• Join our community!

    Do you have questions about celiac disease or the gluten-free diet?

  • Ads by Google:
     




    Get email alerts Subscribe to Celiac.com's FREE weekly eNewsletter

    Ads by Google:



       Get email alertsSubscribe to Celiac.com's FREE weekly eNewsletter

  • Announcements

    • admin

      Frequently Asked Questions About Celiac Disease   09/30/2015

      This Celiac.com FAQ on celiac disease will guide you to all of the basic information you will need to know about the disease, its diagnosis, testing methods, a gluten-free diet, etc.   Subscribe to Celiac.com's FREE weekly eNewsletter   What are the major symptoms of celiac disease? Celiac Disease Symptoms What testing is available for celiac disease?  Celiac Disease Screening Interpretation of Celiac Disease Blood Test Results Can I be tested even though I am eating gluten free? How long must gluten be taken for the serological tests to be meaningful? The Gluten-Free Diet 101 - A Beginner's Guide to Going Gluten-Free Is celiac inherited? Should my children be tested? Ten Facts About Celiac Disease Genetic Testing Is there a link between celiac and other autoimmune diseases? Celiac Disease Research: Associated Diseases and Disorders Is there a list of gluten foods to avoid? Unsafe Gluten-Free Food List (Unsafe Ingredients) Is there a list of gluten free foods? Safe Gluten-Free Food List (Safe Ingredients) Gluten-Free Alcoholic Beverages Distilled Spirits (Grain Alcohols) and Vinegar: Are they Gluten-Free? Where does gluten hide? Additional Things to Beware of to Maintain a 100% Gluten-Free Diet What if my doctor won't listen to me? An Open Letter to Skeptical Health Care Practitioners Gluten-Free recipes: Gluten-Free Recipes
0
erikamarie87

Gaps Or Scd? Opinions & Advice Please!

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Ok I seem to be Extremely confused on this subject..What diet do I go with GAPS or SCD?? From what I'm understanding is GAPS was established on the basis of the SCD. My question though is How do you know which one to go by? I've been reading a lot of success stories with people following the SCD but also finding people who found that SCD didn't work and went on the GAPS vise verca...??? I've been doing a TON of research on the SCD but seem to come out empty handed when it comes to all my questions about the specifics of the diet? It seems as though GAPS is wayyyy easier to find information on as the SCD is not. Does it boil down to one's symptoms? I'm finding that SCD is always mentioned when it comes to Chrohn's, Colitis, etc. I understand that SCD is from the finding's of Dr. Hass for Celiac Disease and that is what's intrigued me to dig deeper on the subject as I am fighting SOOO many underlying problems that going Gluten Free alone has not helped with. Maybe for better understanding of my situation somebody can give me hopefully some Helpful advice with clear understanding.

So let me begin,

3 Years ago my twin sister brought to my attention that she seemed to be suffering from Celiac, well at that point I was 93 lbs and was Extremely sick all the time. Without question I went Gluten Free Instantly as she recommended. I found relief within a few days and after a week I realized I hadn't had the throwing up or gastro problems. I felt A LOT Better.

Well now after 3 years of being Gluten Free I'm no longer suffering the diarrhea, throwing up, acid reflux, etc (unless glutened) although ALL of my other symptoms/problems have not improved what so ever!!!

I'm 24 and on Disability due to the inability to hold down a job. Emberrassing enough to say those words I want and NEED Help More NOW than ever!!! I suffer from a wide range of symptoms, my diagnosis's are: Bipolar II (mainly severe depression), Anxiety/Panic Disorder, ADD, OCD, Borderline Personality, CHRONIC FATIGUE!!! (My Main Concern!), as well as self diagnosed Celiac. Now these are my "Diagnosis's".

The symptoms and theories I have are as follows: Candidiasis (which I believe is more severe than any doctor could see) If I eat sugar I wake up drenched in sweat, get Extremely irritable, Lethargic, and many many more reasons. Also I KNOW I have more food intolerance's but am in the process of trying to figure them out?...

