Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Gluten Challenge Question


H8 Wheat

Recommended Posts

H8 Wheat Newbie
(edited)

What percentage of people who do a gluten challenge and an endoscopy test positive for celiac? I’m asking because I’m about six weeks into the challenge, and I’m not sure it’s worth it. 

I’m positive for DQ2, but I don’t have a lot of digestive problems, except for reflux. Right now my arthritis is the worst it’s ever been. Could that be gluten? In the past I’ve had several problems that are associated with celiac: fatty liver, low iron, low B12. I have osteoporosis too.

I was miserable for the first month on gluten, but I’m feeling better now, except for my reflux and arthritis. And I’m tired. I’m just dragging myself through life. 

I felt MUCH better on a gluten-free diet, and I’m really discouraged right now. Is it worth it, or not?

Edited by H8 Wheat

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Scott Adams Grand Master

This is a very difficult question. Nearly all doctors would say do the challenge (normally 6-8 weeks) so you can get a formal diagnosis, which is supposed to help you stay gluten-free (the idea here is that you may go off the diet if you don't have that piece of paper telling you that you shouldn't eat gluten).

Other things to consider is that once you get formally diagnosed, both life and health insurance could be harder to get, or may be more expensive than those without such a diagnosis.

HannahBick Explorer

For where you're at in the challenge, I think it is worth it.

If you have that piece of paper your friends and family members are more likely to take your condition seriously. Also, first degree relatives of a celiac patient are also at an increased risk for developing celiac disease, even if asymptomatic and they are more likely to be willing to get tested themselves if you actually have a confirmed diagnosis. As far as I know, you need to eat four to six slices of bread per day, every day, for at least 6-8 weeks. Then go in for a blood test (celiac panel) and duodenal biopsy. 

HannahBick Explorer
On 7/21/2018 at 9:23 AM, Scott Adams said:

Other things to consider is that once you get formally diagnosed, both life and health insurance could be harder to get, or may be more expensive than those without such a diagnosis.

Didn't see this before ^

Is it possible to get tested/diagnosed and not have the results placed on your record? Is there a way to pay a bit extra for privacy in this regard? I think getting diagnosed is worthwhile, but didn't give the issue you mentioned above much thought.

H8 Wheat Newbie

Thank you, both. I’m still eating gluten, but now I’m actively trying to get my testing moved up. Fortunately, my insurance won’t be a problem either way, and I’ll never be tempted to eat gluten again after this. 

Scott Adams Grand Master

Unfortunately it would become a pre-existing condition and I don’t know how this could be kept from insurance companies. If having the piece of paper will help you stay gluten-free, by all means finish the process, but this issue is definitely worth consideration.

GFinDC Veteran
(edited)

The University of Chicago Celiac Center recommends 12 weeks of eating gluten before the blood tests.  If you need the piece of paper for some reason, it is up to you if you want to continue the challenge.  I didn't do it because I had to work for a living and that was dang near very troublesome while eating gluten.  And it was clear to me that I didn't do at all well healthwise while eating gluten, and did much better being off gluten.  So no-brainer for me.

The end result either way for me was the same, I had to stop eating gluten if I wanted to live.  So a doctor saying "yeah, you should stop eating gluten" was not very important to me.  I  didn't need their permission or advice at that point.  Dr. Fassano listened to my symptoms and said they sounded like celiac to him.  That's all I needed to hear.

Edited by GFinDC

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



H8 Wheat Newbie

GFinDC, thank you. You’re right. I’m missing out on everything that I don’t have to do, and I’m “faking it” through what I do have to do. I’m exhausted, and I feel terrible. This isn’t living. I’m abandoning my gluten challenge and changing doctors.

cyclinglady Grand Master
7 hours ago, H8 Wheat said:

GFinDC, thank you. You’re right. I’m missing out on everything that I don’t have to do, and I’m “faking it” through what I do have to do. I’m exhausted, and I feel terrible. This isn’t living. I’m abandoning my gluten challenge and changing doctors.

@H8 Wheat — You said that you were nearly six weeks into the challenge.  That might very well be enough to find elevated antibodies in your bloodstream.  The University of Chicago issues pretty conservative numbers.  Their goal to is catch as many celiacs as possible.  We are all individuals and researchers really do not all agree on specific cut off dates during a challenge.  It is certainly worth paying for a complete panel.  Do not settle for just the TTG tests after going through a grueling challenge.  

I would suggest the blood test now before going gluten free.  But you must weigh all the options and decided what is best for you.  Scott is right that insurance could be impacted.  Heck, before the US National Healthcare Act, I was denied health insurance because I had Acne Rosacea and Hashimoto’s even though my doctor wrote a letter indicating that I was not medicating the Rosacea and that my thyroid was stable with hormone replacement and....I was doing Triathalons.  I was still denied.  I got insurance but was put in a high risk pool which impacted my premiums.  

