Jump to content

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.


  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Confused - False Positive

ccooper

Recommended Posts

ccooper Newbie
ccooper
Posted

My 11 year old son seen the GI specialist yesterday. The GI said that he believed the blood test was a false positive. He had a score of 67(?). The 67 was high but the other two test were normal. The GI is now running a test for IgA only. What does this mean? If it's not celiac what is it? I was hoping that the celiac diagnosis was going to be our answer to his symptoms. He has a history of intestional issues (watery stools sometimes, cramping, short stature 5% range), canker sores, itchy skin and sores, fecal incontinence, IRRITABILITY (he doesn't get along with himself most of the time). Any ideas would be appreciated.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


WorryMom Newbie
WorryMom
Posted

I have done a lot of research on false positives and weak positives in the last few months because my 9 year old son's tTg IGA was 4.3 on a scale where 0-4 negative, 4-10 weak positive.

What I found indicates that you are much more likely to have a false negative than a false positive. According to most of what I read, even if not all the tests are positive they should still do an endoscopy to check for damage especially if they are having symptoms such as your son is. Did they do the endoscopy yet? Some of the things that could cause a false positive on the tTg are cirrhosis of the liver, diabetes or heart failure but this is very rare. Given his symptoms it seems much more likely he has celiac. I hope they are able to figure it out soon so your son can start healing.

My son is seeing a specialist next week. He was tested due to family history and not really sick at the time but in the last few months he has started being tired all the time and complaining of stomach aches. He has occasional bathroom issues and has become whinier than usual. I'm hoping the doctor will agree to do the endoscopy so we can see if he has it or not.

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

Most of us here "don't believe in" false positives. Why? Because your body is not going to produce an antibody to itself with no reason and without doing damage. It's kinda what autoimmune diseases are all about.

Do you know WHICH test came back "positive"? I'm assuming, from your comment about testing total IgA, that it was the anti-gliadin IgA test. About 10% of celiacs are IgA deficient, which means that they will always have low numbers, regardless of whether or not they are producing "more" anti-gliadin IgA. But that means they'll more likely get a false negative, not positive.

ravenwoodglass Mentor
ravenwoodglass
Posted

Your son's symptoms and the postive test make it pretty certain that he is one of the 'family'. If you are going to have them do an endoscopic exam on him, which also has a risk of a false negative, you need to make sure to keep him on the full gluten diet. If you are not going to do an endoscopy then go ahead and put him on the diet.

ccooper Newbie
ccooper
Posted
  • Author

I called the pediatrician to get a list of actual scores - Here they are:

IgA - 64

Gliadian IgG - 67

TtG - 3

No biopsy has been scheduled. More blood test were ordered in order to check for IgA deficiency. Does the above mentioned scores mean anything to anyone? The doctor is calling it a false positive.

ang1e0251 Contributor
ang1e0251
Posted

Could you please put the lab's ranges with those numbers? Each lab is different.

Many, many people have false negatives but I have never heard of someone who actually had a false positive.

ccooper Newbie
ccooper
Posted
  • Author
Could you please put the lab's ranges with those numbers? Each lab is different.

Many, many people have false negatives but I have never heard of someone who actually had a false positive.

O.k, this is the best that I know:

IgA - 64 with range of 65 to 246

IgG - 67 range of 1 to 11 normal

TtG - 3 normal range 3 and below

Does this help?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted
O.k, this is the best that I know:

IgA - 64 with range of 65 to 246

IgG - 67 range of 1 to 11 normal

TtG - 3 normal range 3 and below

Does this help?

As I suspected, the IgG test is positive, and the others negative. The tTg test being borderline just gives you an idea of how much damage is happening. (Still, why would he have any if there wasn't some response going on?) The IgA test being low tells you nothing if he's IgA deficient. The IgG test is QUITE DISTINCTLY POSITIVE. He is clearly have an immune reaction to gluten. (Most doctors *want more* because they so hate to put their patients on a gluten free diet. BAH!)

ccooper Newbie
ccooper
Posted
  • Author
As I suspected, the IgG test is positive, and the others negative. The tTg test being borderline just gives you an idea of how much damage is happening. (Still, why would he have any if there wasn't some response going on?) The IgA test being low tells you nothing if he's IgA deficient. The IgG test is QUITE DISTINCTLY POSITIVE. He is clearly have an immune reaction to gluten. (Most doctors *want more* because they so hate to put their patients on a gluten free diet. BAH!)

The GI acted like the IgG elevation wasn't anything if the other two areas weren't positive also. If he doesn't have celiac than I want to know why the levels were so high..... I guess I will have to wait and see what happens on Monday when I get the IgA deficiency results back. I don't mind the doctor wanting to know more, but I feel like I know less than I did before I went to the office.The GI stressed that grains are a very important part of ones diet and that no diet changes should be made unless something else shows up

Jestgar Rising Star
Jestgar
Posted

***Personal opinion alert***

The GI stressed that grains are a very important part of ones diet and that no diet changes should be made unless something else shows up

That's complete and utter crap. The human race survived for thousands of years without grain.

