Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Different Reactions To Different Foods With Gluten


wsieving

Recommended Posts

wsieving Contributor

I posted this in another forum and never seemed to get any kind of response, so I will post it here in hopes that I can get an answer.

I am wondering if the concentration of gluten is higher in some foods, thus causing a stronger reaction, than in others. Our biggest clue to start looking in the direction of celiac disease was that our DD just cannot tolerate pasta at all. Other foods seem to bother her, but mildly compared to what pastas do to her. Is it because pasta contains more gluten than other things?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



ksymonds84 Enthusiast
I posted this in another forum and never seemed to get any kind of response, so I will post it here in hopes that I can get an answer.

I am wondering if the concentration of gluten is higher in some foods, thus causing a stronger reaction, than in others. Our biggest clue to start looking in the direction of celiac disease was that our DD just cannot tolerate pasta at all. Other foods seem to bother her, but mildly compared to what pastas do to her. Is it because pasta contains more gluten than other things?

Pasta would be pretty much all gluten, but understand that with celiac it doesn't matter. ANY amount of gluten will cause a reaction if you are celiac. Sometimes you may not have outward symptoms but if you are celiac your intestines are getting damaged all the same. Hope that helps. I would definately have her tested for celiac but keep in mind that sometimes children will get a false negative so if that happens, try the diet and see if that helps. If you start the diet before testing you will probably get a false negative. Welcome, this is a great site to learn about celiac.

MarsupialMama Apprentice

We have just started the gluten-free journey as of about 3 months ago because of my daughter. We put her on the diet before we tested for anything because she was losing weight so fast that I didn't want to wait another day before starting something that might help - and I didn't want to damage her intestines for one more hour. Right now my two daughters (almost 2 and almost 4 y/o) and I have been gluten free for about 3 months. We have all experienced positive results. (My husband still eats wheat bread). I have had digestive issues and other health problems my whole life and I can say for sure that the things that caused me the most indigestion were gluten steaks and whole wheat bread and pasta. Oatmeal was another terrible one, but I guess that might just be my personal thing since the gluten content from cross-contamination is probably not that high.

Gluten steaks are things that I made to replace meat (we are vegetarian) which is 100% gluten. I always got sick after eating them. Bottom line: We are not "diagnosed" celiacs, but have found that in our experience, the more gluten it contained, the worse the bloating and indigestion was. With my daughter though, even a bite of something cross-contaminated will cause her to drop weight and get the dark circles under her eyes and the cranky attitude (and sometimes bloated belly). So I think it depends on the individual, their level of sensitivity, etc.

My friend's son (2 y/o) got a bite of oatmeal and puked immediately from it. When he got ahold of a whole box of oatmeal cookies (and ate 12 of them!) he didn't vomit. But the next few weeks had diarrhea faster than she could clean it up! Maybe the amount of gluten-containing food plays a part as well. If it is complete gluten overload, it seemed with him to by-pass the immediate reaction, but come back full-force after the inital "gluten shock."

Who knows!

Amyleigh0007 Enthusiast

I also had stronger reactions to pasta, especially 100% whole wheat pasta. 100% whole wheat bread bothered me too. I would have to run to the bathroom within 30 minutes of eating. White breads and pastas did not bother me as much but I would still get ill after eating them. I do not have Celiac, but I do have gluten intolerance.

ksymonds84 Enthusiast

Congratulations MarsupialMama on figuring out the gluten intolerance. I wouldn't worry about getting an official diagnoses when your dietary response is so amazing and your little girl is now thriving. As I said in a previous post, a lot of times children are false negative anyway because they haven't produced enough of the antibodies to show positive. Some celiacs can add back oatmeal after their intestines heal but it has to be premium oatmeal from a health food store gauranteed not to have cross contamination. This is what I was told from my local sprue association but I've only been gluten free for 8 months and still don't want to risk it yet. My brother in law was diagnosed 4 years ago and still can't tolerate oatmeal, so like you said, its probably and individual thing, but it does sound like your son loves oatmeal :) 12 cookies! To be a kid again lol!

crunchy-mama Apprentice

I was wondering about this as a newbie. I have suspected gluten for a few years, but always have been confused that sometimes I have a strong reaction to something and sometimes not. I have also noticed the more whole grain something is, the more troublesome it seems.

purple Community Regular

I remember reading somewhere that whole wheat bread has more gluten in it than regular white bread.

