Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Is What The Doc Said True?

bunnybaby

Recommended Posts

bunnybaby Newbie
bunnybaby
Posted

I am in the UK and my GP is convinced I am celiac. I have been gluten free for about 8 months and know my body cannot take wheat.

I have just come back from the doctor at the hospital where I had been referred for a biopsy as my bloods where negative. (in the UK).

The doc said my rash was nothing like DH despite lookinhg like it to me and my GP and that it could not be as mine are painful and irritating and DH is never painful only itchy. Is this true as I had read it was painful?

He also said that as my symptoms were massivly improved by my diet change then it could not be celiac as in his experieince celiacs rarely if ever have symptoms ( is this true to?) and see no change when they give gluten up?????.

He seemed to think that I just wanted to be celiac and said that if I went back on gluten for 6 months he would do the biopsy but he was hap;py to say that I am not celiac. I said no way as it would kill me to do that. And that was it - dismissed!

I am not sure what to make of it. I do not want to be celiac but I don't like being seen as a nutter either really. He was nice enough but very patronising. I will just continue to manage it myself but I was /am convinced I am celiac due to my symptoms, improvement on giving gluten up and the effect of even the slightest bit in my system now.

I just wanted to know if all he said to me is correct?

Thanks so much.

Ruth

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


KathiSharpe Apprentice
KathiSharpe
Posted

Time to fire your doctor.

bunnybaby Newbie
bunnybaby
Posted
  • Author
Time to fire your doctor.

Thank you! I think youmay be right :lol:

JillianLindsay Enthusiast
JillianLindsay
Posted

What?! Your DR is grossly misinformed. My DR said that Celiac doesn't cause vitamin B12 and Iron deficiency (which is one of the main indicators). DR's are smart, but they can't (and don't) know everything, that's for sure!

I don't have DH so I can't comment on that, however the primary reason for people to go gluten-free is because they see a reduction (or even elimination) of their symptoms! Time to ask for a referral to a GI doc or if possible a DR that specializes in celiac disease.

If you want (or need) medical confirmation that you have celiac disease then go back on gluten for the biopsy. If you feel better on the diet and don't care about (or don't feel you need) confirmation, then just keep on doing what is making you feel better :)

Good luck & I hope you find better informed DRs in the future!

Jillian

I am in the UK and my GP is convinced I am celiac. I have been gluten free for about 8 months and know my body cannot take wheat.

I have just come back from the doctor at the hospital where I had been referred for a biopsy as my bloods where negative. (in the UK).

The doc said my rash was nothing like DH despite lookinhg like it to me and my GP and that it could not be as mine are painful and irritating and DH is never painful only itchy. Is this true as I had read it was painful?

He also said that as my symptoms were massivly improved by my diet change then it could not be celiac as in his experieince celiacs rarely if ever have symptoms ( is this true to?) and see no change when they give gluten up?????.

He seemed to think that I just wanted to be celiac and said that if I went back on gluten for 6 months he would do the biopsy but he was hap;py to say that I am not celiac. I said no way as it would kill me to do that. And that was it - dismissed!

I am not sure what to make of it. I do not want to be celiac but I don't like being seen as a nutter either really. He was nice enough but very patronising. I will just continue to manage it myself but I was /am convinced I am celiac due to my symptoms, improvement on giving gluten up and the effect of even the slightest bit in my system now.

I just wanted to know if all he said to me is correct?

Thanks so much.

Ruth

bunnybaby Newbie
bunnybaby
Posted
  • Author

Thanks I just felt so low and cross when I came out and I just needed to hear what I know already from someone else.

Thanks

Ruth

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

Your doctor is horribly ill informed. His misconceptions about celiac disease are the worst I have ever heard. I have DH and yes it can be extremely painful as well as itchy. If you can find a new doctor please do so but if your healing well on the diet keep it up. That is the best test there is. Your body is clearly showing you the answer that doctor could not.

tiggsy Newbie
tiggsy
Posted

In my opinion the doctor at the hospital needs retraining. I personally would write to the management at the hospital and tell them that he should not be allowed to do anything connected with diagnosing celiac disease until he has been retrained. In my view he should be struck off, but i guess that's too much to hope for.

On the other hand, at least your gp seems to know his stuff. Unfortunately, sending you to another hospital for this sort of check will cost him, but if you do get sent elsewhere, remember that you must be on a normal gluten rich diet for several weeks before the test to have a chance of it being accurate.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


bunnybaby Newbie
bunnybaby
Posted
  • Author

Thank you both, i feel so much better to know that I was right about him. It makes you doubt yourself when you think they are the one you are trusting to be expert. Thanks everyone for replying it really helps.

ang1e0251 Contributor
ang1e0251
Posted

The doc said my rash was nothing like DH despite lookinhg like it to me and my GP and that it could not be as mine are painful and irritating and DH is never painful only itchy. Is this true as I had read it was painful?

