Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Negative Biopsy


hollyd

Recommended Posts

hollyd Apprentice

I had my biopsies done by a specialist in celiac who is also a researcher in the disease. They were negative, they said they were going to take them from several sites and take a large number of them. There is no evidence of damaged villi. I am now 4 months gluten free and the bloating and "runs" are gone. The only time I have a problem is if I accidentally get glutened and then I feel the way I used to. Except for when recently getting glutened from a restaurant I am no longer getting that flu-y achey muscle thing that I kept getting previously which had me filling sick for a week.

The doctor is calling it IBS but I've never really had the symptoms of IBS. The "runs" were only in the morning - very wierd. He's questioning whether I have fructose malabsorption and/or lactose intolerance but I don't react to lactose when I eat it. The fruit I'm not so sure about.

He cannot explain why it took 2 years of zinc supplementation to get my zinc to normal or more than 2 years of iron supplementation to get my iron to something other than scraping the bottom level of normal (below normal w/out supplementation). One would think that if I was not absorbing these things from my food the villi would appear damaged.

He wants me to see some expensive nutritionist to check for fructose and lactose stuff but I'm wondering whether I can just do that on my own. It doesn't sound like rocket science. I guess you try various foods one at a time and see how you react, right? Anyone done this on their own?

Can I still be celiac? There's just no way I can tolerate gluten anymore. Can it be just gluten intolerant without celiac and can you get malabsorption of minerals from that? Can having IBS make you intolerant to gluten? I was reading that gluten is not considered an offending food for people with IBS, quite to the contrary as whole grains are supposed to be good for it.

Thanks very much for any information you can offer.

Holly


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



mle-ii Explorer

For me, my fructose malabsorption showed up when I started eating more honey in my teas. So try 1 or 2 tablespoons of honey, you can raise or lower the amount to determine your threshold for symptoms.

For me my symptoms were lots of gas, cramping, pain and sometimes loose stools.

Ursa Major Collaborator

Holly, were the biopsies taken after you were gluten-free for four months, or before? If they were taking after, then they are totally invalid, as your villi could have healed in that time.

rogue Rookie

I was diagnosed with celiac disease one year ago- even with a negative biopsy. I also had Vitamin B12 Definiency Anemia, which can only be caused by malabsorption problems or by being a strict vegan. Since I eat animal bi-products on a regular basis, it only left the former to be concluded. You have 20-22 feet of intestines and the endoscope reaches only a fraction of it. The biopsy, in my opinion and the opinion of my doctor, is not all that accurate. It can tell you 100% for sure whether you have it, but is not entirely conclusive.

Rikki Tikki Explorer

I agree if you feel better on the gluten-free diet than stay on it. I firmly believe that the biopsy can miss some of it, or the villi could just not be damaged yet. I have read many posts that speak of this.

CarlaB Enthusiast

My first question was the same as Ursula's, were you gluten-free before the biopsy?

There is such a thing as non-celiac gluten-intolerance. My ob/gyn told me to quit looking for clinical proof, my dietary response IS clinical proof.

If you are feeling better gluten-free, then I wouldn't bother with the other tests. If you still have issues, then I would look into what else it could be.

My biopsy was negative, too. Were your blood tests positive? If so, that indicates that you do react to gluten. The fact that your intestines looked fine could just mean that they weren't significantly damaged yet, or the damage was spotty and they biopsied the wrong spots. I don't understand why GI docs seem to think that the biopsy can prove that you don't have it. All I've heard says it is the gold standard for proving you do have it, but a negative biopsy cannot rule it out.

Super Bellybutton Rookie
You have 20-22 feet of intestines and the endoscope reaches only a fraction of it. The biopsy, in my opinion and the opinion of my doctor, is not all that accurate. It can tell you 100% for sure whether you have it, but is not entirely conclusive.

