Jump to content

  • You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

What's The Science Behind Celiac Soy Intolerance?

Chakra2

By Chakra2
in Coping with Celiac Disease

Recommended Posts

Chakra2 Contributor
Chakra2
Posted

I have read about why some celiacs have trouble digesting dairy at first -- you need the lactase from the tips of the villi. But why are so many gluten-sensitive people also bothered by soy?Is there a similar anatomically-based reason?

Also, I'd love to know if/when/how anyone was able to reintroduce soy. I was vegetarian for 19 years (now pescatarian) so I did learn to love my miso and my tofu! And wheat-free soy sauce would be a big treat now that it looks like I'll be eating a lot of rice from here on out. :)

I'm curious about a dairy issue, too. Are all lactose-intolerant (non-celiac/non-gluten sensitive) folks out there missing the tips of their villi? Or are there other reasons that "normal" people become lactose intolerant?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Jestgar Rising Star
Jestgar
Posted

Soy is a big, giant, hard-to-digest protein, as is casein. It may be that a lot of people don't digest it well, but don't get enough symptoms to be bothered by it.

Many adults are lactose intolerant. You are designed to consume milk only as an infant, it's a recent mutation that allows the lactase enzyme to persist in adults.

GlutenFreeManna Rising Star
GlutenFreeManna
Posted

I don't have any science (sorry) but I read on some natural medicine sites that there was a connection between soy and thyroid disease. Hypothyroidism runs in my family so I cut out soy when I first did my elimination diet. When I tried to add it back in I had fatigue, joint swelling, muscle pain and extreme moodiness. So even though my thyroid tests are still coming back as normal, I'm inclined to think from my own personal testing that soy messes with my thyroid. Like I said I don't have any hard science to back this up, but if you do a search you will find all kinds of sites warning about giving infants soy formula. Perhaps that could be a starting place for you to find some scientific articles.

Marz Enthusiast
Marz
Posted

Well if certain gene mutations cause the body to produce antibodies in response to gluten, when not soy? Especially if they're similar structures.

I'm wondering if there are some "soy" celiacs out there that are being missed because their body is producing antibodies to soy, and not gluten? Maybe that's why lots of blood tests are false negative - we're just not looking for the specific antibody that some of us are producing? Just speculating at this point, because I have no scientific basis for any of this :)

I do know I react in *exactly* the same way to soy as I do to gluten, both immediately and days later.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

With the gluten and dairy, some celiacs' anti-gliadin antibodies recognize casein. This doesn't happen in all celiacs, so there are some negative studies around as well.

Open Original Shared Link

Open Original Shared Link

There was also an interesting study on biopsied mucosa where damaged mucosa could not break down casein. Bigger fragments of food protein are more immunologically active.

Open Original Shared Link

Celiacs have more anti-casein and anti-soy antibodies in general.

Open Original Shared Link

Open Original Shared Link

If you piece things together, you can hypothesize that celiacs have a combination of more antibodies in general and poor digestion. Bits of undigested food might react with all the antibodies so you get a soy or casein reaction in unhealed celiacs.

By the way, it took me between six and nine months to reintroduce casein and soy.

kwylee Apprentice
kwylee
Posted

With the gluten and dairy, some celiacs' anti-gliadin antibodies recognize casein. This doesn't happen in all celiacs, so there are some negative studies around as well.

Open Original Shared Link

Open Original Shared Link

There was also an interesting study on biopsied mucosa where damaged mucosa could not break down casein. Bigger fragments of food protein are more immunologically active.

Open Original Shared Link

Celiacs have more anti-casein and anti-soy antibodies in general.

Open Original Shared Link

Open Original Shared Link

If you piece things together, you can hypothesize that celiacs have a combination of more antibodies in general and poor digestion. Bits of undigested food might react with all the antibodies so you get a soy or casein reaction in unhealed celiacs.

By the way, it took me between six and nine months to reintroduce casein and soy.

This info is so helpful!!! And thanks so much for the synopsis of the links in everyday speak! Appreciate that!

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

This info is so helpful!!! And thanks so much for the synopsis of the links in everyday speak! Appreciate that!

Summarizing links was Jestgar's excellent advice. :) Glad it helps and you found the info useful.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


tweeks2010 Apprentice
tweeks2010
Posted

Today I tested myself with the ingredient soy lecithin i about 5 different things I ate today. Guess what...I get the same symptoms with that as I do when I get glutened. I only did a somewhat small amount , but it was enough to give me stomach cramping that has so far lasted hours and is still going.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. nancydrewandtheceliacclue
      - nancydrewandtheceliacclue replied to nancydrewandtheceliacclue's topic in Super Sensitive People
      12

      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      @Aretaeus Cappadocia and @Russ H thank you both for your helpful advice and information. I haven't seen a GI in years. They never helped me aside from my inital diagnosis. All other help has come from my own research, which is why I came here. I will be even more careful in the future.
    2. Aretaeus Cappadocia
      - Aretaeus Cappadocia replied to nancydrewandtheceliacclue's topic in Super Sensitive People
      12

