• Ads by Google:
     




    Get email alerts Celiac.com E-Newsletter

    Ads by Google:



       Get email alertsCeliac.com E-Newsletter

  • Announcements

    • admin

      Frequently Asked Questions About Celiac Disease   09/30/2015

      This Celiac.com FAQ on celiac disease will guide you to all of the basic information you will need to know about the disease, its diagnosis, testing methods, a gluten-free diet, etc.   Subscribe to FREE Celiac.com email alerts   What are the major symptoms of celiac disease? Celiac Disease Symptoms What testing is available for celiac disease? - list blood tests, endo with biopsy, genetic test and enterolab (not diagnostic) Celiac Disease Screening Interpretation of Celiac Disease Blood Test Results Can I be tested even though I am eating gluten free? How long must gluten be taken for the serological tests to be meaningful? The Gluten-Free Diet 101 - A Beginner's Guide to Going Gluten-Free Is celiac inherited? Should my children be tested? Ten Facts About Celiac Disease Genetic Testing Is there a link between celiac and other autoimmune diseases? Celiac Disease Research: Associated Diseases and Disorders Is there a list of gluten foods to avoid? Unsafe Gluten-Free Food List (Unsafe Ingredients) Is there a list of gluten free foods? Safe Gluten-Free Food List (Safe Ingredients) Gluten-Free Alcoholic Beverages Distilled Spirits (Grain Alcohols) and Vinegar: Are they Gluten-Free? Where does gluten hide? Additional Things to Beware of to Maintain a 100% Gluten-Free Diet What if my doctor won't listen to me? An Open Letter to Skeptical Health Care Practitioners Gluten-Free recipes: Gluten-Free Recipes Where can I buy gluten-free stuff? Support this site by shopping at The Celiac.com Store.

Celiac Vaccine? Not For Me
0

96 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

notme!    287

hey grodey - i read your link to a blog quoting an article about a study.  ya got me.  gimme the shot.   oh, wait.  there isn't one........

 

eating gluten free is the best shot we have so far?  no?  who knows how long one was going to live if they didn't die.  pesky death   <_<

 

and everybody on this board is going to heal up juuuuust fine, because we're less than 10% of all celiacs  :)

  • Upvote 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ads by Google:
Ads by Google:


Wow what a gross generalization about many doctors and scientists working together for the ultimate benefit of society. That's not how it works at all.

You think Big Pharma wants to cure disease? Think again.

There may be a few altruistic doctors out there, but Big Pharma isn't going to fund their research. The goal is to produce a drug that the patient becomes dependent upon for life. And that is exactly what this drug is about. People will come to depend on it, and Big Pharma milks the cash cow.

Maybe you should get new glasses. The rose-color tint in the lenses might be affecting your thinking.

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lisa    457

I have enjoyed reading this thread. I love a good healthy discusion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
grodeylocks    8

So we shouldn't invest in alternative therapies?

hey grodey - i read your link to a blog quoting an article about a study.  ya got me.  gimme the shot.   oh, wait.  there isn't one........

 

eating gluten free is the best shot we have so far?  no?  who knows how long one was going to live if they didn't die.  pesky death   <_<

 

and everybody on this board is going to heal up juuuuust fine, because we're less than 10% of all celiacs   :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
grodeylocks    8

You clearly have no understanding of how Pharma works, and this is coming from someone who as a Biochemist knows the field in and out. I'm assuming you are also one of those people that believe MSG is the devil and that all vaccinations are bad. You can make your broad generalizations without any backing what so ever because of you're own pessimistic view of the world but however don't ruin it for the rest of us that would like to have a cure or at least some sort of protection from cross contamination.

 

You think Big Pharma wants to cure disease? Think again.

There may be a few altruistic doctors out there, but Big Pharma isn't going to fund their research. The goal is to produce a drug that the patient becomes dependent upon for life. And that is exactly what this drug is about. People will come to depend on it, and Big Pharma milks the cash cow.

