Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Negative Antibody, Positive Genetic Marker ... Now What

Salima

Recommended Posts

Salima Newbie
Salima
Posted

I went to my GP last fall with escalating digestive issues. She suspected a food allergy and put me on an elimination diet. After six weeks, I added foods back and only reacted to gluten with diarrhea, cramping, naseau. I also got poison ivy at the same time, which is very odd since it was December and I've NEVER gotton poison ivy in the 15 years I've lived in this state.

My GP diagnosed me gluten sensitive and told me to stay gluten-free. A Celiac friend recommended I see a GI doc and be tested for Celiac's. The GI doc put me on a three week gluten "light" diet then blood tested me. Today the results came back as anti-body negative but genetic marker positive.

I also have hypothyroidism, and have for years. Now my GI doc says I'm fine, no Celiac's and eat what I want (either gluten or no gluten). My GP says she wants me tested for Hashimoto's Disease, which some studies suggest correlates with Celiac. She recommends gluten-free for the most part because I feel better that way.

My question is, what to do next? I feel crappy when I eat gluten, so I guess I shouldn't. How careful should I be? If I have the genetic markers should I be regularly retested for Celiac's? What's the harm of eating some gluten in my case as long as I feel alright?

Hoping for the voice of experience here!

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Roda Rising Star
Roda
Posted

Well it is very likely that you could have gotten a false negative test because of you being off gluten for 6 weeks. That is enough time for some people to skew the tests. Also only back on a "gluten light" diet for three weeks isn't sufficient enough to get accurate testing either IMHO.

If gluten bothers you don't eat it. Or if you want to persue further testing with a scope/biopsy you will need to go back on a full gluten diet for appx. 3 months consuming about four slices of bread or equivilent per day. This still could lead you to a potential false negative. Or it is possible to have non celiac gluten intolerence(NCGI). Some people believe they are two separate things and others believe that NCGI is just a different form or a precursor to celiac. Either way for both type, gluten is bad news. Since you don't really know which one you are, if it were me I would treat is as celiac and be as viligent as can be with avoiding gluten. This is how I do it with my 11 year old son who appears to be gluten intolerent(negative celiac blood work and biopsy).

Definately get tested for the thyroid. Tests should include a TSH, Free T3, Free T4, and the thyroid antibody tests(don't know the names off hand). Autoimmune diseases tend to run in groups. Having one seems to make you more susceptible to others. I am currently diagnosed with three. Hashimoto's in 2000, celiac 2008 and raynauds in 2010.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

The Hashi's tests are anti-TPO and anti-thyroglobulin. :)

Roda Rising Star
Roda
Posted

The Hashi's tests are anti-TPO and anti-thyroglobulin. :)

Thanks Skylark. For some reason I can't seem to remember them.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

Thanks Skylark. For some reason I can't seem to remember them.

I wish I could forget about them. <_<

Roda Rising Star
Roda
Posted

I wish I could forget about them. <_<

I found out I had hashimotos when I was pregnant with my now 11 year old. I was already being treated for hypothyroidism 3 months before I got pregnant. I was having wonky symptoms during my pregnancy that prompted my PCP to test for the antibodies. They went down but I'm not exactly sure "when" since noone ever thought to test them again for a long time. I've had the antibodies checked within the last two years and they were normal. Unfortunately the years leading up to the diagnosis left permanant damage. Also each pregnancy left me more hypo after than before. Nothing improved gluten free since the damage was already done. However I have been stable since 6 months gluten free without any major adjustments in my meds.

UKGail Rookie
UKGail
Posted

I tested negative for antibodies, and also had a negative biopsy after a gluten lite diet. That was 2 years ago, and the GI said to carry on eating as normal. I took his advice and as a consequence my health continued to decline, and I ended up seeing a rheumatologist for a suspected connective tissue condition. The rheumatologist suggested I go gluten free, and that reversed many problems, and I am now much, much better. However I could have saved myself 2 years of pain and struggle, and my health is now much more fragile than it was 2 years ago, if I had stuck to my instincts and not listed to the GI.

I also have an unreliable thyroid, but not to the same extent of the other posters above.

An international group of leading Celiac doctors have just published a summary of the spectrum of gluten sensitivity. This includes a non-celiac gluten sensitivity, which has similar symptoms to celiac, and which responds well to the gluten free diet. There are currently no tests for it, other than by response to the diet, and problems with reintroducing gluten. Someone recently posted a link to the report, if you can find the thread.

As others pointed out, your tests were not properly carried out, so they may well have missed a celiac diagnosis anyway.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Salima Newbie
Salima
Posted
  • Author

Thanks for all your input. This gives me some information to work with. I appreciate the help.