The last 4 days or so my eyes are soo swollen I have to ice them often and put vaseline on my eyelids because they itch so bad and are flaking from being so dry! I'm congested every morning when I wake up, as if I all of a sudden caught a severe cold. My throat feels swollen most of the time, having a hard time swallowing things often. I ache all over, some days are better than others. I'm soooo Extremely lethargic and drained of ANY energy what so ever all I can do is try and stay awake by taking my Adderral as prescribed and drink caffeine just to get through the day.

The thing that's scaring me the most is my Brain!!! I'm totally not with it! I feel daized and confused, very slowed down, slurred speech at times, Very Foggy! I can't remember anything anymore and I constantly feel like I'm not in "reality" almost like an out of body experience...?? It's sooo hard to explain I'm hoping somebody can relate to me on some level :( Also my eyesight use to be perfect vision and now I'm in reading glasses, bifocals, and now going to Eye Therapy b/c of Convergence Insufficiency.

With all this being said, I'm just hoping somebody can steer me in the right direction as far as if GAPS would be better than doing the SCD or SCD better than GAPS or maybe combining them (if that's possible)??? I just really feel as though my gut is soooo messed up I need to heal it to start to even try to figure out what I'm intolerant to or anything else...???

Can Somebody please HELP with answers!!! I would very much appreciate ANY help I could get! Thank You!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:
Ads by Google:


I would go GAPS with all the mental symptoms. You probably need to do GAPS introduction which has a really intensive gut-healing phase. Malabsorption and nutrient deficiency can do really bad things to your mind.

Full GAPS (what you eventually transition to from GAPS intro) and SCD are pretty much the same. GAPS has more emphasis on bone broth is all. Also you can do GAPS dairy-free because the probiotic can be homemade sauerkraut rather than SCD 24-hour yogurt. Make sure you are tolerating the sauerkraut. I am sensitive to tyramine and I do better taking a probiotic pill.

You also need to have your thyroid function tested. Your problems could be partly due to hypothyroidism.

I'd also recommend you look into a supplement for mental illness. I found EMPowerPlus from http://www.truehope.com to be life-changing for my bipolar and anxiety. I take it every day with some fish oil.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go GAPS with all the mental symptoms. You probably need to do GAPS introduction which has a really intensive gut-healing phase. Malabsorption and nutrient deficiency can do really bad things to your mind.

Full GAPS (what you eventually transition to from GAPS intro) and SCD are pretty much the same. GAPS has more emphasis on bone broth is all. Also you can do GAPS dairy-free because the probiotic can be homemade sauerkraut rather than SCD 24-hour yogurt. Make sure you are tolerating the sauerkraut. I am sensitive to tyramine and I do better taking a probiotic pill.

You also need to have your thyroid function tested. Your problems could be partly due to hypothyroidism.

I'd also recommend you look into a supplement for mental illness. I found EMPowerPlus from http://www.truehope.com to be life-changing for my bipolar and anxiety. I take it every day with some fish oil.

Girl you're a Godsend! Really! I appreciate all your help. :) I was reading your profile some and can relate to you with a lot of what you've experienced. I was actually going to ask you about the EMPowerPlus. :) I react so differently to meds than anyone. MY doctors can't understand why...I get ALL the side effects from everyone of them and have never truly found any that work that well. I've learned to just go day by day...:/ I am SOOOO Interested in this product! What would you recommend as far as where to start with coming off my meds and trying this product?...I have many more questions but I won't overwhelm you with them! lol Sorry If I already have. I have a hard time figuring out where to start with anything. The docs say my brain is wired from top down unlike most who think bottom up... :(

On to the other part of my problems... :blink: I'm wanting to start the diet soon and am doing all I can to get prepared..?? :unsure:

You say the GAPS "can" be dairy free but I thought that fermenting the yogurt for the 24 hrs made it so it was basically dairy free from the fermentation it took all the lactose out?...I don't think I'll be able to stomach sauerkraut! :huh: It's one of those things I can't even smell, I've just never liked it. So I'll probably have to take some probiotics...

