Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

NCGS - should I gluten challenge/EGD?


OHtummytroubles

Recommended Posts

OHtummytroubles Rookie

Hello,

I took a break from this board for nearly 10 years as I had a scope done years ago that showed I wasn’t Celiac. Fast forward 10 years, and my troubles continue. Since that time, I’ve had further testing, a gallbladder removal, colonoscopy and an exploratory lap to discover the source of continued stomach pain/bloating/distress. All have turned up clear, aside from the Gallbladder removal which also did not relieve symptoms. In early May, my father told me he tested recently and had the Celiac genes. I mentioned this to my Gastro, and she sent my bloodwork for testing as well. I am DQ 2.5 from what I understand. DQ alpha 1 2:01,2:01, and DQ beta 1 05:05. Gastro told me that doesn’t mean I have Celiac, but that I have the genes for it to develop. Said I could gluten challenge and to another EGD. My concern is that I’ve been gluten free since 5/12/22 and feel better. Not 100 percent, but better. I’m also not convinced that they would take more than one biopsy from the Duodenum.  I have had 2 scopes over maybe 15 years and each time they only took one biopsy from the Duodenum, and other samples from other areas due to checking for Barrett’s or HPylori. My understanding is you’d want them to take at least 4 samples from the Duodenum due to the patchiness of celiac vili bluntening, but maybe I’m incorrect. The doc said we could forego the scope and call it NCGS, but that I need to be strict with my gluten avoidance at this point and have my kiddos tested periodically since they are also at risk due to my father and I’s genetic testing. 
 

My question is, would you agree to a gluten challenge and scope if you weren’t confident the Dr would take enough samples for an accurate diagnosis? I just had my exploratory lap 5/12/22, so didn’t want to push another procedure so soon after:( Should I be content that it’s NCGS and I finally have some sort of answer?

Thanks for reading this far!


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



knitty kitty Grand Master

Welcome back to the forum!  

Sorry to hear you're having diagnosis problems.  Many of us have endured years of symptoms in a struggle to get a diagnosis.  

Since you've only been off of gluten for a month or so, doing a gluten challenge for eight weeks and another endoscopy may be the best way for you to get that diagnosis.  

Anemia can affect not only red blood cell production, but also white blood cells, including antibodies, which could explain your "normal" celiac panel tests.  

Could you please post the results of your blood tests?  Along with the reference ranges?  Some people have total IgA deficiency which would affect the Ttg IgA test for Celiac antibodies.  This can be missed if a doctor runs only the Ttg IgA test.  

Your doctor is missing the subtle signs of Celiac Disease like having the genes for Celiac, anemia, low Vitamin D, gallbladder problems, continuing symptoms that are alleviated on a gluten free diet.  

A diagnosis of Non Celiac Gluten Sensitivity should be made after Celiac Disease is ruled out.  

And, yes, more than one or two biopsy samples should be taken.  If your doctor doesn't agree, find another.    

Hope this helps! 

Awol cast iron stomach Experienced
Just now, Awol cast iron stomach said:

 

Is the Dr willing to put NCGS in the medical chart based on all the medical history and past tests? Are you willing, and able to be strict with just that label? Will your Dr's and medical providers honor that label? Will they help maintain your health and support it?

It does sound like in my opinion you know that you should avoid gluten. If you are committed enough to accept this and live the life of a Celiac . I can share I am labeled NCGS. In my experience I am labeled NCGS, but live like a Celiac. I could not finish my gluten challenge. I was to do 2 weeks I barely made it 6 days. So NCGS it is for me.  My cousin is diagnosed Celiac.

My reaction during the challenge was stronger and the impact longer lasting. I resigned from a job during that time as I was physically unable to get to work. I will not go into the details, but the symptoms fall out I could not make the drive to work on various levels. I did not even feel remotely normal for 2 years, and 4 months. I also had many symptoms, and developed additional intolerance during that time. 

I do not want to convince you not to do it, but just want to ensure if you already know, give you the reality of what it entails. IF someone didn't have celiac in their genes or family, I may say consider the challenge. Your situation has a strong indication that gluten or a subset of gluten is a problem for you.  

Best wishes

Scott Adams Grand Master

Wow, welcome back and I'm sorry to hear that you're not doing well. 