That's such a good point. An endoscope is never 20 feet long...or even half that.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



hollyd Apprentice

Hi Everyone,

Thanks a lot for your replies. I was definitely eating lots of gluten before my tests and had never gone gluten free until after my tests.

I guess I won't ever know if it's celiac or that non-celiac gluten intolerance. I just don't know how you can take all those supplements and have them have NO effect until you've built up 2+ years worth of it in your system. Some people have very serious negative effects from taking too much zinc and obviously you can from iron as well. I would guess that those who are diagnosed as celiac who have mineral deficiencies would have to supplement and it might take a long while before they get the benefits - which seems like what happened to me. it just isn't good enough for me to have him say he doesn't know why I had those deficiences that wouldn't respond to supplements for so long. I guess they do get very narrow in their definitions - if they see no damaged villi, they say no celiac and have no curiosity as to why you weren't absorbing minerals.

I am definitely feeling better gluten free. I'm not sure whether I'll bother with the expensive dietician. I've cut out fruit for awhile now and I think I'll try adding some back in and see what happens. I am using a bath soap that has some wheat germ oil in it as I've been thinking if it isn't celiac it's not a problem - maybe I should see how I do with a totally gluten free soap. There is still one symptom that is mildly annoying that hasnt gone away yet.

In terms of the length of the endoscope, what I read was that the majority of the damage would be at the stomach end of things where the food first enters and so that is why they biopsy from there.

CDFAMILY Rookie

Hi Holly,

I have a hard time with biopsies also....can you really trust them...I had and still have a positive AGA IgA, tTG and EMA...but my biopsy only showed "Mild Chronic Inflammation and slight Villous Blunting....Comment: The possibility of partially treated celiac sprue cannot be excluded. Clinical correlation is required".....It was a positive dx but with my high numbers it should have been total villous atrophy according to most info on having positive tTG and EMA. So, where was/is my damage...I don't think it is in the Duodenal area...I think mine is somewhere else otherwise they would have seen the major damage I have.

The doctors have so much to learn and some are now saying the IgA's are going into the brain and CNS which is where I believe most of mine hangout...LOL....we are the people that are showing neurological damage.

This is a really interesting site on TIght Junction Dysfunction:

Zonulin and Tight Junction Dysfunction

An interesting site about tight junction dysfunction Open Original Shared Link

My interpretation of this is: This tells how you have villi in the small intestine that absorbs nutrients and has a barrier that prevents bad things like gliadins from entering the blood stream. If you click on next a few times you will see the attack of gliadins from gluten destroying the barrier and opening up the bloodstream to the gliadins, which of course go to the brain and start their attack on the neurological system. This is called a leaky gut syndrome….which basically is what Celiac is all about….but also is the probable cause of Diabetes and other autoimmune diseases.

Also some good info on Zonulin:

Open Original Shared Link

Diabetes. 2006 May;55(5):1443-9.

Related Articles, Links

Zonulin upregulation is associated with increased gut permeability in subjects with type 1 diabetes and their relatives

Hopefully they will figure a way just to do blood or bowel tests to find the answers to all our health problems.

hollyd Apprentice

Hi celiac disease Family,

Thanks for the interesting links. I would definitely think I had celiac for sure if I had your family history and blood results. It does seem like they haven't gotten it all worked out yet if they didn't find the atrophy in your biopsies. My blood work showed only elevated IGA IgG which is the sensitive marker but not specific. All the others came out normal. It makes it harder for me to make the case that it's celiac though the malabsorption of minerals despite supplementation and response to a gluten free diet and reaction to accidental glutenings tell a different story.

Can I ask what sort of neuological symptoms you're having? I'm curious about that for myself.