I was diagnosed five years ago.  But 17 years ago, my hubby went gluten free per the poor advice of two medical doctors.  Poor?  Well, the gluten free diet worked, but does he have celiac disease?  We will never know because he refuses to do a challenge.  Who could blame him?  (We like for him to be able to work so that we can pay our bills.)  He will say that I have received way more support from family, friends, and medical.  

Only you can decide what is best for you!  

 

  • 2 weeks later...
HannahBick Explorer
On 7/29/2018 at 6:02 PM, H8 Wheat said:

GFinDC, thank you. You’re right. I’m missing out on everything that I don’t have to do, and I’m “faking it” through what I do have to do. I’m exhausted, and I feel terrible. This isn’t living. I’m abandoning my gluten challenge and changing doctors.

A 6-week gluten challenge is often enough for people to show changes on biopsy.

As long as you are willing to follow the gluten free diet for the rest of your life (from this day forward, for better, for worse), and you don't mismanage the situation by eating gluten-containing food once in a while, I think you have made the right decision. 

Further to what @cyclinglady said, it might be worthwhile getting tested for celiac antibodies (tTG (IgA), EMA (IgA), DGP (IgA and IgG) and Total IgA Level) because as soon after going gluten free, the disease quickly becomes undiagnosable.

HannahBick Explorer
On 7/29/2018 at 6:02 PM, H8 Wheat said:

GFinDC, thank you. You’re right. I’m missing out on everything that I don’t have to do, and I’m “faking it” through what I do have to do. I’m exhausted, and I feel terrible. This isn’t living. I’m abandoning my gluten challenge and changing doctors.

There may be a quicker and easier way to diagnose celiac disease in the future. I just finished watching a video from the Celiac Disease Foundation of Dr. Bob Anderson speaking about a potential diagnostic test that may not require the 6-12 week gluten challenge.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,346
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Thomas D Cosgrove
    Newest Member
    Thomas D Cosgrove
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):




  • Who's Online (See full list)


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • maryannlove
      Though trying to diligently eat gluten free, recent bloodwork was bad so searching for culprits.  Eat lot of (preferably mixed) nuts.  Most allergen labels say may be processed on equpment that also processes wheat, etc.  Finally found ONE kind (unsalted mixed) at BJ's.  Wessley (their store brand) that did not contain that warning.  Says in large letters "A GLUTEN FREE FOOD."  Well, all nuts are a gluten free FOOD!  Have been eating and now wonder if this is intentionally decieving.  So stopped eating until find culprit.  Nuts are so good for protein and fiber (especially if trying to not eat meat).  'Tis so frustrating.  Thanks to above, I'll look into Tierra Farms.   
    • somethinglikeolivia
      Fascinating! This was very helpful, thanks for sharing
    • maryannlove
      Despite being very diligent about eating gluten free, my recent bloodwork was bad.  So been on a mission to find the culprit(s).  During Covid my daughter found "certified gluten free" Yasso mint chocolate chip yogurt bars at Costco.  I was elated and have been eating them since.  When delving into possible culprits I discovered that the boxes with 12 bars at both Costco and BJ's no longer say "certified gluten free."  But the boxes with 4 bars at groceries and Target still say "certified gluten free."  Contacted the manufacturer and was told to go by what the box says.  So guess different machinery is used.  Was also told they were in the process of changing boxes.  Will be interesting to see what that brings.  
    • maryannlove
      Before I could call them (after all my research), Costco Pharmacy called and told me they found a generic gluten-free levothyroxine.  Was told name is Amneal brand.  Said they called and company  confirmed is gluten free.  Only one I had found was Lannett so did more research and found:  “BRIDGEWATER, N.J., Nov. 12, 2018.  Amneal Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NYSE: AMRX) today announced that it has completed a transition agreement with Lannett Company. Under the terms of the agreement, Amneal will take over the distribution and marketing of Levothyroxine sodium tablets from Lannett beginning December 1, 2018 through March 23, 2019, ahead of when the Company's previously announced 10-year Levothyroxine distribution agreement with Jerome Stevens begins on March 23, 2019.” So looks like we’re good until at least 6/23/29.  Active ingredients are colloidal silicon dioxide, lactose, magnesium stearate, CORN STARTCH, acacia, sodium startch glycolate. Bottom line:  We can tell our pharmacists we need gluten-free, generic Amneal brand Levothyroxine.   AMEN.  
    • Scott Adams
      Given your severe symptoms it sounds like you would be much better off going 100% gluten-free!
×
×
  • Create New...