Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. ×


Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-m):

  • You've found your Celiac Tribe! Join our like-minded, private community and share your story, get encouragement and connect with others.

    💬

    • Sign In
    • Sign Up
  • Scott Adams
    Scott Adams

    By Scott Adams •

    "Gluten-free" Grain-based Foods in India Contain Up to 90 Times Permitted Gluten Levels

    Followers 2
    Reviewed and edited by a celiac disease expert.

    Field survey reveals substantial gluten contamination in "Gluten-Free" and "naturally gluten-free" food products in India.


    Caption: Indian spice vendor. Image: CC BY 2.0--Bryce Edwards

    Celiac.com 05/25/2020 - A food survey in India found that ten percent of grain-based foods labelled "gluten-free," and more than one-third of products that are "naturally gluten-free," have been found to be contaminated with gluten, with some products testing at 90 times permitted gluten levels.

    Gluten contamination is a serious and potentially dangerous problem for people with celiac disease, since gluten consumption by celiacs triggers an immune reaction that damages the small intestine, and can lead to serious health complications over time.


    Celiac.com Sponsor (A12):




    Celiac.com Sponsor (A12-m):



    For people with gluten or wheat allergies, gluten consumption can trigger serious allergic reactions, including anaphylactic shock, and potentially death. A research team at the National Institute of Nutrition (NIN) in Hyderabad, India bought 160 grain-based food products, including RTE foods, flours, grains, from regional retail shops and online grocers. They then analyzed these products for gluten content. A total of 51 products were labelled "Gluten-Free," while 109 were naturally gluten-free, and supposedly contained no added gluten, including dahl, millet, quinoa, buckwheat, oats, etc.

    Tests showed that many of these products labelled "Gluten-Free" contained gluten at levels above the legal limit of 20 ppm the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI). Other products contained gluten at levels above 200 ppm for products labelled "Low-Gluten."

    The team's analysis showed that nearly 40% of naturally gluten-free products and 10% of food products labelled "Gluten-Free" contained gluten levels above legally permitted limits. One of the biggest culprits was oats, with almost 85% of oat products showing gluten levels above 20ppm, and the most contaminated sample clocking in at 1,830ppm of gluten, over 90 times the permitted levels.

    Flours labelled "Gluten-Free" are "still risky no matter the source though - nearly 70% of the local brands, 30% of the flour mill samples and 13% of the branded samples were contaminated, likely due to cross-contamination from the usage of common collection bags, utility areas or handling procedures with wheat flour."

    Of the naturally gluten-free products, rice (44%), ragi (32%) and sorghum (20%) all showed significant levels of gluten contamination, as did all four samples of gram flour. By contrast, for products labelled "Gluten-Free," the biggest problem was seen in from multigrain products, with high gluten levels seen in 25% of those products.

    The team found no gluten contamination in branded rice, ragi or sorghum, but did find contamination in branded millets and gram flour, said principal investigator Dr Devindra. The safest products in this study turned out to be buckwheat, quinoa, pulses, millets and soy, none of which showed elevated gluten levels.

    Products labelled "Gluten-Free" were generally safer than those which are "naturally gluten-free." Prior studies have shown that celiac disease rates in India may be higher than 1% previously reported. In India, as in many countries, many people rely on naturally gluten-free foods to treat celiac disease and lower the financial costs of a gluten-free diet. That makes the revelations about the dangers of "naturally gluten-free" foods even more disturbing.

    The problem of gluten contamination in gluten-free foods is not limited to India, as Australia, Brazil, UK, and the United States have all had similar reports about gluten contamination in our otherwise gluten-free food supply chain.

    Contaminated products could be one reason that so many people with celiac disease, who are trying to follow a gluten-free diet, are exposed to gluten on a regular basis.

    Read more in Food Additives & Contaminants: Part A; Volume 37, 2020 - Issue 4

    Edited by Scott Adams

    Followers 2
    Go to articles

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Ging

    I've had more and more trouble with this lately.  Multiple 'gluten free' products that seem to cause reactions.  Sadly, I think I'm seeing this with some basic ingredients which is truly awful.  How do you cook when you can't even trust the simple ingredients?  There's a low level of stress constantly waiting to see if you're going to be sick... .