Maybe you should get new glasses. The rose-color tint in the lenses might be affecting your thinking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Adalaide    361

You clearly have no understanding of how Pharma works, and this is coming from someone who as a Biochemist knows the field in and out. I'm assuming you are also one of those people that believe MSG is the devil and that all vaccinations are bad. You can make your broad generalizations without any backing what so ever because of you're own pessimistic view of the world but however don't ruin it for the rest of us that would like to have a cure or at least some sort of protection from cross contamination.

 

Pharmaceutical companies pay doctors to promote their drugs. This is a fact which is supported through the fact that there is complete visibility of this. I have seen my (previous) doctor's kickbacks on this. When he made it clear that he was interested in prescribing only name brand drugs, not things there were even generics for, for a medical condition he couldn't diagnose, it was obvious there was a problem with the way things were working. Many here have similar stories. I see the same damn thing with my husband. High cholesterol? Did his doctor ever tell him to change his diet? No, they prescribed a pill. High blood pressure? Did they advise a lifestyle and diet change? Nope. THERE'S A PILL FOR THAT!

 

Why the hell should we take medication for things that don't need to be medicated? The idea is beyond preposterous. I've said before, but because you don't care to read that part of what I wrote, protection from occasional CC is a good thing. For dining out, for traveling, that sort of thing. But a day to day pill for something that is easily remedied by lifestyle change is, in plain English, complete bulls$#& and moneygrubbing.

 

Once a drug is on the market the pharmaceutical company has one interest alone, making back the money they invested developing it. They run a business, they aren't philanthropists. I don't give two craps what industry you're in, you can't change the simple fact that they're in it for the money. That is what running a business is all about. Otherwise it would be called a charity.

  • Upvote 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
grodeylocks    8

Pharmaceutical companies pay doctors to promote their drugs. This is a fact which is supported through the fact that there is complete visibility of this. I have seen my (previous) doctor's kickbacks on this. When he made it clear that he was interested in prescribing only name brand drugs, not things there were even generics for, for a medical condition he couldn't diagnose, it was obvious there was a problem with the way things were working. Many here have similar stories. I see the same damn thing with my husband. High cholesterol? Did his doctor ever tell him to change his diet? No, they prescribed a pill. High blood pressure? Did they advise a lifestyle and diet change? Nope. THERE'S A PILL FOR THAT!

 

Why the hell should we take medication for things that don't need to be medicated? The idea is beyond preposterous. I've said before, but because you don't care to read that part of what I wrote, protection from occasional CC is a good thing. For dining out, for traveling, that sort of thing. But a day to day pill for something that is easily remedied by lifestyle change is, in plain English, complete bulls$#& and moneygrubbing.

 

Once a drug is on the market the pharmaceutical company has one interest alone, making back the money they invested developing it. They run a business, they aren't philanthropists. I don't give two craps what industry you're in, you can't change the simple fact that they're in it for the money. That is what running a business is all about. Otherwise it would be called a charity.

A vaccine wouldn't be something you take day to day. Oh yea pharmaceutical companies are horrible, why don't you tell that to all the cancer patients who are only alive today thanks to the development of modern drugs. Yup you're right. We secretly actually gather around in our labs and come up with ways to make you sick first. Then we purposely come up with drugs that don't cure you only keep you alive enough to keep you buying our product. Yup that's exactly how it works. This reminds me of a great saying, "never argue with an idiot, they'll drag you to their level and beat you with experience."

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kareng    1,992

All right, Kids!  This is not a forum to debate the evils or benefits or politics of "Big Pharma".   I think we know where everyone stands on the original question.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GFinDC    609
Gemini    785

For those of you interested this is a real good breakdown of why being gluten free simply is not enough. http://scdlifestyle.com/2012/03/the-gluten-free-lie-why-most-celiacs-are-slowly-dying/

Actually, it is enough for those of us who study this disease and how it works so we can make informed decisions on what and how we eat.  The amount of people who do not return to a normal, functioning life after a diagnosis of Celiac Disease are small, overall, or they have multiple issues/diseases or they haven't learned enough to make good choices regarding gluten free food.  You can't argue this nonsense with me because I came very close to dying 8 years ago and now live a normal life and am very active. If I can do that, most people can too.

