Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Positive Blood, Negative Scope

shai76

Recommended Posts

shai76 Explorer
shai76
Posted

I have had life long reflux disease, and food allergies and environemental allergies. My allergist recently diagnosed me as "allergic to everything," which is near the truth. I am allergic to milk, corn, soy, wheat, eggs, oats, yeast, turkey, fish, tree nuts...and probably a few more things I failed to mention. I had a endoscopy and colonoscopy in February. The pre-op diagnosis was a blood test positive for celiac antibodies, but the report of operation states there is no evidence of sprue seen. The GI doc says that I might not have it now, but I might get it in the future. They were kind of like the drive thru gastroenterologist, so I don't get detailed explainations out of them. I'm just wondering if I had celiac disease if that could be the reason why I have so many food allergies? My allergist says he is no GI doctor but what does it matter if I have it or not because I am allergic to wheat anyway, but I tend to think that there might be even more restrictions when it comes to gluten then just not eating wheat, or oats.

How common is it to have positive celiac antibodies, but not actually have the disease?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted
I have had life long reflux disease, and food allergies and environemental allergies. My allergist recently diagnosed me as "allergic to everything," which is near the truth. I am allergic to milk, corn, soy, wheat, eggs, oats, yeast, turkey, fish, tree nuts...and probably a few more things I failed to mention. I had a endoscopy and colonoscopy in February. The pre-op diagnosis was a blood test positive for celiac antibodies, but the report of operation states there is no evidence of sprue seen. The GI doc says that I might not have it now, but I might get it in the future. They were kind of like the drive thru gastroenterologist, so I don't get detailed explainations out of them. I'm just wondering if I had celiac disease if that could be the reason why I have so many food allergies? My allergist says he is no GI doctor but what does it matter if I have it or not because I am allergic to wheat anyway, but I tend to think that there might be even more restrictions when it comes to gluten then just not eating wheat, or oats.

How common is it to have positive celiac antibodies, but not actually have the disease?

You may not be celiac, yet. But you will be if you continue to consume and use this poison. You are however clearly gluten intolerant. You should avoid wheat, rye, barley and oats. There are some people who will not have villi damage for a long time while this poison eats away at the muscles, joints and brain. Many American doctors will blow off preceliac conditions until life is unbearable and their precious biopsies come back postive. You need to read as many postings on the board as you can, especially under related conditions, get as much knowledge as you can and if I were you I would get gluten free ASAP rather than waiting till it gets severe enough that you have permanent problems to your body.

moonunit Apprentice
moonunit
Posted

Hello! One thing I'd recommend is to get a look at the biopsy they sent to the lab. The use of the word "sprue" (which is by some considered a little outdated) might mean that the doctor you saw is not current with information about celiac disease and did not take enough biopsy samples to test accurately.

This happened with my doctor -- the minimum number of samples even by NIH standards is 4-6, with other experts recommending at least 15 (the disease can be very patchy and may not necessarily be doing damage in the location they biopsied). Mine took two samples, probably from the exact same area, and told me that they were "normal" so that's the end of that, no disease. Someone (sorry I don't remember who, or whether it was in a book or on here) used the analogy of trying to biopsy a mole for skin cancer by closing your eyes and picking any random sample of skin, and saying nope, no skin cancer! Not necessarily. Maybe, but not necessarily.

The information you will find on this site is very valuable and for whatever reason, most doctors are not even close to aware it exists! Please try to find out more before you accept the diagnosis at face value. The good news is that a gluten-free diet will probably help you regardless... :)

Matilda Enthusiast
Matilda
Posted

..

megsylvan2 Apprentice
megsylvan2
Posted
They were kind of like the drive thru gastroenterologist, so I don't get detailed explainations out of them.

