Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Celiac Disease Vs Gluten Sensitivity - Please Help!

cami

Recommended Posts

cami Rookie
cami
Posted

After >10 yrs of health issues (mainly diarrhea, bloating, periodic weight loss, loss of energy, anemia, excema etc) which both I and my Dr thought were related to some GI-problem, I believe I have identified the cause... Dr thought IBS first, then some other food intolerance. About a year ago I started to suspect gluten. After removig it totaly from my diet I got SO much better. Called the Dr again, who was supportive and ordered test & a biopsy - went back on gluten for a couple of monthe (which was horrible). Tests came back borderline and the biopsy was clear, som my Dr said: "No celiac disese, but you may be sensitive to gluen anyway, so you might want to cut down..." But whenever I have pasta or bred it starts again. Not directly, but within a week or so. So, I called my Dr again and she said: "Actually there is no such thing as gluten sensitivity... There is celiac disease, which you don't have..." Please help me out:

1) Is it scientifically proven thet non-celiac gluten sensitivity really exists?

2) If yes, can I eat pasta etc every now and then or do I need t be as strict as someone with celiac disease?

I would really appreciate your opinions on this!!!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Jestgar Rising Star
Jestgar
Posted

I think you already know the answer to this. Gluten makes you sick. You can't eat it. Your doctor can only say that there was no evidence of destruction to your villi on the pieces that they took. There is no way to know what's going on in the rest of your intestine. Also, even if you aren't destroying your intestine, gluten makes you sick. You can't eat it.

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

Well, there's no scientific definition of non-celiac gluten-sensitivity. So technically, there can't be "proof".

There is, however, scientific evidence of villious atrophy concordant with celiac disease that resolves on a gluten free diet in the absence of the celiac genes. There is scientific evidence of varying levels of villious atrophy. There is scientific evidence of false negatives for both the blood test (varying reasons, including insufficient damage to the intestines and high references ranges in some labs) and the biopsy (again, varying reasons, including varying levels of damaged required to be categorized as damage and the chance of missing patchy damage by only taking a few spots to biopsy). And, there is scientific evidence that YOUR BODY does not like - at the least - wheat containing items. (The dietary challenge is a VALID DIAGNOSTIC TOOL.)

The problem with the label "celiac disease" is that some doctors are *very* literal. The classic diagnosis requires specific levels of damage to sufficient amounts of the intestines. Kinda like asking "are you bald?" to someone in the middle of balding. There isn't room in the literal definition for "gluten damages me, but not bad enough to pass your test, yet".

You know you don't do well with wheat - so listen to your body and get rid of it from your diet. Whether it's more than just wheat... well, you haven't talked about reacting to other gluten sources, so my suggestion would be to test them. That runs you the risk of making you feel crappy again, so it's a very personal decision.

Chicklet Rookie
Chicklet
Posted

I have this book ~ Open Original Shared Link and the author makes a case for gluten sensitivity before celiac. It's a good book you might want to see if your library has it or you might want to buy it.

Sensitive or celiac a gluten free diet is a must.

Nancym Enthusiast
Nancym
Posted

Isn't it amazing how our bodies can speak to us so clearly, so compellingly, yet we don't trust them as much as some doctor who spend 11 minutes in medical school on the subject celiac disease, 20 years ago. :P

cami Rookie
cami
Posted
  • Author

Hi everyone,

thank you so much for you replies. Point taken - I should trust my body! I just need to know... Sure, I feel crappy if I eat pasta for a couple of days, but, is it dangerous.. I mean, REALLY dangerous. I'm thinking of the kind of illnesses that I read are connected to celiac disease: cancer, arthrithis etc...??

Jestgar Rising Star
Jestgar
Posted
Hi everyone,

thank you so much for you replies. Point taken - I should trust my body! I just need to know... Sure, I feel crappy if I eat pasta for a couple of days, but, is it dangerous.. I mean, REALLY dangerous. I'm thinking of the kind of illnesses that I read are connected to celiac disease: cancer, arthrithis etc...??