 

Besides, because of the overlap in the small intestine, we have a back-up for parts that may not function as well, long term. It's God's little beautiful design built in to prevent starvation, when sections of the small intestine become damaged and may not heal.  Not many people take the time to learn that.  I don't care about all this as I am too busy living to waste any time on what Big Pharma is doing.  I have no desire to eat any other way so it's not an issue for me. Medication is never cheap and I can only imagine how much they would charge for that.

 

But keep on trying to make people even more paranoid that then already are about the gluten-free diet...that seems to be the object around here nowadays.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
nvsmom    332

For those of you interested this is a real good breakdown of why being gluten free simply is not enough. http://scdlifestyle.com/2012/03/the-gluten-free-lie-why-most-celiacs-are-slowly-dying/

 Those numbers looked alarming but I started checking us against the norm:

 

Where is says 56% of celiacs have poor vitamin status... well, somewhere between 40-75% of people are deficient in vit D, that would put as at about typical.

 

It says we have 72% increased chance of death in the first year if we have intestinal inflammation. A healthy middle aged woman would have a 5% chance of dying in the next 10 years. I'm not a math person, but I'm guessing that means I have a 0.5% chance of dying this year - if I assume that I have inflammation, then I have about a 0.6% chance of dying in my first year gluten-free.... Well "had" since I made it through my first year. ;)

 

Yes, it sucks that we got this disease, and yes it would be great if we could fix some of the permanent damage that we are left with, but it could be so much worse. For starters, we could be one of the majority of celiacs who are undiagnosed!

 

I would be interested in some drug that could repair me. I am not interested in some drug that could make it so I could eat gluten again - gluten has no nutritional value so why bother. It would be nice to have protection against accidental glutening during those times when I have less control over my food, like when travelling, but I don't need it for eating at home most days.

 

I don't see how a celiac vaccination would work... I had symptoms from babyhood, they would have had to vaccinate me as a newborn. And I am one of "those" who doesn't agree with vaccinations for babies or all at once. I have heard wayyy too many first hand "coincidental" medical stories from people who vaccinated against various diseases only to end up with that sickness (like chicken pox) or developed other health problems from it. I honestly don't think they help all individuals.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gemini    785

The vaccine thing.......someone with babies told me that kids in the US get something like 28 vaccines in their first 2 years.  That is insane.  Vaccines can be hard on the immune system, if given in many batches at once.  I really believe that's why we have a proliferance of mental problems with kids today.  The assault on their immune systems must be hard.  I think the ones like polio, diptheria, tetanus...things like that are good but 28 different vaccines?   :blink:  Between this and the messed up diets of kids today, no wonder autism has skyrocketed.  If you hadn't noticed, the overuse of vaccines in this country and explosion of Celiac has also coincided with the explosion in autism and other behavior that is not entirely normal.  I think there is a connection somewhere but proving that is going to be difficult. 

 

I think if you want to use a celiac vaccine, as an adult, you have choices. I think it brave of you to be the guinea pigs..... :)

 

And I apologize for high-jacking this thread but it was about a vaccine to begin with..... ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
grodeylocks    8

First point. There has never been any proven link that vaccines cause autism. That is a myth. In fact if it wasn't for the extensive vaccination campaigns our life expenctancies would be drastically different. In all honesty I would be more trustworthy of xenobiotics coming out of pharma then I would of herbal supplements coming out of your local health food store as at least the big pharma drugs have to go through extensive testing of which 99 percent of all drugs fail.

 

Second point. The enzyme based therapies would be cheap, and not unlike the digestive enzyme supplements. They would protect against cross contamination and would make it safer for us to eat out.

 

Third point. The vaccine is interesting because it is the first such vaccine being developed for an autoimmune condition and may hold promise in preventing the development of other autoimmune disorders in addition to potentially calming the cycle of inflammation and repair that continues to go on in our gut long after we adopt a gluten free diet.