What a great and accurate description! :lol: I do not understand how gastroenterologists (and probably many other specialists too) can expect to do justice to a patient within a 10 minute appointment. So far the ones I've been to have been watching the clock and running for the door as soon as possible. It is very difficult to discuss your condition with them. I feel like I want to tie them to the chair just so I can have a decent conversation with them. In my mind, it would take at least 20-30 minutes for a decent appointment. (Sorry - this is a bit off topic of your post, but I couldn't resist. )

Anyway, welcome! You've come to a good place to learn and receive support. There are many helpful people here and much knowledge and information. I'm still a newbie, and still one of the ones asking the questions too, so I'll leave it to others to answer. But I can tell you that within a few weeks, you will know a whole lot more than your doctor, and should be able to help yourself, even when your doctor can't (or doesn't) help you. So at least you will be on the road to getting your health back. Welcome aboard!

chrissy Collaborator
chrissy
Posted

i have 3 children with celiac---all had positive blood work. one had a negative biopsy, one had an iffy biopsy, and the doc did not biopsy the youngest.

christine

tiredofdoctors Enthusiast
tiredofdoctors
Posted

The biopsy only represents that there isn't damage to your small intestine -- yet. The positive antibodies (especially if you have Antitranglutaminase and Antiendomysial antibodies) mean that yes, you are positive for Celiac Disease. If you have elevated Antigliadin antibodies, it means that you are gluten intolerant. All of these mean that you have developed an autoimmune disease. Gluten will continue to attack your body -- sometimes in ways that aren't apparent for quite some time. I would encourage you to begin a gluten-free diet, with or without damage to the intestinal villi. If you have the antibodies, you do have the autoimmune disease. The only way to control it, so far, is through a gluten-free lifestyle. Good luck to you . . . Lynne

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


shai76 Explorer
shai76
Posted
  • Author
Hello! One thing I'd recommend is to get a look at the biopsy they sent to the lab. The use of the word "sprue" (which is by some considered a little outdated) might mean that the doctor you saw is not current with information about celiac disease and did not take enough biopsy samples to test accurately.

This happened with my doctor -- the minimum number of samples even by NIH standards is 4-6, with other experts recommending at least 15 (the disease can be very patchy and may not necessarily be doing damage in the location they biopsied). Mine took two samples, probably from the exact same area, and told me that they were "normal" so that's the end of that, no disease. Someone (sorry I don't remember who, or whether it was in a book or on here) used the analogy of trying to biopsy a mole for skin cancer by closing your eyes and picking any random sample of skin, and saying nope, no skin cancer! Not necessarily. Maybe, but not necessarily.

The information you will find on this site is very valuable and for whatever reason, most doctors are not even close to aware it exists! Please try to find out more before you accept the diagnosis at face value. The good news is that a gluten-free diet will probably help you regardless... :)

Thanks! That explains things a lot for me. I am actually looking over the report of operation right now, and it basically says that they took one sample of my small intestine, one of my esophagus, and one of my colon and no evidence of "sprue" is seen, though I do have a lot of inflammatory cells in my stomach which I read somewhere else could screw up the results. Pre=operative and post-operative diagnosis both state positive celiac antibody, but it doesn't say what kind of antibody. I should probably get a copy of the blood test results too. I've just been wandering if gluten intolerance could be at the base of my multiple food allergies. Maybe if I stopped all forms of gluten I would eventually get over my food allergies.

The problem is I am so allergic to so many things restircting my diet even further just depresses me, but it would be better then this constant belly ache. My food allergies are all class 2 and 3, so I am supposed to completely avoid all those things (wheat, oats, milk,eggs, soy, corn, yeast, turkey, fish, tree nuts). If I even eat a small amount of wheat I have a terrible asthma attack, hives, eczema, as wel as gas and stomach problems. My family doctor originally ordered the scopes to be sure the damage from my food allergies wasn't so bad, and to see if I needed to start steroids or something. But now the doctors say everything is fine, except a hiatal hernia, positive celiac antibodies, gastritis, reflux, esophagitis...they act like these things are no biggy and that I should just learn to live with it. Doctors are, for the most part, so annoying! I love my allergist,a nd my family doctor, but every GI doctor I have been to so far seems like an idiot! Should I worry about my son getting gluten intolerant? He is already seeing a pediatric gastroenterologist for his reflux since birth, and his multiple food allergies.

It's all so over-whelming. :(

Janie Beast Newbie
Janie Beast
Posted

My allergist told me NOT to get the biopsy done, because it is so inaccurate. She said unless they hit the exact sites it can show no celiac problems. She wanted me to get some other test that insurance won't cover. You mail fecal sample in for test, which evidently is much cheaper. Not being fond of playing with feces, I asked her what else can I do? She said I'd tested positive on one of the three blood tests. She said she was almost positive that I had it, she really hammered away at this. So I am just trying the diet for a while and things are improving somewhat. I gather it takes a long time to find foods you like.

shai76 Explorer
shai76
Posted
  • Author

Thanks for the reply!