My DH was so painful it repeatedly woke me out of my sleep at night.

He also said that as my symptoms were massivly improved by my diet change then it could not be celiac as in his experieince celiacs rarely if ever have symptoms ( is this true to?) and see no change when they give gluten up?????.

Look at just about any post on this website and tell me if none of us had symptoms and improvement on the gluten-free diet. Why in the world would we live such a restrictive lifestyle if not?

He seemed to think that I just wanted to be celiac and said that if I went back on gluten for 6 months he would do the biopsy but he was hap;py to say that I am not celiac. I said no way as it would kill me to do that. And that was it - dismissed!

As if anyone would "want" to have celiac disease. I feel he should be "dismissed".

I just wanted to know if all he said to me is correct?

Sounds to me like none of what he said to you was correct. Maybe God will look down and bless him with celiac disease just to school 'im!!

lovegrov Collaborator
lovegrov
Posted

My DH was not painful. Still, your doctor is an idiot.

richard

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

I am in Europe too, and your doctor is wrong wrong.

There are some new articles about celiac now saying many never reported any symptoms, that is because of family screening after the first celiac is diagnosed in a family.

But their symptoms (which they did not report before) got better off gluten. all kins of ills and illnesses, joint pain, depression, lots of things they did not connect to celiac before.

Thos articles are called the new face of celiac or new presentations og something like that. And that only 5% are underweight and 39% are overweight now.

On the local forum most have had symptoms and they do improve on a diet, but there are occasionally some who still have problems but they are few. And most have to do with wheat starch, that they do not improve until they also omit wheat starch.

If you can get a biopsy of the rash (healthy skin that has not had an outbreak, but during an outbreak) and it is positive for DH, this means you have celiac too. It can be positive for a year after going gluten-free.

Mine was negative but I had been gluten-free for a year and it was done without an outbreak.

(mine is burning a little bit right now as I ate a little bread with wheat starch while travelling)

bunnybaby Newbie
bunnybaby
Posted
  • Author
I am in Europe too, and your doctor is wrong wrong.

There are some new articles about celiac now saying many never reported any symptoms, that is because of family screening after the first celiac is diagnosed in a family.

But their symptoms (which they did not report before) got better off gluten. all kins of ills and illnesses, joint pain, depression, lots of things they did not connect to celiac before.

Thos articles are called the new face of celiac or new presentations og something like that. And that only 5% are underweight and 39% are overweight now.

On the local forum most have had symptoms and they do improve on a diet, but there are occasionally some who still have problems but they are few. And most have to do with wheat starch, that they do not improve until they also omit wheat starch.

If you can get a biopsy of the rash (healthy skin that has not had an outbreak, but during an outbreak) and it is positive for DH, this means you have celiac too. It can be positive for a year after going gluten-free.

Mine was negative but I had been gluten-free for a year and it was done without an outbreak.

(mine is burning a little bit right now as I ate a little bread with wheat starch while travelling)

Thank you, I will pursue it through the DH. I know it is caused by wheat, as it the link to outbreaks is so strong now.

I have been Gluten free for 7 months or 8 I think so that should be fine. I am just recovering from an outbreak now thanks to slipping up somewhere 2 weeks ago.

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Maybe get a biopsy done during an outbreak. Must be done right (on skin that is healthy) (I read a posting somewhere that the doctor took several samples and the person did get a diagnosis)

I think some pwople need several biopsies before one turns out positive. Don't give up.

I still have to get a big rash and a biopsy ( my rash lasts only a short time)

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to mamaof7's topic in Parents, Friends and Loved Ones of Celiacs
      6

      Help understand results

      That test is saying that your daughter is not making normal amounts of any IGA antibodies. She's not making normal amounts of antibodies against gliadin, not against bacteria, not against viruses. She is deficient in total IGA, so the test for antigliadin antibodies is not valid. The test was a failure. The test only works if all different kinds of antibodies...
    2. knitty kitty
      0

      Vitamins I Take

    3. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to hjayne19's topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      10

      Insomnia help

      @hjayne19, So glad you found the information helpful. I know how difficult my struggle with anxiety has been. I've been finding things that helped me and sharing that with others makes my journey worthwhile. I like Life Extension Bioactive Complete B Complex. It contains the easily activated forms of B vitamins needed by people with the MTHFR...
    4. trents
      - trents replied to pothosqueen's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      1

      Positive biopsy

      Welcome to the celiac.com community @pothosqueen! Can you be more specific about which IGA test was run that resulted in 114 score and said to be "normal" and could you please include the reference range for what would be normal? By the size of that number it looks like it may have been what we call "total IGA" but that test is not usually run...
    5. pothosqueen
      - pothosqueen posted a topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      1

