Jump to content
This site uses cookies. Continued use is acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. More Info... ×

  • Welcome to Celiac.com!

    You have found your celiac tribe! Join us and ask questions in our forum, share your story, and connect with others.



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A1):

    Celiac.com Sponsor (A1-M):

  • Get Celiac.com Updates:
    Support Our Content
    eNewsletter
    Donate

Gluten Challenge - Length

alioubba

Recommended Posts

alioubba Apprentice
alioubba
Posted

Hello, I'm new to the board and looking for advice.

I suspect celiac or gluten intolerance in my 7 year old daughter due to quite a few issues (iron deficiency, weak nails, fatigue, mouth sores, dark circles under eyes, constipation, bloating, irritable, aggression, social anxiety, possible inattentive ADHD and small for her age). 

I took her off gluten for just over 3 weeks and then tried re-introducing. It didn't go well. She had massive meltdowns and bloating for 2 days afterwards (we gave her a tortilla, some animal crackers and naan bread in the span of 12 hours). I wasn't convinced it was gluten but we stopped giving it to her for another 10 days and re-introduced again. It's been 8 days and she has symptoms - constipation, bloating, irritability, aggression, everything bothers her. I decided to keep her on gluten because I wanted to have her tested for celiac  (it would be important to know for family history, government tax credit and school). She was off gluten for almost 3 weeks and then 10 days. Now I have her on a gluten heavy diet and the doctor said two weeks should be sufficient. I know the standard is 12 weeks, but since she wasn't off gluten that long - do you think 2-3 weeks is okay?

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


Charli61 Apprentice
Charli61
Posted

I think 3 weeks is ample, especially if she is feeling so awful during the challenge.  I am an adult and it darn near did me in doing a challenge, and mine was 3 weeks.  I had been essentially off of it for several months, and then did the challenge and it was sufficient.

cyclinglady Grand Master
cyclinglady
Posted

I am sorry that your child is unwell!  

From my research, in as little as two weeks, antibodies can reverse or become undetectable.  This does not happen to everyone, but it is possible.  Kids too, tend to heal fast.  Researchers recommend 8 to 12 weeks of consuming gluten daily (one slice of bread or equivalent).  Just doing a two week challenge?  I suppose you could provided your doctor will re-order the test at 8 or 12 weeks if the first result is negative.  I would also urge you to ask for the complete panel instead of the standard screening TTG.  Here is more about testing:

Open Original Shared Link

We are a gluten free household.  My kid (16 years old) only gets gluten in her school lunch.  When I have her re-tested, she will consume gluten daily for 12 weeks.  I want to make sure celiac disease is not overlooked.  

I hope this helps you.  

 

alioubba Apprentice
alioubba
Posted
  • Author
23 minutes ago, Charli61 said:

I think 3 weeks is ample, especially if she is feeling so awful during the challenge.  I am an adult and it darn near did me in doing a challenge, and mine was 3 weeks.  I had been essentially off of it for several months, and then did the challenge and it was sufficient.

Charli61 you tested positive for celiac? How high were your antibodies?

alioubba Apprentice
alioubba
Posted
  • Author
20 minutes ago, cyclinglady said:

I am sorry that your child is unwell!  

From my research, in as little as two weeks, antibodies can reverse or become undetectable.  This does not happen to everyone, but it is possible.  Kids too, tend to heal fast.  Researchers recommend 8 to 12 weeks of consuming gluten daily (one slice of bread or equivalent).  Just doing a two week challenge?  I suppose you could provided your doctor will re-order the test at 8 or 12 weeks if the first result is negative.  I would also urge you to ask for the complete panel instead of the standard screening TTG.  Here is more about testing:

Open Original Shared Link

We are a gluten free household.  My kid (16 years old) only gets gluten in her school lunch.  When I have her re-tested, she will consume gluten daily for 12 weeks.  I want to make sure celiac disease is not overlooked.  

I hope this helps you.  