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    Guest joshi

    Guest joshi

    Posted

    As one of the researchers who worked on the above and co-wrote the paper, I can tell that if someone suffers from gluten sensitive celic disease, then the only way to manage the condition is by avoiding foods that contain components of gluten. Its important to be aware of possibility of contamination of other foods with something like wheat due to processing in facilities which also process wheat 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    Ging
    On 6/17/2020 at 7:47 AM, Guest joshi said:

    As one of the researchers who worked on the above and co-wrote the paper, I can tell that if someone suffers from gluten sensitive celic disease, then the only way to manage the condition is by avoiding foods that contain components of gluten. Its important to be aware of possibility of contamination of other foods with something like wheat due to processing in facilities which also process wheat 

    I think most of us are well aware of this. The problem becomes when we're given bad or no information about possible contamination or processing methods/materials/products from the manufacturer.  Testing, as is implied in the article, is hit or miss or completely falsified so that the Celiac sufferers are left with meaningless information on packaging.  In a perfect world we would make all our own food with basic ingredients that are uncontaminated.  Sadly, the world is not perfect, we often don't have time, and even the basic ingredients are not reliably safe.

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites


    Join the conversation

    You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

    ×

  • Join eNewsletter

  • About Me

    Scott Adams

    Scott Adams was diagnosed with celiac disease in 1994, and, due to the nearly total lack of information available at that time, was forced to become an expert on the disease in order to recover. In 1995 he launched the site that later became Celiac.com to help as many people as possible with celiac disease get diagnosed so they can begin to live happy, healthy gluten-free lives.  He is co-author of the book Cereal Killers, and founder and publisher of the (formerly paper) newsletter Journal of Gluten Sensitivity. In 1998 he founded The Gluten-Free Mall which he sold in 2014. Celiac.com does not sell any products, and is 100% advertiser supported.

  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):
    Celiac.com Sponsor (A17):



    Celiac.com Sponsors (A17-m):