I'm going gluten free completey the past couple days. It's not that big of a change since I am allergic to wheat and oats anyway. But I have had a stomach ache the past fee days, really bad. It feels like someone punched me above my belly button,and my stomach swells up like I am pregnant any time I eat. It sucks. :(

I'm really hoping if I stay gluten free that my food allergies might go away, at least some of them. I would love to be able to enjoy a chunk of cheese again. :(

Ursa Major Collaborator
Ursa Major
Posted

Hi Shai, I am probably intolerant to at least as many things as you are, probably more, and I manage! Most of the time I feel so much better when I stay on my own special diet. All your symptoms sound like you have celiac disease. And you're right, if you stay on the gluten free diet, some of your allergies might go away........but it could take a year for that to happen.

And when babies already have reflux, and he's got a mother with probable celiac disease (which is genetic), I strongly suspect that he is gluten intolerant, too. Take him off all gluten and dairy (most celiacs can't tolerate dairy either, at least not until the intestines have healed, and then some can have it again), and see if his reflux improves! I bet it will.

lonewolf Collaborator
lonewolf
Posted
(wheat, oats, milk,eggs, soy, corn, yeast, turkey, fish, tree nuts).

Welcome to the board! I hope we can help you out. Lots of people here have multiple food intolerances/allergies, so you're in the right place.

If you've been avoiding all of these things, then you'll do fine with gluten-free. It's not much more of a change. It's all the "other" things that make it difficult. When I first found out I had food allergies I could only eat fish, rice some fruits, some vegetables, sunflower seeds and cashews. Now, I "only" have to avoid gluten, dairy (but can get away with small amounts of butter and raw goat cheese), eggs and soy. Going completely gluten-free, rather than just wheat-free has made a huge difference for me in terms of stomach aches, bloating and cramping.

Can you eat chicken, other meats, rice, potatoes, tapioca, fruit, vegetables and seeds? If so, you'll be able to get a lot of recipes from people here - many are already posted in the recipes section. Let us know what you like to eat and I'm sure you'll get lots of help.

shai76 Explorer
shai76
Posted
  • Author
Hi Shai, I am probably intolerant to at least as many things as you are, probably more, and I manage! Most of the time I feel so much better when I stay on my own special diet. All your symptoms sound like you have celiac disease. And you're right, if you stay on the gluten free diet, some of your allergies might go away........but it could take a year for that to happen.

And when babies already have reflux, and he's got a mother with probable celiac disease (which is genetic), I strongly suspect that he is gluten intolerant, too. Take him off all gluten and dairy (most celiacs can't tolerate dairy either, at least not until the intestines have healed, and then some can have it again), and see if his reflux improves! I bet it will.

Thanks Ursula :)

My son is almost 2 and has had reflux since birth, and multiple food allergies, just like me...lucky him.

He doesn't eat wheat because he has allergic type reactions from it, and he has already shown allergic reactions to milk and soy and corn, so he is on a "hypo-allergenic" diet, and he takes prilosec twice a day (just like me). I love for us both to be off the medicine some day. I noticed that the prilosec wasn't working so well for me before. Then I went off the gluten completely and now I have no reflux, but I am still on the medication.

It's just confusing because almost 2 years aog, after having my son, I had terrible problems and developed more allergies. I was tested and the doctor tol dme I was gluten intolerant. Then a half a year later a different doctor told me I wasn't, now a GI doc says I am but I am not. Why can't they just make up their minds?

Welcome to the board! I hope we can help you out. Lots of people here have multiple food intolerances/allergies, so you're in the right place.

If you've been avoiding all of these things, then you'll do fine with gluten-free. It's not much more of a change. It's all the "other" things that make it difficult. When I first found out I had food allergies I could only eat fish, rice some fruits, some vegetables, sunflower seeds and cashews. Now, I "only" have to avoid gluten, dairy (but can get away with small amounts of butter and raw goat cheese), eggs and soy. Going completely gluten-free, rather than just wheat-free has made a huge difference for me in terms of stomach aches, bloating and cramping.

Can you eat chicken, other meats, rice, potatoes, tapioca, fruit, vegetables and seeds? If so, you'll be able to get a lot of recipes from people here - many are already posted in the recipes section. Let us know what you like to eat and I'm sure you'll get lots of help.

