Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Thoroughly Confused

jbuckeye

Recommended Posts

jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted

I'm hoping someone can help me. Two years ago, with a tTg of 76, an endoscopy (which the gastroenterologist said looked like a "classic textbook case of celiac disease"), and a positive biopsy, I was diagnosed with celiac disease. I went on a gluten free diet; symptoms disappeared; life was good. Fast forward to today. My mom wanted to know if she had celiac disease, so she submitted a cheek sample to Kimball Labs. The results came back DQ2 positive. So she asks me if I will take the test because she wants to know if I'm DQ2 or DQ8. I send off my cheek sample, and it came back today negative for DQ2 and 8 with big writing that says, "It is highly unlikely that this patient has celiac disease."

So--could the gastroenterologist have been wrong? Is there some other condition that would explain a high tTg and positive biopsy? Help. Very confused.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Lisa Mentor
Lisa
Posted
I'm hoping someone can help me. Two years ago, with a tTg of 76, an endoscopy (which the gastroenterologist said looked like a "classic textbook case of celiac disease"), and a positive biopsy, I was diagnosed with celiac disease. I went on a gluten free diet; symptoms disappeared; life was good. Fast forward to today. My mom wanted to know if she had celiac disease, so she submitted a cheek sample to Kimball Labs. The results came back DQ2 positive. So she asks me if I will take the test because she wants to know if I'm DQ2 or DQ8. I send off my cheek sample, and it came back today negative for DQ2 and 8 with big writing that says, "It is highly unlikely that this patient has celiac disease."

So--could the gastroenterologist have been wrong? Is there some other condition that would explain a high tTg and positive biopsy? Help. Very confused.

A positive biopsy is a little hard to deny. But...I don't know too much about the gene testing and will leave that to others.

bareden Newbie
bareden
Posted

I just read an article the other day that many males who have celiac do not have a positive DQ 2 and 8. I don't know if you are male or not but I will try to find a link to the article if you are interested.

jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted
  • Author

Thanks--am female, though.

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

the two common genes do not cover all cases of celiac. not having dq2 or dq8 may make it less likely that you would have celiac, but doesn't in any way whatsoever make it impossible.

kdaley Newbie
kdaley
Posted

I am negative for DQ2 and DQ8, and female. I have 1/2 of the DQ2 gene, and have Celiacs, "Mine was highly unlikely, but still possible (like less than 1% chance, but still a chance - I seem to always fall into that category :))." Science still knows very little about all the factors that result in Celiacs. One member here told me that countries other than the United States include more genes in the diagnosis - I don't know what those are (anyone?).

Anyway, I have my life back since my diagnosis. If being Gluten Free did not solve a life time of pain for me, than I would be searching for a different diagnosis. I am happy where I am at!

Good Luck,

Kelly

aikiducky Apprentice
aikiducky
Posted

What Tarnalberry said - all the genes for celiac aren't well researched yet, the two most common ones don't cover 100% of the celiacs. You probably just have a version of genes that the lab doesn't test for. I wouldn't argue with a positive biopsy and TTG and positive diet response though, you pretty much can't have more positive proof than that.

Pauliina

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Mistyping does happen, especially if they use serotyping.

The wikipedia article explains more about that.

Open Original Shared Link

and they found thar some have half the gene and that is mised if they do not do an elecrtopheresis and test both alpha and beta chains.

Open Original Shared Link here they found some mistyped celiacs and some half genes and some DQ1 subtype 5 (why onearth do they just write DQA1*01-DQB*05 and not tell us that this is DQ1 subtype 5? is it so they do not have to give Dr. Hadjivassiliou right in that he found 20% of the gluten ataxia subjects in his research being DQ1??

And they found DQ7 and DQ9 celiacs:

Open Original Shared Link DQ7

Open Original Shared Link DQ9

And, they have found that the DQ genes only predispose only with a half. Now they found another location that predisposes for celiac. Your mom probably has this, and you too.

nora

jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted
  • Author

Thanks, everyone!

fedora Enthusiast
fedora
Posted

Did they tell you what genes you do have?

jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted
  • Author
Did they tell you what genes you do have?

No--they only looked for DQ2 and 8. I wonder if another lab would look for more. Is Enterolab a good lab to use?

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Enterolab will tell you all the beta chains but not the alpha chains. Kimball I think will only tst for DQ2 or 8 but will check for alpha chains I think. Those not positive for DQ2 or 8 need the enterolab test to find out if they areDQ5,6, 7 or 9 or 4, I think.

I have not seen anyone posting with results form Kimball that they have half a DQ2 gene, though. But they do test for it, it sounds like.