  • Related Articles

    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 04/02/2018 - Exactly how hard is it for people with celiac disease to faithfully follow a gluten-free diet? Anyone who’s ever tried to completely avoid gluten for any length of time likely has a story to tell about accidental gluten consumption, and the consequences that follow. It’s not at all uncommon for gluten-free celiacs to be exposed to low levels of gluten that can trigger symptoms and cause persistent intestinal histologic damage.
    To gain an understanding of gluten consumption across a wide population of celiac patients, a team of researchers recently set out to determine how much gluten people eat when they are trying to follow a gluten-free diet. 
    The team included Jack A Syage, Ciarán P Kelly, Matthew A Dickason, Angel Cebolla Ramirez, Francisco Leon, Remedios Dominguez, and Jennifer A Sealey-Voyksner. They are variously affiliated with ImmunogenX in Newport Beach, CA, the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center at Harvard Medical School in Boston MA, and with Biomedal in Seville, Spain.
    The team began by analyzing data from previous clinical studies. That meta-analysis focused on data from a clinical study of gluten in stool and urine in celiac patients, a second study on non-celiac populations; and an analysis of data from trials for the investigational therapeutic latiglutenase. 
    As part of the stool and urine studies the team included controlled gluten challenges. They then applied a calibration factor that allowed normal ingestion of gluten to be computed from the urine and stool measurements. They determined gluten consumption by estimating how much gluten was eliminated from patients’ diets due to a trial effect that resulted in improved histology, even in the placebo group.
    Using the stool test, the team estimated the average inadvertent exposure to gluten by celiac disease individuals on a GFD to be about 150–400 mg/d, while they estimated the median exposure to be about 100–150 mg/d. Using the urine test, those numbers showed an average exposure of about 300–400 mg/d, with a median of about 150 mg/d. 
    Meanwhile, data analyses showed that celiac patients with moderate to severe symptoms showed that patients ingested substantially more than 200 mg/d of gluten.
    The data indicate that many gluten-free celiacs regularly consume enough gluten to trigger symptoms and perpetuate gut damage.
    Source:
    The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Volume 107, Issue 2, 1 February 2018
    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 02/25/2019 - Even when following a gluten-free diet, many people with celiac disease occasionally ingest small amounts of gluten in food. However, researchers don’t have much good data on how that plays out in real life. Testing patient stool and urine is an excellent way to measure the frequency of gluten exposure in celiac patients who are on a gluten-free diet. To get a better picture, a team of researchers recently set out to explore the pattern of fecal and urinary excretion of gluten immunogenic peptide (GIP) during a 4-week period in celiac patients on a long-term gluten-free diet. 
    The research team included Juan P Stefanolo; Martín Tálamo; Samanta Dodds; Emilia Sugai; Paz Temprano; Ana Costa, Ana; María Laura Moreno; María Inés Pinto Sanchez; Edgardo Smecuol; Horacio Vázquez; Andrea F Gonzalez; Sonia I Niveloni; Elena F Verdu; Eduardo Mauriño; and Julio C Bai. They are variously affiliated with the Dr. C. Bonorino Udaondo Gastroenterology Hospital, Buenos Aires, Argentina, Argentina.; the Farncombe Family Digestive Health Research Institute, McMaster University Health Sciences Centre, Hamilton, ON, Canada; and with the Research Institutes at the Universidad del Salvador, Buenos Aires, Argentina. 
    For their descriptive and prospective study, the team enrolled consecutive adult celiac patients who had been following a gluten-free diet for more than two years. All participants filled out a celiac symptom index (CSI) questionnaire to document related symptoms. Patients collected stool and urine samples for 4 weeks. The team designed the collection protocol to measure gluten excretion during week-days and week-ends. For GIP detection, the team used ELISA test for stool (iVYLISA GIP-S ®, Biomedal S.L. Spain) and point-of-care tests (GlutenDetect ®; Biomedal S.L., Spain) for urine. 
    The team found that, regardless of symptoms, celiac patients on a long-term gluten-free diet frequently ingested gluten, especially on weekends. The steady increase in GIP over the month-long study indicate that people may be less vigilant about eating gluten-free, especially on weekends. 
    This study indicates that many people with celiac disease are lowering their vigilance, and accidentally or deliberately eating gluten, whether or not they have symptoms. These results drive home the importance of constant vigilance for people with celiac disease.
    Source: Digestive Disease Week 2019
    Jefferson Adams
    Celiac.com 10/14/2019 - One of the big debates among people with celiac disease concerns how vigilant celiacs need to be to make sure they avoid gluten. What does science say about gluten contamination in three common scenarios? How careful do you need to be about gluten contamination?