The only meats I can't eat every day are fish and turkey because I had class 1 allergies to them I can eat them occassionally. I would to learn to bake with rice flour, so I definitly will check out the recipes. I can't eat yeast, sot hat causes a big problem sometimes too. I'm pretty allergic to yeasts and molds. :/

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. HectorConvector
      - HectorConvector replied to HectorConvector's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      335

      Terrible Neurological Symptoms

      I think it's just part of the natural water retention/release cycle that happens, just in my case the retention part hurts my hyper-sensitive nerves. So its just another thing to add to the huge list of "irritants" rather than the cause. I tend to underhydrate a bit by habit. I don't have any health conditions according to any testing other than celiac disease...
    2. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to Ben Cohen's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      11

      How much gluten do I need to eat prior to testing?

      Can you tell us about your experiments? Are you consuming dairy, too?
    3. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to Lotte18's topic in Publications & Publicity
      11

      Prospective CRISPR research

      Human Leukocyte Antigens are coded for in our DNA. They act like street signs on cells so the body knows that they are "Self". Tissue typing in organ transplantation looks for donors with "Self" street signs similar to the recipient's in order to prevent rejection of the transplanted organ. The HLA DQ genes code for immune cells. Some immune cells...
    4. knitty kitty
      0

      Thiamine and Autoimmune Diseases

    5. Lotte18
      - Lotte18 replied to Lotte18's topic in Publications & Publicity
      11

      Prospective CRISPR research

      Got it. Thanks Aretaeus.
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,758
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    luckyhoneybee
    Newest Member
    luckyhoneybee
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • HectorConvector
      Terrible Neurological Symptoms

      By HectorConvector · Posted

      I think it's just part of the natural water retention/release cycle that happens, just in my case the retention part hurts my hyper-sensitive nerves. So its just another thing to add to the huge list of "irritants" rather than the cause. I tend to underhydrate a bit by habit. I don't have any health conditions according to any testing other than celiac disease, at least nothing serious (I have Gilbert syndrome but it's harmless apparently).  With central sensitization, what should be normal changes in vascular contraction etc... (so including with exercise, and temp changes, changes in blood viscosity etc...) triggers pain in me, generated in the brain, which it doesn't in "normal" people.
    • knitty kitty
      How much gluten do I need to eat prior to testing?

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Can you tell us about your experiments?  Are you consuming dairy, too?  
    • knitty kitty
      Prospective CRISPR research

