Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×
  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.




  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):



    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):


  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Getting Enough Calcium & Vitamins


squirmingitch

Recommended Posts

squirmingitch Veteran

I had a bone scan last year (before I knew I had celiac)& it showed I had very mild osteopenia. Over the years I had tried every type of calcium supplement imaginable & they ALL gave me bad indigestion. Oyster calcium, the chocolate chews, liquid calcium gelcaps, & all the normal calcium pills. In order to increase my calcium intake I began drinking soy milk as it has more calcium than milk or yogurt. Now, since the soy milk has so much iodine in the form of carageenan that's out. And since dairy is to be in limited quantities (if at all) then the calcium from that is not a factor.

I had also tried B vitamins for years but they gave me indigestion also.

So how do you guys make sure you get enough calcium? And for that matter all the other vitamins especially the B's?


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



Marilyn R Community Regular

I

I had a bone scan last year (before I knew I had celiac)& it showed I had very mild osteopenia. Over the years I had tried every type of calcium supplement imaginable & they ALL gave me bad indigestion. Oyster calcium, the chocolate chews, liquid calcium gelcaps, & all the normal calcium pills. In order to increase my calcium intake I began drinking soy milk as it has more calcium than milk or yogurt. Now, since the soy milk has so much iodine in the form of carageenan that's out. And since dairy is to be in limited quantities (if at all) then the calcium from that is not a factor.

I had also tried B vitamins for years but they gave me indigestion also.

So how do you guys make sure you get enough calcium? And for that matter all the other vitamins especially the B's?

I'm just doing a multi-vitamin. I supplement that with a Calcium tab and D-3 drops. I make my own soup stocks in the pressure cooker or slow cooker. I have a weird craving for marrow bone. I think it's good for us.

Jestgar Rising Star

Green leafy vegetables. :)

itchy Rookie

Why do you feel you have to avoid iodine?

Preventing bone disease seems a higher priority than preventing DH. In theory DH will go away on its own once you get the gluten out of your diet and leave enough time.

Calcium and iodine are both essential to health, wheat gluten is not.

Also, I'm curious why you eliminate dairy? I still can't tolerate raw milk, but I eat loads of yogurt, cottage cheese, sour cream, frozen yogurt, and cheese without apparent ill effect.

Finally, are you sure that you are free enough of gluten? Many digestive problems will go away once the guts get a chance to heal. Maybe as you have gluten out of the diet you are not as senstive to those supplements as you once were? Just checking.

itchy Rookie

Hi squirmingitch

Just checked a couple earlier posts, where you mention you eat hash browns and don't eat oatmeal.

Personally I consider hash browns a high risk due to browning agents containing wheat that are used to make them look nice fried up. Without checking labels I wouldn't know, however.

Where I live it is easy to buy wheat free oatmeal. I eat loads of oatmeal without any problems. Others may not be able to tolerate oat products, but most of the literature suggests oatmeal is okay for celiacs, at least most of us. Actually I ate regular oatmeal without any problems previously, suggesting that most commercial oatmeal has quite low contamination with wheat. I prefer not to trust that theory however, now that wheat free oatmeal is easy to find (at least in Canada).

Finally, I have the same reaction to baked goods that you seem to have. I still get indigestion from gluten free baked goods. I prefer to limit these, which is a problem because well meaning friends seem to think that because I eat gluten free that I therefore must want to eat a lot of gluten free baked goods.

pricklypear1971 Community Regular

Why do you feel you have to avoid iodine?

Preventing bone disease seems a higher priority than preventing DH. In theory DH will go away on its own once you get the gluten out of your diet and leave enough time.

Calcium and iodine are both essential to health, wheat gluten is not.

Also, I'm curious why you eliminate dairy? I still can't tolerate raw milk, but I eat loads of yogurt, cottage cheese, sour cream, frozen yogurt, and cheese without apparent ill effect.

