Get email alerts Get E-mail Alerts Sponsor: Sponsor:

Ads by Google:

   Get email alerts  Subscribe to FREE email alerts

  • Announcements

    • Frequently Asked Questions About Celiac Disease   09/30/2015

      This FAQ on celiac disease will guide you to all of the basic information you will need to know about the disease, its diagnosis, testing methods, a gluten-free diet, etc.   Subscribe to FREE email alerts What are the major symptoms of celiac disease? Celiac Disease Symptoms What testing is available for celiac disease? - list blood tests, endo with biopsy, genetic test and enterolab (not diagnostic) Celiac Disease Screening Interpretation of Celiac Disease Blood Test Results Can I be tested even though I am eating gluten free? How long must gluten be taken for the serological tests to be meaningful? The Gluten-Free Diet 101 - A Beginner's Guide to Going Gluten-Free Is celiac inherited? Should my children be tested? Ten Facts About Celiac Disease Genetic Testing Is there a link between celiac and other autoimmune diseases? Celiac Disease Research: Associated Diseases and Disorders Is there a list of gluten foods to avoid? Unsafe Gluten-Free Food List (Unsafe Ingredients) Is there a list of gluten free foods? Safe Gluten-Free Food List (Safe Ingredients) Gluten-Free Alcoholic Beverages Distilled Spirits (Grain Alcohols) and Vinegar: Are they Gluten-Free? Where does gluten hide? Additional Things to Beware of to Maintain a 100% Gluten-Free Diet Free recipes: Gluten-Free Recipes Where can I buy gluten-free stuff? Support this site by shopping at The Store. For Additional Information: Subscribe to: Journal of Gluten Sensitivity