Open Original Shared Link

nora

  • 2 weeks later...
jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted
  • Author

UPDATE:

Kimball reran my lab test and sent the sample out to a larger lab. (They were very helpful.)

Results: positive for DQ8.

Figures I'd have the rarer one....

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted
UPDATE:

Kimball reran my lab test and sent the sample out to a larger lab. (They were very helpful.)

Results: positive for DQ8.

Figures I'd have the rarer one....

Very intersting that they first told you that you were negative, and then re-ran the test and even sent it out to another lab.

D wonder how many others have just given up after they were told the test was negative.

I have re-read the wiki page on DQ and they give several reasons as to why people are mistyped.

Did they give you an explanation to why your first test was negative, and the second test was positive?

I suspect one lab used serotyping and the other used a different method.

On the wiki page they mention that the serotyping tests for DQ8 are not so sensitive I think.

Open Original Shared Link

Did the doctor question the gene test result and refer to the positive Ttg result and ask them to re-do the test? Or did you manage to get them to re-do the test?

Added: this may explain why the tests for DQ8 can be a bit difficult, as I can see 5 different Dq8 here:

Open Original Shared Link

and the other wiki page on DQ gives some reasons for mistyping.

nora

darlindeb25 Collaborator
darlindeb25
Posted

This is what I found in another forum, I think back in March--I truly believe this to be true. Scientist just do not know yet what genes truly do cause celiac, they only know a few, not all:

Open Original Shared Link

ScienceDaily (Mar. 5, 2008)
jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted
  • Author

I called Kimball and told them that it was very odd that I would be negative DQ2 and 8 since I was a biopsy proven celiac with a mother who was DQ2 positive and a paternal aunt with Celiac disease. They agreed and said they were going to rerun the test. I called a couple of days later, and they said that the picture was "getting clearer" and that they were sending my sample to a larger lab for gene sequencing--or maybe it was gene typing--can't remember-sorry. Very very interesting, but it makes me worry about other family members who have been told that they are DQ2 and 8 negative--like my son.

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Wow , really thought-provoking.

Like Dr. Lewey writes. He has two patients who he thinks are mistyped.

I think the wiki DQ page has the anwer to what happened: They maybe used the cheap serotyping first.

"To detect these potential combinations one uses a technique called SSP-PCR (Sequence specific primer polymerase chain reaction). This techniques works because, outside of a few areas of Africa, we know the overwhelming majority of all DQ alleles in the world. The primers are specific for known DQ and thus, if a product is seen it means that gene motif is present. This results in nearly 100% accurate typing of DQA1 and DQB1 alleles."

So we have to request sequence specific primer polymerase chain reaction.

Now which lab does that? Kimball obviously does not. It would be interesting to know which lab does that.

nora-n Rookie
nora-n
Posted

Added: here it says Kimball uses PCR testing, the type that is better according to the Wikipedia page on DQ.

https://www.celiac.com/articles/834/1/-Your...dams/Page1.html

"PCR analysis for DQ2 alleles (DQA1*0501, DQA1*0505, and DQB1*0201/*0202) and DQ8 allele (DQB1*0302). "

Maybe their method was not sensitive enought for DQ8, or the method for DQ8 is more difficult, since tehre seem to be several different DQ8 gene types, or you have half a DQ8 gene and they only test the beta chain (according to their site they only test the beta chain for Dq8) ?

Anyway, the wikipedia page says tests for DQ2 are more accurate, leaving DQ8 less accurate by deduction....your case just proved that.

jbuckeye Newbie
jbuckeye
Posted
  • Author

It's VERY interesting and somewhat confusing. We're now waiting for my son's results from Kimball.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. marlene333
      - marlene333 replied to Grace Good's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      3

      Bee balm lipbalm not gluten free

      To play it safe, use Vasoline Lip Therapy. No questions as to it containing gluten.
    2. Mari
      - Mari replied to Jmartes71's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      4

      Related issues

      jmartes, Thank you for sharing more information with us. Most of us Celiacs whose problems do not clear up with in a few years have to decide what to do next. We can keep seeing DR.s and hope that we will get some medication or advice that will improve our health. Or we can go looking for other ways to improve our health. Usually Celiac Disease is...
    3. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams replied to catsrlife's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      4

      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      It's unfortunate that they won't work with you on this, but in the end sometimes we have to take charge of our own health--which is exactly what happened to me. I did finally get the tests done, but only after years of going down various rabbit holes and suffering. Just quitting gluten may be the best path for you at this point.
    4. catsrlife
      - catsrlife replied to catsrlife's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      4