Ask him to name you ONE essential nutrition that can only be found in grain.

tarnalberry Community Regular
tarnalberry
Posted

that might "just" be jestgar's opinion, but I think she's completely correct. in my opinion, anyway.

your doctor is full of crap if he thinks grains are a mandatory part of a diet, or even that you can't have any grains if you're gluten free. wrong and wrong.

ccooper Newbie
ccooper
Posted
  • Author

Maybe he's full of crap and being ignorant. On a positive note, maybe he just didn't want us to get to alarmed yet- so that's why he said the grain thing???? I don't know.

I have read some other post that says that an elevated IgG is sometimes something else. Any ideas?

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Celiac.com:
    Join eNewsletter
    Donate
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-M):



  • Recent Activity

    1. knitty kitty
      - knitty kitty replied to MoniqueCham's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      4

      Celiac Disease, Lymphocytic colitis and Bowel rupture

      Welcome to the forum, @MoniqueCham, What a challenging journey you've had! Like you, I studied nutrition, but I earned a degree in Microbiology because I wanted to understand what essential vitamins and minerals were doing inside our bodies. I've come across some information that may be of interest to you. I'll post links below. On my journey...
    2. dsfraley
      - dsfraley posted a topic in Post Diagnosis, Recovery & Treatment of Celiac Disease
      0

      9 y/o Son Diagnosed with Celiac Disease; Persistent Symptoms: Does this Sound Familiar?

      Hello all, I am writing here in hopes of hearing from the community as to whether the issues my son is facing are relatively common for individuals suffering from Celiac Disease. He is 9 years old, has the HLA2 gene, tested high for the gliadin IgG antibody (not the primary one, but still on Celiac panel), and biopsy of the duodenum came back as Marsh...
    3. MoniqueCham
      - MoniqueCham replied to MoniqueCham's topic in Related Issues & Disorders
      4

      Celiac Disease, Lymphocytic colitis and Bowel rupture

      Thanks for your reply Scott! A long time ago I realized I didn’t fit neatly into uncomplicated celiac disease. Over the years I’ve been diagnosed and treated for SIBO, pancreatic insufficiency and diagnosed with Stage 2 liver fibrosis. I think all the complications occurred because of the refractory celiac disease. When I hit menopause my gut issues seemed to ...
    4. HelenH
      - HelenH replied to HelenH's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      3

      Malt vinegar

      Thank.you both
    5. Scott Adams
      - Scott Adams replied to HelenH's topic in Gluten-Free Foods, Products, Shopping & Medications
      3

      Malt vinegar

      Yes, unfortunately malt vinegar can definitely trigger a strong reaction in people with celiac disease. Malt vinegar is typically made from barley, which contains gluten, and unlike distilled white vinegar, it is not considered gluten-free. Even a small amount — especially if you’ve been strictly gluten-free for years — can cause a more intense reaction becau...
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      133,552
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    dsfraley
    Newest Member
    dsfraley
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.6k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):

  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Celiac Disease, Lymphocytic colitis and Bowel rupture

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Welcome to the forum, @MoniqueCham, What a challenging journey you've had!  Like you, I studied nutrition, but I earned a degree in Microbiology because I wanted to understand what essential vitamins and minerals were doing inside our bodies.   I've come across some information that may be of interest to you.  I'll post links below.  On my journey, I suffered from malnutrition due to the malabsorption of Celiac disease.  I regained my health by supplementing with essential vitamins, especially Thiamine B1.  Thiamine is needed by every cell, so a low level of thiamine can cause many problems over time.  I was put on some medications that aggravated my thiamine deficiency.  Many medications can cause interactions with vitamins resulting in deficiencies. Methotrexate causes folate deficiency, but can also cause thiamine deficiency because folate and thiamine share some of the same cellular transporters.   Notes on Folate Carriers, Anti-Folate Medications, and Thiamine Deficiency https://hormonesmatter.com/notes-on-folate-carriers-anti-folate-medications-and-thiamine-deficiency/ Thiamine deficiency can affect the health of the digestive tract.  Thiamine helps regulate the intestinal microbiome, and keeps SIBO in check.   Thiamine, gastrointestinal beriberi and acetylcholine signaling https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12014454/ Thiamine deficiency aggravates experimental colitis in mice by promoting glycolytic reprogramming in macrophages https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39890689/ Other organs can be affected by thiamine insufficiency.  The thyroid, gallbladder, liver and pancreas can be affected by low thiamine. High-dose vitamin B1 therapy prevents the development of experimental fatty liver driven by overnutrition https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7988776/ Thankfully, I found that Thiamine in the form Benfotiamine can improve gastrointestinal dysfunction, as well improve liver function, and thyroid and pancreas health.   Benfotiamine can improve harm done by Methotrexate... Protective effect of benfotiamine on methotrexate induced gastric damage in rats https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33325753/ I was deficient in other vitamins.  I had skin issues that improved with niacin.  Perhaps niacin can help your skin problem if it comes back.   Response of generalized granuloma annulare to high-dose niacinamide https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6225398/ I'm very curious as to what you did to correct your nutritional deficiencies caused by refractory Celiac disease.   Refractory Celiac Disease: What the Gastroenterologist Should Know https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11477276/ Tests for Serum Transglutaminase and Endomysial Antibodies Do Not Detect Most Patients With Celiac Disease and Persistent Villous Atrophy on Gluten-free Diets: a Meta-analysis https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28545781/ Hope this is helpful!
    • dsfraley
      9 y/o Son Diagnosed with Celiac Disease; Persistent Symptoms: Does this Sound Familiar?