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Human Leukocyte Antigens are coded for in our DNA.  They act like street signs on cells so the body knows that they are "Self".   Tissue typing in organ transplantation looks for donors with "Self" street signs similar to the recipient's in order to prevent rejection of the transplanted organ.   The HLA DQ genes code for immune cells.  Some immune cells are encoded to recognize certain protein strings when that protein string attaches to the receptor on its cell membrane.  Originally, these protein strings were found in the cell walls of harmful viruses and bacteria.   I like to think of these immune cells as patrolling police with orders to "be on the lookout for armed and dangerous suspects matching your cell membrane receptor description".   However, segments of these dangerous protein strings are also found in the carbohydrate storage protein Gluten.  During digestion, Gluten segments bind with Tissue Transglutaminase, an enzyme that builds and repairs structural components of our "Self" cell membranes in our bodies.   This Gluten-Transglutenaminase globule fits into the receptors on the patrolling police immune cells and sets off an alarm.  Mother immune cells begin producing antibodies (anti-tissue Transglutaminase antibodies ie, tTg antibodies) against the Transglutaminase-Gluten globule.   Unfortunately, we have tissue Transglutaminase in the structure of all our cell membranes.  The antibodies attack healthy cells in our digestive tract, damaging them, causing them to signal to nearby cells "I'm sick, get away from me so you don't catch it!".  Spaces appear between cells.  The tight junction between cells is lost.  Gastrointestinal permeability is compromised.  This allows for other Transglutaminase-gluten globules to leave the intestinal tract, enter the blood stream, and travel to other organs and cause problems there.  All the while, more police immune cells are alerted along the way with more mother cells producing more antibodies.  Sort of ends up looking like a "Smokey and the Bandit" movie in my mind, but with more than one "Bandit" driving around.   So, people with a genetic predisposition (they have HLA DQ genes known to code for Celiac Disease) can go for years without developing Celiac Disease.  There needs to be a trigger that turns the genes on.  Triggers can be physical stressors like having an infection (like the flu or the common cold), or an injury, or an emotional stressor (like losing a loved one or abuse).   There's some scientific proof that Thiamine insufficiency triggers autoimmune diseases.  During times of illness and emotional stress, the body requires additional Thiamine to provide the energy for the increased metabolic demand that comes with physical and emotional trauma or stresses.  Athletes have higher metabolic demands.   People who work outside in sunshine have higher metabolic demands, too.  This is because light (sunlight or indoor lighting) breaks thiamine down, denatures it, so that it cannot be used.  People who drink alcohol need more thiamine because alcohol will cleave thiamine in half making it useless.  People who eat a diet high in carbohydrates have a higher metabolic demand for thiamine and the other B vitamins needed to turn food into energy.   Mitochondria are involved in producing energy, ATP, from Thiamine Vitamin B 1.  When there is a thiamine deficiency inside a cell, the mitochondria can no longer make energy ATP.  This is relayed to the DNA.  On the DNA, a switch is thrown to signal there's no thiamine, and another switch is turned on.  This is the switch that turns on the DQ autoimmune genes coded for in that DNA.  Whatever autoimmune genes are on your DNA start turning on.  Thiamine Vitamin B 1 is needed to turn food into energy for the body along with the seven other B vitamins and minerals. Thiamine and magnesium make life sustaining enzymes.  Thiamine does stuff by itself, too, like regulate the immune response, and prevent mast cells from degranulating histamine. Thiamine influences which bacteria grow in our microbiome.  Thiamine deficiency allows Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (SIBO).  Immune responses and inflammatory cytokines are higher in thiamine deficiency.   Thiamine cannot be stored long (18 days).  Thiamine insufficiency or deficiency can occur within three days if stores are depleted due to high metabolic demand and depleted stored thiamine.    The majority of people with Diabetes have been shown to be deficient in Thiamine.  People with obesity who plan gastric bypass surgery have been found to have insufficient thiamine.  People Hashimoto's (autoimmune thyroid problems) have been found to improve with thiamine supplementation.  People with autoimmune arthritis have been shown to improve with thiamine supplementation.  People with MS have been shown to improve with thiamine supplementation.    Blood tests are not reliable measures of thiamine level.  The brain controls the amount of thiamine in the blood stream.  The brain will order tissues to release their stored thiamine into the blood stream in order to keep a constant supply going to the brain, heart, and lungs.  So, there can be organs with depleted thiamine stores, while blood levels stay constant.  This results in a localized deficiency within the organ or tissue.   The best way to tell if there's a deficiency is to take thiamine hydrochloride for several weeks and look for health improvements.  Higher amounts of thiamine are needed to correct thiamine insufficiency or deficiency.  This helps replenish thiamine stores inside cells and tissues as well as meet increased metabolic demands.   Processed foods containing wheat are required to have vitamins added to them to replace the ones lost with the removal of the germ and bran.  Food manufacturers use Thiamine Mononitrate, a cheap, shelf-stable form of thiamine that is not easily absorbed nor utilized by the body.   A diet high in ultra processed foods, high in sugar and simple carbohydrates requires additional thiamine to turn the carbs into energy for the body.  Excess carbohydrates and low thiamine encourages SIBO.  For every 1000 kcal of carbohydrates the body needs an additional 500 mg of Thiamine.  The RDA is based on the minimum amount required to prevent disease.  This was set in the 1940's, when people ate very differently.   Early symptoms of thiamine insufficiency include depression, anxiety, impulsivity, and changes in mood and cognitive function, digestive problems, nausea, abdominal pain, diarrhea, constipation, fatigue, muscle cramps, high blood pressure, tachycardia, blurry vision, insomnia or other sleep disturbances.  All so easily overlooked or attributed to daily stresses.    
    • Lotte18
      Prospective CRISPR research

      By Lotte18 · Posted

      Got it.  Thanks Aretaeus.  
    • xxnonamexx
      Gluten Free Sugar or Starch known to increase gas?

      By xxnonamexx · Posted

      As I have been mapping what I eat etc to eliminate what gluten-free foods give gas/bloating and I have eliminated protein bars with sugar. I have switched to RX bars that don't have any added alcohol sugars and what a difference it has made. Its hard to find good protein bar w/o added sugars but this has been the best I have found that doesn't cost so much.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.