Skylark Collaborator
Skylark
Posted

An international group of leading Celiac doctors have just published a summary of the spectrum of gluten sensitivity. This includes a non-celiac gluten sensitivity, which has similar symptoms to celiac, and which responds well to the gluten free diet. There are currently no tests for it, other than by response to the diet, and problems with reintroducing gluten. Someone recently posted a link to the report, if you can find the thread.

You mean this?

Open Original Shared Link

My thyroid is a mess, very unstable lately. It got bad well after I went gluten-free. I'm praying the switch to natural thyroid will help.

UKGail Rookie
UKGail
Posted

yes, thanks Skylark. It's not wildly helpful on non-celiac gluten sensitivity, but at least it acknowledges its existence. Hopefully it might help reduce the number of GIs telling patients who have had a negative biopsy or blood test to carry on eating gluten...

What still annoys me is the idea implicit in that black and white approach that one day you are fine to eat gluten, and the next you are very ill with malabsorbtion et al and have to avoid it like the plague. Our bodies tell us that you don't get there overnight.....

Sorry about your thyroid playing up. My celiac aunt became hypothyroid 2 years ago, some 8 years after her celiac diagnosis, and didn't think to mention it to anyone else in the family. We only found out about it a few weeks ago when her celiac sister's adult son was diagnosed as very severely hypothyroid. He is now being tested for celiac too. None of them even know what Hashi's is, so I guess their doctors haven't even tested for it.

Ginger7 Rookie
Ginger7
Posted

Just wondering, are you certain it was poison Ivy and not DH which can c

Be extremely itchy with some clear fluid. Need a biopsy of area next to rash to test. DH is demirtitis herpertiformis.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty commented on Scott Adams's article in Multiple Sclerosis and Celiac Disease
      3

      Gluten-Free Diet Linked to Reduced Inflammation and Improved Outcomes in Multiple Sclerosis (+Video)

      I worried at one point on my journey whether I had MS, having many of the symptoms myself. However, my symptoms improved dramatically with high dose thiamine hydrochloride, Benfotiamine, and Thiamine TTFD. Thiamine deficiency symptoms overlap with MS symptoms, including changes on brain MRIs. Thiamine deficiency affected my eyes (light sensitivity),...
    2. trents
      - trents replied to Matthias's topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      1

      Unexpected gluten exposure risk from cultivated mushrooms

      Welcome to the celiac.com communiuty, @Matthias! Yes, we have been aware that this can be an issue with mushrooms but as long as they are rinsed thoroughly it should not be a problem since the mushrooms don't actually incorporate the gluten into their cellular structure. For the same reason, one needs to be careful when buying aged cheeses and products...
    3. Matthias
      - Matthias posted a topic in Coping with Celiac Disease
      1

      Unexpected gluten exposure risk from cultivated mushrooms

      The one kind of food I had been buying and eating without any worry for hidden gluten were unprocessed veggies. Well, yesterday I discovered yet another pitfall: cultivated mushrooms. I tried some new ones, Shimeji to be precise (used in many asian soup and rice dishes). Later, at home, I was taking a closer look at the product: the mushrooms were growing...
    4. trents
      - trents replied to catnapt's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      9

      how much gluten do I need to eat before blood tests?

      I might suggest you consider buckwheat groats. https://www.amazon.com/Anthonys-Organic-Hulled-Buckwheat-Groats/dp/B0D15QDVW7/ref=sr_1_4_pp?crid=GOFG11A8ZUMU&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.bk-hCrXgLpHqKS8QJnfKJLKbKzm2BS9tIFv3P9HjJ5swL1-02C3V819UZ845_kAwnxTUM8Qa69hKl0DfHAucO827k_rh7ZclIOPtAA9KjvEEYtaeUV06FJQyCoi5dwcfXRt8dx3cJ6ctEn2VIPaaFd0nOye2TkASgSRtdtKgvXEEXknFVYURBjXen...
    5. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams replied to SilkieFairy's topic in Celiac Disease Pre-Diagnosis, Testing & Symptoms
      2

      IBS-D vs Celiac

      What you’re describing really does not read like typical IBS-D. The dramatic, rapid normalization of stool frequency and form after removing wheat, along with improved tolerance of legumes and plant foods, is a classic pattern seen in gluten-driven disease rather than functional IBS. IBS usually worsens with fiber and beans, not improves. The fact that y...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,328
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    VerafromNJ
    Newest Member
    VerafromNJ
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • trents
      Unexpected gluten exposure risk from cultivated mushrooms