 

my doctor just ordered the TTG-IGA, I called the clinic and it looks like the ones I am missing are Total IGA and IGG. The test names are super confusing, maybe I can just get her to change it to "celiac panel" and that would cover everything? I asked her about genetic testing and she had no idea how to order that test. We have to pay for the test here in Canada - It's $125.

cyclinglady Grand Master
cyclinglady
Posted

The genetic test will not diagnose celiac disease because some 30% of the population carries the genes that could trigger celiac disease.  Only a FEW actually go in to develop it though.  Start with the TTG IGA and the IgA deficiency test.  (The IgA deficiency test tells you if the TTG IgA test is valid/control test in regards to celiac testing.  You need both.). If negative you could go on and order the DGP and the EMA tests?  Why?  The TTG test does not catch all celiacs like me!  I test positive only to the DGP.  It is not a fluke. It is how I test in follow-up  testing too.  

cyclinglady Grand Master
cyclinglady
Posted

The challenge is much shorter....two weeks for the biopsies obtained by endoscopy.  

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):
Celiac.com Sponsor (A8):

Celiac.com Sponsor (A8-M):


  • 3 weeks later...
alioubba Apprentice
alioubba
Posted
  • Author

I have an update, we decided to go with the doctor and test after 2 weeks being back on a heavy gluten diet. I asked for the results when I went to see the nurse for another issue.

Doctor has said they are "inconclusive" and is sending us to a specialist. I wasn't allowed to take the results with me until she finishes reviewing but I did get to look at the screen.

Total Iga - normal

Transglutaminase IgG - normal

Deamidated Gliadin IgG - normal

Deamidated Gliadin IgA - she is still reviewing this one and wouldn't provide the result. Can anyone explain further what this one is for?

Transglutaminase IgA ab - 27.0 (anything over 25.0 is considered abnormal)

I am wondering if the specialist will re-test? Or send it for her an endoscopy?  She is only 7 years old so I am worried about putting her through that.  I thought she had iron deficiency (she did when she was younger but we tested that and it was fine). Any thoughts or advice would be greatly appreciated. I am feeling really confused right now! 

 

 

 

 

cyclinglady Grand Master
cyclinglady
Posted

With her IgA level normal, all the IgA tests for celiac testing work.  It would be interesting to see what the DGP IgA test result is.  With a slightly elevated TTG IgA, she should probably get an endoscopy.  But that could be related to another autoimmune disorder.  Going back on  gluten for two weeks is not really enough time for the blood tests.  ☹️   There is a reason why experts recommend 8 to 12 weeks of consuming gluten daily.  Symptoms do not necessarily correlate with antibodies results.  It takes a while to build up antibodies to be measured in the bloodstream.  

Consult with a celiac-savvy GI.  

Oh, when she was gluten free she could have healed enough to absorb iron.  My levels went up and down for years.   

I hope she feels better soon!  

alioubba Apprentice
alioubba
Posted
  • Author

I figured I would get the testing now (it would probably be negative) and then just test again in 3-6 months if we were still having issues.  I was mostly interested in her iron levels as she had started sucking on rocks and eating mud! I really wasn't expecting a positive result.

Anyway, I thought I would just have to take GI specialist that my doctor refers me to? How do I find a celiac savvy GI specialist?

cyclinglady Grand Master
cyclinglady
Posted

Not sure how Canadian Health works.  My insurance allows me to choose a GI within my network. I check the doctor biographies.  

  • 2 weeks later...
Victoria5289 Apprentice
Victoria5289
Posted
On 4/14/2017 at 7:11 PM, alioubba said:

Hello, I'm new to the board and looking for advice.

I suspect celiac or gluten intolerance in my 7 year old daughter due to quite a few issues (iron deficiency, weak nails, fatigue, mouth sores, dark circles under eyes, constipation, bloating, irritable, aggression, social anxiety, possible inattentive ADHD and small for her age). 