Finally, are you sure that you are free enough of gluten? Many digestive problems will go away once the guts get a chance to heal. Maybe as you have gluten out of the diet you are not as senstive to those supplements as you once were? Just checking.

The OP can answer for herself but I will chime in on the desperation to alleviate DH....

Uhm.....when I am in the middle of a DH episode there is absolutely NOTHING more important than making the itching, pain and burning stop. Not to mention the longing to have your brain not constantly occupied by the mental challenge of stopping your hands from scratching. Makes the thrill of shopping for "the perfect" clothes that don't touch or irritate the lesions (btw, such clothes don't exist) even better....

I'm serious when I say this...

If the devil appeared in front of me at 8 pm as those damn sores were filling, when that insatiable itching starts, when I am seriously in danger of losing it....I'd probably agree to any terms offered for a cure. Especially after almost 3 years of incessant torture.

Did I mention the part about cringing when people touch you, especially your excited child? The inability to fully extend your arms because the scabs rip open? What about the wet spots on your clothes where the sores weep?

Dairy is high in iodone. Iodine withdrawal is temporary.

itchy Rookie

Prickly Pear: I didn't mean to minimise the suffering. I've certainly experienced excruciating symptoms of DH and I can well imagine that there are others that have it much, much worse than me, especially judging from the photos on the internet.

Perhaps my observations are coloured by the fact I've never been able to detect a strong response to iodine containing food. I vary my diet quite a lot over time, and one would think that if I got a strong response from iodine containing foods, it would be noticeable. I continue to watch for it.

Which leads to my point that perhaps not everyone should assume they have to get rid of iodine, if it means not dealing with other health issues. I think people should check it out for themselves for their own response.

I don't know that squirmingitch hasn't done that.


Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):



Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):



pricklypear1971 Community Regular

The only way to know is to try...

squirmingitch Veteran

Itchy, ---- What pricklypear said. I couldn't have stated it better myself!

The iodine withdrawal is temporary. And it is in line of a test to see how I react. One has to do these things sometimes. AND I was suffering so badly --- well --- that ole devil prickly mentioned? We would be fast friends that devil & me. I have considered the filet knife at times to peel my skin off. Surely the pain of that would be better than the itching. At least it would be different.

BTW, the hash browns are potatoes. No other ingredients. No browning agents. Nothing but potatoes (peeled of course).

tarnalberry Community Regular

Studies have shown that supplementing magnesium, necessary for the use of calcium to build bone, is even more important in celiacs than calcium. Make sure you're getting ample D as well.

tarnalberry Community Regular

Oh, and weight bearing exercise, and lots of it!

squirmingitch Veteran

Thank you everyone! Ah yes, the leafy greens of course. I did know that but couldn't think of it. Chalk it up to temporary insanity due to intense itching & hunger. This stuff is making me stupid. But I know you've all been there, done that & it's nice to have you to turn to to keep me straight. And I do hope to discover down the road that I can take supplements because the problem with them stemmed from the celiac disease.

The magnesium is a good tip. I didn't know that.

I have long been a fan of weight bearing exercise. Tarnalberry, I see you teach yoga --- I taught ballet & practice the exercises throughout the day in the way I move doing anything around the house. Also love to walk with the dog which is a great weight bearing exercise.

I made a run to the store this morning & couldn't find cream of buckwheat so will have to order it online. Picked up some refried beans, stocked up on more fruit & fruit juices, unsalted nuts ( not many unsalted choices there) & picked up 6 Larabars, 2 of which went into the glove compartment for those desperate snacks away from home. Was getting shaky so I inhaled one while putting away groceries & YUM, YUM, YUM!!!!!! They are GOOOOOOD!

Threw myself a fine pity party last week at one point but I suppose you guys are familiar with that too. Got that over with & am ready to move forward with renewed strength.

Will have to get the Udi's bread online too as locally only Schar is available.

I think I'll be able to make the next few days without getting hungry. Wooooooo Hoooooo!!!! :D

pricklypear1971 Community Regular

If you can find Kind+ bars try one.