 

I'm not saying lets get these drugs and eat unhealthy stuff again. I'm saying that this can become another tool in our fight against the disease in terms of protecting us against cross contamination or accidental glutenings. Will the vaccine have major side effects? I can't answer that now, but it doesnt mean that we shouldn't be conducting research on it. Can you really argue though with having a safety drug on you to protect when you eat out or from unseen accidental glutenings? And yes there are many people who take years to heal from this disease. I am a year and a half strictly gluten free and I am still not back to normal. Also, the zonulin modulating drug larazotide acetate shows promise for a multitude of autoimmune disorders and not only celiac disease and could be an amazing breakthrough. For those of you who aren't aware zonulin seems to play a major role in the triggering of celiac disease and regulates the intercellular tight junctions between epithelial cells. It has been shown to be spiked not only in celiacs but is also seen to spike prior to the development of other autoimmune disorders. It may also be the cause of leaky gut which we all know can cause us to be intolerant to all other sorts of foods other than gluten. It is possible that drug could be used to help speed up the repair of leaky gut.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
aeraen    24

It seems that pumping ourselves full of drugs to allow us to tolerate gluten is a bit like injecting everyone with a substance to make them glow so we can find them in the dark... rather then just turning on a light. 

 

We found a very simple solution... don't eat gluten.  Why do we need drugs in our systems?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gemini    785

First point. There has never been any proven link that vaccines cause autism. That is a myth. In fact if it wasn't for the extensive vaccination campaigns our life expenctancies would be drastically different. In all honesty I would be more trustworthy of xenobiotics coming out of pharma then I would of herbal supplements coming out of your local health food store as at least the big pharma drugs have to go through extensive testing of which 99 percent of all drugs fail.

 

Second point. The enzyme based therapies would be cheap, and not unlike the digestive enzyme supplements. They would protect against cross contamination and would make it safer for us to eat out.

 

Third point. The vaccine is interesting because it is the first such vaccine being developed for an autoimmune condition and may hold promise in preventing the development of other autoimmune disorders in addition to potentially calming the cycle of inflammation and repair that continues to go on in our gut long after we adopt a gluten free diet.

 

I'm not saying lets get these drugs and eat unhealthy stuff again. I'm saying that this can become another tool in our fight against the disease in terms of protecting us against cross contamination or accidental glutenings. Will the vaccine have major side effects? I can't answer that now, but it doesnt mean that we shouldn't be conducting research on it. Can you really argue though with having a safety drug on you to protect when you eat out or from unseen accidental glutenings? And yes there are many people who take years to heal from this disease. I am a year and a half strictly gluten free and I am still not back to normal. Also, the zonulin modulating drug larazotide acetate shows promise for a multitude of autoimmune disorders and not only celiac disease and could be an amazing breakthrough. For those of you who aren't aware zonulin seems to play a major role in the triggering of celiac disease and regulates the intercellular tight junctions between epithelial cells. It has been shown to be spiked not only in celiacs but is also seen to spike prior to the development of other autoimmune disorders. It may also be the cause of leaky gut which we all know can cause us to be intolerant to all other sorts of foods other than gluten. It is possible that drug could be used to help speed up the repair of leaky gut.

First point...there never will be any research to suggest or even prove that there is a link between vaccinations and autism because then the AMA and drug companies would be open to massive lawsuits.  Just like there are no warnings to women that long term use of the birth control pill "can" increase your risk of certain cancers later in life.  We have had an explosion of breast cancer in the past 30 years and what has been the one constant in those 30 years?  Women are pumping themselves with hormones, long term, to prevent pregnancy (which is a good thing in many cases) and there are downsides to that.  Doctors are not going to bring that up, just like they downplay the side effects of numerous Rx drugs.  I am not saying that all drugs are bad because sometimes the risks do not outweigh the benefits so you have to research carefully and make really informed choices.  I am also not against vaccines.

I though I made that clear but obviously you need to have it re-iterated a number of times for it sink in.  I am just against the number of vaccines that kids are pumped with today.

 

Second point....You really think enzyme based therapies are going to be cheap?  Really?  OTC enzymes, the good ones, are not cheap.  It's all about profit.  They may not be outrageously expensive but cheap?  I am not that naive.