      By trents · Posted

      Welcome to the celiac.com communiuty, @Matthias! Yes, we have been aware that this can be an issue with mushrooms but as long as they are rinsed thoroughly it should not be a problem since the mushrooms don't actually incorporate the gluten into their cellular structure. For the same reason, one needs to be careful when buying aged cheeses and products containing yeast because of the fact that they are sometimes cultured on gluten-containing substrate.
    • Matthias
      Unexpected gluten exposure risk from cultivated mushrooms

      By Matthias · Posted

      The one kind of food I had been buying and eating without any worry for hidden gluten were unprocessed veggies. Well, yesterday I discovered yet another pitfall: cultivated mushrooms. I tried some new ones, Shimeji to be precise (used in many asian soup and rice dishes). Later, at home, I was taking a closer look at the product: the mushrooms were growing from a visible layer of shredded cereals that had not been removed. After a quick web research I learned that these mushrooms are commonly cultivated on a cereal-based medium like wheat bran. I hope that info his helpful to someone.
    • trents
      how much gluten do I need to eat before blood tests?

      By trents · Posted

      I might suggest you consider buckwheat groats. https://www.amazon.com/Anthonys-Organic-Hulled-Buckwheat-Groats/dp/B0D15QDVW7/ref=sr_1_4_pp?crid=GOFG11A8ZUMU&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.bk-hCrXgLpHqKS8QJnfKJLKbKzm2BS9tIFv3P9HjJ5swL1-02C3V819UZ845_kAwnxTUM8Qa69hKl0DfHAucO827k_rh7ZclIOPtAA9KjvEEYtaeUV06FJQyCoi5dwcfXRt8dx3cJ6ctEn2VIPaaFd0nOye2TkASgSRtdtKgvXEEXknFVYURBjXen1Nc7EtAlJyJbU8EhB89ElCGFPRavEQkTFHv9V2Zh1EMAPRno7UajBpLCQ-1JfC5jKUyzfgsf7jN5L6yfZSgjhnwEbg6KKwWrKeghga8W_CAhEEw9N0.eDBrhYWsjgEFud6ZE03iun0-AEaGfNS1q4ILLjZz7Fs&dib_tag=se&keywords=buckwheat%2Bgroats&qid=1769980587&s=grocery&sprefix=buchwheat%2Bgroats%2Cgrocery%2C249&sr=1-4&th=1 Takes about 10 minutes to cook. Incidentally, I don't like quinoa either. Reminds me and smells to me like wet grass seed. When its not washed before cooking it makes me ill because of saponins in the seed coat. Yes, it can be difficult to get much dietary calcium without dairy. But in many cases, it's not the amount of calcium in the diet that is the problem but the poor uptake of it. And too much calcium supplementation can interfere with the absorption of vitamins and minerals in general because it raises gut pH.
    • Scott Adams
      IBS-D vs Celiac

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      What you’re describing really does not read like typical IBS-D. The dramatic, rapid normalization of stool frequency and form after removing wheat, along with improved tolerance of legumes and plant foods, is a classic pattern seen in gluten-driven disease rather than functional IBS. IBS usually worsens with fiber and beans, not improves. The fact that you carry HLA-DQ2.2 means celiac disease is absolutely possible, even if it’s less common than DQ2.5, and many people with DQ2.2 present later and are under-diagnosed. Your hesitation to reintroduce gluten is completely understandable — quality of life matters — and many people in your position choose to remain strictly gluten-free and treat it as medically necessary even without formal biopsy confirmation. If and when you’re ready, a physician can help you weigh options like limited gluten challenge, serology history, or documentation as “probable celiac.” What’s clear is that this wasn’t just random IBS — you identified the trigger, and your body has been very consistent in its response.
    • Scott Adams
      Question

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      Here are some results from a search: Top Liquid Multivitamin Picks for Celiac Needs MaryRuth's Liquid Morning Multivitamin Essentials+ – Excellent daily choice with a broad vitamin/mineral profile, easy to absorb, gluten-free, vegan, and great overall value. MaryRuth's Liquid Morning Multivitamin – Classic, well-reviewed gluten-free liquid multivitamin with essential nutrients in a readily absorbable form. MaryRuth's Morning Multivitamin w/ Hair Growth – Adds beauty-supporting ingredients (biotin, B vitamins), also gluten-free and easy to take. New Chapter Liquid Multivitamin and New Chapter Liquid Multivitamin Orange Mango – Fermented liquid form with extra nutrients and good tolerability if you prefer a whole-food-based formula. Nature's Plus Source Of Life Gold Liquid – Premium option with a broad spectrum of vitamins and plant-based nutrients. Floradix Epresat Adult Liquid Multivitamin – Highly rated gluten-free German-made liquid, good choice if taste and natural ingredients matter. NOW Foods Liquid Multi Tropical Orange – Budget-friendly liquid multivitamin with solid nutrient coverage.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.