Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

How Is A False Negative Possible? (if It Looks Like A Duck...)

Tim86

Recommended Posts

Tim86 Apprentice
Tim86
Posted

You've heard the expression...if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it's a duck. But what if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, but clucks like a chicken? It's still probably a duck, but why does it cluck?

I've read many examples on this website of people who were clearly positive for Celiac, based on their experiences with gluten-free diets, and sometimes biopsy results, but their blood test results were negative. Assuming they had been consuming sufficient amounts of gluten at the time of testing, then how is this possible? How could all of their blood results be "normal" even though other evidence proves they have Celiac? I just don't understand. Please be specific and objective. I'm not looking for emotional responses here. I'd like a somewhat scientific explanation, if possible.

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Generic Apprentice
Generic
Posted

I can't give a scientific explanation, but some people just don't make the antibodies. I am example of this and so is my dad. He has rhuematoid arthritis SP?. A-typical polymyalgia and most likely Celiac, too but doesn't show it on any blood work. Other than the fact that his bloodwork is negative he has all the symptoms/damage.

There a few people on here who can give a more scientific explanation.

Korwyn Explorer
Korwyn
Posted
You've heard the expression...if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it's a duck. But what if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, but clucks like a chicken? It's still probably a duck, but why does it cluck?

I've read many examples on this website of people who were clearly positive for Celiac, based on their experiences with gluten-free diets, and sometimes biopsy results, but their blood test results were negative. Assuming they had been consuming sufficient amounts of gluten at the time of testing, then how is this possible? How could all of their blood results be "normal" even though other evidence proves they have Celiac? I just don't understand. Please be specific and objective. I'm not looking for emotional responses here. I'd like a somewhat scientific explanation, if possible.

It doesn't have anything to do necessarily with being IgA deficient, it is just that the blood tests have a low sensitivity (as compared to specificity). Some of the statistics I've seen are as high as 80%. My doctor told me that she has never seen a positive blood work up come back even with some people confirmed later through biopsy. There are a lot of reasons having to do with individual immune system function, diet, enviornmental chemistry, other physiologic and immunologic issues, and the labs themselves. To be blunt, some labs just seem to do crappy workups.

Tim86 Apprentice
Tim86
Posted
  • Author

Does anyone else have some ideas on this? I know there are a lot of smart people out there who could chime in! ;)

Jestgar Rising Star
Jestgar
Posted

The tests for Celiac are based on production of antibodies to a specific region of gluten. They take your blood, put it on a plate with these specific sequences stuck to it, and then wash off your blood to see what stuck. If your body made antibodies to a slightly different region of the protein, your antibodies won't stick to the plate, and you will test negative.

The tests are designed to pick up MOST people's response, they won't pick up all.

Another Undiagnosed Newbie
Another Undiagnosed
Posted

I am so confused right now. A little over a year ago my doctor suspected I had Celiac due to a host of digestive issues, so I had the biopsy and the blood test. I recall being told that the biopsy was normal, but the doctor wanted me to get the blood test anyway (which makes me question if the biopsy was TOTALLY normal). Well, the blood test came back negative.

Recently I've been having all sorts of weird neurological stuff going on: tingling, twiching, occasional tremors. I also have all the frequent digestive complaints that I'm sure you all can figure out without me going into detail. I'm going to a neuro soon to rule out Multiple Sclerosis, but I've also heard Celiac can cause similar symptoms. To add to my suspicion, someone in my immediate family was recently positively diagnosed with Celiac. Is there any chance that, even after a biopsy and a blood test, maybe I do in fact have it? I am sort of hoping it is the case because even though it is a tough thing to live with, in my case it beats the alternative. Thanks everyone.

nasalady Contributor
nasalady
Posted
I am so confused right now. A little over a year ago my doctor suspected I had Celiac due to a host of digestive issues, so I had the biopsy and the blood test. I recall being told that the biopsy was normal, but the doctor wanted me to get the blood test anyway (which makes me question if the biopsy was TOTALLY normal). Well, the blood test came back negative.

Recently I've been having all sorts of weird neurological stuff going on: tingling, twiching, occasional tremors. I also have all the frequent digestive complaints that I'm sure you all can figure out without me going into detail. I'm going to a neuro soon to rule out Multiple Sclerosis, but I've also heard Celiac can cause similar symptoms. To add to my suspicion, someone in my immediate family was recently positively diagnosed with Celiac. Is there any chance that, even after a biopsy and a blood test, maybe I do in fact have it? I am sort of hoping it is the case because even though it is a tough thing to live with, in my case it beats the alternative. Thanks everyone.

I had all of the same neuro symptoms you describe along with the gastro symptoms as well. I went to a neurologist and had an MRI of the brain, which was negative. I began to suspect celiac disease was behind the neuro symptoms because I had run across references to celiac ataxia, etc., in my research.

False negatives are common in both bloodwork and biopsy, so it is definitely possible you do have celiac disease.