 

Third point.....I have already calmed my immune system down by following a strict gluten-free diet.  I have 4 autoimmune diseases in total and have not developed another one and it's been 8 years gluten-free.  You seem to think this is impossible to achieve without pharmacological intervention.  I disagree.  If someone wants to use any Celiac vaccine, that's fine with me.  I probably won't but why is that a concern to anyone else?

 

Last point.....when you stop behaving like a victim, then you might heal.  What is this pervasive BS that so many people do not heal and lead normal lives?  You act like we cannot do this on our own and live to tell about it.  I was 94 pounds at diagnosis and had no medical intervention when diagnosed. I walked away and did my recovery myself and got further than I would have if I had been scrutinized by the AMA.  Many people are capable of this.  I know about zonulin, leaky gut and all the rest.  But I want to let others know that with persistence and a strict gluten-free diet and, most importantly, a good, positive attitude, you'd be surprised at what you can achieve.  Yes, it does take a long time, but it's the norm.  We live in a society that has taught us to go to the doctor and get a pill and be better in 2 days.  Real health and recovery does not work like that. It's normal for it to take a long time.

 

When you get futher down the road in your healing and knowledge of this disease, you will be able to go out to eat and not be cc'd.  I do not eat out often but when I do, I never get sick anymore and there are many reasons for that.  I think a pill, not a vaccine, for travel would be useful but I would not rely on it all the time because I don't have to.  I have learned not to rely on pharmaceuticals because it's rarely a win-win situation.  If you get all excited about a vaccine, that's fine and I hope it works out for you but don't get all bent out of shape because others have no interest in it. 

  • Upvote 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Coeliacblog    2

This subject divides opinion between Celiac's.

 

For me it's a no if I have to take the vaccine every day of my life. I enjoy my gluten-free diet now, why would I want to go back to quick processed foods??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The safety and efficacy of vaccines in general has been thoroughly studied: http://www.health.ny.gov/prevention/immunization/vaccine_safety/science.htm

 

Low vaccination rates lead to an increase in death from preventable diseases.

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/whatifstop.htm

http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2011/05/16/vaccines-and-infant-mortality-rates/

 

Whether or not people want to get a vaccine for celiac disease is up to them.  It is not contagious so it shouldn't make much difference to others.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
GFinDC    609

Here is a link to a video on the planned celiac disease vaccine.  Dr. Bob Anderson explains how it is planned to work.  It's a long video but is worth watching if you are curious about the vaccine project.

 

 

 

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Support-Dr-Bob-Anderson-Celiac-Vaccine-Under-Development/112855685492141?ref=stream&hc_location=stream

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
frieze    114

The safety and efficacy of vaccines in general has been thoroughly studied: http://www.health.ny.gov/prevention/immunization/vaccine_safety/science.htm

 

Low vaccination rates lead to an increase in death from preventable diseases.

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/whatifstop.htm

http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2011/05/16/vaccines-and-infant-mortality-rates/

 

Whether or not people want to get a vaccine for celiac disease is up to them.  It is not contagious so it shouldn't make much difference to others.

so, we need to get our kids vac. for things that rarely lead to mortality/morbidity?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
MissyBB    3

I going back to reply to the original post. I am new here so just got to reading this thread.

 

Vaccine? I think this speaks to exactly what is wrong with our world and why so many more people have celiac or NCGI these days. We are thinking the wrong way as a society. A vaccine just covers up a problem; it doesn't deal with the real problem. And the real problem is one, we have bastardized wheat to such an extent that our bodies have not evolved enough to keep up with the changes in wheat, and two, that we have become a wheat/processed carbohydrate dependent society.

 

We need to get back and look at the real issues here. A vaccine, while handy to some, is not the answer. It's like a band-aid solution. What's next? Will be need a vaccine in the future due to GMO corn, tomatoes, fruit......all because we think we are smarter than the innate Universe that originally designed REAL, honest-to-God food. 

