Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Gluten Challenge

Nic

Recommended Posts

Nic Collaborator
Nic
Posted

My 4 year old son Lucas has not been diagnosed as a Celiac. His brother has. Lucas does have some syptoms that match Celiac but when I had his antibodies tested through the lab my insurance company uses he tested negative. So I looked into Enterolab which my doctor has never heard of but suggested I get his blood tested with Prometheus (they ran my older son's blood). I am apprehensive about using Enterolab because of my doc not knowing them but really don't want to put him through more blood work (he has had a lot of problems since infancy and has had more blood drawn then I have in my entire life). So I figured the easiest way to go is to do a gluten challenge. My question is this: his symptom is constipation (as was his brothers) and I know that does not clear up quickly. How long do you usually do a challenge before you decide it is not working. Obviously if he gets better I will know it is working but I was wondering how long to wait if it is not. Anyone have any experience with this?

Nicole

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Guest nini
Guest nini
Posted

I would try the gluten-free diet for at least 6 months before deciding it isn't working. But that's just me.

CarlaB Enthusiast
CarlaB
Posted

So, what you're talking about is how long to have him OFF gluten before you can tell it's working? Or, is he already off gluten and you want to challenge it?

If he's already off gluten, it shouldn't take more than a few days for symptoms to start showing up again.

If you're taking him off gluten to see if his symptoms improve, I'd do it for at least a couple months. I know some around here have said that they didn't start feeling better for a longer time than that, but I'd bet that you'd start seeing some changes right away, and others after a couple months.

I was tested by Enterolab. Dr. Fine's research is not yet published, but he has had a good correlation between his tests determining someone is gluten sensitive and them having a positive response to the diet. This is cutting edge research, and basically, those of us using his lab are putting trust in newer methods that are not proven enough to be trusted by doctors across the board. I was very happy with their service, and their results were of no surprise to me. Also, one of my daughters tested positive, the other I had tested did not.

Nic Collaborator
Nic
Posted
  • Author
I was very happy with their service, and their results were of no surprise to me. Also, one of my daughters tested positive, the other I had tested did not.

My original plan was to use enterolab but it made me nervous that my doc didn't support it. I guess I worry about a false positive because while it would be no harm done if he ended up eating gluten free for no reason, it would be very hard to take away his favorite foods. He is not like my older son. He is developmentally delayed and while his cognitive skills (letters, numbers, etc) have been on target, his ability to communicate is delayed. I have a hard time explaining things to him and having him accept it. His brother was easier because I was able to explain what the problem was and he accepted it. It will not be as easy this time. Anyway, that is neither here nor there if he is Celiac, but if he is not I don't want to put him through it. I am sure Dr. Fine is "fine" :P and can be trusted but it makes me uncomfortable to not have the support of a doctor. So we will probably just use prometheus or try removing gluten. I am going to give it some more thought, thanks for the help.

Nicole

SarahTorg Apprentice
SarahTorg
Posted
My original plan was to use enterolab but it made me nervous that my doc didn't support it. I guess I worry about a false positive because while it would be no harm done if he ended up eating gluten free for no reason, it would be very hard to take away his favorite foods. He is not like my older son. He is developmentally delayed and while his cognitive skills (letters, numbers, etc) have been on target, his ability to communicate is delayed. I have a hard time explaining things to him and having him accept it. His brother was easier because I was able to explain what the problem was and he accepted it. It will not be as easy this time. Anyway, that is neither here nor there if he is Celiac, but if he is not I don't want to put him through it. I am sure Dr. Fine is "fine" :P and can be trusted but it makes me uncomfortable to not have the support of a doctor. So we will probably just use prometheus or try removing gluten. I am going to give it some more thought, thanks for the help.

Nicole

oooh, Nicole!!! This sounds like my son!

He is now almost 7 years old, and for years he took speech therapy, and I could NOT have a conversation with my son. Therapists said he was autistic. He has a hard time focusing on what people say, or following directions.

He walks around like he is in a fog, or stoned like. He is fascinated with peoples eyes and other strange things.

I cut gluten out of his diet after cutting it out of mine because of a skin rash I had. (dh) My son showed drastic improvement!!! Last week he ate lots of gluten foods after being off of them for a few months. I decided to keep letting him have it to see if it was truly the food, or if it may have been a phase.

on about day four, I couldn't stand my son. LOL He could NOT pay attention to anything. He put his clothes on backwards, and just stared at things like they were magic. LOL His temper would flare easily, and He was constantly thirsty.

So, if my reply here can help you make any decisions, I'll be glad I could share my experiences!

Sarah

Nic Collaborator
Nic
Posted
  • Author
oooh, Nicole!!! This sounds like my son!

He is now almost 7 years old, and for years he took speech therapy, and I could NOT have a conversation with my son. Therapists said he was autistic. He has a hard time focusing on what people say, or following directions.

He walks around like he is in a fog, or stoned like. He is fascinated with peoples eyes and other strange things.

I cut gluten out of his diet after cutting it out of mine because of a skin rash I had. (dh) My son showed drastic improvement!!! Last week he ate lots of gluten foods after being off of them for a few months. I decided to keep letting him have it to see if it was truly the food, or if it may have been a phase.

on about day four, I couldn't stand my son. LOL He could NOT pay attention to anything. He put his clothes on backwards, and just stared at things like they were magic. LOL His temper would flare easily, and He was constantly thirsty.