    For example, how likely are you to get gluten over 20ppm if you share a toaster, pasta water, or slice a cupcake with the same knife used to cut a non-gluten-free cupcake?
    A team of researchers recently set out to assess three common scenarios where people with celiac disease might reasonably fear gluten contamination. How did the actual risk for each situation measure up?
    Scenario 1: Water used to cook regular pasta is reused to cook gluten-free penne and fusilli. The gluten-free pasta is then rinsed and served. Scenario 2: Toasting Gluten-Free Bread in an Uncleaned Shared Toaster Gluten-containing bread is toasted in a toaster. Immediately afterward, gluten-free bread is toasted in the same toaster. Scenario 3: Slicing a Gluten-Free and Regular Cupcake with Same Knife The research team included Vanessa M. Weisbrod, BA; Jocelyn A. Silvester, MD PhD; Catherine Raber, MA; Joyana McMahon, MS; Shayna S. Coburn, PhD; and Benny Kerzner, MD. They are variously affiliated with the Celiac Disease Program, Children’s National Health System, Washington, DC, USA; and the Harvard Celiac Disease Program, Boston Children’s Hospital, Boston, MA.
    Their paper titled, Preparation of Gluten-Free Foods Alongside Gluten-Containing Food May Not Always Be as Risky for Celiac Patients as Diet Guides Suggest, appears in Gasterojournal.org.
    Control samples of gluten-free pasta, bread, and cupcakes all tested below the limit of detection. Samples were individually packaged in plastic bags with randomized sample numbers. To avoid “hot spots” and ensure even analysis, all items were homogenized for analysis. 
    Gluten content was measured with R5 sandwich ELISA (R7001, R-Biopharm, Darmstadt, Germany) which has a limit of detection of 5 ppm gluten by Bia Diagnostics (Colchester, Vermont). All control samples were similarly tested. 
    The team then quantified gluten samples as under 5ppm, 5-10ppm, 10-20ppm, or over 20ppm, and based their confidence intervals upon binomial distribution.
    Boiling Gluten-Free Pasta in Regular Pasta Water
    In the first scenario, the team boiled sixteen-ounce packages of gluten-containing Barilla brand penne and fusilli separately in stainless steel pots in fresh tap water for 12 minutes, then removed with strainers. The water was reused to cook Dr. Schar gluten-free penne and fusilli. The team also tested the effect of rinsing some samples of the cooked and contaminated pasta under cold tap water for 30 seconds. 
    The team found that Gluten was detected in all pasta samples cooked in water used for gluten-containing pasta, ranging from 33.9ppm to 115.7ppm. The rinsed gluten-free pasta samples tested at 5.1 ppm and 17.5 ppm detectable gluten. 
    Interestingly, rinsing pots with water alone after cooking gluten-containing pasta was as effective as scrubbing with soap and water to prevent detectable gluten transfer. 
    Toasting Gluten-Free Bread After Non-Gluten-Free Bread
    In the second scenario, the team toasted regular gluten-containing bread in two rolling toasters in a busy hospital cafeteria at 20-minute intervals, or in one of three shared pop-up toasters. Immediately after toasting the gluten-containing bread, they toasted Dr. Schar Artisan White Bread. Gluten-containing crumbs were visible in all toasters. They team did not clean the toasters. 
    The team found that toasting in a shared toaster was not associated with gluten transfer above 20ppm; the four samples with detectable gluten had levels ranging only from 5.1 ppm to 8.3 ppm gluten.
    Slicing a Gluten-Free Cupcake with Knife Used on Gluten Cupcake
    In the third scenario, the team used a knife to slice frosted gluten-containing cupcakes. The knife was then reused to slice a frosted gluten-free Vanilla Cupcake from Whole Foods Gluten-Free Bake House. 
    The knife was then washed in soap and water, rinsed in running water, or cleaned with an antibacterial hand wipe (Wet Ones) and a new gluten-free cupcake was sliced. Both gluten-free cupcakes were analyzed for gluten content.  Although 28/30 cupcake samples had detectable gluten transfer, only 2/28 tested over 20ppm. 
    The team found that cutting cupcakes with a knife used to cut frosted gluten-containing cupcakes was associated with low-level gluten transfer even when crumbs were visible on the icing adhered to the knife. All three knife washing methods tested were effective in removing gluten. 
    The team acknowledges the limitations of their study, including small sample size, etc. They are calling for further study to assess best kitchen practices for people with celiac disease who are trying to avoid gluten contamination in shared kitchens.
    Main Takeaways
    1) Some kitchen activities may pose less of a risk of cross-contact with gluten than is commonly believed. 
    2) Standard washing effectively removes gluten from shared utensils.
    3) Cooking gluten-free pasta in the same water as regular gluten-containing pasta is likely okay, as long as the pasta gets rinsed well.
    4) Sharing a toaster is unlikely to result in gluten contamination.