My Health, My Choice

11 posts in this topic

I am a nurse on disability. I have a long history of autoimmune problems and in the last week accidentally realized gluten is causing me problems. Of course I do not know whether it is celiac or gluten sensitivity, I only know that since I started avoiding gluten I am feeling better. I support strong positive relationships between patients and physicians. I strongly advocate patient education and encourage people to become active participants in their own health care.
That being said, all advances in science and medicine have come because someone looked at the status quo and wasn't satisfied. It is our right and responsibility to ask questions and when we are not satisfied with the answers to keep questioning until we find answers. This isn't only something we do for ourselves, but for those who come after us. We have the right to expect attention especially when the quality of our lives needs improvement. Pain and misery deserves the utmost attention. 
I’m reading other people's posts, people who are waiting for specialist appointments and eating gluten. They are miserable. Some are on a challenge but their labs are not reflecting expectations so they continue eating gluten. They are miserable. This is disturbing to me.
Let’s pretend for a minute that we are not dealing with gluten. What if someone bought hand cream and after using it their hands turned red and started peeling. This person goes to the doctor who takes one look and diagnoses Contact Dermatitis. The doctor tells them not to use the hand cream again. Why? When the body starts having reactions to a substance, continued exposure causes more, severe and possibly dangerous reactions. 
The person may now start having reactions to other products that contains lower amounts of the sensitizing agent to which they had not previously reacted. Sensitivities are not static. There can change, develop and worsen, which means if someone is prone to a sensitivity, one day there may not be a detectable problem and next day they have a reaction. After someone has become sensitized, it gets worse until that substance is removed.
I am not going to tell anyone how to manage their life or disease but I will share my plan on the issue whether it is gluten or any other health problem. I will explain my symptoms and history to the doctor, the circumstances of realizing the problem and the effects of my efforts at home. I favor blood tests, biopsies and skin sensitivity testing. However, if I’m asked to continue using something known to cause me health problems, I will consider the benefits. If I decide to return to eating gluten, I am not going to agree to continue past a return of symptoms proving the relationship of diet and those symptoms without the expectation of a clear benefit. I will also expect to be seen by the doctor making that request when my symptoms reoccur. I will not remain avoidably sick for long periods of time.
Chemotherapy is not withdrawn to verify a diagnosis. Insulin is not withdrawn to verify diabetes. If the person can manage their diabetes with other means (diet and exercise) there is not a question if they were misdiagnosed and they are not asked to prove their illness by returning to a previously dangerous lifestyle. Thyroid replacements are not withdrawn just to see what happens. These things are not done because it would put people at risk, it would cause harm. Advocating a course of treatment that causes harm and people at risk is not ethical.
The difference between those conditions and problems relating to gluten are what? The difference is the ability to see the problem in what is called an “objective” manner: in other words, visually, by lab tests, medical imaging studies, and so forth. What a person reports to the doctor is called “subjective” and in the eyes of many doctors, inferior evidence.  
I expect treatment as responsive to my needs in this situation as I would expect for any other. No person would invent symptoms causing such restrictions on their life as avoiding gluten without an actual problem. No person could detect the gluten hiding in foods or the environment allowing a report of a reaction without an actual problem. 
If I am asked to damage my body for the sake of a lab test, my response will be that such a requirement is inappropriate without a clear indication of benefit that outweighs the risk and damage caused. If I have to go farther, I will suggest reconsideration of the ethics involved. Damaging my body for the sole purpose of proving a point is unacceptable to me. 
If I have to say all that to a doctor, they may refuse to treat me. That is always their choice. We all have choices. I do know one thing. This practice will eventually change. History tells me this is true. Physicians bow to patient demands. This is fact but isn’t always a good thing. As patients, we got ourselves into trouble by demanding doctors offer treatment every time we dropped in with a mild virus. Since doctors knew we would go somewhere else if they didn’t comply, they handed out prescriptions for antibiotics until the antibiotics became ineffective. While it is a cautionary tale, this is still a good example of the power of the patient. When used wisely and properly, the power of patient expectations can and  eventually will change medical practice.
In a general practice, people with celiac or gluten problems are a large group and with specialists of gastroenterology, endocrinology and rheumatology the percentages are very large. There are always a few doctors who are willing to step out on limbs for the benefit of patients. After one of these doctors is found and the word spreads, social and financial pressures alone cause cascading changes throughout that community and beyond. 
If I need a cardiologist, I can expect to have the attention of my primary or emergency doctor who immediately finds a way for me to be seen by a specialist. Of course gluten is not as likely to cause death in the short term but I would argue that the relationship between high blood pressure and heart disease is as significant as the relationship of gluten and life altering complications of body systems including cancers of chronic inflammation.
So there isn’t a way to diagnose objectively and differentiate diagnosis? That only indicates an increased need to stay on top of current research and improve use of available measurements. Focusing on the development of tools to discriminate the differences of patient signs and symptoms could span the intervening gap and improve immediate care. 
Some conditions can only be diagnosed by subjective symptoms. When the choice is between listening to a patient or putting that person at risk, there is no ethical room for question. There is not an ethical reason to risk a person’s health,or damage well-being and quality of life if  another option exists. In the wide range of health issues related to gluten, is the quality of care improved by the certainty of knowing the origin enough reason to justify a prolonged illness to obtain a determination? If I am given a valid benefit..... wait, I’m sorry but someone has to chime in here because I sincerely can’t think of a valid benefit. As far as I am aware the treatment is the same, removal of the offending substance.
In medicine there is a saying: Treat the patient, not the machine. Machines can break and lack sensitivity, machines cannot see the big picture. My body can be more sensitive to insult than a machine can measure. Biopsies can become confused and misread, the results can be incorrectly filed or lost in the system of machines. I will be happy with the physician who understands the limitations and fallibility of the health care system, is sensitive to my needs, overall health, well-being and quality of life.  
I wouldn’t continue to use a hand cream causing me to walk around with reddened, peeling, cracked, oozing skin lesions while indefinitely waiting for a specialist appointment or positive lab results. I will decline to eat in a way that causes me to live with pain, diarrhea, constipation, sleeplessness, complications, damage of other body systems and in misery, simply to have medical records reflecting unnecessary determinations. I have nothing to prove to anyone.  
I choose this path for my health now and am unwilling to wait for the medical community in general. I choose to at least begin a trail for those who don’t feel they can speak up. I know others are joining in. This is who I have always been, I see no reason to start changing now. My choice may or may not be right for someone else but will always remain my choice to make.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

In a Celiac book and online I've read about a test called Rectal Biopsy.

