Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

News: Celiac.com: The science is in — why gluten sensitivity is probably fake

Scott Adams

By Scott Adams
in Publications & Publicity

Recommended Posts

Scott Adams Grand Master
Scott Adams
Posted

Unless you have Celiac Disease, your sensitivity to "gluten" probably has nothing to do with gluten at all. Following is ... But it's also in gluten-free foods like agave, artichokes, asparagus, garlic, leeks, and onion. ... The people weren't allergic to gluten but they ate gluten-free due to digestion sensitivity.

Open Original Shared Link

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Victoria1234 Experienced
Victoria1234
Posted
4 hours ago, admin said:

Unless you have Celiac Disease, your sensitivity to "gluten" probably has nothing to do with gluten at all. Following is ... But it's also in gluten-free foods like agave, artichokes, asparagus, garlic, leeks, and onion. ... The people weren't allergic to gluten but they ate gluten-free due to digestion sensitivity.

Open Original Shared Link

Also see this: Open Original Shared Link

Wonder if this will help self diagnosed people decide if they are celiac or not? 

Feeneyja Collaborator
Feeneyja
Posted

This is a much better paper than the article posted above.

Open Original Shared LinkThe Overlapping Area of Non-Celiac Gluten Sensitivity (NCGS) and Wheat-Sensitive Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS): An Update

 It is very thorough, and describes the complications in illucidating the causes of NCGS and how to separate it from IBS. Of note from this paper: Fodmaps do NOT cause extra intestinal symptoms.  Also noted is the difficulty in recruiting subjects to investigate NCGS since most refuse to reintroduce gluten for testing. So there may be some bias in these studies towards those with less severe/complex symptoms. 

There is much more to this paper. I’m just scratching the surface and need to give it a thorough going over.  

Jmg Mentor
Jmg
Posted
29 minutes ago, Feeneyja said:

Of note from this paper: Fodmaps do NOT cause extra intestinal symptoms.

That was one of the faults of the Monash experiments in my view. They specifically selected patients with IBS symptoms. They then established that most of them weren't responding to gluten and from that finding came a spate of 'no such thing as gluten sensitivity' articles. Of course the reality is that NCGS is primarily non intestinal so the entire area of gluten ataxia and NCGS has been summarily dismissed due to Monash's headline grabbing research. 

The damage from that is still being felt to this day. I regularly see smug, vacuous, statements from people who wouldn't know a polyol from a polythene bag saying that NCGS has been proved not to exist. I've long since lost the will to direct them to the relevant papers etc. 

I know however that anyone coming up to me and telling me:

22 hours ago, admin said:

Unless you have Celiac Disease, your sensitivity to "gluten" probably has nothing to do with gluten at all. 

is going to have a very bad day!

Victoria1234 Experienced
Victoria1234
Posted
2 hours ago, Jmg said:

saying that NCGS has been proved not to exist.

Including my doctor. 

Jmg Mentor
Jmg
Posted
13 hours ago, Victoria1234 said:

Including my doctor. 

It's just bad science for them to say that. Certainly if he or she is going off the Monash research. When studies are conducted according to the Salerno criteria the results are different:

Open Original Shared Link

Gluten-free-01 Enthusiast
Gluten-free-01
Posted

I’m getting tired of reading about fructans. Let’s say someone thinks they might be gluten sensitive. They get tested for celiac and the results are negative. So they remove gluten from their diet and see a huge improvement in their symptoms.

If fructans were to blame, wouldn’t they get rid of the symptoms only after removing BOTH wheat, rye and barley AND other high-fructan foods such as onions, garlic, Brussels sprouts, cabbage, broccoli, artichoke, asparagus and leeks?    

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      130,035
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    ssarahbishop
    Newest Member
    ssarahbishop
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.3k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Wends
      Toddler recently diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes and need help understanding coeliac screening test results

      By Wends · Posted

       So sorry and sending well wishes. Replying from the UK. The NHS Coeliac Screen test is igAttg (including total igA). Your toddler is unlikely igA deficient with a titer of 22, as a positive test. When the igA anti-tissue transglutaminase antibodies are raised above the reference value or positive, the endomysial test is performed. The TTG test is suggestive of coeliac disease BUT it can be transiently raised in type 1 diabetes, milk protein intolerance (common in early childhood. Can also cause malabsorption similar to coeliac disease). Can be slightly raised in other food sensitivity and food allergy and some other conditions. Whilst it is more specific for coeliac disease than the older anti-gliadin test the EMA test gives a high specificity for coeliac, but labour intensive test so is checked when the TTG shows positive as a further confirmation of a likelihood of Coeliac. Sometimes in children the anti-DGP (deaminated gliadin peptide) igA and IgG are performed as more likely positive in childhood coeliac disease. Unfortunately less used test these days in favour of ttg test. Though in research studies still utilised in addition to ttg and EMA. It usually follows that the EMA test will be positive in active coeliac disease later than the TTG shows positive. It may be classic transient antibodies with type 1. Likely what the Dr is counting on to not worry you or put your child through unnecessary testing. it also takes time as in weeks/months for antibodies to build up. The new guidelines by Gastroenterology Society say in children coeliac can be diagnosed without biopsy if the ttg is ten times the upper value. Plus positive EMA. EMA is usually positive after ttg. It’s a good sign it’s negative and the Doctor is doing the right thing to retest in three to six months. It’s the only way for a definite diagnosis and whether further testing is needed (endoscopy and biopsy). The Doctor is taking the wait and see approach as it is common in type 1s for the TTG antibodies to normalise too, and will be following standard practice. Return to your Dr sooner though, if there are signs of malabsorption and sudden deterioration. It wouldn’t be unreasonable to request another blood test sooner with symptoms of coeliac. It’s a tough one. Have you a family history? Re type 1, Dr Bernstein book invaluable, and type 1 grit online. If you’ve not heard of this elderly type 1 Dr (diagnosed as a child) and his story already you need to. Sadly he recently passed in his 90s still practicing and treating type 1s and 2s. Wealth of info on his diabetes university you tube channel. Was the first to start testing blood glucose numbers at home, he was an engineer and retrained as a Dr. He gave the information to the world and diabetics that its possible to have normal blood glucose numbers and prevent the complications. The law of small numbers. Hope this reply is helpful.  
    • trents
      Toddler recently diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes and need help understanding coeliac screening test results