My doc tested my TSH level in January and the results were 0.88 mIU/L, normal range being 0.34-5.60..?? Is there a different test I can ask for?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you're thinking of EMPowerPlus I'd highly recommend you speak to someone in their call center. They're not doctors but they help people transition from meds to EMPowerPlus all the time so they have quite a bit of experience. They're really sweet and supportive too and most of the people in the call center are on EMPowerPlus themselves. It can be a bit of an interesting road becasue you can feel really weird starting the EMPowerPlus. They say it's "detox" but I think it's the unaccustomed flood of vitamins and minerals changing your mental chemistry. Whatever it is, it seems to amplify med side effects so you have to cross-taper your meds and the EMPowerPlus. TrueHope has a lot of tricks and supplements like amino acids that can get you through any trouble you have with the transition and the call center will help you with a protocol.

It took me about three months to do the changeover from meds to EMPowerPlus, a month of cross-taper and two months of feeling really odd. After three months the clouds parted and the bipolar was gone almost like magic. My shrink couldn't believe it. :lol: The only mood swings I've had in the last 5 1/2 years since I started EMPowerPlus were thyroid-related.

As for the diets, dairy-free and lactose-free are not the same. Yogurt is still dairy and it has whey and casein (milk proteins) you can react to.

That TSH is very good so it's probably not thyroid. I'd look more at the food intolerance and I bet GAPS helps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      108,922
    • Total Posts
      943,520
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      67,127
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    GlutenFreeBree
    Joined
  • Popular Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I know-pretty dumb. I'm usually very careful. I didn't check into it. Thanks for reply. DebLee
    • LexieA, This thread might help you. You say you never have "heartburn/GERD". You can have something called Silent Reflux. It  could also be NERD. some of these links are in this thread but I will post some releavent information in this reply as well. here is a good overview of the difference in this fox news article. http://www.foxnews.com/health/2012/11/13/gerd-or-nerd-new-type-acid-reflux-doesnt-respond-to-drugs.html but if your throwing up it is probably from Bile Relfux. . . . instead of acid reflux. I actually wrote a blog post on celiac.com about these conditions. the NYTimes article called Bile Reflux a "Shadowland" in Medicine and part of the reason for the title of the post. here is the NYtimes article about some of the issues you are describing. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/30/health/30brod.html throwing up is actually a protective reaction. and this normally protect us from poison's or food poisioning etc. but when our biofeedack loop is broken down like having bile in the stomach instead of the small intestine . . . it can be hard to break this cycle. The green portion is probably the bile portion. It is actually very caustic as Plumbago pointed out.  this would/coul scald our insides (lower GI/Small Intestines). Normally stomach acid is neutralized by bile after it leaves the stomach . .. not while in the stomach. I wouldn't never recommend anybody do this on purpose . .. but if you are already puking your food up then simply buy a pH test kit. testing your food/chyme/puke (food outside the body) you will quickly get an idea of how acidic/basic your food chyme (digested food) is. It will almost be a pH of 4.0 or more. the paleo nurse explains this well why strong stomach acid is important to your health. http://thepaleonurse.com/the-truth-about-stomach-acid-why-low-stomach-acid-is-jeopardizing-your-health/ quoting the paleonurse. "In the infinite wisdom of the human body, the stomach was designed to produce the acid that is necessary for proper digestion of food.  When functioning properly, the parietal cells of the stomach secrete hydrochloric acid that bring the stomach pH to a range of approximately 1.5 to 3.0" if it is a higher pH than this you can benefit from taking BetaineHCL to restore your stomach acid to more natural level. . . especially if you are not already taking PPI's since a proton pump inhibitor is lowering stomach acid. .. . by their very ability to cut off almost all stomach acid production. **** this is not medical advice I only know taking powdered stomach acid (BetaineHCL capsules)  helped me. I was not barfing my meals though. . . so your experience my be different. Maybe Ennis_tx will comment because he has some of the same symptom's/issues. But if I was puking I think I would be curios to know what my pH really is? And not Assume? anything at this point. If you test your stomach pH with easy to buy pH strips you will know whether it really is high pH (low stomach acid or a little stomach acid as your describe it) or low pH (really high stomach aid) that is causing the issue's. Once you know for sure you  will know who to go about correcting it. Supplementing with BetaineHCL is fairly harmless . . .unless you have an ulcer. And you will/would probably know it instantly if you take some BetaineHCL and it feels like someone is putting out a cigarette in the middle of your stomach.  It is acid burning your sore/ulcer. thankfully eating protein/food quickly neutralizes/raises stomach acid especially when taken with a glass of water. staying hydrated with a meal also helps improve digestion so be sure to take some water/drink like a tea or juice etc. for example if you want to the BetaineHCL to work properly. Milk has the opposite effect.  If you feel a burning milk can coat the lining of your stomach helping to erase/ease the effect of strong acid. And why people who eat hot **** five alarm peppers aka known as Hot heads keep milk close by if they need to dampen the fire in their stomachs from eating too many peppers. . . . and drinking water can aggravate this practice of eating the hottest peppers you can find. I hope this is helpful. I have rambled on long enough. be sure to read the sickboy user in the medhelp thread of how he helped his GERD/bile reflux. here is medhelp link for easy reference included in the "silent reflux" thread if you haven't read it yet. https://www.medhelp.org/posts/Gastroenterology/UNCONTROLLABLE-BILE-REFLUX-PLEASE-HELP/show/738242?page=1 he was suffering for 5 years and got better so don't lose hope. It can seem very daunting but people on this board do get better. we have used different methods but people do get better. again this is not medical advice just things that have helped me. good luck on your continued journey but it is not a long way back if you know the way. 2 Corinthians (KJV) 1:3,4 3) “Blessed be God, even the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of mercies, and the God of all comfort; 4) who comforteth us in all our tribulation, that we may be able to comfort them (sufferer still suffering)   which are in any trouble, by the comfort wherewith we ourselves are comforted of God.” posterboy by the grace of God,    
    • LOL sorry but really? You trust that, dominos, papa johns, and pizza hut ALL say they can not 100% guarantee their gluten-free pizza are celiac safe. THEY USE the same prep areas, same ingredient bins, same ovens and in many cases the same cutters and spoons used to spread the sauces and cut the pizza. I doubt the employees would even bother changing gloves between pizzas during rush.   Seriously if you want a gluten free pizza....gut a premade one in the freezer section from UDI, Dayia, RealGoodPizza or a crust from cappellos or califlower foods and make your own....Here please save yourself here is a list. BTW Pizza hut uses UDI crust and just tops them with their sauce etc....CCing in most cases and delivering them. Also the REAL good pizza will mail you cases of their pizzas fully made. Califlour foods and capello will mail you empty crust by the case. SO you can order them if  local stores do not carry them.