In 6 hours the test is done. No months of eating bread.

I asked a microbiologist at the hospital and he never heard of this test.


There's also tests for testing leaky gut but they're not available.


Keep us sick but not dead is the medical business model.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Very well put!  I've been thinking about this quite a bit since I am currently eating gluten so I can have an accurate test done.  I'm only on day 5 (after only being gluten free for 12 days) and am ready to just do the test and hope it's accurate.  Sometimes I'm feeling ok but most of the time I just feel so yucky.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

It's hard when you have to ask for exceptions to be okay with not having that full spectrum. I'm studying abroad this summer and had to ask for housing exceptions so that I can continue to stay healthy while I'm in Austria. This required me to have a full biopsy test for medical evidence. Luckily, I found out the documentation requirements while I was eating gluten again for my biopsy, which came back positive, thank god. But even if it had come back negative I would have gone off gluten forever. So for me, it was worth it. Yes, my grades took a major hit and I only vaguely remember three weeks of the past month, but there is nothing left to question, which feels so safe to me.


For those of us who aren't in control of our food (ie. students of all levels), those three extra weeks of hell are the only way to make sure that there never has to be any harm again. But oh how I wish we all had that level of choice. 


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you for posting this. It is something I have been struggling wth lately. I've been gluten-free since February, and my body is starting to heal after 12+ years of daily headaches (that turned to daily migraines in Jamuary), chronic fatigue, and other symptoms. I'm pretty upset that my doctor didn't have me do the testing when I saw her 5 days after starting a gluten-free diet and reported its immediate effects. But now that I'm doing better, I really don't think I would survive any repeated exposure to gluten. When I had a flour communion wafer, I was deathly ill for 3 days. There's no way I could handle that for long enough to do the tests. I do think that people think I'm making it up some times, and I'd like to have a diagnosis to "prove" to them that I'm not, but it's just not worth it. So I'll never know.


Of course, if one of my kids started showing symptoms, I'd push for testing right away before removing gluten.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for posting this.  I went gluten free before having blood tests and found there was no way to subject myself to a gluten challenge.  I had a positive response to the diet, a positive genetic test, and a pregnant looking belly.  My MD looked at all these things and told me that I had celiac disease and should never eat gluten again. 


Do no harm.  I remember spending a week super-fatigued after drinking "glucola".  The pregnancy I was in also began some complications after that.  After that experience I forced myself to only do what seemed safe to me.  I decided that I would never have my blood sugar tested that way again.  I would also run any desired test through my own brain first and decide if it is worth any risk that it causes.


You put all of this so well.  It sounds like my friend Lisa M who is also a nurse.  We are responsible for our own health.  Beware.  Don't let anyone be little or disrespect  you  in order to do a foolish test.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Great post OP. 

I also have read about the mucosal challenge where a gluten suppository is used either rectally or orally. The tissue is then biopsied a few hours later to look for the antibodies. This test means that suspected celiacs do not have to poison themselves for weeks or months for a chance to be diagnosed. I first read about this years ago and have to wonder why it is not being used widely yet.  But then I look at the aisles of OTC drugs to control celiac related symptoms along with all the script meds......


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Emi, I can see you were offered a clear benefit and even though the time was lengthy, was not indefinite. I would never diminish your ability to make the choice that is right for you.

After reading other replies , I believe I would go through testing, even  lengthy testing, if it would help diagnose my child or family member. I would be able to see a clear benefit in that situation. 

I therefore stand corrected, there are situations where testing is beneficial.

I want  everyone  to understand, supporting each individual's choice is as important as supporting our own decision. So often we give ourselves over to the demands of those who don't know us, our lives, dreams and needs. We do what we are told is best without knowing why. 

