The Rise of Gluten Avoidance Without Celiac Disease: A Long-Term Population Study

Celiac.com 05/10/2025 - In recent years, avoiding gluten has become increasingly common—even among people who do not have celiac disease. But how many people actually follow a gluten-free diet without a medical need? And what drives this trend? A long-term Finnish study tracked the prevalence and characteristics of adults avoiding gluten without a celiac disease diagnosis over an 11-year period. The findings reveal a significant increase in gluten avoidance, along with insights into the dietary habits and psychological well-being of this group.

Study Design and Methods

Researchers analyzed data from two large, nationwide health surveys conducted in Finland—one in 2000 and another in 2011. These surveys included:

• Health questionnaires covering diet, medical history, and lifestyle
• Blood tests to screen for celiac disease antibodies
• Psychological assessments measuring depression and general well-being

Celiac.com Sponsor (A12):
The study focused on adults who reported avoiding gluten but did not have celiac disease or positive celiac-related antibodies. This group was labeled PWAG (People Without Celiac Disease Avoiding Gluten).

Key Findings

1. Gluten Avoidance Increased Dramatically

• In 2000, only 0.2% of Finnish adults avoided gluten without celiac disease.
• By 2011, this number had risen to 0.7%—a more than threefold increase.
• The highest prevalence was in adults over 70 years old (1.3%), suggesting that older individuals are also adopting gluten-free diets.

2. No Clear Medical Reason for Gluten Avoidance

Unlike celiac disease—which is linked to anemia, autoimmune conditions, and genetic risk factors—PWAG showed:

• No higher likelihood of celiac-related health issues before starting a gluten-free diet.
• No signs of pre-celiac disease in blood tests. This suggests that most people avoiding gluten without celiac disease do so for reasons other than undiagnosed celiac risk.

3. Multiple Dietary Restrictions Were Common

People avoiding gluten were also more likely to follow other restrictive diets:

• 41.7% avoided lactose (vs. 12% of the general population).
• 12.5% restricted foods due to allergies (vs. 3% of the general population). This pattern indicates that PWAG may have broader food sensitivities or dietary concerns beyond gluten.

4. Psychological and Lifestyle Differences

• In 2000, PWAG had higher depression scores than the general population.
• By 2011, this difference was no longer significant, but PWAG still visited doctors more frequently and were less likely to work full-time.
• These findings suggest that gluten avoidance may be linked to stress, anxiety, or general health concerns rather than a direct reaction to gluten.

Why This Matters for People with Celiac Disease

1. Differentiating Between Celiac Disease and Non-Celiac Gluten Avoidance

This study confirms that most people avoiding gluten do not have celiac disease. For those with diagnosed celiac disease, this distinction is important because:

• It reinforces that celiac disease is a medically necessary condition, not just a dietary choice.
• It highlights the need for proper testing before assuming gluten is the issue.

2. The Role of Media and Misinformation

The rapid rise in gluten avoidance—without a clear medical cause—suggests that popular health trends and marketing may influence dietary choices. For people with celiac disease, this can lead to:

• Misunderstanding about the seriousness of celiac disease.
• Difficulty finding reliable information about gluten-free diets.

3. Nutritional Risks of Unnecessary Dietary Restrictions

PWAG often followed multiple restrictive diets, increasing the risk of nutrient deficiencies. For celiac patients, this underscores the importance of:

• Working with a dietitian to ensure a balanced gluten-free diet.
• Avoiding unnecessary food restrictions that could worsen health.

4. The Need for Better Support and Education

Since PWAG often reported higher healthcare use and psychological distress, the study suggests that:

• Doctors should assess why patients avoid gluten—whether due to real intolerance, perceived benefits, or other health concerns.
• Mental health and dietary counseling could help those struggling with food-related anxiety.

Conclusion

This study reveals a striking increase in gluten avoidance without celiac disease—a trend likely driven by factors beyond medical necessity, such as dietary trends, perceived health benefits, and psychological well-being. For people with celiac disease, these findings emphasize the importance of:

• Accurate diagnosis to distinguish true celiac disease from self-imposed dietary restrictions.
• Evidence-based dietary guidance to avoid unnecessary restrictions.
• Public education to clarify the differences between celiac disease and non-celiac gluten sensitivity.

As gluten-free diets continue to grow in popularity, further research is needed to understand the long-term effects of gluten avoidance in people without celiac disease—and how healthcare providers can best support those with genuine medical needs.

Read more at: bmcgastroenterol.biomedcentral.com