      http://udisglutenfree.com/product-category/pizza-crust/
      https://daiyafoods.com/
      http://iansnaturalfoods.com/products/gluten-free-cheesy-french-bread-pizza/
      https://www.geefree.com/collections/all/products/cheese-pizza-pocketshttps://cappellos.com/collections/pizza
      *^Grain Free Pizza crust to make your own with using eggs, coconut and arrowroot for a base crust blend. The Naked pizza crust is dairy free. Order frozen by the case and they ship them to you.
      https://realgoodfoods.com/productpage/
      *^Grain Free Pizza They use Dairy Cheese blended with chicken breast to form personal pizza crust. You can order them frozen and shipped to you. NEW PRODUCTS they do Enchiladas NOW
      https://www.califlourfoods.com/collections
      *^ This is the only one I buy, grain free, low carb crust, and the plant based one is great, NOTE these make a New york style flat crust, I use 15 min prebake before adding toppings to make them extra crispy
      http://glutenfreedelights.com/our-sandwiches/
      ^Gluten free hot pockets? YES they make them for when you need the old instant hotpocket, odd craving but I know they hit sometimes.
      CRUST MIXES Grain free
      https://www.simplemills.com/collections/all/products/almond-flour-pizza-crust-mix
      https://julianbakery.com/product/paleo-pizza-crust-mix-gluten-grain-free/
    • My MRI has been clear. They did a spinal tap back in May which was also good.  MS ruled out many times. All my symptoms match Gluten Ataxia, but I don't know for sure since I don't have a dx. However, I DO have Hashimotos so at least going Gluten Free is necessary for that. I go to my Rheumatologist on Jan. 30th, 2018. Can a Rheumatologist determine Gluten Ataxia? If so how long should I be back on Gluten for testing?  Thanks for the heads up on Free and Clear products. I will look into that.
  • Upcoming Events