      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      My doctor didn't take the time to listen to anything. I don't even think she knows what it means. She is more concerned about my blood pressure that is caused by her presence than anything else and just wants to push pills at me. The so-called dermatologist wouldn't do a skin test. she prescribed all of these silly antihistamine skin meds. This lady...
    5. Jmartes71
      - Jmartes71 replied to Jmartes71's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      4

      Related issues

      I had the test done by one of the specialist through second pcp I had only a few months because he was saying I wasn't.Even though Im positive HLA-DQ2 .My celiac is down played.I am with new pcp, seeing another girl doctor who wants to do another breathe test next month though Im positive sibo this year.I have high blood pressure not sure if its pain from...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      132,263
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Elyn Joy
    Newest Member
    Elyn Joy
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.5k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Who's Online (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • marlene333
      Bee balm lipbalm not gluten free

      By marlene333 · Posted

      To play it safe, use Vasoline Lip Therapy. No questions as to it containing gluten.
    • Mari
      Related issues

      By Mari · Posted

      jmartes, Thank you for sharing  more information with us. Most of us Celiacs whose problems do not clear up with in a few years have to decide what to do next. We can keep seeing DR.s and hope that we will get some  medication or advice that will improve our health. Or we can go looking for other ways to improve our health. Usually Celiac Disease is not a killer disease, it is a disabling disease as  you have found out. You have time to find some ways to help you recover. Stay on your gluten-free diet and be more careful in avoiding cross contamination . KnittyKitty  and others here can give you advice about avoiding some foods that can give you the gluten auto immune reaction and advice about vitamins and supplement that help celiacs. You may need to take higher doses of Vit. B12  and D3.  About 20 years before a Dr. suggested I might have Celiac disease I had health problems that all other Dr said they could not identify or treat. I was very opposed to alternative providers and treatments. So many people were getting help from a local healer I decided to try that out. It was a little helpful but then, because I had a good education in medical laboraties she gave me a book  to read and what did I think. With great skeptism I started reading and before I was half way through it I began using the methods outlined in the book. Using those herbs and supplements I went from hardly able to work to being able to work almost fulltime. I still use that program. But because I had undiagnosed celiac disease by 10 years later some  of my problems returned and I started to loose weight.    So how does a person find a program that will benefit them? Among the programs you can find online there are many that are snake oil scams and some that will be beneficial. by asking around, as I did. Is there an ND in your area? Do they reccomend that person? If you would like to read about the program I use go to www.drclark.net   
    • Scott Adams
      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      It's unfortunate that they won't work with you on this, but in the end sometimes we have to take charge of our own health--which is exactly what happened to me. I did finally get the tests done, but only after years of going down various rabbit holes and suffering. Just quitting gluten may be the best path for you at this point.
    • catsrlife
      Patiently Waiting to See Results

      By catsrlife · Posted

      My doctor didn't take the time to listen to anything. I don't even think she knows what it means. She is more concerned about my blood pressure that is caused by her presence than anything else and just wants to push pills at me. The so-called dermatologist wouldn't do a skin test. she prescribed all of these silly antihistamine skin meds. This lady didn't even know what she was talking about and said "they never turn out as celiac, they usually just say it's dermatitis so here's your meds," just like my regular quack. I'm trying to change insurance companies at the moment and that has been a battle because of red tape, wrong turns, and workers having wrong phone numbers. What a joke! The allergy blood days say I have a wheat allergy of .31. Hopefully it's just that and until I find a decent doctor and dermatologist, I'll just lay off the wheat anyway, since it gives me asthma, high blood sugar, and joint pain. So frustrated at this point. The rash on my back of arms/elbows is mostly gone. Both calves and chest have started up. smh. It comes and goes. It fades faster now, though, although my forearms still produce one or two bumps on each side. The itching has calmed down a lot except for the bump area. I have dry skin to begin with so anything affecting it just makes it crazy. i'm never going to eat wheat again. I don't care if they need it to produce results or if it is just an intolerance, allergy, or celiac. It gives me hell.
    • Jmartes71
      Related issues

      By Jmartes71 · Posted

      I had the test done by one of the specialist through second pcp I had only a few months because he was saying I wasn't.Even though Im positive HLA-DQ2 .My celiac is down played.I am with new pcp, seeing another girl doctor who wants to do another breathe test next month though Im positive sibo this year.I have high blood pressure not sure if its pain from sciatica or sibo, ibs or hidden gluten. Im in disability limbo and I should have never been a bus driver because im still suffering and trying to heal with zero income except for my husband. This isnt fare that my health is dictating my living and having ti beg for being revalidation of my disregarded celiac disease. Its an emotional roller coaster I don't want to be on and the medical made it worse.New pcp new gi, exhausted, tired and really fed up. GI doctor NOT girl..
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.