    Read more in Gastrojournal.org
    Conflict of Interest Declaration: JAS has served on an advisory board of Takeda Pharmaceuticals and received research support from Cour Pharma, Glutenostics, and the Celiac Disease Foundation. The other authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose. Funding Source: Supported by philanthropic gifts from the Celiac Disease Foundation, Dr. SCHAR USA, and Bia Diagnostics. JAS is supported by the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number K23DK119584. 
    Kelly Carter
    Celiac.com 12/13/2019 - I wanted to add some new revelations I've had about cross contamination, including how not to go crazy worrying about it, and what I believe to be the number one way to prevent getting sick from it.
    There are a lot of posts on Facebook in the Celiac Groups about cross-contamination—let's talk about what it is and why it's bad for those with celiac disease.
    Cross-contamination is Our Worst Enemy
    For someone with celiac disease, cross-contamination is our worst enemy. We all know that we can't have gluten—no bread, pasta, etc. We all know that even the slightest amount of gluten can hurt us.
    Studies have shown that 1/64th of a piece of bread has enough gluten to cause autoimmune problems in celiacs. The FDA has set 20 parts per million (ppm) as the maximum threshold for gluten in something labelled gluten-free. It isn't much.
    Let's use an example to describe what is happening. I'm going to use a very simple example because it's, well simple. The kids like peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, chips, and an apple for their lunch. You pull out the bread, swipe the peanut butter and jelly on, and put it in their lunch box. Put the chips into a smaller container, open the fridge, pull out an apple, and call it a day.
    Here's the issue—if you put the bread for the sandwich on a plate, awesome, except the plate must now be cleaned before you can use it for any gluten-free items. The knife you used to swipe the peanut butter and jelly across the bread likely has crumbs embedded in the remaining peanut butter and/or jelly. Then if you stuck the knife back into the peanut butter and/or jelly they are also likely contaminated and should be used by those with celiac disease. You likely have introduced crumbs into the containers that you cannot get out.
    Next are the chips—you thought you were safe there—wrong!! If you didn't wash your hands and I'm pretty sure you didn't, you may have also introduced crumbs into the chip bag. If the bag is contaminated with crumbs it is now unsafe for celiacs. Also, did you wash your hands before touching the fridge door? You get my drift.
    All of this can be controlled if we are careful. But most people don't think about any of this unless they have a food allergy or a family member who has one.
    You might think this is a little extreme. It might be. But would you say the same thing for someone with an anaphylactic reaction to peanuts? Or tree nuts? Or anything for that matter? But food is a problem for people with celiac disease and such things can be a serious issue for them.
    Many times celiac reactions aren't immediately obvious but they do come. Sometimes the reactions are even violent—explosive diarrhea or vomiting. They might be more subtle like brain fog, extreme fatigue, or joint aches or any of the other 300+ symptoms associated with celiac disease. Not to mention the longer term damage to the villi in the small intestine which can take 6 to 12 months to repair themselves. With ongoing long term damage they may never recover.
    Then, really long term there is anemia, malnutrition, and potentially cancer. So continued gluten ingestion, even in small amounts, may have the potential over time to cause cancer in those with celiac disease.
    Other hotbeds of cross-contamination are: toasters, butter dishes, scratched non-stick pans, wooden cutting boards and utensils, shared fryers, waffle irons, stirring the gluten pasta then putting the spoon in the sauce, gluten pasta water, non-squeeze bottle condiments, kitchens, etc.
    Bottom line—If it has gluten and you touch it, you must wash your hands or the item before it is safe for a celiac.
    Cross-contamination is Everywhere
    Cross-contamination is everywhere unless you are really careful. Most people don't understand it but I'm hoping this gave you a good introduction into where cross-contamination starts and why it is bad.
    Each time you leave the house, someone that has recently touched gluten will have touched something you are currently touching or are about to touch—door knobs, buttons on the card machines, grocery store carts, seats, computer keyboards, everything. All of it. Washing hands with soap and water before cooking or preparing food is the number one way to prevent this from causing an issue.
    A recent study suggested that using a common toaster, cooking gluten-free pasta in pasta water previously used to cook pasta, or using a knife that was previously used to cut a cake may not pose a significant risk of gluten contamination. Each scenario tested to below 20ppm for gluten. I'm not 100% sure I'm on board with this study, but it does make me a little less worried about cross-contamination. I would say, however, if you can avoid the such scenarios, do so just to be on the safe side.
    There are a couple of other scenarios I see talked about often—non-stick pans, separate plates for gluten and gluten-free food, kissing someone that has recently consumed gluten, or simply having prepackaged gluten foods next to pre-packaged gluten-free foods.
    The non-stick pans and separate plates issue—if you can replace the non-stick pans, great. If not, hand wash and then run the pans and dishes through the dishwasher and they should be safe.
    Kissing someone who recently consumed gluten, I think you are okay on this one, too, especially if they have a glass of water or other gluten-free beverage before engaging in a lip lock! As a side note, I would not let this disease get in the way of a passionate kiss, EVER! But that's just my bias.
    If a package of gluten-free food is in a sealed container and the seal is not broken, the food in the package is still gluten-free.
    I saw a recent post about a college student wanting to take Lysol wipes into class to wipe down desks before she sat down for fear that someone before her might have been eating a gluten snack at the same desk. My answer was first, are you going to be eating off the desk? Second, are you going to be able to wash your hands before the next meal? If the answer to the first question is yes, then yes, take wipes and wipe everything down. But why the heck are you eating directly off a desk in a strange place and maybe you need to rethink your eating habits. If the answer to the second question is yes, then no you don't need wipes. A good hand washing should be sufficient to protect you from any incidental cross-contamination picked up in the outside world.
    We Have to Live in a World That is Covered in Gluten
    Cross-contamination is a serious issue in the celiac community that has to be monitored and minimized. At the same time, we cannot let the disease or fear of cross-contamination rule our lives. We cannot be afraid to go out or to do anything for fear of getting sick. There must be a balance. My balance may look different from your balance, but we have to find a way to get to a place where we feel comfortable living our lives without being in constant fear. What I might see as acceptable risk, someone else may not, and that is fine. My whole point is that you have to find a way to be comfortable and not make your life feel like you are living in a gluten-free jail.
    Balance and the ability to live a full gluten-free life with few restrictions is the entire point of my blog—in addition to providing information about celiac drugs, new studies and talking about celiac disease.

  • Popular Now

HONcode Trustworthy Health Info Compliance

0_HONConduct789191_hr1.jpg

This site complies with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health information:
verify here.
View HONcode Certificate.

Navigation

About Celiac.com


Join eNewsletter

Popular Articles

Cookie Use

 

This site places cookies on your device (Cookie Settings). Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.     

×
×
  • Create New...