      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      @nancydrewandtheceliacclue, you are welcome. After looking at this thread again, I would like to suggest that some of the other comments from @Russ H are worth following up on. The bird-bread may or may not be contributing to what you are experiencing, but it seems unlikely to be the whole story. If you have access to decent healthcare, I would write down...
    3. Aretaeus Cappadocia
      - Aretaeus Cappadocia replied to nancydrewandtheceliacclue's topic in Super Sensitive People
      12

      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      @Russ H, I partly agree and partly disagree with you. After looking at it again, I would say that the slick graphic I posted overestimates the risk. Your math is solid, although I find estimates of gluten in white bread at 10-12% rather than the 8% you use. Somewhat contradicting what I wrote before, I agree with you that it would be difficult to ingest ...
    4. Peace lily
      - Peace lily commented on Scott Adams's article in Latest Research
      2

      New Study Reveals How the Immune System Learns Which Foods Are Safe to Eat

      Hi everyone well I don’t understand totally,I look for gluten-free only. I seem to be super sensitive. I had a problem the other day don’t know why it happen . I’m the only that handles my food . My husband has pancreatitis he’s fine with me cooking gluten-free I’ve tried doing both it doesn’t work for me strictly gluten-free kitchen. But he can actu...
    5. nancydrewandtheceliacclue
      - nancydrewandtheceliacclue replied to nancydrewandtheceliacclue's topic in Super Sensitive People
      12

      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      @Aretaeus Cappadocia thank you for your reply and the link, that is very helpful to get a visual of just how small of an amount can cause a reaction. I know I am not consuming gluten or coming into contact with gluten from any other source. I will stop touching/tossing bread outside! My diet has not changed, and I do not have reactions to the things I am...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      134,061
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      10,442
    Francisco1007
    Newest Member
    Francisco1007
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.7k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • nancydrewandtheceliacclue
      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      By nancydrewandtheceliacclue · Posted

      @Aretaeus Cappadocia and @Russ H thank you both for your helpful advice and information. I haven't seen a GI in years. They never helped me aside from my inital diagnosis. All other help has come from my own research, which is why I came here. I will be even more careful in the future. 
    • Aretaeus Cappadocia
      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      By Aretaeus Cappadocia · Posted

      @nancydrewandtheceliacclue, you are welcome. After looking at this thread again, I would like to suggest that some of the other comments from @Russ H are worth following up on. The bird-bread may or may not be contributing to what you are experiencing, but it seems unlikely to be the whole story. If you have access to decent healthcare, I would write down your experiences and questions in outline form and bring this to your Dr. I suggest writing it down so you don't get distracted from telling the Dr everything you want to say while you have their attention.
    • Aretaeus Cappadocia
      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      By Aretaeus Cappadocia · Posted

      @Russ H, I partly agree and partly disagree with you. After looking at it again, I would say that the slick graphic I posted overestimates the risk. Your math is solid, although I find estimates of gluten in white bread at 10-12% rather than the 8% you use. Somewhat contradicting what I wrote before, I agree with you that it would be difficult to ingest 10 mg from flinging bread.  However, I would still suggest that @nancydrewandtheceliacclue take precautions against exposure in this activity. I'm not an expert, I could easily be wrong, but if someone is experiencing symptoms and has a known exposure route, it's possible that they are susceptible to less than 10 mg / day, or it is possible that there is/are other undetected sources of exposure that together with this one are causing problems. At any rate, I would want to eliminate any exposure until symptoms are under control before I started testing the safety of potentially risky activities. Here is another representation of what 10 mg of bread would look like. https://www.glutenfreewatchdog.org/news/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/10mgGlutenCrumbsJules.jpg Full article that image came from: https://www.glutenfreewatchdog.org/news/what-does-10-mg-of-gluten-look-like/
    • nancydrewandtheceliacclue
      Celiac flare years after diagnosis

      By nancydrewandtheceliacclue · Posted

      @Aretaeus Cappadocia thank you for your reply and the link, that is very helpful to get a visual of just how small of an amount can cause a reaction. I know I am not consuming gluten or coming into contact with gluten from any other source. I will stop touching/tossing bread outside! My diet has not changed, and I do not have reactions to the things I am currently eating, which are few in number. My auto immune reaction just seems so severe. The abdominal pain is extreme. It takes a lot out of me. I guess I will be this way for the rest of my life if I ever happen to come into contact with gluten? I appreciate the help. 
    • Jmartes71
      Skin issues

      By Jmartes71 · Posted

      Thankyou I did find out the Infectious disease is the route to go rather than dermatologist. I did reach out to two major hospitals and currently waiting on approval for one of them in Infectious Diseases to call me. I also did have implants ( I didn't know and sense not properly in my medical. Neither did surgeon)in 2006 and there was a leak 2023 during the same time I was dealing with covid, digestive issues, eyes and skin.Considering I " should  be fine" not consuming gluten/wheat, taking vitamins for sibo and STILL feeling terrible.It has to be parasites. I also take individual eye drops prescribed, could there be an issue there? Anyways my pcp thinks I need therapy because again they don't acknowledge my digestive issues because in my records it shows im fine, hintz the reason I had to go back to bay area hospital:(  I thought skin issues maybe sibo related but I feel and have seen and seriously trying not to think about it because it's disgusting. 
×
×
  • Create New...