      Positive biopsy

      Upper endoscopy last week resulted in positive biopsy for celiac disease. The IgA they ran was normal (114). Does positive biopsy automatically mean definitive diagnosis?
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      132,993
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Tchudi
    Newest Member
    Tchudi
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.5k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Help understand results

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      That test is saying that your daughter is not making normal amounts of any IGA antibodies.  She's not making normal amounts of antibodies against gliadin, not against bacteria, not against viruses.  She is deficient in total IGA, so the test for antigliadin antibodies is not valid.  The test was a failure.  The test only works if all different kinds of antibodies were being made.  Your daughter is not making all different kinds of antibodies, so the test results are moot.  Your daughter should have the DGP IgG and TTG IgG tests done.   The tests should be performed while she is still consuming gluten.  Stopping and restarting a gluten containing diet can make her more sick, just like you refuse to eat gluten for testing.  Call the doctor's office, request both the IGG tests. Request to be put on the cancellation list for an appointment sooner.  Ask for genetic testing.   Celiac disease is passed on from parents to children.  You and all seven children should be tested for genes for Celiac disease.  Your parents, your siblings and their children should be tested as well.  Eating gluten is not required for genetic testing because your genes don't change.  Genetic testing is not a diagnosis of Celiac disease.  Just having the genes means there is the potential of developing Celiac disease if the Celiac genes are activated.  Genetic testing helps us decide if the Celiac genes are activated when coupled with physical symptoms, antibody testing, and biopsy examination. It's frustrating when doctors get it wrong and we suffer for it.  Hang in there.  You're a good mom for pursuing this!  
    • knitty kitty
      Insomnia help

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @hjayne19, So glad you found the information helpful.  I know how difficult my struggle with anxiety has been.  I've been finding things that helped me and sharing that with others makes my journey worthwhile. I like Life Extension Bioactive Complete B Complex.  It contains the easily activated forms of B vitamins needed by people with the MTHFR genetic variation often found with Celiac disease.   Avoid B Complex vitamins if they contain Thiamine Mononitrate if possible.  (Read the ingredients listing.)  Thiamine Mononitrate is the "shelf-stable" form of B 1 that the body can't utilize.  B vitamins breakdown when exposed to heat and light, and over time.  So "shelf-stable" forms won't breakdown sitting on a shelf in a bright store waiting to be bought.  (It's also very cheap.)  Thiamine Mononitrate is so shelf-stable that the body only absorbs about thirty percent of it, and less than that is utilized.  It takes thiamine already in the body to turn Thiamine Mononitrate into an active form.   I take MegaBenfotiamine by Life Extension.  Benfotiamine has been shown to promote intestinal healing, neuropathy, brain function, glycemic control, and athletic performance.   I take TTFD-B1 Max by Maxlife Naturals, Ecological Formulas Allthiamine (TTFD), or Thiamax by EO Nutrition.  Thiamine Tetrahydrofurfuryl Disulfide (TTFD for short) gets into the brain and makes a huge difference with the anxiety and getting the brain off the hamster wheel.  Especially when taken with Magnesium Threonate.   Any form of Thiamine needs Magnesium to make life sustaining enzymes and energy.  I like NeuroMag by Life Extension.  It contains Magnesium Threonate, a form of magnesium that easily crosses the blood brain barrier.  My brain felt like it gave a huge sigh of relief and relaxed when I started taking this and still makes a difference daily.   Other brands of supplements i like are Now Foods, Amazing Formulas, Doctor's Best, Nature's Way, Best Naturals, Thorne, EO Nutrition. Naturewise.  But I do read the ingredients labels all the time just to be sure they are gluten and dairy free. Glad to help with further questions.  
    • trents
      Positive biopsy

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the celiac.com community @pothosqueen!   Can you be more specific about which IGA test was run that resulted in 114 score and said to be "normal" and could you please include the reference range for what would be normal? By the size of that number it looks like it may have been what we call "total IGA" but that test is not usually run without also running a TTG-IGA. Total IGA tests for IGA deficiency. If someone is IGA deficient, then the celiac-specific IGA tests like the TTG-IGA will be inaccurate. Was this the only IGA test that was run? To answer, your question, yes, a positive biopsy is normally definitive for celiac disease but there are some other medical conditions, some medications and even some food proteins in rare cases that can cause positive biopsies. But it is pretty unlikely that it is due to anything other than celiac disease.
    • pothosqueen
      Positive biopsy

      By pothosqueen · Posted

      Upper endoscopy last week resulted in positive biopsy for celiac disease. The IgA they ran was normal (114). Does positive biopsy automatically mean definitive diagnosis?
    • hjayne19
      Mallorca Guide

      By hjayne19 · Posted

      This is great thank you very much @Scott Adams
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.