive. Your book is "spun" negative but that doesn't make it right. It just makes it profoundly biased. I can pick and choose articles from Pubmed to support just about any hypothesis and make it look scientific. It would be easy to write a book on the health benefits of coffee consumption. I could even slap my Ph.D. from a much better university on the cover. It wouldn't sell though. People are looking for a villain at the bookstore and in puritanical America, drugs are an obvious choice.

Also, there is genetic polymorphism in adenosine receptors and in P450 metabolism that profoundly affects a given individual's response to caffeine. I'd be willing to bet money that almost none of the studies this fellow cites take those into account when selecting the study populations or evaluating dosages. A lot of caffeine research is essentially comparing apples to oranges.

If caffeine makes you feel ill, definitely don't drink it. I do genuinely hope that you have found something that helps you feel better. But please don't come here telling us that it's the be-all and end-all cure for autoimmunity based on one fellow's obviously biased and very out-of-date book.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When-dee I was just discussing and I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings. To me it was an interesting discussion with differing points of view. I'm sorry if you felt attacked because I don't think anyone intended that.

I actually gave up coffee with all my health issues right now because it didn't feel good drinking it. I'm drinking black tea in the mornings instead. The research on the benefits of tea is extensive and I haven't heard it disputed either.

But you have to do what works for you. Coffee and tea are God given natural substances and for many people they are fine. If you don't feel good drinking them and you feel better caffeine free then do it. Personally I am moderate in my caffeine intake. I do think that people go way overboard and drink far too much of it. They are compounding it by drinking coffee, tea and soda. For me I have two servings of caffeine. One cup of tea or coffee in the morning and one in the afternoon if I want a pick me up.

I never drink soda because I do believe soda is poison. That's the study I want to see. Rates of cancer and other diseases among high soda drinkers. I'd like to see studies on diet soda too. I think diet soda is so bad you may as well just drink a little bit of cyanide everyday as drink diet soda. I won't touch it. Soda is pure chemicals and either sugar or fake sugar- more chemicals. Except for taste, it has not one redeeming value, it can't be found in nature, and I've never seen a study that actually says it's good for you. Sadly, soda is such a staple in our society, they might not be able to find very many people who don't drink it to compare with the heavy drinkers.

But that's me. There are others who will say their soda is fine and I say have at it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe it. I used to drink coffee a lot. Maybe a Dunkin Donuts extra up to 4 times a day sometimes. Sometimes more. Then one day, I was home. I made some fresh coffee from some beans and I added it to a french press with some clean water.

I had a really bad panic attack. I had to go to the hospital. I thought the world was ending and I started roaming around, fearing for my life and with high anxiety. That was years ago. Every now and then I try some coffee beans and I get the same thing. I've been to the hospital at least 2x and I saw some doctors and a psychiatrist. They don't know what's wrong with me. I psychiatrist gave me a diagnosis of "mood disorder" which is sooooo broad a conclusion. They said that they could offer me some drugs and meetings and counselling sessions but I declined.

I decided to improve my diet and lose a lot of weight and stay off the coffee. Since then I've been better. If the coffee is the cheap kind and its DECAF I only get a little bit of the jitters. But anytime I eat lots of chocolate, I get anxious feelings and I'm afraid to fall asleep because I think I might die.

Anyway, that's the short of it. I'm going to take coffee and chocolate more seriously and stay away from sources of caffeine. I wouldn't wish my condition on anyone. I was so strong when I was young. Now I feel like I have a broken body.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome albybaby!

Wanted to let you know the original poster hasn't been back since their last post in this thread a year ago. There is no problem adding info to older threads - just start a new one if you are wanting to start a conversation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Ads by Google:


Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      108,146
    • Total Posts
      939,918
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      66,132
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    Whhyyy
    Joined
  • Popular Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Just wondering if you have an update at all? Going through the same thing at the the moment with my type 1 14 yr old. I would be interested to know what your gi said and how your daughters doing now? xx
    • Please check the date on post, you just responded and tried talking to a person from 7 years ago. On consideration to the subject Poatoes are a huge flare factor for my UC and cause my blood sugar to sky rocket...I am not even diabetic but for some reason potatoes (hash browns) that I tried a few months ago with some eggs shot it up over 400. not even a control test with table sugar managed that.
    • Have you tried eliminating high glycemic foods? Fruits, added sugars, starchy grains, potatoes. etc? Also adding in slow digesting fibers and fats can prevent insulin spikes, MCT oil is also known to help and protein. Many find consuming nuts and seeds higher in fiber early on in the meal or before a meal can slow down insulin responses and prevent spikes. I always tend to eat a hand full of whole shell pumpkin seeds, hemp seeds, cocoa nibs, etc. while fixing my food, this gets me starting to feel fuller sooner, and seems to help in over all down the road. I know I had some references somewhere to these. I know I read somewhere about the antioxidants in in whole shell seeds like pumpkin and hemp also helped the body regulate insulin levels.
    • Dear AWOL Cast Iron Stomach, Your husband is right bread is bad for you. Of course it's more than bread and gluten, until now it was amateur hour trying to self diagnose and tame this "lion". However they let you down. You slipped through the cracks over and over again it is not your fault your not the Dr. You made mistakes and errors acting like a celiac , not knowing for sure you were, and not feeling like you could fully claim to be or reach out for support . Now you know your husband was closer than any Dr. up until now to determine your illness. Now something is in your record, now hopefully you will be dismissed less,respected more, maybe they will realize its an actual condition going on- not all in your head. Will they? Who knows! Do you care? This is now official, now explained, you not only have to give up gluten, but milk, and corn. In fact give up 98% of processed anything. The cluster of lifetime symptoms were not  "just you", "in your head", "you are not a difficult patient", "when the Dr or nurse looks at you like a nut job you don't have to feel the dismissiveness and condescension. It's an illness and nothing to be shameful of  what is shameful is they and their colleagues missed you failed you. In fact being missed for 4 decades is unjust to you. You were missed time and time again from age 5 to 43, decade after decade after decade, symptom after symptom. It's not that you didn't try from the 5 year old begging to go to the Dr, to the 20 going to the hospital again for another bout of gastroenteritis hoping to get an IV, to the thirty year old saying something is wrong why is this happening, to the forty something a restaurant fed me gluten when I asked for gluten-free, I have been gluten free for 3 1/2 years ,  I have more symptoms and pain than before . I felt so good for those gluten-free years- please help me-make it stop. So many things explained it makes you experience a range of emotions. Grateful: Relief and gratefulness someone finally agreed to send you to someone to test you. She saw past the other diagnosis' and the albatross IBS diagnosis. All the ages and stages of symptoms are explained they all fit. Everyone of them! Someone else also has had them. You are not alone. Read the forum-you fit like a glove. Anger: Anger for the way you have been treated by the medical community, family, some ex boyfriends, friends and coworkers. Anger for the length of time you endured this. Hurt: Hurt for the times people said unkind things to you when you were symptomatic or flaring . you are experiencing symptoms that change your body people are rude to congratulate you on a "pregnancy" you didn't announce or ask why you are not slim when you hardly eat. you are not over emotional -  you are suffering from neuro symptoms, you are not making this up for attention Sad & Guilty: Can I work again? Do I want to work again? What kind of work can I do now? Can I find a job and work PT from home? You didn't envision this your husband having to be sole bread winner now what? I am overwhelmed thinking about this-stop? You now have closure and know how and why you lost your first pregnancy. You now know why you were high risk, complications,  with your children in Pregnancy & Delivery that they couldn't be explained back then It explains why in pregnancy you lost weight and why your morning sickness was extreme and seemed to last longer than anyone you knew,  that your Puppp rash was likely misdiagnosed DH It is not your fault none of it. Please forgive yourself for what you did not know. Your children forgive you. Believe them when they say its not your fault. You can cry, but you can no longer blame yourself. You are a good mother just one with an illness your children will learn to accept. Withdrawn: Why are you withdrawing from your husband? Should you ask him if he wants a divorce? Should you push him away? You didn't know before marriage what was happening you knew something autoimmune was brewing shortly after, but nothing showed on tests. Was this unfair to do to him? Doesn't he deserve someone better? Someone well? Now you can't retire and travel the world as society retirement cliché dictates. Can you afford this illness ? How will this financially impact your spouse, your family?. Why did you do this to this poor man? You are so selfish, you wanted marriage and kids, but was this fair to them? Don't your kids deserve a healthier mom? How will this impact them? Oh my gosh are they going to get this too? Will they grow to resent you? Your illness and diet has taken over their lives! Oh gosh no one say hi to me-please. I hate people and I am too sick to pretend and be fake friendly today. I don't want to tell you I am ill. I don't want to talk about this. I have to absorb this. I hate you people for being healthy. Don't tell me I don't look well. I will snap, I don't want to snap, I am irritable ,and don't feel well. Just keep giving off the unapproachable vibe keep them away.  Am I strong enough to do this? Acceptance: Calm down the inflammation, lack of nutrients, and GI damage is messing with your head. Your husband said for better for worse. Your kids have no choice you are their mother and you are a good mom -you have always been, always will be even on your worst day. If they get this they will be ok. You are strong enough to do this you are just ill and most importantly you must remain here in case they get this so you can guide them and be there for them. Got it? Go on the forum you are not alone it will be ok. You will get this lion back in the cage and manage it. It will be ok. If you can't travel in retirement one day you will find other hobbies or things to occupy your time. He's not going to leave you over this. If he does it will be ok. You'll manage-you always do. You have an answer, you knew it was coming, keep reading, learning, seeking support, and one day it will all work out. You will process all this and will be at peace-until then keep going and above all AVOID GLUTEN!    
    • I know for certain gastritis  is one of the main reasons I had the scope. That and my EOE symptoms . If it wasn’t for those I would have never been diagnosed 
  • Upcoming Events