 Everyone has permission  to make their own choice. I didn't give it to you. It was yours all along. Don't let anyone take that permission away. I will always support whatever choice one person makes to suit their own life.

When we go to a doctor or have a procedure we are asked to sign a permission form. No one emphasizes the importance of that form and if asked, it is explained in negative terms such as "we can't treat you unless you sign the form". Permission forms are actually the signposts of patient power. Treatment and procedures require adequate explanation before these forms should be presented. We should always, stop a minute and think if we have been given understandable reasons of benefit. 

Our power of choice should be shared for good reasons with those who are willing to treat us with the respect we deserve.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • turkey
      Turkey is gluten-free as long as it is not stuffed. You can make a good gluten-free stuffing using gluten-free bread. Dry the bread first and add what ever spices or veggies you wish, but cook it in a separate baking dish because stuffing the bird with it can cause bacteria to breed. And gravy must be thickened with corn starch or potato starch instead of wheat flour.
    • turkey
      so you can't even cook without stuffing inside turkey and not get gluten? Sorry I'm not familiar with turkey and wondering if I can have it while rest of family gets stuffing? In other words is turkey gluten free?
    • Numbness, Tingling in limbs & Joint Aches
      Hi Ender, Although you didn't get a complete thyroid panel, from what I see you are hypothyroid.  Most Dr's only care about TSH and yes yours is in the range, but when mine is that high I get terrible joint aches.  I feel best with mine around 1.  Your free T4 isn't just a tad low...most people feel best with it around 50% of the range.  I think you could benefit from some thyroid replacement medication.  You should also get a full thyroid addition to what you've had done a free T3, TPOAB and TgAb.   The last 2 are antibody tests.  Hashimotos is found fairly frequently with celiac.   Low vitamin D can also cause aches.  It would be really good to have your levels checked again.  Until you are healed you may not absorb it well enough so it's good to keep supplementing.  It took me a year and a half gluten free to get mine to an acceptable level for my Dr and he's keeping me on 2000 daily for maintenence.  For the numbness and tingling my Dr had me add magnesium as I was having horrible tingling in my feet and my B12 was good.  I have to say it has helped a lot. I hope you are able to get this figured out...I would definitely start with a complete thyroid panel and recheck of Vitamin D.  Here's a bit of reading on thyroid stuff if you have time.  Hugs!
    • Positive & Increasing TTG -- questions re: testing & history
      I'm a 31-year-old high school teacher (currently on disability) who has been dealing with 4 years of major gastrointestinal problems, which resulted in major surgery for a rectal prolapse & redundant colon last August, prior to which I had lost about 20 pounds. The source of all my gas, bloating, distention & diarrhea has remained basically unexplained though ("lets trust the surgery resolves your obstructed defecation and in turn your gas... d'oh it made both  worse"  ) , and my symptoms have only gotten significantly more severe since surgery. I'm facing a permanent ostomy. I've also, for the first time in a lonnng time, been eating a lot of gluten every day... primarily out of depression and (misguided?) attempts to gain weight and keep stool soft. I've been typically slightly underweight for 10+ years. Suffered anorexia for a period 10 years ago, and since recovering have "naturally" maintained a low weight and low-wheat lifestyle (I've always been put off by heavy wheat items like bread, sandwiches & pasta, *shrug*). As a child I had crazy severe & unexplained constipation issues. I've also had strong teeth discoloration & marked enamel defects (& two missing adult teeth(?)) since childhood. Depression & anxiety have been longterm issues. I have osteoperosis, which was perviously explained by me being anorexic from 19-22. Everything changed 4 years ago upon the onset of all my (severe) classic-IBS symptoms (gas/bloat/d+c). On a low-gluten diet, TTG bloodwork came back "low-positive" repeatedly. A biopsy showed no damage, but my gluten intake at the time was limited to 2 cookies a day, or occasionally 2 cookies and a piece of