IMO better than Lara.

squirmingitch Veteran

I'll look for them online with everything else on my list. Thanks!

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):



  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,107
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748

    ashleynicole
    Newest Member
    ashleynicole
    Joined

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):


  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):





  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):



  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Wends
      Hi RMJ. I read your post. Sounds like you need a second opinion? Have you been advised by Dietitian or referred to one? There are protocols for treating patients that have ongoing celiac disease antibodies / histology. Particularly as you have nausea and pain. You probably already know about the gluten contamination elimination diet. It may be that you are super sensitive to even the allowed 20parts per million gluten in certified gluten free flours and products? An elimination of all grains for a time may be necessary? Especially oats if you currently include them? It’s worth noting that a minority of Celiacs have oat intolerance and T cell response similar to gluten (particularly carriers of high risk HLADQ2.5), and ongoing celiac damage to the gut can occur with oats. Even certified gluten free oats. If you are already super strict and careful about cross contamination, do you eat cheese or have any cow’s milk in your gluten free diet? It’s often overlooked, even by specialists and Celiac dietitians. But there are case study reports in children. There’s a study in adults showing mucosal reaction to casein in Celiacs, and quoted 50% of Celiacs react to casein similar to gliadin because of molecular mimicry. Then there was this letter to the editor following up a case that states, ”We conclude that given this novel information, pediatric, and possibly adult, celiac disease patients with suspected “refractory” celiac disease and no detectable gluten exposures, should be trialed on a combined CMP-GFD with close monitoring for disease activity resolution prior to consideration of more restrictive diets…” (Jericho H, Capone K, Verma R. Elimination of Cow’s Milk Protein and Gluten from the Diet Induces Gut Healing in “Refractory” Pediatric Celiac Patients. Ann Pediatr. 2021; 4(2): 1082.) CMP-GFD: cow’s milk protein-gluten free diet. Hope you figure it out.  
    • trents
      Welcome to the forum, @BlakeAlex! Is this the GI Reset product you are using?: https://inwellbio.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/GI-Reset_Info-Sheet.pdf There is a lot of weird stuff in that you could be reacting to. Personally, I would discontinue it as I doubt it's really doing you any good anyway. Getting to the point where you are truly eating gluten free consistently usually involves a significant learning curve as gluten is hidden in the food supply in many ways by manufacturers. For instance, would you ever expect to find it in soy sauce or Campbell's tomato soup? But it's there and a main ingredient. Getting rid of macro sources of gluten is relatively easy. Just cut out bread, cake and pasta. But avoiding the hidden sources and the cross contamination sources is much harder. I am including this article that might be of help to you as a new celiac in getting off to a good start:    Long-term undiagnosed celiac disease inevitable leads to nutritional deficiencies because of the damage done to the lining of the small bowel where almost all of the nutrition in our food normally is absorbed. We routinely recommend that newly diagnosed celiacs invest in some quality gluten-free vitamin and mineral supplements. And I'm talking about more than a multivitamin. We recommend a high potency B-complex, 5-10,000 IU of D3 daily, Magnesium glycinate, and zinc. I suspect your mouth and throat ulcers are nutritional deficiency related. Costco is a good place to get good quality gluten-free vitamin and mineral supplement products at a reasonable price. Are you on medications? May we ask your relative age?  
    • BlakeAlex
      Hello, I was recently diagnose with Celiac Disease and without realizing, I had every symptom on the list. Now I am moving as fast as I can to a total recovery. I thought I was doing well but I notice my ulcers on my tongue and throat and cough are starting to come back again.  Has anyone experience these symptoms? Also, I am incorporating GI Reset powder for a jump start to recovery.  Thanks in advance, Blake     
    • trents
      No. There is no damage done to the gut lining with NCGS.
    • MagsM
      Hi Trents, Thanks for the feedback. Yes, I do have concerns about NCGS. Would this show up if I did the endoscopy testing?
×
×
  • Create New...