I also read that your body reacts the same way.

Think of it likes fleas on a dog...you try to kill them right away. Compared to fleas on the carpet...you smoke bomb the whole house. Both cause harm/trouble. The dogs can get worse, spreads to other animals/carpet.

All gluten causes harm. Some is worse. Eliminate it all to be safe. We don't know about what we can't see...that's the hard part.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      129,874
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    Kelly Bates
    Newest Member
    Kelly Bates
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Being low in B12, Folate B9, ferritin, zinc and copper sounds consistent with anemia which can often occur with Celiac.  What did your doctor recommend? What about your Vitamin D?  It helps regulate the immune system.  
    • ehb
      @knitty kitty thank you I am exploring these options, I really appreciate all the suggestions and info. I am only slightly below the normal range for folate, zinc and copper. And in the low end of the normal range for B12, ferritin, and vitamin A. I’m good for carotene magnesium and iron, but I’ve been taking 400 mg magnesium daily 
    • Alibu
      I just had my endoscopy the other day and the doctor took 12 samples because he said if we're going to find something we're going to find it today LOL. But when he got down there, he said everything looked good. So I have it in my head again that it's going to be negative because everyone I've heard of who had a positive biopsy had their endoscopies where the doctor was like yep, I can see the damage. My tissues all look great apparently. So if they come back negative, I'm not sure where to go from here. Could it still be a non-celiac gluten sensitivity even with my blood work? I thought NCGS didn't show up on blood tests. Is it possible that the biopsy still comes back positive even if everything looked healthy on endoscope? I had it done at a big hospital in the state, so I would think they'd have the kind of equipment where they'd be able to see it well. I even have pictures in my report and they don't seem to have the damage that others have seen.
    • trents
      That's just it. When they are doing an EGD, even with biopsy, if they aren't thinking about celiac disease they may miss it. They should take several samples from both the duodenum and the duodenum bulb. Damage can be patchy and easily missed if sampling isn't through. And patch damage may explain lack of dramatic symptoms. Let me assure you that we frequently have posters on this forum who were silent celiacs for years and were diagnosed incidentally with celiac disease when their docs were checking for other things. They developed other medical problems such as anemia or vitamin and mineral deficiencies, neurological deficits, Hashimodo's thyroid, osteoporois, etc. - non GI symptoms - but their docs recognized those problems as often connected to celiac disease and had them checked for celiac disease, both blood antibody testing and biopsy, and found damage. A couple of years ago the Mayo Clinic did a large study involving over 300 people. They started with those officially diagnosed with celiac disease and also tested their first degree relatives. They found that almost 50% of  the first degree relatives tested positive for celiac disease and many or most were totally caught by surprise because they were largely asymptomatic. Their diagnosis was confirmed by biopsy. I really don't have anything more to say. You have some decisions to make.
    • knitty kitty
      Blood tests are affected by what you've had to eat in the previous day or two and any vitamin supplements you've taken in the past month or two.   If you have been taking vitamins before the time of the blood test, the vitamins supplements could mask a deficiency.  So get the tests before supplementing, or allow eight to twelve weeks for the supplements to wear off.    The thing with blood tests is that they measure what is in the blood, not what is stored inside organs and tissues where vitamins are actually utilized, and may miss subclinical deficiencies.  In times of shortages, the brain can order cells to release their stored vitamins into the blood stream in order to keep important organs like the brain and heart functioning.   Overall, getting blood tests for deficiencies is a good idea if it's available to you.  Ask for an Erythrocyte Transketolace test for Thiamine deficiency.  If you're deficient in any of the B vitamins, take a B Complex with all the B's in it.  The eight B vitamins work with one another like an orchestra.  Supplementing just one can throw the others off.  
×
×
  • Create New...