      By trents · Posted

      Here is an article that gives an overview of all tests that can be used to detect celiac disease:    As you can see, the different tests vary in their degree of specificity and sensitivity. So, it is to be expected that if someone has celiac disease, not all the tests will be positive. Also notice that the tests break down into two large groups, IGA-based tests and IGG-based tests. There is also the EMA (Endomysial Antibodies) which is an older test and has largely been supplanted by he tTG-IGA which is less expensive to administer. So, when you report that the TTG score from your daughter's bloodwork is 22ku/l, we assume you are referring to the tTG-IGA test, which is the most popular test ordered by physicians when checking for celiac disease and considered to be the centerpiece test. However, you do not mention if there was a "total IGA" test run. Whenever the tTG-IGA is ordered, a total IGA should also be ordered to check for IGA deficiency. IGA deficiency will result in other IGA test scores, such as the tTG-IGA being artificially low, even falsely negative. This is especially true for young children. This is discussed in the article I linked. If your physician did not order total IGA test, this should have been done. Do you have a recourse for requesting such? I should also mention that you must not withdraw gluten from your toddler's diet until all testing for celiac disease is completed. Doing so would invalidate the testing.
    • Scott Adams
      Toddler recently diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes and need help understanding coeliac screening test results

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      I’m so sorry to hear about your toddler’s recent Type 1 diabetes diagnosis, and I understand how overwhelming it must feel to now be navigating possible celiac disease as well. The slightly elevated TTG antibodies (22 ku/L) with normal endomysial antibodies could indicate a few things—sometimes, mild elevations can occur due to factors other than celiac disease, such as recent infections or even Type 1 diabetes itself. However, the symptoms you’ve noticed (changes in stools, itching, and hair thinning) could potentially align with celiac disease, so it’s understandable why you’re concerned. Since the consultant wants to retest in 3–6 months, it may be because they’re assessing whether the antibody levels persist or increase, which would strengthen the case for further investigation (like a biopsy). In the meantime, if your daughter’s symptoms worsen or you feel uneasy waiting, it’s completely reasonable to ask for an earlier review or a referral to a pediatric gastroenterologist for further advice. Keeping a symptom diary until the next test might also help track any patterns. You’re doing a great job advocating for your little one—trust your instincts and don’t hesitate to push for more clarity if needed. Sending you lots of support.
    • mytype1diabetes
      Toddler recently diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes and need help understanding coeliac screening test results

      By mytype1diabetes · Posted

      Hi all, Posting from the UK.  My 2 year old was recently diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes. In the UK they routinely screen for coeliac disease. The test showed slightly elevated levels of TTG antibodies. The consultant wants to repeat these antibodies in 3-6 months time to determine clinical significance. In our letter it said "marginally elevated TTG antibodies (22ku/l), normal endomysial antibodies". I'm not exactly sure what this means, especially given one of the tests were within the normal range, and if we should be worried about the numbers. It is difficult to know if she has any "symptoms" but at the time she was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes I noticed that her stools had changed. They are now probably a Type 6 on the Bristol stool chart. She seems to be quite itchy which is a recent thing and over the past week I have noticed some hair loss/thinning. I feel very worried and I'm not sure I can wait for her to be retested in 3-6 months time.  I'd appreciate any wisdom, advice or information you have. Thanks 🙏🏼
    • slkrav
      Glutened from hair conditioner- check your body products and makeup !

      By slkrav · Posted

      I was feeling really sick last week, for several days I kept thinking I was getting cross contamination. Typical symptoms like not sleeping well at night and waking up with widespread inflammation in all of my joints, foggy head and of course bowel issues. I had read the article recently that was talking about body products. I was starting to get depressed. I was showering and decided to read the ingredients in the products I've been using. It turns out that two of the ingredients in my conditioning hair mask contain GLUTEN. I felt really stupid for not checking before and I threw that away and also checked the ingredients of everything else I've been using. I've heard of skin issues from gluten containing body products, but this opens up a whole new way if being proactive. 
×
×
  • Create New...