The only way you'll ever really know is by getting one of these. Is it worth it?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      129,739
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    gexewib
    Newest Member
    gexewib
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.2k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • nanny marley
      Feeling of Phlegm and thickness in throat

      By nanny marley · Posted

      Has anyone had any feeling in the throat like Phlegm , thick throat feeling after eating gluten ? Just wondering if this could be a symptom ?
    • nanny marley
      Feeling of phlegm and thickness in throat

      By nanny marley · Posted

      Has anyone had any feeling in the throat like plemb, thick throat feeling after eating gluten ? Just wondering if this could be a symptom ?
    • knitty kitty
      Still unsure.....

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      If you're more comfortable starting slow, that's fine, but do increase your dose to 500 mg per day as quickly as possible.  The World Health Organization recommends 500 mg thiamine HCl per day when deficiency is suspected.  Dr. Lonsdale had researched high dose thiamine for decades, and he has used higher doses, 1 to 3 grams in some cases.   Like I explained above, it's at that 500 mg level or higher that passive diffusion happens and thiamine can get into cells.  Inside the cells, thiamine turns the mitochondria back on.  Mitochondria produce energy the cells use to function.  I had been taking a multivitamin containing thiamine HCl regularly and still had become deficient.  Malabsorption of celiac disease really affects vitamin absorption.  I bought a bottle of thiamine HCl.  I was skeptical, too. I thought it couldn't be that easy.  I took 500 mg all at once.  I had improvement within minutes.  I couldn't believe the sensation of energy spreading to all parts of my body.  My brain felt like it was lifted out of a sub-sub-basement by an elevator and lights were coming on, floor by floor, of a skyscraper.  It was mental improvement, mental clarity.  Thiamine is needed for nerves to transmit electrical impulses, so the more nerves transmitting electrical impulses, the more my brain started working better.  The better my brain started working, the better I felt physically.  My muscles had more energy.  I wanted to get up and do stuff.   P.S. Questions are welcome.  "there's no poverty like ignorance, no wealth like knowledge". Keep learning!
    • badastronaut
      Still unsure.....

      By badastronaut · Posted

      Thanks! I think I'll start slow. See what happens. Should I notice the thiamine working almost straight away if I'm really deficient? What kinda of difference did you notice? More mental? Of also physical in the sense of more energy?    Sorry for all the questions! 
    • knitty kitty
      Still unsure.....

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Absolutely no danger of overdosing on the stuff.  Thiamine is nontoxic, and safe.  I had gotten to 1000 mg of Thiamine HCl a day at one point.   Do continue taking the multivitamin with the other B vitamins.  You may want to add a magnesium supplement because magnesium and thiamine make enzymes together.  I like Magnesium l-Threonate (Neuro-Mag by life extension).  You may want to add a B Complex in addition to the multivitamin (take them at different times).  All the B vitamins are water soluble.   With Thiamine HCl, there's a "magic moment" about 500 mg, where sufficient thiamine can get into the cells by passive diffusion, and the difference is amazing.  In thiamine insufficiency, the thiamine transporters (special gates into the cell) shut down.  Thiamine cannot get into the cells until there's a higher concentration outside of the cell.  Once that happens, the  thiamine can get through and go to work inside the cells.   If you're brave, start with 300 mg at one meal and 200 mg at the next meal.  Increase as you feel comfortable.  You may want to stay at one amount for a few days before increasing again.  Just keep adding another 100 mg as long as you keep feeling improvement.  If you feel uncomfortable, skip the next dose.  Thiamine HCL is water soluble and excess is easily excreted.  Don't take thiamine close to bedtime because you may feel too energized to sleep.   Thiamine HCl may feel like riding in the back of a pick up truck on a gravel road.  Benfotiamine feels like you're in a chauffeur driven Rolls Royce.  TTFD feels like you're driving a Lamborghini.  You'll get there no matter what kind of thiamine is taking you there.  Just keep taking it.  The health improvements can be very subtle, but you'll notice in the long run.   I started with 500 mg of Thiamine HCl, to see what would happen and had amazing improvement within an hour.  I took 300 mg with each of two meals and 100 mg with snacks.  I eventually added in Benfotiamine (250 mg  a couple of times a day) and reduced the thiamine HCl.  Later I added in TTFD (50 mg) several times a day.  Just experiment and see what feels right for you. Everyone is different and has a different level of deficiency.   I kept having additional improvement with each type of thiamine.  I've taken thiamine for almost fifteen years now.  I still take all three kinds on maintenance doses.  You have to experiment and see which ones work best for you in which combination.   I'm right here if you need anything.   You'll be fine.
×
×
  • Create New...