I tested negative to both blood work and biopsy for celiac, although I had a good reason for that: I was (still am) on very high doses of prednisone and Imuran (which suppress the immune system) because of my autoimmune hepatitis...my immune system is trying to kill my liver, among many other things. Of course, these drugs suppress the body's ability to make antibodies and allow villi to regenerate in those with celiac disease. However, I still managed to register a "3" (0-5 being "normal" range for that lab) for the presence of the celiac antibodies, despite the drugs.

You didn't say whether or not you have tried the gluten free diet; my response to the diet was dramatic! My frequent headaches, vertigo, hand tremors, peripheral neuropathy, gastric problems, etc. all virtually disappeared or at least diminished on the gluten free diet. That was enough for me! The only issues that I have which have not (yet) resolved on the gluten free diet are those associated with my fibromyalgia and rheumatoid arthritis.

Good luck with everything!

JoAnn

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


nasalady Contributor
nasalady
Posted
I can't give a scientific explanation, but some people just don't make the antibodies. I am example of this and so is my dad. He has rhuematoid arthritis SP?. A-typical polymyalgia and most likely Celiac, too but doesn't show it on any blood work. Other than the fact that his bloodwork is negative he has all the symptoms/damage.

There a few people on here who can give a more scientific explanation.

As Jestgar explained in such helpful detail, some people make more exotic antibodies that just won't show up in the standard tests. I too am seronegative for RA, but you can see the damage on xrays and my fingers are starting to develop the classic nodules at the joints. Even though I'm on prednisone and Imuran... :(

Amyleigh0007 Enthusiast
Amyleigh0007
Posted

:lol::lol::lol: I used that exact same expression with my doctor on Monday!! I love it!

He admitted to me that he usually only will diagnose someone with Celiac disease if they have smooth villi. Even with a positive blood test. That is very dangerous and I told him so. He went to med school 30 years ago and that is what he was taught. Perhaps these old school doctors are the reason so many of us go undiagnosed or are diagnosed incorrectly.

momxyz Contributor
momxyz
Posted

To add to the confusion, try searching the board for Fructose Malabsorption.

This entity was pointed out to me recently. It will cause many of the same symptoms that celiac or gluten intolerance do, but the mechanism by which it does so is different.

nasalady Contributor
nasalady
Posted
To add to the confusion, try searching the board for Fructose Malabsorption.

This entity was pointed out to me recently. It will cause many of the same symptoms that celiac or gluten intolerance do, but the mechanism by which it does so is different.

Lyme Disease mimics celiac too. But you won't generally find the antibodies or the gene markers for celiac disease if it's Fructose Malabsorption or Lyme. And you won't have problems with other autoimmune diseases developing with the mimics either. :)

elye Community Regular
elye
Posted
Is there any chance that, even after a biopsy and a blood test, maybe I do in fact have it? I am sort of hoping it is the case because even though it is a tough thing to live with, in my case it beats the alternative.

My husband had all of the classic symptoms of gluten intolerance/celiac, and a brother who was diagnosed three years ago. DH had a negative blood panel and a negative biopsy. He sprung for the enterolab stool test, and lo and behold, there were the antibodies - - lots of them. As well, there was a great deal of fat in the stool, another strong indicator of malabsorption. He immediately went gluten-free, and all of his symptoms were gone within a couple of weeks. So I would say that yes, it is definitely possible to have a problem with gluten even though the gold standard tests are telling you otherwise.

Generic Apprentice
Generic
Posted

Ok, I guess my dad and I make "exotic antibodies". Works for me.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      131,189
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    Eric bell
    Newest Member
    Eric bell
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.4k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • Ginger38
      Food Allergies

      By Ginger38 · Posted

      So I recently had allergy testing for IGE antibodies in response to foods. My test results came back positive to corn, white potatoes, egg whites. Tomatoes, almonds and peanuts to name a few.  I have had obvious reactions to a few of these - particularly tomatoes and corn- both GI issues. I don’t really understand all this allergy versus celiac stuff. If the food allergies are mild do I have to avoid these foods entirely? I don’t know what I will eat if I can’t  have corn based gluten free products 
    • Kris2093u4
      Bread choice for a newbie

      By Kris2093u4 · Posted

      Geography makes a difference.  I'm in the West and Trader Joe's gluten-free bread tastes great and is a better price than most gluten-free breads sold elsewhere in my area.  
    • JForman
      7yo struggling!

      By JForman · Posted

      We have four children (7-14 yo), and our 7 year old was diagnosed with NCGS (though all Celiac labs were positive, her scope at 4 years old was negative so docs in the US won't call it celiac). We have started her on a Gluten Free diet after 3 years of major digestive issues and ruling out just about everything under the sun. Our home and kitchen and myself are all gluten-free. But I have not asked my husband/her dad or her other siblings to go completely gluten-free with us. They are at home, but not out of the home. This has led to situations when we are eating out where she has to consistently see others eating things she can't have and she has begun to say "Well, I can't have <fill in the blank>...stupid gluten."  How have you supported your gluten-free kiddos in the mental health space of this journey, especially young ones like her. I know it's hard for me as an adult sometimes to miss out, so I can't imagine being 7 and dealing with it! Any tips or ideas to help with this? 
    • Jane878
      My mo,ther married a bread making when I was 4