 

More big-pharma and GMO crops are not the answer - they are the problem.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

0

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      107,908
    • Total Posts
      938,620
  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      65,829
    • Most Online
      3,093

    Newest Member
    vi6609
    Joined
  • Popular Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Your first post stated that it took you 7 days of continuously eating gluten to get symptoms. So maybe it's not related to gluten at the hospital at all? Maybe you picked up an illness from the hospital? if I hadn't read your first post I'd say that the hospital food probably glutened you. Imho they don't do a great job at following dietary restrictions. Which may have still happened, and your symptoms kicked in faster this time. fyi any gluten exposure, even a crumb, kicks in the autoimmune response for celiac.
    • Hospitals and the ER....will normally ignore your dietary requirements with celiac. If they gave you so called gluten-free food...it had gluten. You have to have your own brought in or ask for plain whole foods. I wear medical dog tags with emergency contact info, allergies, blood type, and medical info on them. And my emergency contacts have been told where I keep emergency room stashes...IE Julian Protein Bar, MRM meal shakes to take up there if I get stuck in the hospital.
    • Hello- I was DX Celiac 2 years ago.  Last week I had a terrible accident, broke ankle and had to be taken to emergency. I was pumped full of drugs mostly Versed and Fentanal  via IV. After the usual couple days of constipation following these sort of drugs I began having GLUTENED intestinal issues.  I've had non stop bathroom runs for 2 days now and everything about it feels like I've been seriously glutened.  I've done some research but found no conclusive answers.  Did any of those things stir up my Celiac disease and cause me to have an autoimmune response? Has anyone had any similar experiences they can share with me?  This is my first post.  Thank you
    • All the issues you said came up after going gluten-free. Three points
      1. Are you sure you eating gluten free? If you eat out good chance your getting CCed, and is everything your eating really gluten free? There are many that are iffy on the market now days and CC can get in on some of the oddest aspects like shampoo, make up, lotion, medication, sauces, spices. etc.
      2. Sounds like your have deficiency issues, what are you eating? Your supposed to eat a varied diet when gluten free, most gluten free processed foods are not enriched...most gluten food is essentially sprayed with vitamins. SO you need to eat a varied diet eating leafy greens meats, eggs, etc. I myself have other limitations and have to supplement what I would get from these. ALSO celiac makes it where you do not absorb all the nutrients from your food I have 2 suggestion of stuff you NEED to take. Liquid health Stress & Energy, Liquid Health Nurological Support, and Doctors Best Magnesium.... these will help with stress, muscle aches, and energy issues. NOW you might need some other things like D and a few others.
      3. Sugars can cause all kinds of issues I know the issues with the craving.....I can not avoid them myself. I use some sweeteners like erythrol, stevia, monk fruit, etc to avoid the real sugar and the chemical BS ones. I make grain free, dairy free, gluten free baked goods, nut butters and snacks and even make a living off of selling them......I have a focus on making everything super moist as I know that is a huge craving for those of us with this.  Try moving to a healthier option if you can spiking your insulin and glucose levels is going to raise all kinds of havoc and the excess sugars can lead to candida or sibo in your intestines.

      Oh and yeah if you think death is bad we had a member have to get a emergency colonstomy. They ignored it and ate gluten and kept on doing it.....yeah having to poop in a bag sounds worse then death or cancer to me....and those are your other options.
    • Your daughter is only 7 years old.    I believe with a strict gluten-free diet, and some time, she will grow. My daughter was diagnosed at age 10.   When she was younger, she was always tall for her age.   She was in the 90% percentile as a toddler.   When she was finally diagnosed at age 10, we noticed that she did not grow at all for a little over a year, and she was at 25% percentile, and shorter than all her girl friends.   (She used to be one of the taller kids in the class) She is 14 years old now, still growing, and she is catching up with her friends, (no longer the shortest).   She is 5' 3'' right now.   She does not have her period yet, so we hope she will grow another few inches.   If she can be 5' 6", that would be a very good height for a girl. I think your daughter will be fine.  With a strict gluten-free diet, of course.
  • Upcoming Events