You are correct to question your doctor regarding the number of samples they plan to take during a endoscopy for celiac disease, and you are correct that the recommended amount is at least 4 samples. We had someone post here recently that they spoke to their gastroenterologist (in the UK I believe) and asked them beforehand if they would be taking at least 4 samples, got a semi-positive response, but then the doctor took only 2 samples, so you just don't know who you are dealing with, as it seems some doctors don't appreciate patients who go the extra mile and may actually know more then they do.

I agree with @Awol cast iron stomach that you have already discovered that 1) you have the genetics to get celiac disease; and 2) you know that going gluten-free provides you some level of symptom relief. This means at the very least you are likely in the non-celiac gluten sensitivity area, and there isn't a test for that yet.

Does it make sense for you to eat 2 slices of wheat bread daily for 6-8 weeks before a celiac blood panel, then at least 2 weeks before an endoscopy if you need to be gluten-free anyway due to your NCGS? What if the tests show that you don't have celiac disease, or are borderline or inconclusive? Would you still go gluten-free? To me it seems like your answer might be "probably," but that would be for you to decide. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      129,667
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    NormanW
    Newest Member
    NormanW
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.2k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • plumbago
      @Joe R Thanks for clarifying! That's what I've heard, too, about Italy, but I've never been, sad face. Almost no one on these boards would recommend the approach of your GI doc, and would instead stick with yours. (Maybe if a "glutening" causes so many discomforts and inconveniences that it just overwhelms your life, and you have nothing else to do...maybe.) But, generally in the clinical setting, coming off prednisone requires a taper, as suddenly quitting can cause problems. Anyway, good for you!
    • Joe R
      I am 58 years old and was diagnosed two years ago with Celiac Disease based on an EGD showing lymphocytic infiltrates and blunted villi in my duodenum. Lab work shows a severe IgA deficiency. Is it worthwhile to consult with an immunologist regarding the IgA deficiency?  I don’t seem to have any chronic sinus issues or infections but feel like I should get more information regarding the consequences of not having IgA from an expert. I live in Atlanta and surprisingly I have yet to find an immunologist that specializes in this area. Does anyone have a suggestion as to who I con consult with?  I’m sure that telemedicine consults can easily be accomplished these days if I can’t find a local expert. 
    • Jmartes71
      I was diagnosed in 1994 with celiac disease by Kaiser with biopsy and was told to stay away from wheat and I'll be just fine.I have and Im not.Had my first baby in 94 and my tolerance level was horrible.Having a celiac episode we all know how its horrible with the vomiting and digestive issues. Never googled because internet wasn't around.Still pushing through that's my normal.In 2001 was busy with my sick baby that went through the ringer with severe chronic Neutropenia it was horrible times he out grew it now almost 24 years old this month. In 2007 still digestive issues had blood drawn and have many food allergies.  told my primary im celiac ( i had primary Dr 25 YEARS up til May 2025.My savior was tramadel thats what my doctor gave me and thats what ive been on up til 2023 stopped when i got covid for the 3rd time to give my body a break. Been through  every test.Gi Dr as well who said I wasn't. celiac in 2024 Ive been glutenfree for 30 years at the time now 31 years. Im going to Standford this year and had breath test and sibo which is positive. I have ulcers on my body and I asked how when it was diagnosed as staph 4 years ago, not wanting to admit its from my dismissed celiac condition. Currently dealing with that.My last job was a bus driver last day of work was in March 2023. I was released from my job because of being out so long dealing with health issues. Disability is not helping at all, no income stressed.Currently doing more test and will be going under again next month with new GI doctor at Standford. Depressed because Im literally falling apart and it seems as if menopause is activating it more.Not eating what im not supposed too,always feeling full, tired, eye sensitivity to sunlight, constant bumps in back of my throat, pain down my left leg. Going through more test.Why is it so hard to get help or is it because I was dismissed all these decades?Should I take legal action?Im Currently not doing well which is keeping me from holding a job and im getting older.I can't push through anymore.Im very much into natural supplements that help but im still declining with one thing after another. What miracle will help so I can get back in the production line to make money.
    • Joe R
      That was the suggestion from my GI doc but I never book the medicine and maintained a strict gluten free diet. Actually, Italy is much more sensitive to gluten free diets than the US, I found. 
    • plumbago
      @Joe R are you saying that while traveling in Italy as a person with Celiac disease, you are eating gluten-containing foods and taking prednisone to dampen down the flares? Plumbago
×
×
  • Create New...