I took her off gluten for just over 3 weeks and then tried re-introducing. It didn't go well. She had massive meltdowns and bloating for 2 days afterwards (we gave her a tortilla, some animal crackers and naan bread in the span of 12 hours). I wasn't convinced it was gluten but we stopped giving it to her for another 10 days and re-introduced again. It's been 8 days and she has symptoms - constipation, bloating, irritability, aggression, everything bothers her. I decided to keep her on gluten because I wanted to have her tested for celiac  (it would be important to know for family history, government tax credit and school). She was off gluten for almost 3 weeks and then 10 days. Now I have her on a gluten heavy diet and the doctor said two weeks should be sufficient. I know the standard is 12 weeks, but since she wasn't off gluten that long - do you think 2-3 weeks is okay?

Um I really don't think it is gluten problems it sounds like an abrasion of some kind

kareng Grand Master
kareng
Posted
3 hours ago, Victoria5289 said:

Um I really don't think it is gluten problems it sounds like an abrasion of some kind

Do you know what an abrasion is?  Maybe you need a better "translate to English" program?  

Victoria1234 Experienced
Victoria1234
Posted
1 hour ago, kareng said:

Do you know what an abrasion is?  Maybe you need a better "translate to English" program?  

I agree. She joined today and most of her 26 posts are offering medical advice that is a bit odd.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A19):


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      129,768
    • Most Online (within 30 mins)
      7,748
    deniserdh
    Newest Member
    deniserdh
    Joined
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A20):

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      121.2k
    • Total Posts
      1m
  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A22):



  • Celiac.com Sponsor (A21):


  • Upcoming Events

  • Posts

    • knitty kitty
      Refractory or super sensitive?

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      @Levi, How are you doing?  Sorry I missed your posts.   How's your thyroid?  Did your Vitamin D stabilize?  Do you have long hauler syndrome after Covid? Consider switching to Vitamin D 3, the natural form of Vitamin D.  Vitamin D 2 is the synthetic form of Vitamin D which the body can have difficulty changing to an active form.  Also, Thiamine is needed to active Vitamin D.   Hypothyroidism can be caused by Thiamine deficiency.  The thyroid is an organ that uses lots of thiamine.  sometimes thyroid deficiency can also cause hyperthyroidism, or swings between both hyper- and hypo-thyroidism. We need more Thiamine when we're sick with an infection (like Covid) or injured.  We need more Thiamine when we're physically active.  We need more Thiamine when we're emotionally stressed or worried.  Our brain uses the more Thiamine just thinking than our muscles do while running a marathon.  Thiamine is extremely important in fighting infections.  Covid patients and long haulers have found taking Thiamine has improved their survival rate and long term symptoms.   Consider taking a Thiamine supplement like Benfotiamine which has been scientifically shown to promote intestinal healing.  Damaged villi need thiamine to grow back.   Be sure to take a magnesium supplement, too.  Thiamine and magnesium make life sustaining enzymes together.  You also need magnesium to keep calcium in the bones.  The thyroid regulates calcium.  A wonky thyroid can lead to reduced bone density.   Remember the B vitamins all work together in concert so adding a B Complex to Benfotiamine and magnesium supplements and Vitamin C would be great in improving absorption of nutrients while we're dealing with celiac disease. Namaste
    • lizzie42
      Gluten free and oat free bars not sugary?

      By lizzie42 · Posted

      I'm looking for bars or non perishable snacks for my 2 kids. They are 5 and 3. The 3 year old seems sensitive to oats also. We do a lot of long hikes and bike rides. They eat mostly fresh foods but for these rides and hikes we need easy and non perishable. Also that taste good! We do a lot of larabars and freeze dried apples but those are getting old. Any ideas? 
    • knitty kitty
      Inflammation and Menier’s disease link?