Thanks :-)

Holly

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,182
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Portia
    Newest Member
    Portia
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      First, welcome to the forum, @boy-wonder! Second, a little clarification in terminology is in order. Granted, inconsistency is rampant when it comes to the terminology associated with gluten disorders, but it has more or less become settled in this fashion: "Gluten intolerance" is a general term that car refer to either celiac disease or NCGS (Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity). "Gluten Sensitivity" is the shortened version of NCGS. Third, Celiac disease is not an allergy to gluten. It is an autoimmune disorder characterized by gluten ingestion causing the immunes system to attack the lining of the small bowel, causing damage to it over time due to the constant inflammation that wears down the "villi" (mucosal finger-like projections that make up the lining). Over a significant period of time as gluten continues to be consumed, this generally results in impaired nutrient absorption. There are specific blood antibody tests available to check for celiac disease but the testing will not be valid while on a reduced gluten diet or a gluten free diet. Those already having having begun a gluten free diet must go back to consuming generous amounts of gluten for a period of weeks if they wish to pursue testing for celiac disease. Fourth, NCGS shares many of the same symptoms of celiac disease but does not damage the lining of the small bowel as does celiac disease. There is no test for it. A diagnosis for NCGS depends on first ruling out celiac disease. It is 10x more common than celiac disease. Some experts feel it can be a precursor to the development of celiac disease. Eliminating gluten from your life is the antidote for both. Fifth, you state that you are convince you don't have celiac disease by are just "gluten intolerant" (aka, gluten sensitive). How do you know that? It seems to me you are making a dangerous assumption here. I suggest you consider getting formally tested for celiac disease.
    • AllyJR
      Has anyone found a gluten free parakeet seed mix? I can't find a single one! My doctor wants me to make sure all pet food in the house is gluten free but I'm not sure if that's even possible with parakeets. We love our birds so much! I'm wondering if anyone has ever made their own bird seed mix if gluten free ones are not available. 
    • boy-wonder
      Hi, new member. About me, I had been suffering with weight gain, bloating and irregular and extreme bowel habits for a year or so. For example, I went on holiday in 2023, then again I  2024 at the same time of year and every shirt I wore in 2023 didn't fit anymore, couldn't even do the buttons up. Being in my mid 50s I put it down to age and middle aged spread. I'd been lucky all my life having good metabolism and being able to eat anything and as much as I like without putting on any weight, it drove my other half mad. Over a conversation with a friend health and age Related stuff came up and he mentioned someone he knew who had recently found out they were gluten intolerant,  I looked it up and had every one of 8 or so symptoms listed. Bloating,  weight gain,  headaches, brain fog,  constipation, etc etc. I took the decision to give going gluten free a try. Within 1 week I had lost 4 lb, now 7 weeks in I've lost 13 lb. I feel much better in general,  the bloating has severely subsided, it used to keep me awake at night as I felt so uncomfortable.  So pretty much a success story, as everyone here knows,  going gluten free isn't always easy, and eating out can be awkward,  but I consider myself lucky that I appear to have an intolerance rather than an allergy or being celiac.  I can deal with most of the gluten free options at the supermarket but, the big one for me is bread, I love bread, and the gluten free options I've tried are pretty poor. I was at a posh black tie event last night and chose all the food options I thought would be gluten free,  however,  there was bread on the table and I couldn't resist it, I had I small piece of bread,  god it was good, I wanted more but I resisted. Today I feel a bit dodgy, my stomach is churning, and I generally feel a bit urgh.  So here's the question, is that really down to 1 small piece of bread or is it coincidence?  I'd be interested in hearing how other people have reacted to a similar situation,  as I was considering having a day off every now and then and enjoying some lovely fresh bread.
    • ValerieC
      Does anybody know of a guide that ranks reevaluates universities and colleges in terms of their accommodation of celiac disease or food allergies?   Thanks in advance for any leads! Valerie 
    • thejayland10
      thank you, i have been doing that the last few weeks and will continue to do so. I had not had my ttg iga checked since I was diagnosed 14 yrs ago so I am not sure if they ever dropped below the 15-20 range.    all my other labs are completely normal but I am concerned that this may be signs of refractor celiac or something else since I'm so careful with gluten-free diet 
×
×
  • Create New...