      By Jane878 · Posted

      By the time I was 5 I had my first auto0immune disorder, Migraine headaches, with auras to blind me, and vomiting, sensitivity to light and sound. I was 5 years old, and my stepfather would have pizza night, milling his own flour, making thick cheesy gluten pizza, that I would eat and the next day, I would have serious migraines, and my mother & stepfather did nothing about my medical problems. When I was 17 in my first year at college, I was diagnosed with my 2nd known auto-immune disorder, Meniere's disease. I was a elite athlete, a swimmer, and soccer player. And once again my parents didn't think anything of understanding why I had a disorder only older people get. Now after my mother passed from Alzheimer's disease she also suffered with living with gluten. She had a rash for 30 years that nobody could diagnose. She was itchy for 45 years total. My brother had a encapsulated virus explodes in his spleen and when this happened his entire intestines were covered with adhesions, scar tissue and he almost lost his life. He has 5 daughters, and when I finally was diagnosed after being pregnant and my body went into a cytokine storm, I lost my chance to have children, I ended up having Hashimoto's disease, Degenerative Disc disease, and my body started to shut down during my first trimester. I am 6ft tall and got down to 119lbs. My husband and I went to a special immunologist in Terrace, California. They took 17 vials of blood as we flew there for a day and returned home that evening. In 3 weeks, we had the answer, I have Celiac disease. Once this was known, only my father and husband made efforts to change their way of feeding me. At the family cabin, my stepfather & mother were more worried that I would ruin Thanksgiving Dinner. It wasn't until one of my cousins was diagnosed with Celiac disease. They finally looked into getting Gluten Free flour and taking measures to limit "gluten" in meals. He did nothing but ask for me to pay for my own food and wi-fi when I came to the cabin to stay after our house burned down. When he informed my mother, they proceeding to get into a physical fight and she ended up with a black eye. The is just more trauma for me. Sam had no interest in telling the truth about what he wanted. He lied to my mother that he had asked my husband if I could pay for "food" when he asked Geoffrey if I had money to pay for my wi-fi. My mother hates when he spends so much time on the computer so he lied and said I could pay for my own food. I will remind you I weighed 119lbs at this time. (At 6ft) that is a very sick looking person. Neither parent was worried about my weight, they just fought about how cheap my stepfather was. As my mother was diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease in 2014. He had her sign over the will to a trust and added his children. He had no testimonial capacity at the time, so she signed without proper papers. Making this Trust null and void. When I gave my brother my childhood home, my mother stated I would be getting an equal part of inheritance to the house on Race. It currently worth 2.0 million $. I got nothing, and my stepfather has since disowned me b/c of my claim and he knows that my mother would never have left it uneven between my biological brother and myself. She sat me and my husband down, as we lived at the Race Street house and treated and took care of it as our own. My brother took over b/c he was going through a horrific divorce and needed a home so he could get a better custody deal with his soon to be ex-wife who was a Assist DA for Denver. She used the girls against him, and he & I were the primary caregivers. We, Judd and I spent the most time with them pre the divorce. Once Judd moved into the house, he threw all of my mother, grandmother and my family heirlooms out to the Goodwill. Nobody told my mother about this as she was going through cancer treatment and had Alzheimer's disease in her mother and her sister. My stepfather and biological brother took advantage of this matter, as I called a "family council" that my brother just never could make it to at the last moment. All of the furnishing, kitchen ware, everything was in the house my brother just moved into. He had had 2 weddings, I chose to elope b/c my stepfather ruined my brother's first wedding by talking about his relationship with my brother in front of my dad and his entire family, insulting him and having my grandfather leave the ceremony. It was a disaster. My stepfather just plays dumb and blames my father for the slight. I was the only child not to have a wedding. So, my mother and stepfather never had to pay for a thing. My mother had had an agreement with my father he'd pay for college and all medical issues with their kids, myself and Judd. So truly my mother never had to pay for anything big for me in her entire life. I am looking for anyone that has had a similar story, where they grew up in a household that had a baker that regularly milled flour and ate gluten. What happened to you? DId you suffer from different auto-immune diseases b/c of living with a baker using "gluten" Please let me know. I have been looking into legal ways to get my stepfather to give me what my mother had promised, and he erased. Thank you for listening to my story. Jane Donnelly  
    • trents
      Blood results

      By trents · Posted

      Possibly gluten withdrawal. Lot's of info on the internet about it. Somewhat controversial but apparently gluten plugs into the same neuro sensors as opiates do and some people get a similar type withdrawal as they do when quitting opiates. Another issue is that gluten-free facsimile flours are not fortified with vitamins and minerals as is wheat flour (in the U.S. at least) so when the switch is made to gluten-free facsimile foods, especially if a lot of processed gluten-free foods are being used as substitutes, vitamin and mineral deficiencies can result. There is also the possibility that she has picked up a virus or some but that is totally unrelated to going gluten-free.
×
×
  • Create New...