      By knitty kitty · Posted

      Oh, @MagsM, Sorry you had that happen with Niacin.  500mg is the maximum amount of Niacin one should take.  Niacin works hand in hand with Thiamine, so a big influx like that can imbalance thiamine if not supplemented at the same time.  All the B vitamins work together in concert.  Niacin in doses at 500 mg or above have been used by doctors to lower triglycerides levels and raise HDL, the good cholesterol.  Pharmaceuticals to do the same thing are more expensive and thus more profitable for physicians. Has your doctor tested you for H. Pylori?  An infection by H. Pylori can be tested for by your doctor.  H. Pylori can cause low tTg IgA results, too.   I would hold off on the microbiome test for now.  Your microbiome is going to change when you go gluten free.  Your microbiome will change when you start taking Thiamine.  Thiamine supplementation influences which microbes grow in the intestines, encouraging beneficial bacteria and getting rid of the bad ones.  Thiamine in the form Benfothiamine promotes intestinal healing, too.  Adopting the Autoimmune Protocol Diet (by Dr. Sarah Ballantyne, a Celiac herself) after diagnosis will also change your microbiome.  This is the best diet to heal and recover, IMO.   If you're going to have more testing done for vitamin deficiencies, don't take vitamin supplements beforehand, otherwise the tests will measure the vitamin supplements in your bloodstream and give false results.  Same thing will happen if you take B vitamin shots.  The supplements you mentioned (Arterosil HP and Vascanox HP) are herbal support and do not contain all eight B vitamins.  There's no harm in taking them, but I prefer a B Complex that contains all the B vitamins in activated forms like Life Extension's Bioactive Complete B Complex.  All the B vitamins work together in concert.  Magnesium is important to supplement as thiamine and magnesium make life sustaining enzymes together.  Do not buy supplements containing Thiamine Mononitrate because it is not biologically active.  It is very hard for the body to utilize.  Most of it (70%) passes out unused.    Yes, my Meniere's disease has not returned.  I was deficient in Vitamin D.  I took high doses of Vitamin D 3 to correct the deficiency quickly.  I also took TTFD (tetrahydrofurfuryl disulfide) which is a form of thiamine different from Benfotiamine.  TTFD can cross the blood brain barrier without a carrier, so it can get into the brain very easily.  TTFD helps the Vagus nerve function.  The Vagus nerve regulates the ears and balance, and also the digestive system.  I like Allithiamine by Ecological Formulas.  I also like Thiamax by Objective Nutrients.  You should have improvements within a hour with TTFD.  TTFD is much stronger, so lower doses will give amazing benefits (50-200 mg).   I hope this helps give you some direction to take on your journey!
    • MagsM
      Inflammation and Menier’s disease link?

      By MagsM · Posted

      Thank you so much for this in depth analysis. I am currently taking Vit D3/K2 5000IU daily.i started taking a flushing Niacin but foolishly took a 500mg tab and nearly passed out! I have just ordered a gut microbiome genome test and it will be interesting to see what my current balance of microbes are. After I finish diagnosis I will definitely go gluten free. Diagnosis will inform exactly how strict I’ll need to be regarding cross contamination etc. my focus will be on healing the gut. I have also been focusing on the oral microbiome - cutting out FL and using more natural products as well as daily oil pulling. I read from some of your other forum entries about Benfothiamine and I’ll definitely order that. I’ll make sure my doc orders more detailed vitamin and mineral panel plus total IGA as well as the DGP-IGA and DGP-IGG tests. We will see if I can get the endoscopic biopsy done. Do you think I should request Vitamin B shots to get me started?  My daily vitamin protocol will likely be VitD/K2 5000IU, Benfothiamin 300x2, Niacin (flushing) 50mg working up to 300mg. I also take a EPA/DHA as well as some vascular support (Arterosil HP and Vascanox HP) as well as Magnesium at night. Which B complex brand do you like? I will see what the gut microbiome test comes back with. I’m sure they will try to sell me pre/probiotics and maybe some digestive enzymes. What are you thought on those? I’m curious if you managed to go into full remission from your Ménière’s disease? Thank you so much for your thoughtful insight. I know that building back up my gut health and immune health will help in so many ways as well as protecting me from many other major diseases as I go into my 60s and beyond. 
    • Scott Adams
      Any bad experience with King Arthur Gluten-free bread flour

      By Scott Adams · Posted

      You are right! The logo the have on their packages got me confused--it looks like they are less than 20ppm, not certified GF. Thanks for catching that! My brain also zeroed in on this "less than 10ppm" but I should have seen the rest...
×
×
  • Create New...