      By dsfraley · Posted

      Hello all, I am writing here in hopes of hearing from the community as to whether the issues my son is facing are relatively common for individuals suffering from Celiac Disease. He is 9 years old, has the HLA2 gene, tested high for the gliadin IgG antibody (not the primary one, but still on Celiac panel), and biopsy of the duodenum came back as Marsh 3A classification. He has been dealing with severe nausea (no diarrhea/vomiting), muscle achiness, and flu-like malaise for over 2 months (and he has not been to school during this time -- he has been truly bed or couch-ridden, and to the extent that he can watch a show but does not want to read an easy book or play video games... which he loves). He had a very low-grade rolling fever of about 100.0 that the doctors wrote off because it was very low, occasional, and would only last a couple of hours at a time. Before the onset of this, he struggled with severe weekly migraines that sometimes led to vomiting, or at least not functioning until after sleeping it off (which we thought was associated with too much screen time in school). In any case, given those lab results above, he was diagnosed with Celiac Disease a few weeks back. He has been on a gluten free diet for 3 weeks now. When I say a gluten-free diet, I mean: we have sterilized the house as much as possible (e.g., throwing away everything from the kitchen and replacing unless it was stainless steel, and washing that thoroughly, eliminated all gluten-containing foods from the house except for a few pre-packaged snacks for our other child that she can eat outside of the house such as at school, etc.), we have only given him foods that are certified gluten free unless it was something like meat (not seasoned), have not given him oats (even gluten free marked ones) to be safe, we have purchased new products such as shampoo and toothpaste, etc. He does not have any food not prepared in our house. In other words, if there is cross-contamination, it must be at exceptionally low levels. Despite this, he: continues to have off and on bloating and nausea, continues to have flu-like malaise (though he hasn't had the occasional low-grade fevers for the last 2 weeks, struggles greatly to get to sleep and sometimes wakes up miserable in the middle of the night, cries frequently and constantly expresses how much he doesn't feel good, most often now describes a general feeling of "ickiness" that we cannot pinpoint. The gastro has nothing more to say other than stick with it; the pediatrician says we should try a rheumotologist (if we want) or a psychologist. The former seems unnecessary, and the latter suggests to me a complete lack of understanding of just how miserable he is (and I am highly disappointed by the suggestion and now frustrated with the pediatrician). And so I am looking for support/thoughts:  For those of you who have Celiac Disease, or know those affected by it, does this sound accurate? Is there hope? Or do you think we are on track of needing to get more opinions? Thank you.  
    • MoniqueCham
      Celiac Disease, Lymphocytic colitis and Bowel rupture

      By MoniqueCham · Posted

      Thanks for your reply Scott! A long time ago I realized I didn’t fit neatly into uncomplicated celiac disease. Over the years I’ve been diagnosed and treated for SIBO, pancreatic insufficiency and diagnosed with Stage 2 liver fibrosis. I think all the complications occurred because of the refractory celiac disease. When I hit menopause my gut issues seemed to calm down and because I was stable I made the mistake of not following up with my gastroenterologist. Then other autoimmune problems flared and I tried the methotrexate. It worked like a charm for my skin condition… then my sigmoid colon ruptured. Strange but my autoimmune skin condition remains in remission after 6 months off the medication. We have a very long waiting list to get back into see my GI doctor… I was an emergency referral but am still waiting 6 months after the perforation. I need more surgery to fix a fistula that has formed and to reconnect my colon… I have a colostomy at present. I became a dietitian who specializes in bowel diseases but have never met anyone who’s had so many complications with celiac disease. I have a brother and son who also have been diagnosed. My mother had 4 autoimmune diseases including a vasculitis that eventually resulted in her death and it was my father who had the HLA DQ2 gene. Think I inherited some tendencies from each of them. Thanks again for your response… it feels a little lonely dealing with GI issues when I work so hard to remain gluten free.   
    • HelenH
      Malt vinegar

      By HelenH · Posted

      Thank.you both
    • Scott Adams
      Malt vinegar

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      Yes, unfortunately malt vinegar can definitely trigger a strong reaction in people with celiac disease. Malt vinegar is typically made from barley, which contains gluten, and unlike distilled white vinegar, it is not considered gluten-free. Even a small amount — especially if you’ve been strictly gluten-free for years — can cause a more intense reaction because your body is no longer accustomed to exposure. Many people report significant symptoms after accidental ingestion, including abdominal pain, diarrhea, fatigue, or flu-like feelings. You’re not alone in that experience. It may help to be especially cautious with salad dressings, chips, sauces, and restaurant foods, where malt vinegar is sometimes used.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

NOTICE: This site places This site places cookies on your device (Cookie settings). on your device. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.