So, if my reply here can help you make any decisions, I'll be glad I could share my experiences!

Sarah

Sarah,

Thanks for the input. My son is always thirsty too. Especially when he was younger. He would drink all the time. As an infant and even now as a 4 year old, I have never seen anyone urinate so heavy. He was tested for diabetes and it was negative. And even though he doesn't seem to comprehend cause and effect, he is brilliant in other areas. We jokingly call him "rain man" because while he has so many delays, he was able to tell you what an octagon was at 2 years old and he didn't start naming colors with green or blue, he went right to all the crazy colors. He can match my near 6 year old academically but can't seem to control his impulses when he wants something. What makes it more difficult is that he is 52 pounds and hard to physically handle (his weight is not due to overeating, he eatsnext to nothing, docs. also tested him for hypothyroid). It has been the never ending battle. Anyway, thanks for the help.

Nicole

aprilh Apprentice
aprilh
Posted

it takes approx 1 year for your gut to heal on a gluten free diet. For me, I don't like to mess around and I don't care if my pediatrician heard of enterolab because he ignored me everytime I talked of my sons poop problem. I took it upon myself, ordered the test, and handed him the results. THEN he took the time to go on the website and learn. He agreed gluten free diet would be best and my son showed positive results within 2-3 weeks. Now, since he was hardly growing, I have him on a Hypo-allergenic protein shake, a L-glutamine amino acid (to heal the gut), and a good quality proibotic. I mix it all in to a protein shake and he loves it! We have one everyday. Now his little face is filling out and gaining weight. I also see a naturopathic dr. They have the same schooling as MD's except their last 2 years they go off to learn about nutrition and other alternative approaches to healthcare. I choose to see both for a rounded out health plan. She is the one that recommended the protein shake.

We also did a urinalysis to see what minerals he might be low in since he pooped so much all his life ( he is 2 years old) It came back with NO detectible levels of iron. So I am supplementing. The pediatrician never once talked about looking into that.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,659
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    DML2493
    Newest Member
    DML2493
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      Allergy Testing

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @ARutherford! Have you considered that your child may have gluten intolerance/celiac disease? It's not an allergy, it's an autoimmune response to the ingestion of gluten. It cannot be diagnosed by allergy testing but there are some specific antibody blood tests that any physician can order to check for it. Ask for a "total IGA test" and a "TTG-IGA" test. 
    • ARutherford
      Allergy Testing

      By ARutherford · Posted

      My child keeps getting rashes & stomach aches & l think it’s an allergy to gluten but l need to get a general allergy test done to confirm for sure what it can be. Getting an allergy test seems difficult, l keep hitting dead ends! I live in Christchurch & want to know if anyone can help with who to go to? Thanks
    • trents
      Is "Shield" skincare products gluten-free?

      By trents · Posted

      Good idea, @LynnM! That would be helpful to other celiacs who find themselves on the more sensitive end of the spectrum. You might also want to send them information about how to initiate the process with GFCO. But just a word of caution here, don't be surprised if the company is reluctant to pursue this certification as it can tie their hands with regard to changes in formulation in the future. Manufacturers often make ingredient decisions not only based on desired product outcomes but on cost factors. It can also put them at a liability risk should some ingredient supplier introduce an ingredient that was cross-contaminated with gluten without knowledge and cause someone to have a reaction. Testing for gluten-free certification is not done as frequently as consumers imagine and products can and do get out of spec at times. And once you slap a gluten-free certified label on a product, you are instantly open to possible liable suites. 
    • LynnM
      Is "Shield" skincare products gluten-free?

      By LynnM · Posted

      Hi Everyone. I just heard back from my son's GI doc and nutritionist. SHIELD products ARE gluten free. I am going to ask the company to Pursue gluten-free certification. 
    • Scott Adams
      Question about biopsy

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      Your experience highlights a common frustration in celiac disease diagnosis—discrepancies between lab results, biopsy findings, and clinical symptoms. The "localized mild nodular mucosa" noted in your duodenal bulb could indeed be significant, even if the overall pathology was deemed negative. Nodularity in the duodenum is often associated with lymphocytic infiltration, a feature seen in early celiac disease (before villous atrophy develops) or in conditions like H. pylori infection, chronic inflammation, or even food sensitivities (e.g., gluten or dairy). Since you had strongly positive celiac labs (e.g., TTG-IgA, EMA, or DGP), this nodularity might reflect an early or patchy immune response to gluten that wasn’t severe enough to meet traditional biopsy criteria (Marsh 3 damage). Some studies suggest nodular mucosa can precede classic celiac changes, especially in seropositive patients. Given your lab results and symptoms, it’s possible you have non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS) or are in an early stage of celiac where damage isn’t yet widespread. False-negative biopsies aren’t uncommon due to sampling error (celiac can be patchy) or misinterpretation of subtle changes. If you’re still symptomatic, you might discuss repeat testing (e.g., HLA-DQ typing if not already done, or a gluten challenge with both serology and biopsy) or consider a capsule endoscopy, which can visualize more of the small intestine. Alternatively, H. pylori testing or a trial of strict gluten-free diet with symptom monitoring could provide clarity. Your case underscores the importance of correlating labs, histology, and clinical response—not just relying on biopsy alone. A second opinion from a celiac-savvy GI could be worthwhile!
×
×
  • Create New...