pizza. Would this have been enough to show damage? I trialled going gluten-free for a few months, and didn't find a ton of relief... so assumed I was just FODMAP intolerant... however I was eating lots of oats and lactose that whole time, which I have subsequently identified as major triggers... not to mention just lots of gluten-free junk food. Wheat was obviously a significant gas trigger since this hit, but that seems typical for gut illness in general. Since my major surgery and the continuation and worsening of symptoms, I've connected with an internist who has again and again pushed me towards eating wheat as a method towards weight gain and healthy non-anxious eating. I also found that a high-wheat diet would provide the proper consistency (i.e. very loose diarrhea every day) to allow colorectal function (the surgery I had went very poorly and caused major obstructed defecation). I have not had success gaining weight, and have found my digestive system feeling assaulted like never before 24/7 by bloating, gas and discomfort, despite a relatively low-residue diet and constant elimination. My appetite has never ever been worse. I just had a fourth TTG test, and after this high-gluten diet I am now testing POSITIVE as opposed to BORDERLINE. Questions: 1) I suspect my first biopsy's gluten challenge wasn't quite heavy enough in terms of gluten content (couple cookies a day). Thoughts? 2) Could being underweight alone cause an elevated TTG? How about simply having colorectal surgery? "IBS" or the supposedly non-pathogenic gut bacteria blastocystis hominis which I've been diagnosed with? I haven't been diagnosed with any other autoimmune condition, and I'm so confused. So far everyones just shoving the TTG off on IBS/anorexia, which doesn't make sense to me at all. 3) I really don't know what to do right now. I'm 20 pounds underweight, in digestive hell, with most of my medical support still suspecting I'm merely acting anorexic. I most assuredly am not. They want to put me on a tube. I would really like to get off the gluten in order to ease my system and gain weight, as I'm clearly reacting to it and have been deluding myself for the past year trying to recover from this surgery, but I'd also *REALLY* like some diagnostic confirmation so my doctors & family all stop looking at me like I'm crazy, and that so I can act with appropriate caution/freedom in my dietary future. 4) Do my childhood experiences line up with any celiac sufferers? I've heard about enamel defects, but missing teeth or crazy constipation? Obviously osteoperosis could connect, and doesn't *really* line up with my anorexia considering I was already fully grown. 5) Is there any way to get EMA/HLA blood tests done in Canada (BC)??? It's really frustrating that my only chance for any confirmation is waiting months and months here for another biopsy, especially considering how dire the need to improve my digestion is ASAP. I imagine if I could get an EMA test & it came back positive I would just take that as my confirmation and be able to move on with confidence here. 6) Is it common for celiac sufferers to find themselves reacting to FODMAPS and/or histamines in foods while they're  still maintaining a gluten-filled diet? Gluten definitely isn't my *only* trigger right now, and that's probably a primary reason I haven't been led to eliminate it at. Sorry for all the talk & questions, but I'm in an incredibly challenging place right now, my head is just swimming and swimming, and any thoughts would be greatly appreciated!   Bloodwork Current, after six months of a heavy-gluten diet = Tissue Transglutaminase Ab IgA ---18.0 ---- <12.0 U/mL = normal
      POSITIVE -Probable celiac disease but this should be confirmed with a small bowel biopsy. [Tested by a multiplex flow immunoassay
      (BioPlex) method.] 

      6 months ago = Tissue Transglutaminase Ab IgA ---13.0 ---- <12.0 U/mL = normal
      BORDERLINE - Borderline anti-tTG. Suggest repeat if clinically indicated.Consider the possibility of celiac disease - a small bowel biopsy may be required. [Tested by a multiplex flow immunoassay
      (BioPlex) method.]

      2012, prior to negative biopsy = Tissue Transglutaminase Ab IgA ---24.0 ---- <20.0 RU/mL = normal
      Weak positive anti-TTG. Consider the possibility of celiac disease - a small bowel biopsy may be required.  
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Entries

  • Recent Status Updates

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
    • Most Online

    Newest Member
  • Members